16 ms·
Toyota is trying to put solar panels on a Prius to charge battery during the day
- mdorazio 7y agoThe title doesn't really tell you what they're actually doing. Toyota is basically running a program to put 34% efficient solar panels on a Prius to charge the battery during the day. Using typical panels on roof, hood, and trunk only nets you 4-6 miles / day of solar energy if you do the math. They're increasing surface area of panels here and using what are probably multi-junction (i.e. really expensive) cells for a fair boost in potential range / day. The claim of 18 miles per day of sun seems like a stretch and in actual production and real-world conditions you'd be more likely to get three quarters of that, but I could be wrong. Still impressive, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoOk, we'll use your wording for the title above. Thanks!
- dannyw 7y agoI think any bit helps. If solar panels will ROI over the lifetime of vehicle ownership, then that’s awesome!
- msandford 7y agoHow far is the average commute? There are a lot of places where this level of additional range for "free" could potentially halve your charging needs. Might also mean that people start looking for uncovered airport parking. Or that it's a lot harder to get really stranded with an electric car. Even at 100% efficiency (which we'll never get) I think electric cars will still have to charge off of something. But dragging the panels around with you so that you always have some kind of charging seem pretty reasonable.
- wtallis 7y ago> But dragging the panels around with you so that you always have some kind of charging seem pretty reasonable. It might prevent the worst case scenario of being stranded in a desert without fuel. But for everyday driving, dragging around that extra weight has a real cost, which could quite plausibly outweigh the benefits to everyday driving. Remember, our auto industry has moved to the point where spare tires are starting to become uncommon and full-size spares are almost unheard of. The market isn't trying to optimize for the worst case scenario.
- mattigames 7y agoYou may be underestimating how much people dread chores like manually plugging their car to the electric outlet, and many people don't have those special garages with chargers on them, and if the house is a rented one modifying it is out of question (and renting is not only a poor people problem, a lot of people pay an insane amount of money renting, ask anyone in NYC).
- wtallis 7y ago> You may be underestimating how much people dread chores like manually plugging their car to the electric outlet, I'm simply assuming that, for the foreseeable future, solar panels on your car won't put a noticeable dent in the frequency of those chores compared to with a current production Prius. If you can already go for two weeks of commuting and grocery runs without topping off the gas tank in your hybrid, stretching that by another day or two doesn't meaningfully change the ownership experience even if it does have a long-term impact on the economics of owning that vehicle.
- luminiferous 7y agoWhen I first read your comment, I thought that there was no way that solar panels could be heavy enough to affect your mileage. So I did some quick calculations. Estimates of solar panel weight I found say that solar panels tend to weigh 2-4 lb per sqft.[1] Note that estimate is for roof-mounted solar panels, but if anything, car-based solar panels should be lighter. A Prius has dimensions of 180"x69".[2] The sqft of the solar panels will be less than that, since the panels don't cover the windshield, and they don't go all the way to the edge of the hood, etc. That's 86.25 sqft, so that puts an upper bound on the weight of the solar panels at 345 lb. If we assume the lighter end of the scale for solar panel weight, that becomes 172.5 lb. That's 6-11% of the curb weight of a Prius. That's pretty substantial! For reference, a 50 lb spare tire kit can reduce fuel economy (and presumably mileage, for EVs) by 1%.[3] Although that does imply that you're breaking even if the solar panels can increase your range by ~5%, not accounting for the weight. If you live somewhere like Arizona, that might work out. If you live in Seattle, maybe not. [1] https://sunmetrix.com/is-my-roof-suitable-for-solar-panels-and-what-is-the-weight-of-a-solar-panel/#targetText=On%20average%2C%20solar%20panels%20and,acceptable%20limits%20of%20your%20roof https://sunmetrix.com/is-my-roof-suitable-for-solar-panels-a.... [2] https://www.toyota.com/prius/features/dimensions/ https://www.toyota.com/prius/features/dimensions/ [3] https://www.tirerack.com/tires/tiretech/techpage.jsp?techid=216 https://www.tirerack.com/tires/tiretech/techpage.jsp?techid=...
- delfinom 7y agoThat's the thing. Unless the option costs ~$1k extra, you will never ROI until after at least 10 years. In that time you'll be paying for replacing the glass on the solar panel when a rock inevitably cracks it.
- angrygoat 7y agoThe claimed range would meet easily meet my mileage five days of the week – it's a big win! I'm in a fairly sunny city in Australia so I imagine I'd get a decent charge much of the time. I don't think this'd work so well in say, Vancouver, but then every place has to use the renewable energy sources locally available :-)
- sandworm101 7y agoIf you don't park in the shade. If your parking space doesn't tilt slightly away from the the sun. For the same money you would be far better off installing some solar panels permanently somewhere along with a battery that can transfer that power into the car when you get home. Or, better yet, skip the batteries and plug the solar panels into the grid. The more solar panels attached to the grid the better. Anyone who cares about the environment would put panels on their house, lawn, driveway and pets long before their car. This is a fashion statement, a fancy paint job. (And most people would be shocked at how much solar power is available in Vancouver. Without dust in the air, droughts most summers, and the lack of mountains to the south, Vancouver does fairly well in terms of solar.)
- mianos 7y ago+1 for the idea of putting solar panels on the pets. Pretty sure of the same marketing people who think putting solar cells on a car roof will be cost effective would love that idea.
- sydd 7y agoMost people who live in big cities in the EU dont have a house (and they make up >50% of the population). They live in apartments. Isnt this the case for the USA too?
- sandworm101 7y agoAnd those cars would be parked underground, or at least on city streets ... not the best places for solar.
- 7y ago
- not_a_cop75 7y ago5 * 365 > 1500 miles. I'd take that. And if I perchance ran out of fuel and battery, it'd be nice to know I could eat at a cafe for an hour in the afternoon and probably get it to hobble to a gas station. That's the kind of peace of mind that's worth maybe an extra grand.
- saagarjha 7y agoI'd expect full solar panels to cost significantly more than $1000.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoWell retail, sure. You think the largest auto maker in the world is paying retail on everything?
- ctack 7y agoBut the public will be paying retail.
- jacquesm 7y agoNo, the public will pay much more than that because it is now a car part. Brand specific car parts are sold way above what an equivalent part would cost at retail. There was an interesting business model that consisted of buying brand new cars and breaking them up for parts.
- Ensorceled 7y agoWhy did you say "No"? Clearly it will only be more expensive if you buy it as a part instead of as a car. Your own line explains it to yourself if you think about it: "There was an interesting business model that consisted of buying brand new cars and breaking them up for parts."
- killjoywashere 7y ago
- crooked-v 7y agoIt seems like this could be useful for making electric cars more practical for apartment dwellers, in that a car in an open lot would stay indefinitely topped up when unattended and unplugged instead of the omnipresent worry of the battery running down.
- flukus 7y agoYeah, a lot of people inner city won't drive everyday and often only have on street parking. Or they'll be renting somewhere that has garages without charging stations. Anything that can minimize the number necessary trips to a charging station or eliminate them completely for people that only drive once or twice would a week be a big win.
- benj111 7y ago"renting somewhere that has garages" I still don't think solar panels will help in this situation.
- crooked-v 7y agoA lot of city garages have an open roof level.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoGetting those people to use a shared pool of electric cars would be a bigger win. That low utilisation means the initial environmental cost of producing the car is not amortised over nearly as many trips.
- de_watcher 7y agoYea, if you've got a 15 minutes commute then you charge your Leaf2/Zoe/Ioniq not twice a month but once in three weeks.
- elif 7y ago4-6 miles? you only read the first paragraph, where the author summarized previous efforts. "If the car is driven four days a week for a maximum of 50 kilometers a day, there’s no need to plug into an outlet, NEDO’s Yamazaki said." This car maintains equilibrium at 124 miles per week, so basically anyone with a commute with a 1-way distance up to 12.4 miles, or 15.5 miles if you work from home one day a week, would not need to use a charger.
- mdorazio 7y agoI think you didn’t read my full comment.
- thehappypm 7y agoI just bought a new car. I was interested in a Tesla but don’t have a parking spot with an outlet, among other deterrents, that kept me from spending the initial $10k. My commute is about 8 miles per day. If a solar panel on a Prius could give me an almost free commute I would have bought it in a heartbeat.
- masklinn 7y ago> Using typical panels on roof, hood, and trunk only nets you 4-6 miles / day of solar energy if you do the math. FWIW there's a project to actually do that: https://lightyear.one https://lightyear.one This is an outgrowth from the WSC, the founders are alumni from TU/e. Now the car is really covered in panels (~5 sqm), it looks like they just replaced the rear window by panels (as well as panelling the hood, trunk and roof obviously). IIRC they were claiming up to 12km/h solar charging (as in you could crawl along on solar alone on sunny days). According to their calculator thingie, they're expecting about 5km/day in midwinter aberdeen (on average obviously).
- agumonkey 7y agoThat has some value. How many people get stuck for a simple flat battery ? Having a way to avoid that is pretty nice to me. Depending on how costly is the option.
- whatshisface 7y agoI bet you could get a more useful vehicle by making something more efficient than a Prius - sacrificing some niceties of course. This is a marketing stunt for the Prius brand, but it makes me wonder what you could get if you relaxed that constraint.
- dannyw 7y agoThe Prius is on the leaderboards for MPG. I don’t buy your argument.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 7y agoWould it be on a leaderboard that included empty frames with no air conditioning units? The Prius is nowhere near the best efficiency you can get with a vehicle. Check out the Wikipedia page on solar cars for a couple of pictures: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_car https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_car
- serf 7y agoI guess leaderboard is defined by "Cars that have sustained the rigors of NTSB-style testing to determine roadworthiness and are available for sale to the mass public." Cars are nowhere near efficient, they are just in a nice point between practicality and efficiency for their given use-cases.
- a_imho 7y agoDisagree with the nice point unless we disregard all the externalized costs.
- icebraining 7y agoIf you don't turn it on, all the AC unit does is weight you down a bit, no? Googling a bit, the AC-specific parts weight about 20kg. A Prius weights about 1300kg, so the AC is about 2% of its weight. Doesn't seem exactly life changing. In fact, in a BEV your problem is the 500kg battery, which those solar cars lack. You'd need to reduce it to get solar power to be more viable, but it would be at the cost of getting a lower range when the sun isn't shining directly on it. I'm not sure how many drivers would make that trade.
- colordrops 7y agoAssuming theoretical maximum effeciency for solar cells covering an entire vehicle the size of a Prius, would that be enough for reasonable range?
- outworlder 7y agoYes. You did not specify the time duration, though.
- colordrops 7y ago30 miles total daily commute?
- covercash 7y agoMaybe when parked additional solar panels could “deploy” out of the trunk/frunk?
- gameswithgo 7y agoIf you assume 100% efficient covering the entire vehicle and you live in a sunny area and are always parked and moving in the sun and not shade, its kinda sorta worth it.
- masklinn 7y agoThe highest-rated panels do about 200W/sqm. Very roughly, it looks like the prius has a 1.1sqm hood, 1.7sqm roof and 1.1sqm trunk. That's 750~775W worth of panels. The prius has an EV range of 25mi with an 8.8kWh battery, that's 2.8mi/kWh, so with the 3.9sqm worth of high-power panels above and assuming full sun (full power production) you'd gain a range of 2.17mi/h.
- personjerry 7y agoThere's 0% chance they're "Trying to Figure Out How to Make a Car Run Forever" because then they lose their market.
- outworlder 7y ago> There's 0% chance they're "Trying to Figure Out How to Make a Car Run Forever" because then they lose their market. How does that make sense? If this was possible(and patentable), everyone else would go out of business.
- wtallis 7y agoAnd continuing the silly hypothetical, it seems like it would leave Toyota with a Gillette Razor business model of supplying you with repair parts for the last car you ever buy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wetpaws 7y agoThere are many different reasons to change a car and "not able to drive one" is not the biggest. To name a few - evolution of the safety standards, better reliability, lower cost of maintenance, even something as trivial as not liking a color and wanting to get a newer model. If you take a look at the cell phone market, for example, from the functional point of view there are no reasons not to use 80-s nokia brick because it still makes calls, and here we are and mobile market is working just fine.
- xkcd-sucks 7y agoIf it was any car company other than Toyota, this statement could be plausible, maybe
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.is/qJNov http://archive.is/qJNov
- themattress 7y agoVery cool, but I wouldn’t want to pay to repair that after an accident. Oof.
- Johnny555 7y agoYou already don't want to pay for a repair for a modern car after an accident -- all of the electronics and recalibrations (front camera and calibration, front radar sensor and calibration, blind spot detecting radar/ultrasonic sensor and calibration) adds up to serious money even for a minor accident.
- ansible 7y agoOMG, yes! Had a cracked windshield recently, sooooo expensive
- hourislate 7y agoThe folks that come up with photovoltaic paint are going to get very rich. In the mean time a flexible solar charging car cover/blanket would cover the entire area of the vehicle and could plug right into the charging port while the car is parked. Could even be used across same size vehicles or to sell power back to the grid (if this were available) if car is fully charged.
- jossmexico 7y agophotovoltaic paint .. that could be a near future news headline
- lightedman 7y agoWe already have printable photovoltaics and a spray-on photovoltaic.
- kchamplewski 7y agoIt already exists. https://solaractionalliance.org/solar-paint/ https://solaractionalliance.org/solar-paint/ It just has very poor efficiency compared to panels, and so is not economically viable and probably won't be for some time.
- yourapostasy 7y agoA lot of work going on in this area [1]. [1] https://www.solar-estimate.org/news/solar-paint-hydrogen-quantum-dot-perovskite-solar-cells https://www.solar-estimate.org/news/solar-paint-hydrogen-qua...
- WalterBright 7y agoI used to use a solar battery charger to keep my car battery topped up when it was just sitting around. Worked great.
- outworlder 7y ago> I used to use a solar battery charger to keep my car battery topped up when it was just sitting around. Worked great. Car battery, like a lead acid one? If so, it's a very tiny battery.
- lightedman 7y agoA typical 60-cell panel today provides 300wH. Thats enough to fully charge most typical lead-acid car batteries in about 4 hours.
- fnord77 7y agoCar Trickle chargers put out very little amps. Like 1 or 2
- zolotuke 7y agoSlide Ranch in Marin County in California has a golf cart with solar panel for roof. The guy who drives it around ranch said last couple years he did not have to plug his cart for charging at all. If it was in’s out of the juice he just leaves it on the sun and comes back at the end of the day. Here is a neat use case how this technology already works albeit he has a pretty corner case.
- reaperducer 7y ago180,000 golf carts are manufactured each year, and golf carts pretty much live in the sun. Seems like an opportunity.
- Johnny555 7y agoSolar panels don't have zero environmental cost, I'd be surprised if making them solar powered is a net environmental win, especially when you have to build the charging infrastructure anyway, just in case the weather is not suitable for charging.
- icebraining 7y agoThe extra solar panels installed on the grid to feed those carts don't have zero environment cost either, though. And neither do the batteries required to hold that energy until the carts are plugged-in, which would likely be at dusk/night, when they're not in use. (Grid solar -> grid battery -> cart battery) involves more losses than just (cart solar -> cart battery).
- ajuc 7y agoKinda related: in my city they introduced regular solar cells on roofs of public transport to charge the regular battery on ICE buses and apparently that averages 4-5% lower fuel consumption over a year (so - all the weather conditions, indcluding 3 months of pretty cold winter and cloudy rainy autumn), and it makes the batteries lose capacity much slower. These buses use batteries for lots of stuff - lights, automatic doors, AC, ticket machines, external and internal displays. Apparently there are problems with batteries running empty when the buses have to wait for the next course too long. Also the batteries are losing capacity too quickly when they are charged all the way down often. They introduced the pilot program in 2013 and in 2017 they decided to put solar cells on all the buses. Links in Polish: http://www.mpk.lublin.pl/imgs_upload/image/aktualnosci_fotki/panele_foto.jpg http://www.mpk.lublin.pl/imgs_upload/image/aktualnosci_fotki... http://www.transport-publiczny.pl/mobile/lublin-wszystkie-autobusy-mpk-beda-mialy-panele-fotowoltaiczne-55324.html http://www.transport-publiczny.pl/mobile/lublin-wszystkie-au...
- reaperducer 7y agoWhen I lived in the America's desert southwest, the school buses were partially solar powered. The panels weren't on the roof, though, they were where the buses were parked. Each bus had a port on the side for hooking into the panel grid in between runs. I think the reason there weren't panels on the roof is because the roofs usually had two air conditioners on them. I suspect the solar plug-in wasn't for locomotion, but to power the air conditioners.
- delfinom 7y agoYes. It's a valid technique to keep the temperature on a fleet controlled so you don't waste time cooling down a bus later in the day before picking up students. Solar panels let them make it basically free. And the solar panels on the fixed roofs of the power stations will recoup their cost over time far longer than potential lifespan of a vehicle.
- rock_hard 7y agoI have seen small 20-4 person art cars at Burning Man achieve and impressive range with a solar panel on top This is def going to be huge down the road Unfortunately today most street cars are still way to heavy/bulky for this to have a real impact given current solar panel efficiency
- gameswithgo 7y ago>This is def going to be huge down the road For the cost and mass of the solar panels, you can add more range with more batteries, on normal sized street cars. The math just doesn't work out well until you get to very small/light vehicles with large roof area.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIn my layman's understanding of batteries doesn't the resistance of a battery increase with its level of charge? If so wouldn't these large batteries have so much resistance that at a reasonable level of charge most or a large portion of the energy would be lost as heat? Does it somehow charge individual cells as opposed to the whole thing or am I way off base?
- ansible 7y agoThat's not at all how battery charging works. Whatever the voltage output of the solar panel is, you can always step that up or down. The batteries go up in voltage slightly when they are charging, but not much relatively. For a typical LiIon cell, it may be at "0%" at 3.4V (you don't want to drain it all the way). And "100%" full is around 4.2V. As long as you can supply at least 4.2V, it will charge up to that point.
- souprock 7y agoThat would do for my commute, 0.9 miles each way. It allows running a fan in sunny weather. The more the Sun is cooking the car, the more power there is, so that works out nicely. It helps with long-term parking, for example at an airport. It's annoying to return to a car that won't respond to a key fob and has lost all the settings.
- cortesoft 7y agoMan your commute is that short, and you drive?
- souprock 7y agoI drive if the Sun is beating down or there is a thunderstorm. Sometimes I get dropped off, then walk home later in nicer weather. I also drive when I don't have 20 minutes to spare; the drive is only 3 minutes.
- jws 7y agoI used to drive for a much shorter commute. At the time I could have been urgently summoned to a site 30 miles away at any time so I had to be prepared. I ran out of gas on my way home one night. If you never drive past a gas station and only fill up every month or two it’s easy to forget.
- grecy 7y agoWow, that's amazing. My commute was about 6 miles, and I rode my bike 365 days a year for 4 years. Even in the winter. In the Yukon. -48C one nice morning.
- ip26 7y agoYikes, 365 days a year? I don't envy that work schedule.
- lultimouomo 7y agoLook at the bright side, in 4 years he's bound to have had a free day on February, 29th!
- tjmc 7y agoAnother thing this would be great for is pre-cooling or heating the car before you drive it. At a CoP of 3 which is conservative for modern AC heat pumps, the 860W of solar gives you over 2.5kW of cooling. Even if it just tempered the air whilst parked with fan ventilation through the cabin, it would massively lower the cabin temp which can reach over 90C in sunny locations.
- fnord77 7y agoThe prius already has this with the solar panel sunroof option
- ianai 7y agoI’d love to see panels on car parking roofs - like you see at apartments or over some parking spots. Just the shade cuts a lot of heat, too.
- theshrike79 7y agoThis has been an option for at least a decade. (My 2008 Prius has this, for example) The first version was just a panel that ran a fan, which ran if the inside temp > outside temp. The next generation had an actual separate battery for the solar panel, which engaged the car's AC when needed.
- olefoo 7y agoThis is a convenience feature for fully electric cars. Charge at home, leave it parked at work and it recharges a fair bit. Won't make as much of a difference on a longer road trip; but will increase the range between mandatory recharges. If you want you probably could go full martian if you got an external solar array you could deploy when stopped. The real win is going to be on mid-sized electric vans and RVs since you have more surface area and could deploy a charging array as a canopy. Think of a 300 ft^3 van ( about the size of a Sprinter ) with full wrap solar panels and an additional 100 ft^2 of solar panel that could be deployed when parked. If you were using it as an RV you could plan on extended backcountry camping trips without having to worry about recharging.
- hervature 7y agoFull wrap solar panels would be a silly idea. Almost half of the panels would not be producing power. Effective surface area would be about ~130 ft^2. Even with that additional solar panel, let's call it 250 ft^2, it would produce ~4kW on a clear day. Basically, charging all day might get you 150 miles in a Tesla model S. I would rather just charge my Tesla while eating a sandwich for lunch then pay for the additional complexity.
- olefoo 7y agoThe reason to do full wrap would be so that some of the panels are always producing regardless of orientation of the vehicle.
- driverdan 7y agoYour numbers are off by a lot. A Sprinter roof is around 100ft^2 (not sure why you're saying cubic feet, solar panels are flat and can't overlap). I live in a 25ft shuttle bus. I have solar that covers the roof end-to-end, 1800W. It's a lot but nowhere near enough to recharge batteries to drive a vehicle of this size any reasonable distance.
- olefoo 7y agoUsing cube as the size of the van, not surface.
- 75dvtwin 7y agoIt would be interesting how specifically these panels are different from the ones announced by Kia. https://www.driving.co.uk/news/kia-hyundai-cars-will-use-solar-panels-help-charge-electric-cars/ https://www.driving.co.uk/news/kia-hyundai-cars-will-use-sol... Kia/Hyndai panel produces 100 wh. So it would take about 27 days to charge 64Kwh battery (of course no one expects full recharge with these panels.. but just a comparison. I think, actually people leaving in areas prone to power outages (due to weather, for example), would appreciate built-in solar re-charge capability of a vehicle that can provide temporary power to household devices.
- algaeontoast 7y agoNapkin math on this isn't great, however, if you park your car outside multiple days a week and don't use it every day this could be a worthwhile upgrade.
- songshuu 7y agoIf not Toyota proper, folks have been trying to put solar panels on a Prius from about the launch.
- ameliaquining 7y agoObligatory https://xkcd.com/1924/ https://xkcd.com/1924/
- m463 7y agoI think the problem is that you would have to park your car out in the sun. The sun is hard on cars. Hot temperatures are not great for batteries, and if there is ever any active thermal management, the costs would subtract from the benefits. Elon Musk talked about this a couple of times. At first they explored it, but then said cars wouldn't be outdoors enough to benefit. I have wondered about solar panels on the top of trucks however. A 53' trailer has 450 square feet of roof, which with standard panels works out to be 6kw. Probably much more with the panels toyota is using. It seems the Tesla Semi specs say "less than 2kwh per mile" so 3+ miles for each hour of sunshine, more with better panels.
- danans 7y agoEven if this could eventually be done affordably, this only only makes sense for vehicles meant to only go a short distance on electricity, like Toyota's own Prius Prime, with it's 25 mile electric range. If you have a longer range EV, then you need to plug in anyways to charge the much larger battery, at which point why bother with the solar panels for charging the traction battery? This seems a bit like an attempt to get more out of their hybrid gasoline powered cars, which is a technology they seem very wedded to.
- kchamplewski 7y ago> If you have a longer range EV, then you need to plug in anyways to charge the much larger battery Why can't you, say, have a longer range EV but only have a short commute and so not utilise that range usually? Surely in that scenario, solar is useful on a daily basis, but when you want to go on a long distance journey you can still make use of the charging facilities and longer range.
- danans 7y agoGiven that your short (i.e. 10 miles) commute costs about $1 in utility rate electricity (at 20c/kWh, .5kWh/mi), to be worthwhile, the solar panels would need to cost far less than the $2 per day that such a commute costs. Accounting for rainy or cloudy days, and the inevitable dirtying of the solar panels, it's unlikely to be worth the expense in economic terms, to say nothing of the aesthetics. It would make more sense to use the money to put solar panels on your house, if generating your own energy for commuting is a priority. That's why I maintain that the only value of on-car solar panels for daily commute purposes is for hybrids with small batteries (which are Toyotas strategy) since the alternative to electricity in that case is using petrol, which typically costs 2x per mile compared to electricity.
- masklinn 7y ago> If you have a longer range EV, then you need to plug in anyways to charge the much larger battery, at which point why bother with the solar panels for charging the traction battery? Not everybody has a wired garage available, for one. Especially urban communities of europe or japan. Having to go to the public charging stations a bit less is still a boon. It's a range extender (not a big one, granted) and an emergency charger if you run out of juice as well (that happens).
- bArray 7y agoThis is really not going to be charging your battery much. You can barely justify the energy usage in creating the panels. Useless if you park in a garage at home or at the office, or have a tree overhanging the car. The panels themselves have a shelf life too. I would personally prefer it if you were able to fold out panels (or for extra points, the panels fold out themselves). I think you could quite realistically have a large "sun roof" that folds out panels instead - then you would begin to get some better power returns. Add to that some sun tracking and you can massively improve your efficiency. But really, just give owners of the car something to install on their garage roof and a plug for the car.
- driverdan 7y agoI'm surprised how no one commented about the obvious problems here. These are very expensive high output panels. The ROI would be negative. They'd add thousands of dollars to the cost of the car. Until prices drop significantly you won't be seeing 30%+ solar on a car soon, at least not ones with a positive ROI. It's far more cost effective and practical to install a stationary solar array to recharge from.
- xhgdvjky 7y agoa lot of consumer goods have negative ROI and are still very successful products. people don't just buy things because they'll make/save money
- d--b 7y agoWhat is happening when the battery is full?
- jacobush 7y agoThe panel returns photons to the sun for storage.
- seltzered_ 7y agoPrevious discussion from 2.5 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20364348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20364348
- niceworkbuddy 7y agoThis is just equivalent to canister in gas-powered vehicles.
- de_watcher 7y agoA small canister that is infinitely large inside, and with a very thin neck.
- 0d0d0fsd0 7y agoSeems more like a marketing stunt than anything.. Sounds like a nice idea but the marginal benefit is likely zilch. If you're going to build solar panels, you should put them somewhere where you're optimizing their power generation.
- alanh 7y agoIt is so annoying when people tell me their genius idea, putting solar panels on a Tesla. Why doesn’t Tesla already do this, they wonder? Because the amount of energy captured by such a minuscule surface area would barely recoup the inefficiencies of the added weight... That, and a Tesla is sexy in a way that a vehicle plastered with solar panels would have a hard time replicating. BTW, if you take the ferry to Alcatraz, they will try to impress with you solar panels and a helical wind turbine on the ferry itself. But pay attention, and they admit it doesn’t do anything more than power the loudspeaker. The boat runs on diesel. Because of course it does. If a few panels could power a ferry, we'd have gotten off oil long ago!
- VBprogrammer 7y agoOne way of helping people internalise this is to point out that 1ph is, to a first order approximation, 1kw. The same as many electric heaters. A typical solar panel is 100w in peak conditions. It's then easy to visualise what powering something with solar panels might entail if you can make a guess at the engine HP. Even a small ferry is likely 2000hp+.
- jstsch 7y agoYeah, that’s a good way of looking at it. Note that a typical modern solar panel is around 285-340 watt these days.
- Faaak 7y ago> A typical solar panel is 100w in peak conditions That doesn't mean anything. A standard panel (1m×1.9m) has a peak power of 300W. What we must compare is the solar radiance times the efficiency of the panel, and multiplied by the surface, would give you your available power
- VBprogrammer 7y agoAnd 1hp is actually 745.7w. It makes very little difference with regards to the big picture of whether something is feasible. Whether you tell someone the ferry is going to need 20,000 solar panels or 5000 it's still way more than reasonably be put onboard. The solar factor usually employed in the UK is about 0.1 to get from nameplate capacity to actual production (accounting for hours of darkness and suboptimal atmospheric conditions) so it would be reasonable to assume your 300w is actually more like 30w. At least some percentage of solar panels on our hypothetical solar power ferry are likely to be in shade or not pointing directly at the sun. Then you have various conversions and charging losses to get the power into a usable form.
- ende 7y agoThe problem with this is that we need more parking garages than open air parking lots.
- m3adow 7y agoThe Sion[1] from german car startup Sono Motors will have this. The first cars are planned to be released in 2020. I personally am not sold on the idea of panels on a car. The positioning will probably be subpar to outright bad most of the time and small accident repairs will cost more, as the panel modules will need replacements. [1]: https://sonomotors.com/en/sion/ https://sonomotors.com/en/sion/
- Reason077 7y agoIt depends a lot on where you are in the world. In Germany and other northern locations, panels need to be positioned at specific angles for optimal year-round efficiency. But at lower latitudes closer to the equator, panels facing directly up at the sky will do well year-round.
- seqastian 7y agoThey talk about Solar Range up to 34 km/day. Just 10km a day extra and going 50 every day that extends your range(250km) by another day. Maybe for people who don't go very far and not every day it can even work out to be mostly self sufficient? Im glad someone is trying to make it work and we will see how it works out in the long run.
- vcdimension 7y agoThe Sion has other advantages apart from the solar panels; it has a socket for charging other things (e.g. other electric cars), and custom built-in software and smartphone app for renting it out when you're not using it. This means you can make money from it when you're not using it.
- masklinn 7y agoThe dutch from lightyear one[0] as well, they're apparently trying for 2021 deliveries. Completely different market positioning though. [0] https://lightyear.one https://lightyear.one
- moonbug 7y agomarketing plebdazzle for the innumerate.
- joosters 7y agoI think there used to be an Audi model with a solar panel on the roof that was used to power the aircon when parked. No idea how effective it was, but the concept was clever, since when there was little sunlight, you wouldn’t need the power anyway.
- nottorp 7y agoNow THAT WORLD be incentive to keep my car clean!
- nottorp 7y ago"WOULD" of course... damn spell checker...
- _Codemonkeyism 7y agoTo sum up the comments: Everyone commutes hours so this is not enough (as always readers assume everyone lives in the US). Everyone has a house so put them there (see comment about US). Tesla doesn't have it so it doesn't make sense.
- iamgopal 7y agoThere should be some website for telling people about logically valid stupid idea, like making roads out of solar panel, and this, and hydrogen car. The other day, someone suggested me to put motor on wind turbine so it can produce more power in low wind condition. Someday, people will install wind turbine on top of car for car charging even while driving.
- jvsonica 7y agoI am part of a project that electrifies refrigeration units that operate on trucks (mainly last mile distribution of temperature-sensitive goods). We've installed solar panels on top of the trucks before and the results were very poor. Apart from the various problems we ran into (required thin and flexible panels compatible with automatic car wash brushes, building shades covered the panels in a large portion of the day, etc.) the amount of energy recovered was still very small. Even though the actual results seem great, it's still hard to say something about its performance in real-world usage.
- daddylonglegs 7y agoThis seems... OK? Solar PV panels have come down in price a lot and so the main challenge is installation. You need to manufacture mounts, fit them to a suitable surface and then hook them up so as to deliver the power at a time and place where it can be used. Most cars are outside all day long and electric cars have a big battery sitting there, ready to accept charge. Car manufacturers are the experts at mass-manufacturing so this is probably the cheapest and lowest impact way to install and use some solar electricity generation. If your vision of the future includes solar PV covering every external, manufactured surface then this is the place to start. Of course this doesn't do much for the range of the vehicle in question; building and operating cars is incredibly resource intensive and is only ameliorated by making them hybrid or electric. These panels are a concrete reminder that we need to reduce that usage to soften the damage we're doing to the environment.
- Amygaz 7y agoBlog on this topic: https://solarhub.energy/why-dont-electric-cars-have-solar-panels-on-the-roof/ https://solarhub.energy/why-dont-electric-cars-have-solar-pa...
- emrullahcimen 7y agoActually panels might be very heavy fot the car to carry but what about some kind of nano tech which allows to absorb the energy coming from the sun and supply it in the batteries. Yes its much complicated to do but a valuable idea to think on.
- williesleg 7y agoThey'd get more power from putting a giant windmill on a Prius.
- justanegg 7y agoa very efficient solar panel would be flat and the gains would be offset by bad aerodynamics
- Siecje 7y agoWhat is invisible concrete?
- eyegor 7y agoSo I see the dream here, but there's just not enough surface area for a meaningful amount of energy generation (in car terms). I really wish more manufacturers would use solar panels to spin up an A/C compressor or a small heater to maintain more pleasant temps inside the cabin for when you get into the car. I remember seeing it done as a concept a few years back, but I haven't seen one in the wild yet. Anyone know if a manufacturer is doing this?
- yule 7y agoToyota themselves: Optional features included the solar-PV roof panels to help cool the cabin interior in summer heat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Prius#Third_generation_(XW30;_2009%E2%80%932015) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Prius#Third_generation_...
- gdubs 7y agoWhere’s everyone’s passion for discovery and research? They state clearly that this is decades off at best. Still cool that they’re trying. It’s through trying that you learn things.
- johnatwork 7y agoI totally agree with you, sometimes a small auxiliary tech has a breakthrough and all of a sudden it opens up a lot of doors.
- mycentstoo 7y agoI think an assumption being made is that the surface area can't increase while the vehicle isn't moving. Maybe in the future it might be possible to have the solar panels fold out when parked to at least 2x the surface area. If we are rethinking the grid, I don't see why we can't rethink parking at the same time.
- NullPrefix 7y agoIt could unfold vertically like a solar sail on a spaceship
- NoblePublius 7y agoIt’s upsetting that Toyota continues to delay pure electrics with this nonsense. They sell a hydrogen car (total scam) and hybrids that still burn oil and require costly maintenance. Dear Toyota, please give up your dream to delay pure electrics. You lost.
- vondur 7y agoWhat they could also do is a solar charging port, where you can plug in external panels for charging. A lot of travel trailers have that capability.
- GhostVII 7y agoIf, even just once or twice a week, you park it somewhere where you can plug it in, the power you get from that will be far more than any panels on the roof. You can take the money you saved from not putting panels on the car, and put much larger panels on some roof or in a parking lot somewhere, where they will be always generating electricity. This only really makes sense if you never have access to charging, and if that is the case an electric car is probably not a great fit for your lifestyle anyways.
- magwa101 7y agoToyota is a hype machine right now. They're trying to mask how they are missing the EV opportunity which they squandered on hydrogen.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoThis is somewhere between a gimmick and a break-even solution for daily driving under certain circumstances... But it's my impression that there hasn't been an industrial-scale effort on mobile solar panels that optimize power/weight/limited area like this. I guess maybe some of those camping panels. But if a car can self-power it's daily driving range, and we could get spray-on/paint-on solar (remember that?) with functional yield at reasonable cost... why not? The ideal intermediate electrification step isn't all-battery, as much as I'd like that. For "consumer" driving it's PHEVs with decent all-EV range (40-80 miles)... that maximizes the somewhat restricted (currently) battery component mineral supply to eliminate daily driving greenhouse gas emissions. And if a cheap solar paint can reduce the grid impact of that then why not? Throw some research into that. Yes, generally speaking rooftop solar will be more efficient, but I'm guessing rooftop solar and utility solar will have plenty of uses. There's STILL coal on the grid, and NatGas. Hm. Perovskite spray-on solar cells... Hard to see how they avoid the perovskite degradation when it contacts air https://news.energysage.com/solar-news-scientists-invent-spray-on-solar-cells/ https://news.energysage.com/solar-news-scientists-invent-spr...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shadowtree 7y agoThe fun then starts when they're putting up these massive solar panels on top of parking spaces like they do all over California right now. The big solar cell you park under then shields the one on your roof from charging :)