7 ms·
There's no silver bullet. Tackling overtourism means limiting the number of tourists. One way to do that is to impose high enough prices.
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
There's no silver bullet. Tackling overtourism means limiting the number of tourists. One way to do that is to impose high enough prices.
- buro9 7y agoAnd then only the wealthy may have holidays.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThat's how it is now, from a global perspective.
- tomcooks 7y agoThis unfortunately pleases the state, the tourist service providers and the wealthy. All three of them not being particularly known for their respect of culture, tradition and delicate (eco)systems. Blah.
- balfirevic 7y agoThe wealthy are less well-known for their respect of culture, tradition and delicate ecosystems than the not wealthy?
- johnchristopher 7y agoHolidays doesn't mean "travelling to another country in a plane" or "let's take a credit to tour Italy".
- barry-cotter 7y agoQuite true but if some can and some can’t the social class implications will be picked up on very fast, whether the reason is money or political connections.
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoPeople will find a way to separate themselves into classes no matter what. And those of higher class will separate themselves from the proles using any means available. Even in Soviet Union the running joke was that all people are equal, but some people are more equal than others.
- johnchristopher 7y agoThere is another running joke "Everyone is born equal, then God sort them out".
- farflung12 7y agoYes it does, "holidays" is interchangeable with "vacation" in some English speaking countries.
- kgwgk 7y agoVacation doesn't mean "travelling to another country in a plane" or "let's take a credit to tour Italy" either.
- nickik 7y agoAnd poor people can go to Estonia or Sweden, or whatever other nordic nation. I think humanity might survive only rich people being able to go to Norway.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- strig 7y agoNorway is already very expensive to visit
- timidiceball 7y agoIt really isn’t. Between the existence of Norwegian Airlines and the fact that the Norwegian crown is hovering at 9 to a dollar, flights are almost never over $200 one-way from New York and it’s now cheaper for an American to drink an Aperol Spritz here than in Manhattan.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYou cannot limit the number of visitors and let everyone have this sort of holidays. The most beneficial way to limit the number of visitors for local communities is to increase prices. If they want to reserve a number of places for people to be able to visit at a low(er) cost (e.g. through a lottery) then good for them, but there is no entitlement to go on holidays to others' countries or to unique places.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>The most beneficial way to limit the number of visitors for local communities is to increase prices. // Can you expand on that, it doesn't seem self-evident to me.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoI'm assuming that the money goes to the local communities (even countries). If it does then it seems quite obvious that more money is better than less money.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoSell me your brain? It seems like communities can be ruined by richer tourists in ways that not so rich tourists won't. For example, in Pembrokeshire and areas of Devon some communities have been partially replaced by clusters of second-homes because rich people like to have their holidays there. Locals can no longer afford to live there because they lack the wealth to outbid incomers. Maybe that's not quite in scope for "tourism". I can imagine other issues, like facilities being tailored to richer people (all your green spaces get turned into golf courses, or whatever, all the pubs cost a fortune); teachers, services workers and such can't afford to live locally. Richer people maybe cause more environmental damage? 3 cars, private plane, large concreted property, ..., yes at a holiday home, as one goes further up-market? Perhaps good if you want to work in service industries.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago
- imtringued 7y agoin overcrowded locations that have reached their maximum capacity.
- wellactually 7y agoAnother way would be to charge a modest lottery entrance fee and limit the number of winners to a sensible quota.
- asdkhadsj 7y agoScalpers in that market would be intense haha. Legal or not, people would find a way to make market prices
- yoz-y 7y agoThis is why tickets have to be nominative and identity checking enforced.
- brainwad 7y agoRationing is not a very fair way to distribute goods or services to people. Some people may value it just enough to pay the entry fee, while others might value it a lot more, but now they have the same chances of receiving it. If you prohibit people from on-selling their tickets, then you also causes losses when people change their minds but are already locked in by the lottery.
- wellactually 7y agoIt's not a perfect solution, granted, but it's less likely to result in implicit selection of only the wealthiest people.
- dymk 7y agoWhy is that a problem? Plenty of resources are allocated to meet supply and demand. Is traveling to specific locations inherently different?
- wellactually 7y agoIt depends on the values of the host society. They may want to promote democratic access to their country.
- _pmf_ 7y ago> One way to do that is to impose high enough prices. Norway is already too expensive for us (a German lower middleclass family).
- magicalhippo 7y agoAlternatively we could try to make them not all go to the same few spots, ie make more spots tourist friendly.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoWith the current state of the environment I think that keeping areas that do not see many people that way is more important than indulging people's desire for holidays.
- claytoneast 7y agoThis problem has been solved a long time ago by the Departments of Fish and Wildlife for hunting and fishing. A lottery that is tied to an identity, no transfer allowed. Psuedo-RNG, so that each time you enter the lottery and are not selected, your chance to be selected increases next time. The money from the lotteries are used to help conserve the resource that they draw on. Example: https://idfg.idaho.gov/press/bighorn-sheep-lottery-tag-raised-over-109000-sheep-research-and-management https://idfg.idaho.gov/press/bighorn-sheep-lottery-tag-raise... This is not a new or unique problem, and hunters and fishers figured out the solution a long time ago. This could easily be applied to local, state, and national parks. Well, easily is perhaps not the correct word, but there is a known solution to the problem that _can_ be implemented. EDIT: Hunters and fishers figured this out because they fucked up big time and nearly eradicated large populations of animals (see Bison). They (or the D of F & W's) realized they had to do things differently if they wanted to sustainably continue to hunt && fish.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoWhy would the people of Norway, Barcelona, Venice, or anywhere else make efforts to ensure foreigners can visit cheaply? It may make sense for your own citizens to visit irrespective of money, but I would want foreigners to have as much as is needed to keep the number of visitors under control. I think we'll get there at very famous, very limited places like Venice.