12 ms·
If you have something important to say, don't say it in a paywalled publication
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- disgruntledphd2 7y agoI completely disagree with this statement. I mean, I get where he's coming from (reach is reduced by imposing barriers to the article). But on the other hand, news costs money. You can argue about how much it should cost, but journalism isn't free. Personally, I pay for 4-5 newspapers (which is too much), but after the sh*tstorm of the past three years (Brexit, elections etc), I felt that it was worth the money. It's also a little ironic for someone as rich as Paul Graham to be arguing against paywalls (like he could pay for every news-subscription and never notice the cost). In summation, Carthego delenda est! (or news is worth paying for, at least).
- DannyB2 7y agoThe problem with (some) paywalls is that they also advertise. Either advertise and make it free, or have a paywall subscription model. I get it that news isn't free. What is strange about the struggle is that in the 21st century a big news organization can have a bigger subscriber base than ever before. So why don't they? What is broken?
- TallGuyShort 7y agoWhat's broken is what you said in your first statement: even if I pay, they tend to also advertise. I also used to pay for a number of local / regional newspapers, but me paying them didn't get me quality journalism in a single transaction, it just got me better access to click-bait a lot of the time, and I got to feel good that maybe I was kinda supporting good press. (I also had a big problem with the fact that despite only wanting a digital subscription, I still got paper copies at my house, but because I wasn't supposed to, I had no way to stop it when I left town and I was stuck with a dozen papers on my driveway when I returned - nice and safe for me. I had to resort to borderline illegal harassing behavior to get them to stop.) There are high quality publications that I think do consistently do the original research and due diligence behind their reporting, but they're mostly just not of interest to me anymore because they're national. I'm overloaded with political stuff in my face from other sources anyway - I'm happier just not reading good commentary on it in my spare time. I find BBC is a good source of world news, but they never ask me for money..
- smacktoward 7y ago> I find BBC is a good source of world news, but they never ask me for money.. Because they get their funding by the taxpayers of the United Kingdom, who quite generously allow the rest of us to benefit from the product they paid for. But if we're advocating state-sponsored media, remember that in that field the BBC's commitment to real journalism makes it kind of an outlier. Most state-sponsored media outlets are just propaganda mills for the regime that sponsors them.
- smacktoward 7y ago> Either advertise and make it free, or have a paywall subscription model. I don't understand this fundamentalism. Newspapers and magazines that charged subscription fees have also carried advertising for literally the entire modern history of newspapers and magazines. Why is it suddenly a Fundamental Rule that they can only do one or the other? Who made that decision?
- marcosdumay 7y agoWeb advertising is evil. If I'm paying someone, I won't accept they imposing it to me. Print advertising is merely annoying, and only to the extent that it's numerous. A bit of advertising in a printed media is even funny. As long as web advertisers don't stop being evil, both situations will keep being different.
- chc 7y agoThis is circular reasoning. You essentially answered the question "Why is it OK in one context and not in another?" with "Because it's OK in one context and not in the other." To break the circle: Why is web advertising categorically evil when print advertising isn't?
- JohnFen 7y agoMy answer to that question is simple: print advertising doesn't spy on me. Online advertising does.
- marcosdumay 7y agoKeep in mind that news was (almost worldwide) already in a downtrend before the web. It's more due to low quality content and lack of differentiation by distributing the same low quality text brought from a 3rd party that everybody else. I see some media working to recover their image nowadays, but low quality is still the norm.
- piinbinary 7y agoI had taken the statement as referring to scientific publications. There, the publisher isn't the one paying for the work. (Perhaps I don't view news as having something important to say) However, your point is interesting - sometimes you do have to charge in order to say things effectively. For example, you generally have to charge for a book to cover the cost of putting it together.
- jaspergilley 7y ago> I pay for 4-5 newspapers (which is too much), but after the sh*tstorm of the past three years (Brexit, elections etc), I felt that it was worth the money. This isn't a coincidence: to a large extent, the last few years haven't been THAT remarkable, but news outlets will inevitably cover things as if they're very remarkable, because that's what fuels subscriptions. See also: http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/hatethenews http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/hatethenews
- username90 7y ago> Personally, I pay for 4-5 newspapers (which is too much), but after the sh*tstorm of the past three years (Brexit, elections etc), I felt that it was worth the money. You don't think it is possible that those things could have been avoided if people had better access to high quality information from for example newspapers and scientific studies? Currently a majority of people don't think it is worth it to pay for quality information so they only consume the poor quality crap you get for free. I guess this situation is fine if you want to sit in your ivory tower and lament over the ignorant masses ruining everything, but if you actually want to solve the issue you should clamor for more quality information being made free because in a democracy it is the ignorant masses whose opinions actually matter. "But it doesn't matter, those people are too dumb to understand!" you say, well totally blocking them from accessing information is a good way to ensure that the situation will never improve.
- DannyB2 7y agoAdvertising ruins every medium it ever touches. Newspapers. Billboards. Magazines. Radio. TV. Cable TV. VHS / DVD. Usenet. Email. The Web. Online news. Smart phones. Streaming video. It is a watershed decision to have ads or a subscription model. Ads will doom your platform / media. A subscription can create high quality content, if there is market demand for your content. Do not do both subscription AND ads. That devolves quickly. Just IMO.
- grumpy8 7y agoViewed from a different angle "Advertising powers every medium it ever touches."
- effingwewt 7y agoViewed from yet another angle "Advertising forms parasitic bonds and makes whatever it attaches to dependent on it for survival"
- ken 7y agoBut nobody likes advertising. People like that the product is free, and advertising is merely an unpleasant side effect. Your statement sounds to me about like saying “Exhaust fumes power cars”.
- greggman2 7y agoI like advertising. I don't like distractions and I don't like being tracked but I enjoy seeing ads for products in fields I like. I'm old though and throughout the 80s and early 90s subscribed to several magazines in large part to read the ads. I loved the ads in Byte, Creative Computing, Compute!, Wired, the Game Developer Magazine. I learned about all kinds of products I wanted. If all ads on the net somehow were (a) related to the content and (b) no more than static pictures and a link with no tracking I'd still enjoy them.
- JohnFen 7y ago
- darepublic 7y agoI find it funny that when I try to look at the replies I get a membership wall off. No I don't want to sign up for some new thing just to read some glib self-righteous twitter comments
- farisjarrah 7y agoI don't know if the author of the tweet actually thought through the implications of what they tweeted. They have yet to provide a sensible response to things like book authorship and journalism. Does anyone really think someone like Donald Knuth shouldn't be paid for the work he's done on the Art of Computer Programming?
- CDSlice 7y agoWell, based off of some of my friends history of pirating books they think are too expensive, yes.
- deaps 7y agoI think something like the following makes a bit more sense: "If you have information that you want as many people as possible to know, it's a disservice to yourself to put it behind a paywall" Of course, I don't think that most people read into statements the same way the 'ycombinator crowd' does. So maybe they read it that way anyway.
- JohnFen 7y agoThat was how I read it as well. It seems like a logical and self-evident statement.
- saagarjha 7y agoI’m curious if Paul is referring to online news, academic publications, or both.
- username90 7y agoDo you think that news is important? Then he is referring to news. Do you think academic publications are important? Then he is referring to academic publications. Of course most news and most academic publications are not important so are not covered, please monetize them as much as you want. But the important stuff should be open. I think that is his argument. Example: Someone writes a very good article on climate change which could sway many ignorant persons. If it was behind a paywall then you ensure that only those who already believes in climate change will bother to pay for it and read it making the entire article mostly worthless to the world.
- your-nanny 7y agoOnly context this makes sense in is research paid for from public purse.
- davidw 7y agoIt'd be nice if editorials weren't paywalled.
- chooseaname 7y agoIs it? I get the idealistic point of view here. You certainly don't want to keep important news from people who can't pay. But I'm not convinced this should be the rule.
- Kalium 7y agoAgreed. Important can mean a great many diverse things. If what you have to say is important, but your audience is small and the best way to reach them is a paywalled publication, then this may be the best way to reach them
- raegis 7y agoThe Wall Street Journal is mostly paywalled. However, their editorial to support Brett Kavanaugh's nomination was deliberately not paywalled. All good propagandists know this rule.
- hhs 7y agoAlso, the Economist and the Financial Times are heavily paywalled. Sometimes, articles are not. I'm curious how rules work with respect to which pieces to "give for free"?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m4r35n357 7y agoFake news is never paywalled.
- luckyorlame 7y agoHa, that's fake news right there.
- chc 7y agoIs it? I'm trying to think of actual fake news sites with a paywall and I'm drawing a blank. They generally seem to want to cast as wide a net as possible in hopes of catching some gullible rubes and selling them nutritional supplements.
- joecot 7y agoThis is one of the biggest problems with news currently. Big breaking story about US politics? New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post all have important articles about it. You find them linked in Google News, reddit, Hacker News, and Facebook. And they're all behind paywalls. But if you get your "news" from Fox News, Infowars, or even farther extreme sites like Stormfront.... it's free and instantly accessible. This causes some serious problems.
- smacktoward 7y agoTech's position on the issue of how to fund journalism online is fundamentally incoherent. After 20 years of experiments, there are only two models that have been consistently proven to work: restricting access to paying customers only (a.k.a. paywalling), and open access combined with heavy, invasive advertising (both the traditional kind, and more insidious kinds like clickbait headlines and sponsored content). That's it. Those are the only models anyone's found that don't lead to bankruptcy. The problem is that tech insists that both these models are morally unacceptable. Put up a paywall, and you'll get a parade of tech influencers denouncing you as a greedy elitist. Don't put up a paywall, and you'll get the same parade of tech influencers denouncing you as a purveyor of spyware and clickbait. OK, fine. So what then does tech propose these publications do, exactly? Are they supposed to just lay down and die? Because unless someone can come up with a third model that actually works, that's the only option left after you rule out every other option that works. You can see this incoherence play out in every HN comment thread about journalism. The New York Times consistently produces excellent journalism; but they keep that journalism behind a paywall, so they are Evil. Buzzfeed doesn't have a paywall, but it produces lots of clickbait and sponsored content[1], so they are Evil too. The only publications that aren't Evil, it turns out, are the ones that are going out of business. [1] Although they also produce an increasing amount of very good journalism these days alongside it. Which, of course, the clickbait and sponsored content pay for.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoIt's important to also recognize that I often see sentiments on HN (not that this is a majority, but often enough that it isn't ultra-downvoted) that journalism as an industry is dying, as it should be because journalism is fundamentally flawed. That is to say, yes, people do believe journalism should die.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PretzelFisch 7y agoThere is the NPR, PBS and wikipedia model. Not for profit companies that live off of the public's donations. Also the BBC model
- aphextim 7y agoR.I.P. Aaron Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz
- luckyorlame 7y agoHa, Twitter is a paywall publication! You're privacy is the payment!!!
- luckyorlame 7y agothere is nothing wrong with paying for information. there is nothing wrong with paying for the requests of someone else's labors / effort.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoOne of the problems with putting important information behind a paywall is that it creates an informational divide between the Haves and Have Nots. This deepens class friction and helps both further leave behind the lower classes and also potentially foment bloody revolution because they aren't getting the memo about important discoveries because they literally can't afford the memo, so it worsens the differences between the mental models of the upper and lower classes. This goes really bad places. I don't know what the solution is, but I generally agree with the sentiment, even though as a writer I'm caught in the crossfire here and can't pay my bills because ads are basically dead (and morally/logistically problematic in certain problem spaces) and trying to support writing via other avenues is challenging at best. Most writing pays rather poorly. For every JK Rowling or Stephen King there's an army of underpaid nobodies barely scraping by. But I'm not willing to paywall my blogs. It wouldn't accomplish anything good to deny access to poor people who can't afford to pay. We genuinely need to find ways to fund good writing and pay for the costs involved in disseminating information. Local papers are going out of business left and right and it's a real problem. But it's also a very real problem to create a system where only the people who already have money are allowed to know our latest, greatest hits of information. Among other things, it also means new ideas cannot be effectively challenged by people from diverse backgrounds, which weakens the information ecosystem.
- seem_2211 7y agoI don't agree. Even the most expensive newspaper (probably the FT) can be bought for $3.00 or so. That's hardly prohibitive. Until very recently, being illiterate was common, so it's not as if there was a paradise 150 years ago where everyone was an engaged citizen.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNo, but my understanding is that when the Romans published the code of law publicly somewhere such that anyone capable of reading was capable of knowing their rights without taking the word of their lord and master for it, literacy rates among the lower classes went up dramatically.
- HillaryBriss 7y agoit always cracks me up when I visit the website of a "very serious newspaper" and see a critically important op-ed headline about "saving democracy" or "defending life on planet earth" but cannot read the article because they paywalled it. maybe their message isn't really that important?
- ThinkBeat 7y agoJournalism costs money and I am willing to, and do pay for it. Ivestigative journalism costs even more. Yet it is critical for the existence of a democracy. "First, if you want reliable information – pay good money for it. If you get your news for free, you might well be the product. Suppose a shady billionaire offered you the following deal: ‘I will pay you $30 a month, and in exchange, you will allow me to brainwash you for an hour every day, installing in your mind whichever political and commercial biases I want.’ Would you take the deal? Few sane people would. So the shady billionaire offers a slightly different deal: ‘You will allow me to brainwash you for one hour every day, and in exchange, I will not charge you anything for this service.’ Now the deal suddenly sounds tempting to hundreds of millions of people. Don’t follow their example." 21 Lessons for the 21st Century by Yuval Noah Harari In my opinion, the business press WSJ, and Finacial Times (both expensive) are among the best places for news. Both try hard to be accurate. A lot of rich people read them and make decisions because of information. If it is not accurate that is a real problem. (I am here excluding the editorial pages of the WSJ which exists on an entirely different planet). It also has the added benefit for me of much less nonsense. Sports, celebrity gossip, and all the fluff that takes up way to much space in many news publications.
- konschubert 7y agoIs it possible that he’s talking about scientific journals? That’s how I understood it.
- ElFitz 7y agoI thought he was talking about the people posting on Medium
- leereeves 7y agoThere's absolutely no reason to pay for scientific journals. None of the money paid for journals supports research, it all goes to the publishers, who do not share with the scientists.
- kiliantics 7y ago
- ken 7y agoI assume this is just a Tweet with the title as content, but all I see on my phone is a Twitter logo. I guess their JavaScript fest doesn’t always work. Don’t stop there. When you have something important to say on the web, it’s wrong to use anything other than a plain web page. (CMV.)
- vkou 7y agoI'm assuming that anybody who has ever written a book is in the wrong, then? Because last I checked, books are paywalled...
- crawfordcomeaux 7y agoKill money through developing needs-based giving economies. Then this becomes a non-issue because paywalls will be seen as quaint toys used by the people who still enjoy playing with money, even though it's worthless.
- cameronbrown 7y agoEvery attempt to "kill money" has ended in bloodshed.
- crawfordcomeaux 7y agoThat simply means we've found ways that don't work and aren't peaceful. In computer science, we call these anti-patterns.
- cameronbrown 7y agoYou're amusing basic human nature (competition, survival of the fittest, nepotism, and yes, greed) can be overcome.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- crawfordcomeaux 7y agoThese things are cultural myths. Science doesn't back them up. Some cultures practice these things, some don't. Also, I assume all cultures can change.
- cameronbrown 7y agoThen why do we see the same trends over and over in history? Just because we're more technologically advanced today, I don't think we're any different as humans. There's survival instinct in all of us and denying it is just ignorant.
- seem_2211 7y agoAdvertising being bad as a YC take is the most hilariously out of touch thing possible. How many people commenting on this thread work at Google or Facebook, which are the biggest ad machines this planet has ever seen.
- simplecomplex 7y agoOh shut up Paul. Get over yourself. Also, put your money where your mouth is and ban paywalled articles on HN.
- Myrmornis 7y agoWhy does Paul Graham keep saying that the book "Hackers & Painters" is available for free on his website? I don't seem to be able to find it and neither do any of the other people who are discussing the issue with him. https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1172557323270840323 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1172557323270840323 There's this, but that's a very short book if that's it: http://paulgraham.com/hp.html http://paulgraham.com/hp.html
- retsibsi 7y agoThe book is an essay collection, so I think he's saying each essay from the book is available on the 'essays' section of his website.
- pessimizer 7y agoThe idea that somebody should pay to hear me say something I think is important is weird, and the idea that if I have something I think everyone should hear, I should ask them to pay to hear it is weird. I don't have a problem if that simple statement ruins the business model of the 10,000 court stenographers masquerading as journalists, but traditionally, journalism was done by people trying to spread ideas: either the people who came up with those ideas, or the wealthy sponsors of the people who came up with those ideas. Now, we almost exclusively hear from people being sponsored by the wealthy while people independent of them are denigrated as an unprofessional fringe, and we're expected to feel guilt if we don't pay for it. I send money to the publications that investigate the things I want investigated, who make the arguments that I already agree with, or who teach me things that I want to know, or who just make me smile. I don't even read half the publications I donate to; they're not for me, I already agree, and I don't need to hear the arguments because I make the same arguments. Whereas plenty of the publications I do read I think the world would be better without, and I not only don't want to donate to them, I wish I could somehow take money away from them. I don't care about their suffering. If they don't like it, they should either find something else to do, or something important to say that people would want to pay to keep them saying NOT to hear. They're not the same thing. And no amount of corporate hectoring done through employees is going to change that. NYT editorial columnists should be paying us.
- tptacek 7y ago"I get so much value from this, it's wrong that I have to pay for it."
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI guess I am one of those people who hope that if you really say something important it actually will end up getting known whether you are paywalled or not. I also must admit though that this is a feeling and probably countered by statistical evidence.
- ozymandias12 7y ago>"If you have something important to say, don't say it in a paywalled publication, NO MATTER much they're paying you." There. I've fixed that tweet for you.
- tryitnow 7y agoI think there's an important point here, but twitter is a terrible medium for making that point. Maybe if you have something important to say, don't say it on twitter.
- retsibsi 7y agoTwitter is basically an excuse to make pithy, sweeping pronouncements rather than nuanced or detailed arguments. An essay on this topic might be interesting and useful, but as a 16-word tweet it's just empty. "Don't publish important things behind paywalls" is a very easy moral principle for a rich person to adopt. That doesn't mean it's false -- but to make the point convincingly, one would have to take the perspective of people who have strong reasons to publish behind paywalls in the first place, and explain why they can and should resist these pressures.
- Data_Junkie 7y agoThen Paul should do something about waaaaay to many links on Hacker News to paywalls. It's killing this site.