10 ms·
Snowden calls on France’s Macron to grant him asylum
- empath75 7y agoHasn't Russia already granted him asylum?
- na85 7y agoThey have. I'd rather live in France than Russia, though. Rule of Law, better climate, more familiar culture, theoretically friendlier government, etc.
- simonh 7y agoAlso the optics of a campaigner for open and accountable government living under the protection of Vladimir Putin could be better.
- theandrewbailey 7y ago> better climate Would asylum allow access to overseas possessions? France has some nice tropical locations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_departments_and_territories_of_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_departments_and_terri...
- empath75 7y agoThat's not the way asylum works, though.
- na85 7y agoIn the sense that beggars can't be choosers about where they live? Of course. But no doubt that's why he wants asylum in France extended to him.
- unicornfinder 7y agoTo be fair Russia is huge. The climate varies pretty wildly depending on where in Russia you are.
- amalcon 7y agoThere are a number of reasons that he might prefer not to live in Russia. An example obvious political reason: Russia has a lot of the same issues he criticizes in the US. He'd probably like to safely criticize Russia for these things as well. An example obvious personal reason: France is a much nicer country to live in (due to the weather if nothing else).
- meitham 7y agoHe would be safer though in Russia. It is far easier for the CIA to kidnap him illegally out of France, if they fail to extradite him legally. France might protest such an event a lot but it will unlikely lead to a military confrontation. The US would never likely do this in Russia.
- johnchristopher 7y agoWhat would be the consequences of the US illegally deporting Snowden from France like that? What would be printed in the newspapers?
- jessaustin 7y ago"Snowden goes missing while hiking in Alps; assumed to be buried in glacier crevasse"
- AstralStorm 7y agoPresuming he does something stupid like that, and this cover would ruin US goal of making an example.
- jessaustin 7y agoHe wouldn't have to choose to go hiking, or even venture within 100 km of the mountains, in order for that headline to be reported. USA has plenty of whistleblower examples anyway. We've tortured Chelsea Manning for years. Others who have been punished, to varying degrees, include Bill Binney, Reality Winner, and John Kiriakou. Presumably there are others of whom we're not aware. These people have done really small things to rouse the ire of the TLAs. How could they punish Snowden in a proportional fashion, anyway?
- Waterluvian 7y agoYes. And you can't shop around asylum as many of these comments imply. A country is going to ask, "show me the immediate danger you're in."
- jascii 7y agoYou can "shop around" as much as you want. Whether to grant asylum however, is entirely up to the host country.
- maxlybbert 7y agoRussia apparently granted him temporary asylum that they renew every few years.
- stevespang 7y agoHad a business in Russia, corruption is endemic, police everywhere expect bribes, mafia is everywhere. Sanctions are biting, Snowden's just looking for a better opportunity.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThere is no way any European government is strong enough to grant it. Still, important to rub this fact in their face regularly, since many base themselves solely on appearances. I hope we see more people like Snowden, even if that kind of work comes at huge costs. Overwhelming parts of the press failed in covering this topic too.
- yetiofparis 7y ago+1. Grant Snowden asylum and get a 10% tariff for free!
- _visgean 7y agoafaik you cant tariff single EU country without enacting the tariffs on the whole EEA, not sure if US would go in that direction...
- yetiofparis 7y agoI believe he could; that's why tariffman was considering taxing french wine. https://www.politico.eu/article/trump-says-tariffs-on-french-wine-depend-on-digital-tax-deal/ https://www.politico.eu/article/trump-says-tariffs-on-french...
- _visgean 7y agoyes, but the response to those tariffs would be similar tariffs from whole of EAA, no?
- jacquesm 7y agoIt should be clear by now that reason has left the building.
- ineedasername 7y agoUnless there's a trade treaty stating this, then the US is not beholden to EU rules. Even if there is a treaty, they generally all give the US the ability to ignore their provisions if it is an issue of national security, and it's under that claim that the current administration has issued tariffs already.
- hos234 7y agoHe should appeal to Trump. Pretty sure Trump would enjoy trolling the Left forever about it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PorterDuff 7y ago"He should appeal to Trump. Pretty sure Trump would enjoy trolling the Left forever about it." That's an interesting notion. Perhaps have Trump pardon him. Never gonna happen given who actually runs government. There are a ton of people who are pro-Snowden who are anti-Trump so I do like the idea of watching the uproar. Honestly, I think that kind of paradox is good for peoples' minds.
- nailer 7y agoThey just won't discuss it. Think of how little reporting this received a few weeks ago: https://apnews.com/cdda0a1c21124c4c8a2d68790d99bdab https://apnews.com/cdda0a1c21124c4c8a2d68790d99bdab
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoI'm sure on a personal level he would, but Snowden's legal status is a glaring reminder that the swamp has definitely not been drained, and I can't imagine Trump would appreciate a public reminder of that in an election year.
- tossAfterUsing 7y agommm yeah... he troll'd the left about assange for a minute, too. and now assange is drugged out of his mind & incommunicado. i'd not expect much from the US prez in terms of protection for weaklings like Assange & Snowden. better if they had some power to offer in trade, but who has that type of power?
- bongobongo 7y agoHe defected to Russia. There is nothing this guy does without Putin’s explicit approval and insistence.
- bognition 7y agoCitation please?
- bongobongo 7y agoYou need a citation for the fact that he lives in Russia on Putin’s good graces? You people are so stupid.
- dang 7y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- keymone 7y agohave you seen jon oliver trying to interview him in moscow [0]? i think it's naive to believe his actions aren't strictly controlled and approved by russia's intelligence agency. [0] https://youtu.be/XEVlyP4_11M?t=837 https://youtu.be/XEVlyP4_11M?t=837
- ivanhoe 7y agoStrange idea, considering what France and other EU countries did not so long ago to Ecuadorian diplomatic plane suspected to carry Snowden. Also a big problem for Snowden, because even if granted asylum it's highly unlikely that US would let him get to France. Lots of NATO countries in between to fly over. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evo_Morales_grounding_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evo_Morales_grounding_incident
- kaybe 7y agoWould the land route be safer?
- ineedasername 7y agoThat just means they'd have to charter a special flight that used only Russian, International, and French airspace.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoIDK, of all the choices France feels like an odd one. Is there some particular law(s) that would favor France over other countries? What about Cuba? It's certainly not Russia, and it's unlikely the USA and Cuba will kiss and make up any time soon. Or is this a PR stunt of sorts to sell more books? Note: I'm in favor of ES selling more books as I wish more people were aware of this issue.
- exabrial 7y agoI doubt Russia will let him leave.
- dennisgorelik 7y agoWhy would Trump administration want to prosecute Snowden?
- Simulacra 7y agoBesides the fact that he committed treason?
- dennisgorelik 7y agoSnowden leaks could have hurt Obama administration, but these leaks did NOT hurt Trump administration.
- Simulacra 7y agoI have never seen anything that has convinced me that snow needs anything but a traitor. I do hope he is brought to justice one day.
- humble_engineer 7y agoWhat is Snowden's problem with Russia? Its a beautiful country, the people there revere him as a hero, he's employed because of his talents as an engineer. The women there are beautiful, the common person is sincere and generous. Maybe he is constantly being harassed by Russian intelligence?
- SergeAx 7y agoGood try, comrade major, but nyet.
- humble_engineer 7y agoYou're a bigot.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- forgitude 7y agoI posted my opinion that taking him out is an option. It was flagged and then removed entirely. Hacker News should reconsider allowing me, an American citizen, to suggest that an international fugitive who admits to committing treason and refuses to come home should be taken out. Snowden’s actions are an ongoing act of war against the United States. It is lawful to consider taking him out, in my opinion. I should be allowed a voice to express that view on hn, without concern about censorship, at least in this case. This comment shouldn’t be censored. Please don’t flag it, moderators. Thanks. Edit: if you’re going to downvote, at least please provide a brief explanation.
- ncmncm 7y agoTalking about "treason" (i.e. execution) for exposing lawbreaking by spooks is enough.
- forgitude 7y agoThanks for replying. His actions certainly seem treasonous. He committed a serious attack against the NSA, the primary SIGINT conduit of the USIC and arguably the crown jewel.
- ncmncm 7y agoNo. The NSA committed a serious attack on the American public. No spooks were harmed by Snowden's actions. None of the information illegally collected was destroyed. None of the equipment illegally collecting information was damaged. Even the spooks on the take, using illegally obtained information for criminal extortion, were not exposed.
- Fnoord 7y ago> No. The NSA committed a serious attack on the American public. To which Snowden's action was a direct response. (And I am of the opinion that any post which suggests it is OK to murder another individual should be flagged because such is not lawful.)
- forgitude 7y agoIt’s not difficult to imagine that criminals wised up from the revelations of Edward Snowden. It’s not difficult to imagine that such data would be highly classified despite the programs’ existence being disclosed by Edward Snowden. If that’s the case, then a secret military trial is justified.