7 ms·
I like that the internet archive exists, but I don't like how they implement their opt-out policy. Sites can opt-out at any time, which I suppose is the correct
by ineedasername 7y ago
I like that the internet archive exists, but I don't like how they implement their opt-out policy. Sites can opt-out at any time, which I suppose is the correct thing to allow, but once they opt out then everything the Archive has gathered up to that point also goes away, which seems wrong.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIt doesn’t go away, it’s just not public. This is to comply with copyright law. It’s still safely stored on disk.
- ineedasername 7y agoOkay, if they have no choice in it then I understand. But as for keeping a copy on disk that practically no one can ever see, to me that strikes seems like a distinction without a difference.
- diggan 7y agoI'm pretty sure you can visit the building that Internet Archive operates from (https://archive.org/about/contact.php https://archive.org/about/contact.php) and freely surf/look at all the content, even the content that is not available from the web version.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 7y agoI see no advantage in restricting access. I just believe this to be a mechanism to hide uncomfortable content, which I believe has no benefit as long as no personal information is revealed.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoBetter to save content for a future with more sane copyright law than to not save it at all.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoIt's not a binary fact of having a choice or not. A less restrictive policy would bring a load of frivolous copyright and/or trademark encroachment. Fighting it would be a worthy fight, but would divert resources away from their core mission of archiving, which is hard enough on its own. AFAIK they're thinking of the historical record for future generations, and present access is a sacrificeable side benefit.
- pgeorgi 7y ago"No one" in the next ~70-90 years.
- dTal 7y agoThe block requires active maintenance in the form of robots.txt. If the domain owner allows robots.txt to lapse, the content is automatically republished.
- gizmo686 7y agoOne of the services they are providing is to future historians.
- jMyles 7y ago> This is to comply with copyright law. If that's true, it will be a better resource for humanity if it charts a way to be hosted in a jurisdiction where copyright law doesn't require this kind of censorship.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agohttps://blog.archive.org/2018/07/21/decentralized-web-faq/ https://blog.archive.org/2018/07/21/decentralized-web-faq/
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoReady for public release in roughly 100 years then.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoNot sure about that copyright argument holding water, especially across multiple jurisdictions - I would think some argument could be made that the data was gathered with a robots.txt that allowed it and as such it can be made available. Actually as I've noted before other archive initiatives often ignore robots.txt, for example the Danish National Archive ignores it and is legally allowed to for gathering all relevant Danish material.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoIt doesn't make then compliant [with UK law, at least], it just makes them appear to be. Copyright covers copying, the copying has already been done, and the copies are being retained: meaning any infringement is ongoing. They're just hiding their probable infringement. I'm more than happy for them to do that btw, but I do have strong reservations about letting anyone "archive" a site and offer it to the public. This is an area that's needs legislative development IMO.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe Internet Archive has no physical presence in the UK to my knowledge.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThey copy websites from UK servers. They extend their presence to UK jurisdiction in order to do that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- colejohnson66 7y agoSo when I copy a UK website from to my browser cache, I’m subject to UK jurisdiction? That makes no sense.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoI got frustrated with this one time when I tried to look up a defunct website in the Wayback Machine. The website was gone, but had been replaced by a domain squatter with a restrictive robots.txt. Because of the new roboots.txt, all of the old site was retroactively made unavailable. As time passes and more websites change hands, it would be a nice compromise if the default behavior was only to make retroactive deletions that go back to the last change of ownership in WHOIS data.
- foota 7y agoWould be cool if this could be tied to SSL keys. Being able to serve requests with the same SSL key could be used as verification. (obviously some edge cases like people that are behind some kind of common SSL cert like a subdomain with shared hosting)
- loa_in_ 7y agoThat's impossible due to the way assymetric encryption works. It would help to indicate to the user, and maybe allow searching/grouping by certificate hash to transcend domain names
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- foota 7y agoIsn't that what cert pinning does though?
- chousuke 7y agoI think it would make more sense to tie the behaviour to the domain's whois record. If that changes significantly, chances are the domain has changed owners.
- foota 7y agoThis is true, but the whois isn't really a highly official source.
- ent101 7y agoJust to be clear, the data doesn't seem to be deleted -- it only becomes inaccessible once the site opts out; all the data can come back if the site changes its mind.
- mjevans 7y agoI believe that policy to be morally wrong. If a site WAS accessible then that old version should continue to be until an active legal tool is used to request the offline archiving rather than free access as it was at the time of observation.
- blackflame7000 7y agoYea but I can't just copy a website and start hosting my own version for numerous copyright reasons even if it is just to archive. I can't for example torrent a bunch of movies and store them for the purpose of "archiving"
- ticmasta 7y agoActually, a library is a specific legal context that does allow it to do many things similar to what you're describing. It can't steal movies for archiving, but it certainly can purchase and share legally procured copies. Digital sharing is an admittedly more complex minefield...
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoIn USA. I assume that's where you're talking about. In UK certain libraries can archive (British Library) following a recent change in the law, IIRC. People wanting to access the archive may only do so by physically visiting the library. AFAICT archive.org are flouting copyright law around the World already, they should continue to be cautious about assuming rights IMO.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoArchive.org is an accredited library.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYep, that works for USA law AFAIR, but USA Fair Use is exceptionally liberal compared to other copyright regimes.
- mmagin 7y agoTo be fair, they're operating in a situation (budget vs. volume of material to collect and share with the world) where it's necessary to minimize the human overhead of this mechanism AND to attempt to reduce their legal exposure -- sure they can get legal help from some of the very best, but mostly out of people's goodwill, they don't have the budget to be defending themselves constantly. (Disclaimer: former IA employee, but I do not in any way speak for IA.)
- dTal 7y agoThe archive needs to provide some extra-legal mechanism to allow people to hide data - otherwise they'll be in court all the time. The advantage of this system is that it runs both ways - sites can also neglect to opt out, having previously done so, which immediately republishes all the data.