10 ms·
Banks are getting back into the business of building mortgage bonds
- onetimemanytime 7y agoThis time is different.
- Jonnax 7y agoSo what's the difference this time around? I can't imagine they're going "remember that investment product that crashed? Please buy it again. "
- gigatexal 7y agoThe fall will be even larger.
- gigatexal 7y agoPeople think that greed and an infinite backstop (the fed backing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guaranteeing ~50% of the US mortgages that these MBSes are made up of) is going to end any differently? I doubt it. It will just be bigger because the government mandated that they have larger reserves, they didn't mandate they change they way they think about capitalism or greed, etc. If you had a VC behind you with trillions that would fund your every idea even after you burned many untold billions you wouldn't change your thought process either, it's no different here in my opinion. And that opinion might be jaded or unrealistic but I don't think I am that far off. I don't have much faith in the measures that have been taken to prevent another 2008 style crash.
- dagw 7y agoThey're probably going "remember that investment product that made you a fuck-ton of money right up until the crash? Please buy version 2.0"
- chii 7y agoand get in early, and cash out while the goings' good, and let the late suckers fall. Even pyramid schemes are profitable at the beginning!
- mruts 7y agoAll securities have exposure to something that can result in them crashing. Despite this, people are still buying them. It would be pretty ridiculeous to say “remember the Great Depression? Don’t buy any stocks! It’s a scam!” So what’s the difference with MBSs? Also, what exactly about MBSs do you think makes them fundamentally unsound investments?
- ak39 7y agoChasing yields wherever they can find any. I read this in a tweet recently: "Buying stocks for yield, bonds for capital gains".
- appleflaxen 7y agoAnd why wouldn't they? they lost some money but mostly got bailed out at the taxpayer's expense, and nobody went to jail. If we haven't made the disincentives stronger (we haven't) and if they were inadequate the first time (they were), why are we expecting bankers to make different choices? This is the expected outcome.
- windexh8er 7y ago> And why wouldn't they? they lost some money but mostly got bailed out at the taxpayer's expense, and nobody went to jail. Let's just clarify - American citizens lost $12.8Bn. [0] That money didn't evaporate, it got funneled back into many of the banks and auto manufacturers as a hand out. Some banks that took risk had little to no downside and we know that there were a continuation of bonus payouts to executives by banks that took bailout trailing the debacle. The US had a chance to wipe out some of the hogs of the market but instead chose to feed them. [0] https://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daily-ticker/2008-financial-crisis-cost-americans-12-8-trillion-145432501.html https://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daily-ticker/2008-financial-...
- mruts 7y agoWhile in principle I don’t ever believe in bailouts of any kind, not bailing out the banks would have led to an apocalyptic situation probably worse than the Great Depression. Sometimes those in power have a responsibility to the people instead of some idealistic morality.
- luckylion 7y agoThere's the alternative of nationalizing them before bailing them out if they are too big to fail. When they are stable again, you can put them back on the market. With the 2008 setup, there is little incentive not to repeat it.
- mywittyname 7y agoWe could have bailed the companies out while tossing the executives who facilitated this crisis into the gulags.
- magna7 7y agoBanks gotta make money somehow in a low interest world.
- SamuelAdams 7y ago> Banks today are buying both mortgages that are eligible to be sold to Fannie and Freddie as well as ones that aren’t because they are too large or they are considered riskier—often because they use alternative documentation to approve the borrower. I'm really curious what this "alternative documentation" is. This was part of the problem leading up to 2008: banks did not verify people's information. Some people received mortgages after putting their pet's name on the paperwork. We might not be there yet, but it's a slippery slope.
- adeelk93 7y agoAlternative documentation tends to be for borrowers that don't have good verification of income (like tax returns or paystubs). Often self-employed borrowers, or borrowers with large amounts of assets but little income.
- tialaramex 7y agoThese bonds are fine if they're rated properly. On the other hand, if your rating system is not functioning properly (as was true in 2008) then any product that needs rating is suspect, only investments whose provenance you can directly investigate yourself are safe in that case. Maybe we can blind the rating system? If Standard & Poor can't tell whether this instrument they're rating was created by HSBC or me in my basement, they may take a few seconds more to consider whether the scent of shit is because it is in fact just shit in a thin paper shell. And if you blind them but they still don't give true ratings you can trivially exploit that to fill the market with highly rated shit, destroying the market but leaving the real economy largely untouched. Rinse and repeat until all the dumb money is sucked into your pocket.
- JackFr 7y agoThe yield on the bond is a pretty good indicator that something is amiss. If you're making 100bps over other AAA paper, it's unlikely that you got a really good deal. It's more likely what you're holding isn't really AAA.
- Timothycquinn 7y agoYou are correct that the ratings system is fundamental to the breakdown of these systems. I don't believe we really fixed those corruption issues. I'm looking forward to seeing some analysts of the ratings from independents vs S&P etc. We also cannot downplay the significance of speculation systems themselves. There needs to be more burdens put on such financial mechanisms to prevent them from getting out of hand like in 2008.
- cm2187 7y agoThe problem is that investors do not want to pay for independant research, particularly a rating where it would require the agency to do a lot of due dilligence on a transaction rather than simply rely on audited financial statements as they usually do for a regular company.
- xchaotic 7y ago
- lefstathiou 7y agoHave any two financial crises happened for the same reasons ? I’m in my early 30s and can recall the following in the US. All for different reasons which would lead me to believe that government regulation post crisis can be effective at avoiding the same crisis from repeating (while arguably could cause a new one): - mortgage crisis 07 - dot com 00 - savings and loans late 80s - oil crisis late 70s
- Torwald 7y ago> Have any two financial crises happened for the same reasons ? Yes, all of them for the same reason: FIAT currency instead of real money.
- empath75 7y agoWhat caused the many many financial panics of the 19th century and the Great Depression?
- xadhominemx 7y agoYes, that’s were no banking panics before the end of Bretton Woods in 1971
- naravara 7y agoWhat’s “real” money? We going back to trading livestock? You realize even hard specie only has value because of government fiat declaring that it’s appropriate to use for public debts right?
- Torwald 7y ago> What’s “real” money? Money based on value of some kind, as opposed to debt.
- naravara 7y agoWho decides what "value" is or what things should be values at? The whole point of money is to make unspecified commitments for future production. If you want direct exchange of value then you're bartering. The only reason we ever decided on gold or silver as the store of value was because kings made it so.
- afpx 7y agoOf course they would. Lots of people made loads of money the last time, and no one went to prison. Seems like an obvious thing to try if you're a smart and low-empathy person.
- helpPeople 7y agoWould banks be responsible if the Fed wasn't a lender of last resort? I wonder if thousands of years from now people will look back on our economics like we did to the Romans- "how could they not understand inflation?"
- sambull 7y agoThese banks have been at it awhile. They've spun off 'rating' companies to check these mortgage packages, private not their internal departments. They've used those companies to run their custom models against fannie mae packages (gs against fannie mae i'm 100% of was witness to), with out that other knowing, and other banks. Whatever is going on, they've been prepping to make sure it happens with high velocity.
- neffy 7y agoFor the people who thing that there is nothing inherently wrong about MBS. Unfortunately, that´s not the case. When banks sell off their loans, which is what an MBS is, it fundamentally changes the ratio of money:debt originating from the banking system. In a non-MBS banking system, there is roughly the same amount of deposit money flowing around as there are loans. In an MBS using banking system, there are significantly more loans being created - unlike the initial creation of a loan by a bank, the sale of the MBS does not create any additional money. So the underlying economy may or may not need the extra debt, but creating it this way is anything but side effect free. Granted neither is creating normal bank debt given the money supply side effects. The evidence of history suggests that an economy can get away with small amounts of this, but at some point there is too big an imbalance of debt to money, and this causes solvency issues in paying back the debt. And that´s when everything all goes terribly wrong. But it´s a $1 trillion a year industry in the USA, so perish the thought that minor issues like systemic stability should be allowed to interfere with that. On the plus side, China introduced them a few years ago as well, so it will be very interesting to see what happens there as things play out. For a deeply depressing paper, considering when(2000) and where (US Federal Reserve) it was written, see: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0378426699000527 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S037842669...
- rb808 7y ago> In a non-MBS banking system, there is roughly the same amount of deposit money flowing around as there are loans. Because when you take out a mortgage it gets deposited immediately in someone elses account. The mechanics are effectively the same as for non-intermediated (MBS) debt.
- jblwps 7y agoMaybe not literally, but don't regulations stipulate how many liquid assets a lender must have on hand? Even if the ratio isn't 1:1, it's bounded, unlike an unbounded MBS market. IANA finance expert, but I suppose you could bound the MBS market with some kind of maximum-degrees-removed-from-real-assets metric, and regulate based off of that. But that, to me, would seem unwise since that metric would likely be fairly abstract and therefore dis-preferred as a basis of regulation.
- KaiserPro 7y agoThere is nothing inherently wrong with mortgage bonds. The principle is simple and fine, chop up a bunch of mortgages from all over, with the same risk profile and pool them together. That way local environmental factors don't cause the whole investment to go south. Basically raid for investment What is a problem, and one that still hasn't fully been tackled is the industrial scale fraud that sold delinquent, or knowingly under par mortgages as high quality instruments. Through all the use of fancy words, every seems to have got the impression that commoditized mortgages investments are complex, using words like "tranche", "proprietary instruments" and blended risk. its really not, get a bunch of mortgages, shove them in a blender and make mortgage sausage. So long as there isn't widespread and systematic fraud, then everything will be fine. However considering that there haven't been large scale arrests, I don't hold out much hope.
- bob33212 7y agoRight, this time around people will be careful to keep these bonds off their book but still get a commission for selling them
- michaelt 7y ago> There is nothing inherently wrong with mortgage bonds. If Bank X is sloppy about qualifying customers for mortgages but keeps the mortgages on their own books, the sloppy behaviour will bite them in the ass. Thus, they are incentivised to be careful with no external oversight needed. The moment it's possible to sell the mortgages on, that incentive is removed.
- fbonetti 7y ago> The moment it's possible to sell the mortgages on, that incentive is removed. It's not. Investors in the secondary market don't want to buy shitty subprime loans. The only reason lenders originate these awful loans is because the government incentivizes them to do so by guaranteeing to buy them via Fannie and Freddie. Fannie and Freddie buy half of all US mortgages, and in doing so dramatically distort interest rates and the amount of liquidity in the housing market. They also guarantee these loans, something a lender would never do, which is why mortgage-backed securities were considered "safe" leading up to the crash in 2008. If Fannie and Freddie didn't exist, subprime loans would either not exist or would have dramatically higher interest rates in order to properly protect against the risk of default.