9 ms·
Y'know, the toll that all this activity takes on Reddit's servers gave me an idea for a sort of distributed Reddit. News links and stories assorted into topic-b
by bitwize 7y ago
Y'know, the toll that all this activity takes on Reddit's servers gave me an idea for a sort of distributed Reddit. News links and stories assorted into topic-based groups, with the option for users to comment or respond to others' comments in a threaded discussion. It would be completely decentralized and belong to the users, not some central media company. We could call it Users' Network, or USENET for short.
We could implement it with blockchain.
- Sendotsh 7y agoSign me up. I’d happily contribute to that as much as I can, whenever my parents aren’t using the phone line.
- thrownblown 7y agoDon't forget to turn off call waiting. I always forgot to turn off call waiting....
- _asummers 7y agoI'm showing my youth here, but this is a legitimate question. Isn't call waiting just a thing that exists on the line? Did phones used to have a switch to toggle that? And what was the harm in keeping it on? When I had dial up, I don't recall having to consider call waiting.
- uptown 7y agoThe incoming call tone would disrupt modem traffic so you had to dial a code prior to the number you wanted to dial to disable this temporarily for the duration of your outgoing call.
- xen2xen1 7y agoDialing *67, I think, in the dial string for dialup turned off call waiting for the duration of the call. Otherwise a second call would try to ring through and disrupt your Super Z-modem download.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- function_seven 7y agoCall Waiting used to be a feature that you paid monthly for. As was Caller ID, Three Way Calling, Busy Number Redial, etc. It's amazing how much incumbent telcos nickled and dimed little features like this. I think it was a couple bucks a month to have that feature.
- skissane 7y agoFrom my recollection, there were 3 or 4 different * codes. Separate codes to turn it on and off, and also to turn it on or off permanently or just for the duration of the next call. I think at one point it was a value-added service, and you had to pay extra on your phone bill to enable it, but once it was enabled you could turn it on or off at will. When I was a teenager (in the 1990s), our house had three phone lines. One was for voice calls, and it had call waiting turned on permanently. Another was for modems (first BBSes, then dial-up Internet), and had call waiting turned off permanently. A third was paid for by my Dad's employer, he used it for work calls, work faxes, and call up his work's modem bank to send/receive email, I don't know what he did with call waiting settings. My Dad ordered three phone lines, but only had two pairs running in to the house. So they ran another cable, which I think had 12 pairs in it, but only three were ever connected. My Dad was smiling about how future-proof they made it. Nowadays, only one of those pairs is still active, and I expect within the next 1-2 years that pair will be turned off too. Analog POTS phone system being phased out in favour of VoIP (the Internet comes into the house over coax, not copper pair.)
- bitwize 7y agoWait, you didn't add the disable call waiting code to your dial string?
- mehhh 7y agoLemmy is a federated alternative to Reddit: https://github.com/dessalines/lemmy https://github.com/dessalines/lemmy Edit: Check out the dev instance of Lemmy! https://dev.lemmy.ml/ https://dev.lemmy.ml/
- ryacko 7y agoDeveloping a new fediverse is excessive, but it is unlikely a new sorting algorithm will be added to mastodon soon.
- mehhh 7y agoWho cares about Mastodon? Lemmy is ActivityPub compliant, just like PeerTube, write.as, Pleroma, rustodon, PixelFed and the other wonderful AP projects out there. These platforms do not fracture the Fediverse FYI, you can follow cross-platform & cross-site like normal.
- beatgammit 7y agoWow, this is quite possibly exactly what I've been looking for! I love Rust (have experience with Actix as well), React (so hopefully Inferno will come naturally), and have been looking for a Reddit alternative for some time! I'm not sure if I should thank you or curse you for making me want to spend a ton of time on yet another side project ;)
- mehhh 7y agoLemmy is a fun project that I'm sure you could make even better!
- continuations 7y agoI've started working on a client for this decentralized reddit. I'm giving it the code name "rn".
- groby_b 7y agoI've cloned your inferior version and markedly improved it. And since I like not reading reddit, I decided to name it "Nothing New" or "nn"
- dumbfoundded 7y agoYou mean Steemit?
- conception 7y agoYeah this already exists and was done pretty well actually.
- hobofan 7y agoExcept for the part of how the Steem token works, which basically means that built-in unmarked ads are needed for the economy to work.
- dumbfoundded 7y agoYeah but that's kind of nitpicking. If you're looking for a "decentralized reddit" on blockchain, it's pretty hard to argue Steemit isn't this. There's others too. People are free to fork it and make a new platform. Most of the hard work is already done unless you want to change absolutely everything about it.
- trothamel 7y agoHeh. That being said, I've always thought that the right way to implement a distributed social network would be not with blockchain, but with IPFS, or something similar to IPFS. Pinning someone else's IPFS hash would be the equivalent to an upvote for that item.
- manigandham 7y agoExcept UX is everything. 100s of billions in corporate value are based on nothing more than better UX. If only everyone who talks about usenet, IRC, and the rest could actually be bothered to update the experience to what modern users demand.
- todipa 7y agoYes, but I think it is the community of reddit moderators that make reddit what it is today...
- beamatronic 7y agoIt’s too bad Google doesn’t take on this project.
- Klonoar 7y agoCiting UX in a thread about Reddit, the company with an almost universally hated redesign that moved away from a mostly text-based condensed format is... interesting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 7y agoEvery user engagement metric has increased since the redesign. Unfortunate for some of us, and it doesn't preclude the metrics measuring the wrong thing, but that's reality on the ground. Same reason why Gmail is a bloated mess, because that's what the metrics show is wanted by users.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Every user engagement metric has increased since the redesign. Doesn't that just mean that users are spending more time on the site because it's so much more of a pain to get what they actually want out of it? Like, you could increase "user engagement" of a shopping mall by turning it into a labyrinth and rearranging the shops every day.
- pjc50 7y agoSo, who does the moderation, new group creation, and antispam? Those were always problems.
- dondawest 7y agoExactly. Will this new platform provide a safe space for the brilliant minds at /r/fatpeoplehate? /s The problem with all anti-censorship platforms is that they become hate platforms by default, because only people who get deplatformed have an incentive to move there, and it’s mostly hateful loudmouths who get deplatformed.
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoThe problem with all pro-censorship platforms is that they become hivemind platforms by default, because only people who are worried about catering to the specific opinions of the site hivemind have an incentive to stay there, and it’s mostly smoothbrain dipshits who stay there. By the way, go fuck yourself.
- archie2 7y agoPersonally, I think the solution is just to give users options to censor others from their perspective instead of just trying to create some utopia that is free from hatred of any kind - which is impossible. Personally, I prefer having these disgusting people out in the open. When they do something horrendous, the paper trail can be long and damning - making it much easier to convict them. These people are usually proud of their deviancy and advertise it without shame. The notion that if we just ban all the sick people they will just go away and never do anything evil is ludicrous. The evil is already in their hearts, hiding it won't heal it.
- mehhh 7y agoThis creates echo chambers like 4chan, 8chan, pleroma.site, gab.com & /r/The_Donald where likeminded people gather and decide bashing in the heads of LGBTQ+ people like myself is perfectly acceptable, and proceed to act out their hate in my community (Ballard, WA). My fellow trans and gay friends have lived in Seattle without issue for decades, but now Nazis are coming here from rural Washington to attempt to murder us. This is a huge change from the past, and SPD's hate crime statistics are up significantly due to this.
- bcaa7f3a8bbc 7y agoWhere is the new "alt."?
- cwkoss 7y agoI've specced out a decentralized reddit alternative a little bit, but have too many side projects. Someone please take this and build it. Let me know if you try, would love to spectate and advise on development. The key is there shouldn't be a globally consistent front page. Sorting should be done on an individual basis. Upvotes boost signal signal to peers and downvotes squelch. By propagating content scores transitively through the network proportionally to trust scores, users can moderate their own feeds by voting and managing their friend list. Users have a peer list, containing a list of server/users on it. Each peer has a user-managed 'trust weighting'. Each user has a list of "good content" (ideally hash identified for content addressability), with each item having a score based on that user's votes and votes from peers, weighted by that users trust in that peer. Periodically, your server contacts all of your peers, and asks them for their good content list. The scores from peers are multiplied by your own trust weight for that peer, and you build a personal "good content" list that merges the lists from each of your peers together (and drops insufficient scores). You are presented with a score-descending-sorted page of content. Whenever you upvote something, it increases your score weight for that content as well as the trust weight for each peer who sent you the recommendation, and vice versa for downvotes. Votes are transmitted to peers as a crypto signature of the content hash, but when retransmitted to peer-of-peer, they only see the intermediary's aggregated and trust weighted merged scores. The specifics of the algorithms on how you calculate and adjust weights can be configurable by each individual user, the protocol only cares that peers are able to produce some kind of score list. Dividing content into topics is a bit trickier, could just label content with tags. I think it may be preferable for each user to have multiple topic focused 'personalities' that are basically distinct user accounts with unique peer lists and votes. In that way, I could follow Dave-gardening without having to follow Dave-sports. For this example I'm using 1 user per server for simplicity, though not required. All users could be on same server, which is probably best for MVP to avoid implementing p2p networking stuff until validated.
- cwkoss 7y agoEx. Alice follows Bob with weight of 0.5, Dave with 0.1 Bob scores content A as 0.8, B as 0.2 Dave scored content A as 0.4, B as 0.9 Alice downloads both lists. Alice score content A as avg(0.8 * 0.5, 0.4 * 0.1) = 0.22 Alice scores content B as avg(0.2 * 0.5, 0.9 * 0.1) = 0.095 Content A gets sorted higher than B.
- Throw_Away_6381 7y agoSounds like Aether[1]. In contrast to the Usenet, it is peer-to-peer, instead of federated. It does also have moderation, voting, and a pretty UI – things that are arguably missing in the Usenet. (And it doesn't use blockchain.) [1]: https://getaether.net/ https://getaether.net/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- marknadal 7y agoExactly this already exists, but no blockchain is needed: https://notabug.io/ https://notabug.io/ (beware of content: anonymous decentralized reddit!) @go1dfish runs NAB and all the code is at https://github.com/notabugio/notabug https://github.com/notabugio/notabug . It is built with my P2P graph protocol ( https://github.com/amark/gun https://github.com/amark/gun ), + he has some custom implementations of it.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoThe post was a joke mostly, especially the blockchain part
- bduerst 7y ago>We could implement it with blockchain. Mining would have no monetary incentivization, so the people left controlling the network are the ones who are incentivized to push a message on your new distributed reddit. Like with all things that have a vacuum of power, it will be filled by someone - most likely not who you really want to fill it either.
- fortran77 7y agoDo it in Rust, so it will never crash.
- shanev 7y agoI know you are being sarcastic, but the startup I work at is building something like this: https://beta.trustory.io/ https://beta.trustory.io/. Here is a bit about the technical architecture: https://link.medium.com/yjevZ7y15Z https://link.medium.com/yjevZ7y15Z. Used to be a heavy Usenet user back in the day.
- tetraca 7y agoI lazily made my own little private server a couple days ago implementing this concept by stitching a usenet server to a web login/account portal.
- chrisdhoover 7y agoCould your system break the back of r/sanfrancisco? It has turned into tourist pics of the GGB, sunrises and double rainbows at the hands of moderators that want no dissent
- buboard 7y agoSuch a SPAM system will SPAM never have a SPAM problem with spam
- cheez 7y agoMastadon. I was a Usenet user as well but it isn't user friendly to normies.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoHow would upvoting work on USENET?
- Iv 7y agoVoting is a killer feature. It is an effective spam fighter and makes farm-troll's jobs much harder.
- nine_k 7y agoWhile the joke is not lost, think of the pictures. Of animated gifs and video clips. They are a large part if Reddit. Sending every peer a copy can be wasteful and slow. It only there'd be a cluster of servers to make these media available via http...
- Iv 7y agoFor a long time reddit did not host any media content. It was just a link aggregator.
- rolleiflex 7y agoI made Aether for that, pretty much exactly what you're talking about. https://getaether.net https://getaether.net Been on Hacker News a few times too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19161171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19161171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18373504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18373504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18370208 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18370208 It's the need to make money that makes things go awry, so Aether doesn't need to make money. No servers mean costs are fairly negligible, except my own time spent.
- drdeadringer 7y ago> an idea for a sort of distributed Reddit Free name suggestion: Distreddit