8 ms·
China Experiments with a New Kind of Megalopolis
- rb808 7y agoThere was a Bloomberg show on Shenzen earlier in the year. It actually really surprised me how modern it is, and its built in a few decades from nothing. Worth watching the first few minutes at least. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLmaIbb13GM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLmaIbb13GM
- Steven_Vellon 7y agoScholars speculate that Shenzhen may have been the fastest growing urban center in human history. The growth is staggering, with the population rising from 1.5 million in 1990 to just over 10 million in 2010. Imagine the entirety of Washington State's population moving to one city in the span of 20 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shenzhen#/media/File:Shenzhen,_China,_city_population_dynamics.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shenzhen#/media/File:Shenzhen,...
- sebastianconcpt 7y agoHong Kong's unique role as a separate economic entity, governed by the rule of law, is perhaps its best chance to avoid becoming another Chinese city among many others.
- dirtyid 7y agoSemi related: city Beautiful just released a quick video on Greater Tokyo history. It's always fascinating to see how these megalopolis arise. Though TFW the most expeditious route to modernization is either war, natural disaster or state directed development.
- smaili 7y agoThis paragraph pretty much sums up the potential of what China's Greater Bay Area has to offer: > Shenzhen has become a center for research and development that ranks alongside Silicon Valley. The area around the industrial city of Dongguan produces one-third of the world's jeans, while Foshan accounts for more than half of all refrigerators and air-conditioning units manufactured worldwide. Hong Kong is Asia's leading financial center and Macao is the largest gambling city in the world, with six times the gaming volume of Las Vegas. Ironically, using the Bay Area as an inspiration feels like Apples and Oranges given it's more tech-centric whereas this "Magalopolis" almost feels like a country within a country. Very curious to see how this grand plan progresses over the coming years.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>almost feels like a country within a country Exactly how I always saw the "new" China. Ever since my first intro to it in the early 90's. All of these are city-states trying to get as rich as they can, while acting as partners with each other for the favor of Beijing, and simultaneously competitors with each other for the favor of Beijing. If you go to all these places and they feel very different from each other. (At least, as an outsider they really felt different to me.)
- AFascistWorld 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiong'an https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiong'an Xi's brainchild. "millennium strategy". And new title for Shenzhen, "Frontier Demonstration Area of Socialism".
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoUpvoted. Xiong'an is literally backed by Xi's and it's going to be the 2nd capital city of China according to the plan. This comment meant to be a link for some insight on what the Chinese government's thinking on city planning. Shenzhen's title "Frontier Demonstration Area of Socialism" gives some hints for the upcoming political atmosphere as well. What I don't understand is: Why would someone downvote this comment?! It's nothing controversial and informative. Also, my comment on William Gibson's novel has been downvoted. I know using Hacker News for political and ideological battles are not welcomed, and I actively avoid doing it. I think the reason of being downvoted is mentioning "unrestricted growth under hypercapitalism"... But I was literally talking about the plot of a Sci-Fi novel and comparing it with China, I even added that "it's a pretty common cyberpunk theme", not meant to attack any real entity. Anyway, feel free to downvote, but I'd love to hear some feedback and comments from HN readers if someone believes a comment is inappropriate.
- simlevesque 7y agodo not mention downvotes. " Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sremani 7y ago>> building a megacity in the Pearl River Delta that it hopes will one day rival New York and Tokyo Construction is 50% of their GDP (fact-check me here) and this feels like business as usual to keep the gravy train rolling.
- notaround1111 7y agolooks like its around 40% according to the world bank (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.IND.TOTL.ZS?locations=CN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.IND.TOTL.ZS?location...) which is probably based on data provided by the CCP. which kinda makes fact-checking data a fool-errand anyways.
- whatshisface 7y agoWell there are satellite photos, construction workers can be questioned about their wage, material prices are semi-public (you don't know exactly what was negotiated in each contract but there is something of a market)... Too bad there is no public institution that estimates these things as far as I know. Although I bet most hedge funds along with the CIA have worked it out.
- rolltiide 7y agohave you ever seen a construction project that didn't appear like a total racket? I wouldnt try holding construction groups and Chinese central planning to a higher standard
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>have you ever seen a construction project that didn't appear like a total racket? Yes but none of them were funded or overseen at the state or national level. The source of the funds, the people doing the constructing and the people with the stake in the results was a fairly tight loop. The extra overhead of state/national projects seems to provide enough inefficiency/friction that just turns the whole thing into a money pit.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoChina hasn't had a financial crisis for 40 years, I wonder how long they can last, and how well their ubiquitous multi-million dollar condos would fare; or can they prove again that nothing communists can't tackle, and capitalism with Chinese characteristics are indeed immune to self-correction.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIs that really accurate? China was heavily hit by the Asian financial crisis, even if not as bad as the rest of Asia. The aftermath of Tiananmen wasn’t so great either. The early 00s was a crazy time as well, with bubbles forming and popping fairly rapidly. They had to recapitalize the banks afterwards, as well as nationalize most of their bad debt. I guess it really depends on your definition of financial crisis.
- NTDF9 7y agoChina has had plenty of those. But their levers are different. They actively overspend on infrastructure projects to stimulate the economy whenever there was a downturn. In the past, that worked really well, spending to hand money to the poor who improved their standards of living. Will this work in the future? Nobody knows.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoOne can say that as now the second largest economy, China didn't cause financial crisis in the 40 years of opening up, outside crises didn't trigger significant slowdown, part of the immunity is that China just has so many easy ways to simply write it off.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoWhy stop at 40 years? By that definition, China hasn’t had a financial crisis for the last 70 years, at least.
- Tyrek 7y agoIt's a pretty hot take to suggest that counter-cyclical spending isn't a very strong response to recessions - this is classical economics in a nutshell. Just because the US is too politically paralyzed to spend at the same level doesn't mean that it's an ineffectual tool.
- alisonatwork 7y agoThis article feels like it's rehashing a lot of stale CPC talking points. I moved to the PRD a few years ago because i am a city nerd. I love urban development and i heard that this was the boomtown of the world. It is a pretty interesting place, but it's not as remarkable as it comes across if you live overseas and/or only consume CPC propaganda. Shenzhen is really two cities. There is rich Shenzhen, which is mostly shopping malls and gated communities. Then there is poor Shenzhen, which is urban villages (think Kowloon Walled City) and factories. In rich Shenzhen people drive Porsches, take taxis or ride the subway. In poor Shenzhen people get on the backs of e-bikes or ride the bus. Poor Shenzhen borders Dongguan and Huizhou, which are cities that feel very similar except that their buses and motorcycles still belch out toxic fumes. I had to laugh at the article's assertion that Longgang district was "modern". Large parts of Longgang are still rural and industrial. I have no doubt there are corners of Longgang that some ambitious local party official would love to show off as being the latest and greatest smart city, but that's likely to only exist in very small areas around the cookie-cutter tower blocks built for the petite bourgeoisie who couldn't afford identical (yet more expensive) apartments closer to the city. Over the bay, Hong Kong remains an economic juggernaut. It punches way above its weight on the international scene, but in the context of the Pearl River Delta it comes across as parochial. While people in Zhuhai and Foshan and Guangzhou learned a second language so they could talk to their neighbors in Dongguan and Shenzhen and Huizhou, many Hongkongers did not. There are lots of great aspects of Hong Kong, but i think everyone in the PRD would agree that they are in their own bubble. They have their own concerns and their own dreams. I don't think a bridge to Zhuhai or a high speed rail to Guangzhou is going to make much of an impact either way on that. Macau isn't even part of the story. A handful of people there are spectacularly rich because casinos, but both land-wise and population-wise they are a rounding error. The way i see it this whole "Greater Bay Area" rebrand of what was formerly known as the PRD is just yet another oligarchal circle jerk. Perhaps i am too cynical, but i feel like it's just a new way for the usual suspects to funnel even more money into their personal coffers. Before this "GBA" thing kicked off, the PRD cities already had plans to link their public transport systems. You can already take buses and share bikes all over. Why wouldn't we link the transit systems? We're all squashed up next to one another. Plenty of poor people in the suburbs commute "across the border" to their factory jobs. The government can talk all they like about reducing taxes or opening up the region for international commerce or whatever. To me that just sounds like the rich getting richer and the poor getting evicted. Wake me up when they lift the Great Firewall for the whole PRD and not just a leased section next to Macau. Wake me up when the government provides comprehensive healthcare. Wake me up when migrant workers can get hukou. That will be some real change.
- blacksmith_tb 7y agoFunny to think that William Gibson prescient about The Sprawl[1] but wrong about what continent it would develop on... though the Chinese version is much more top-down, anything but accidental. 1: https://williamgibson.fandom.com/wiki/The_Sprawl https://williamgibson.fandom.com/wiki/The_Sprawl
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoMy understanding is that Gibson's The Sprawl was the result of technical megacorps and their unrestricted growth under hypercapitalism, a pretty common cyberpunk theme. The Chinese version is created in forms of executive order, nowhere close to Gibson's prospective, but regardless, the end-result is quite identical and cyberpunkish, pretty interesting.
- B1FF_PSUVM 7y agoWasn't it somewhat about Japan, the China of 1980 so to speak?
- api 7y agoChina is closer to Gibson's Japan. The sprawl hasn't happened yet, but it could.
- lazyguy2 7y agoIt seems really stupid to talk about 'Economic Miracles' and Shenzhen without mentioning the reason this city even exists: Shenzhen Special Economic Zone When this special regulatory zone was established in 1980 the city area had less then 310,000 residents and 30,000 workers. Now it's a city of over 13,000,000 people. By divorcing these areas from management of the Chinese central government and allowing unprecedented autonomy and lifting restrictions on migration of workers, import duties, and other such things enabled these SEZ areas to pull the greater China into the economic powerhouse it is today. This is what separates places like Szhengzen from the 'Ghost Cities' basket cases that China has tried to build around their country, ostensibly, in a bid to increase GDP numbers.
- xvilka 7y agoThere are also two more gigacities already - Yangtze River Delta[1] and Jingjiji[2]. They all started integration already, for example Shanghai metro is being connected to Suzhou metro. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangtze_River_Delta https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangtze_River_Delta [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jingjinji https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jingjinji
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sunstone 7y agoInteresting that all three gigacities seem to be in low lying coastal areas. I would expect them to hedge their bets regarding global warming and sea level rise.
- gcbw3 7y agohong kong importance is not because it is a megalopoly. It is not. Hong kong is a tax avoidance hub just like Jersey and City of london (see http://spiderswebfilm.com/ http://spiderswebfilm.com/ to understand why the city of london doesn't mean the city of london) tax avoidance and international trust funds are the reason hong kong is "huge"
- kazinator 7y agoYou can't really rival something like New York without the personal freedom and the blending of cultural currents and all that. Copying the skyscrapers and knife-in-a-back-alley grit is merely cargo culting.
- istorical 7y agoEhhh, that's one aspect of a megacity. There are many other aspects which may be shared.
- carapace 7y ago> Longgang is also subjected to continuous surveillance. In the spring of 2017, a couple reported that their three-year-old son Xuanxuan had been abducted. A security camera captured the scene, and it took the police precisely two seconds to identify the kidnapper using facial recognition software. They located the perpetrator and the child on a train shortly thereafter. Wow. This is something to think about. Would you trade privacy for this level of safety? I think we are going to have the surveillance anyway, for economic if not political reasons, but that once we get used to it we will find ourselves better off (I hope!) http://firequery.blogspot.com/2013/10/total-surveillance-is-perfection-of.html http://firequery.blogspot.com/2013/10/total-surveillance-is-... If the "Social Credit" system is administered without corruption, by being self-referential, it seems that the end result could be that it works. A kinder, gentler tyranny of Mrs. Grundy.
- mojomark 7y agoNo thank you.
- chillacy 7y agoWell right now I'm more likely to break some asinine law than get kidnapped so I'll have to pass. Unless footage can't be used pre-emptively or something.
- hnaccy 7y ago>If the "Social Credit" system is administered without corruption Good joke.
- FussyZeus 7y ago> Wow. This is something to think about. Would you trade privacy for this level of safety? The problem I have is never with the system itself, but who is it's master. And this isn't even just a China thing, I'm against pretty much every government on the planet having this kind of system at it's disposal.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rolltiide 7y agoIts nice to read publications from countries that have no relevant geopolitical rivalry with the country being discussed Would like to see more!
- voidreaper 7y agoHere’s a cool interactive map of the Pearl River Delta megalopolis: https://geoshen.com/posts/the-pearl-river-delta-megalopolis https://geoshen.com/posts/the-pearl-river-delta-megalopolis