4 ms·
The fundamental problem which seems to be recurring is that the system is generally hostile towards consumer interests. It's all so broken, it makes me want so
by ilaksh 7y ago
The fundamental problem which seems to be recurring is that the system is generally hostile towards consumer interests.
It's all so broken, it makes me want something dramatic to happen. Maybe the robots will take over soon and be better at governing. Or perhaps yogurt. Or maybe we can start over on Mars.
- grenoire 7y agoThings like these are truly the things that keep me up at night. The more centralised governments' and corporations' power get concentrated, the more suffering we have.
- izacus 7y agoIn reality what needs to happen is strong and consistent lobbying from interest groups like EFF. With a lot of calls to action and advocating. This is how consumer rights happened - with boring hard work and going above corporate fanboyism to protect yourself as a customer. Waiting for some external magic to fix things will not work unfortunately.
- ilaksh 7y agoYes, more lobbying will help, and that's why I donate to the EFF, but there is obviously a very persistent and difficult problem which never goes away. I'm not really interested in "external magic". The core structure is wrong. We should create a new paradigm that works for the citizens by default.
- __MatrixMan__ 7y agoThis future is a long way off, but I expect we'll see the new paradigm you're taking about take shape as a collection of smart contracts on a cryptocurrency platform. Then, it will have to compete with the existing ways. If it's worthy of being the new normal, it should be able to compete and win. I think that means that economic activity on the platform with the sane IP policy would need to be more desirable for both buyers and sellers. It's obvious why sellers would want to avoid using platforms that are either so riddled with bogus IP that they can't operate (like USD), or so bereft of enforcement that they get no credit for originality (like CNY). But an incentive structure that keeps buyers from jumping ship to the latter sort... That's going to take some creativity. My best shot at it would be this: Supposing the underlying system is a proof of stake system, perhaps your staking rewards could be reduced or increased based on the extent to which your purchasing habits transferred value to platforms that don't support the desired IP features. So even though you may pay more for the IP compliant product up front, in the long run the system rewards you for not funding its IP-deviant competitor. The savvy thing for a buyer to do in such a situation would be to have separate identities on each platform, so you spend your no-rules tokens on no-rules products and you spend your regulated tokens on regulated products, thereby avoiding penalties for being a traitor. Hopefully, the market cap of either economy's token would then hinge on which one functioned better independently of the other: May the economy with the best set of policies win (where winning means attracting the participants from its competition). The trouble is, we don't have infinite resources to just spawn economic petri dishes like this. Eventually the competing economies will come into conflict over more that just which is more fun to participate in. Eventually they'll start wasting resources on fighting over access to some mineral or whatever. I'm still noodling on fixes for that, but even so, I think that such a system would be no worse than the one we have.
- rotrux 7y ago> The fundamental problem which seems to be recurring is that the system is generally hostile towards consumer interests. I think you're really close, but have specified the inverse of the fundamental problem. The system is generally dominated by seller interests. There is no consumer advocacy on the level of corporate advocacy.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoAs it no longer promotes progress of science, I have no respect for patents anymore.
- kabdib 7y agoI've seen lawyers look up from reading a particularly convoluted and confusing passage and say, without a trace of irony, "This part of the claims is teaching that . . ." Teaching, yeah right. "Teaching" is what the patents are supposed to do. In reality, there is nearly always nothing to actually learn other than how much of, say, the act of 'breathing' the claimant is trying to do a land-grab on.
- philipkglass 7y agoI have read many American chemistry patents. Up through the 1970s or thereabouts, they often did seem to teach things in enough detail for implementation by "a person having ordinary skill in the art." Now they usually make vague, broad claims and provide fewer, less clear examples of the invention's embodiment. I don't know what drove this drift toward uselessness. To explain this trend I might vaguely gesture toward businesses responding to stresses as the postwar golden economic era ended, except 1) old patents from before the postwar boom (e.g. 1930s) were also useful and to-the-point and 2) academic publications also grew more bullshitty in the same approximate time frame.
- lukifer 7y agoThis was the podcast that took me from opposing software patents, to opposing the very concept of patents altogether: http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/67 http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/67 See also: "The idea that I can be presented with a problem, set out to logically solve it with the tools at hand, and wind up with a program that could not be legally used because someone else followed the same logical steps some years ago and filed for a patent on it is horrifying." - John Carmack
- pnw_hazor 7y agoJC would just have to find a different/better way to solve the problem. Just like someone designing disc brakes or mouse traps.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoNot sure why it is hostile to consumers. Consumers seem to be doing just fine. One can make a principled argument to abolish all patents. (If you don't believe in intellectual property rights for inventions). However, arguments to abolish so-called software patents don't make much sense. Software is just an implementation detail of an invention. It is not the invention.