6 ms·
I think 2. is more ”the person felt that the asking price was unreasonable“. Most of us could afford to pay $30+ for a DVD but I’d imagine most of us wouldn’t b
by taneq 7y ago
I think 2. is more ”the person felt that the asking price was unreasonable“. Most of us could afford to pay $30+ for a DVD but I’d imagine most of us wouldn’t be willing to.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoFor a DRM free digital copy I'd be willing to pay around 20 bucks after release and would expect a drop in prices layer on, just like with physical releases. 1080p, maybe 4k but I don't even have a TV for that yet. I'm only watching movies very occasionally so I'm not sure if that kind of business model would be feasible, but my guess is that just the paranoia of selling something without DRM is too big.
- benbristow 7y ago$20 is a lot of money for about 2 hours of entertainment. If films were like $1-$3 for a high resolution download I think they'd sell like wildfire. I'd definitely pay for the convenience.
- taneq 7y agoTo put that in context, it's about $18 for a movie ticket where I live and $30 if you buy popcorn and a drink. But yeah, it still seems like a lot to pay for a few-year-old movie that you'll only ever watch once.
- Dylan16807 7y agoAnd to put that in context, the closest theater to me generally has month or two old movies and charges $2-6. And I don't want popcorn anyway.
- taneq 7y agoI'm gonna go out on a limb and say people where you live probably torrent less than people where I live. :P
- Dylan16807 7y agoIt's in the middle of the US. It's more about the difference between a brand new movie and one that isn't.
- dkersten 7y agoCinema is still pretty expensive. If I go to a pub to hang out with friends, I spend under $10/hour and get beer for the money.
- jacobush 7y agoOne beer. :-/
- dkersten 7y agoI might drink 8 pints in a night hanging out with friends, spread out over about 6 hours. The beers I drink in pubs cost on average 6 Euro. That works out as 8 euro/hour, which is about US$8.84 and is 1 and 1/3 pints an hour. If I drink one more, for an average of 1.5 an hour, then it works out as US$9.94, still under $10/hour on average spread over about 6 hours.
- benbristow 7y agoI'm more happy to pay for the experience of the cinema though. Even though the film itself is only 2 hours you've got the travel and before/after events to make it more fulfilling.
- magashna 7y agoMovies have dropped down in my perceived value considering within a year or two you can get a 60+ hour AAA video game for ~$15
- oefrha 7y agoWith an AMC subscription I can watch three movies per week (any movie, any theater, any seat) for $20 a month. Pretty decent deal as long as I don’t blow money on popcorns and drinks (that’s how they get you). I still definitely prefer watching movies on the big screen.
- frenchyatwork 7y agoWell, that might work for you, but there's a lot of people that won't work for. I only watch about 3-5 movies a year. I also like popcorn with my movies, so I'm either watching at home, or paying up the wazoo.
- jacobush 7y agoAn increasing number of people don't have the infrastructure to save (large) files. They don't have PCs, only phones or tablets.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoYes that's probably it. As a techie I'd probably even be fine with buying a bluray and ripping it but I don't even know if their copy protection has been defeated for good or whether it's a cat and mouse game like with modern console piracy. So I watched exactly one movie at home this year on a laptop with a friends Netflix account. A DRM free download service would have made that maybe two or three.
- squeaky-clean 7y agoThat's essentially what a rental is. You're stuck with having to stream it, but most people don't care or even know about quality differences from that. But if you're buying the disc it's not just $20 for 2 hours of entertainment. I bought Spiderverse on 4k and have watched it at least 5 times since buying, sometimes solo, sometimes with friends.
- benbristow 7y agoThat's if you're the type to watch movies over and over again. There's only a few movies that I'd ever bother to re-watch.
- squeaky-clean 7y agoThen there's no need to buy and renting is perfect for you is my point. It's typically 2 to 4 dollars. You can rent from iTunes, Amazon, YouTube, etc and get the movie usually for 48 hours.
- benbristow 7y agoPerhaps I really enjoyed the movie though and I’d like to watch it again in a few months time. Do I pay to rent it again or pay $20 for a permanent download?
- nemothekid 7y ago>If films were like $1-$3 for a high resolution download I think they'd sell like wildfire. I'd definitely pay for the convenience. I really doubt that would be the case. It would be way more likely that movies would be stuffed with ads and we'd be crying about the death of "real cinema", like we do today with journalism. $1-$3 doesn't even seem sustainable.
- benbristow 7y agoMovies pay for themselves within the first few weeks/months in cinemas. I’m sure they would. DVDs and Blu Rays are already packed with ads (Trailers etc) at full price. The amount of people paying for them compared to getting them from other means would be higher too.
- jdnenej 7y agoExactly. I spent $20 on a video game that so far I have got 160 hours of entertainment out of. I can afford $20 but that doesn't mean I think it's worth it.
- paulcole 7y agoA classic case of privileged people thinking that the rules don’t apply to them. And if they don’t like the rules someone else made, it is their right to break them and make up some BS justification.
- rayiner 7y agoThey’re anti-social. These are the same people who drive in the HOV lane with nobody else in the car, or litter or jaywalk. They’re free riders. They violate the following moral principle: “If everyone did what I’m doing, what would happen?” In the case of piracy, the thing you’re downloading wouldn’t exist unless the majority of people followed the rules.
- ravenstine 7y ago> They violate the following moral principle: “If everyone did what I’m doing, what would happen?” The reason a lot of people, perhaps most, don't follow that idea is because it's a lot like the slippery slope fallacy. Hypothetically, if everyone pirated all their content, perhaps there'd be serious problems as a result. In reality, that's never actually going to happen.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoSome other sucker is paying for your entertainment, so it's all cool?
- ravenstine 7y agoI never said that. I just don't find the "if everyone did that" argument very compelling. For instance, if all 7.7 billion people lit wood fires every day, we'd have ash constantly falling down on us and the skies would be darkened, but we don't need to feel bad about setting the occasional campfire because the reality is that most people aren't going to be lighting fires all the time.
- 7y ago
- alexis_fr 7y ago$30+ DVD... with ads. I’ve always found it insulting to the consumer. I wouldn’t mind ads on a cheap trinket, but not a full-price DVD.
- DanBC 7y agoA lot of people like the ads. The un-skippable is what people don't like.
- martius 7y agoSeriously? While I sometimes enjoy watching trailers for other films in the "bonuses/special features", when I buy a film (whatever the price), what I want is to watch the film: I put the disc in the player, I press play a couple of times after I chose the spoken language/subtitles, and then, I watch the film. Even if you can skip them, I really dislike the sequence of trailers, ads, "FBI WARNINGs", more ads, "enjoy the full experience of ULTRA HD", THX deep note, yet more ads.
- kgwxd 7y agoI have an old Disney DVD with a feature called FastPlay. It has a 30 second, unskippable, description of FastPlay.
- dkersten 7y agoThey might be fine the first time you watch a DVD, but when, later, you see outdated adverts every. damn. time? That's actually the exact thing that made me abandon DVD's years ago.
- ptero 7y agoThe use case that I did personally hit a couple of times is old, out of print books. They were relatively inexpensive (say, $10-$15 at publication 30 years ago), but did not publish a lot of copies. Thus my choice is between getting free digital scans off hobbyist sites (I guess also known as those evil "pirates") or searching for an occasional seller on ebay asking $200 for a copy of unknown quality. Can I afford $200 for a copy? Yes. Will I pay it? Not so sure, sorry. My 2c.
- delecti 7y agoMaybe there's no clear line between the two, but there's a difference between pirating something out of print which has greatly appreciated in value due to rarity far beyond the typical asking price for media of that type, and being unable/unwilling to pay the typical retail price of a currently in-print item. I may have tried to tell myself otherwise, but when I was pirating blockbuster video games in college it was just because I didn't have $60 spare, not because there's anything inherently unreasonable about a $60 price tag for the game. Not least among the reasons why is that the original creator won't get any of your money for the out of print item.