17 ms·
What Happened to the Real Time Strategy Genre?
- dchuk 7y agoI don't play games much anymore, but when I did, I always had an affinity for RTS games(Command and Conquer, Age of Empires, Warcraft, etc), and Action RPGs (Diablo, Torchlight). It's exhausting to find games nowadays that don't nickel and dime you to succeed. I like the Kingdom Rush Tower Defense games on iPad when I'm traveling. Any other suggestions?
- elihu 7y ago0AD is pretty good.
- edgarvaldes 7y agoI second this. It can be played with a very modest laptop, also.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIt's also surprisingly complete and polished for an open source game. Recommended.
- jonbaer 7y agoAlso this game is fully open source and is a great resource if you are learning something like Blender or want to dev a game / side mod in .js ... https://github.com/0ad/0ad https://github.com/0ad/0ad
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoFrostpunk is like a modern CoC or Warcraft, but the story is so so dark. Actually maybe closer to a Civ game. https://kotaku.com/you-should-be-playing-the-brutal-city-builder-frostpunk-1825656934 https://kotaku.com/you-should-be-playing-the-brutal-city-bui... Northguard is amazing and very much a successor to the games you mentioned. https://kotaku.com/northgard-demands-that-you-take-winter-seriously-1823670669 https://kotaku.com/northgard-demands-that-you-take-winter-se... On mobile you probably would like the Auto Chess game Dota Underlords. The are the next evolution of the RTS games, that grew out of Warcraft like League of Legends.
- phjesusthatguy3 7y agoI was intrigued by "Auto Chess" so I went and looked it up, and it looks sort of like Archon crossed with an idle game. Interesting, but not really my cup of tea. Has anyone made an up-to-date Archon lately? I know there was The Unholy War on the original PlayStation, but that was a long time ago.
- _bxg1 7y agoBloons, despite the goofy aesthetic, is probably the most balanced and polished tower-defense game I've ever played, and mobile/tablet is its primary platform
- sshagent 7y agoi came here to say this. More along the lines of kingdom rush, but an excellent game. For me personally i spent ages trying to research a mobile game i could just buy and play and not be harassed for micropayments. Bloons is where i ended up. Yes, of course you can show them with extra monies but it really isn't needed at all. Excellent fun game, where you can see your progress over playing it.
- MauranKilom 7y agoZero-K would be my RTS recommendation (it's open source!): https://zero-k.info/ https://zero-k.info/ For ARPGs, the elephant in the room is Path of Exile: https://www.pathofexile.com/ https://www.pathofexile.com/ Neither is really viable for mobile, but I didn't quite catch whether that was a major criterion for you.
- voldacar 7y agoCheck out Path of Exile, it's the most interesting ARPG out there currently
- superkuh 7y agoThe Age of Empires 2 scene is actually growing these days. There's plenty of people to play at whatever skill level you are. It's better than ever.
- 314 7y agoTake a look at They Are Billions. It’s a mixture of city-building, RTS and tower defense. Very good fun.
- gmueckl 7y agoThey are Billions is a very well made game! I like it. And it's actually a refreshingly colorful game. The tower defense element (thousands of zombies spawning and storming your settlement) makes it a pretty punishing game: you try to frantically build out your settlement while protecting it from early waves for about two hours before the inevitable overwhelming final wave comes. You don't know until the very end whether you are doing OK or not.
- danielbarla 7y agoIn addition to the Path of Exile suggestions, I'd recommend Grim Dawn as an alternative. An extremely fun and interesting Diablo clone. Coincidentally, the prequel / same engine was used for 2006's Titan Quest, which is now available on iOS and Android. Although I haven't actually played the mobile versions, I think as per the original, there won't be any microtransactions, or multi level marketing schemes to "win", just dozens of hours of campaign. Both games are highly recommended in general, the class systems offer such interesting and unique combinations.
- dleslie 7y agoIMHO, the core series focused too heavily on maximizing the experience for esports, and that spoiled the genre for the mid-range gamers that were its bread and butter. And still, Dawn of War, Company of Heroes, Supreme Commander, Planetary Annihilation et al were not so long ago. And OpenRA itself has been somewhat of a success. BTW, C&C has a Red Alert reboot coming out before too long. It will be classic in design.
- defertoreptar 7y ago> the core series focused too heavily on maximizing the experience for esports, and that spoiled the genre for the mid-range gamers that were its bread and butter. Out of curiosity, in what ways in particular did they do this?
- kyralis 7y agoPersonally, I felt this way about SC2 as compared to SC1. I think one of the largest changes I noticed was an increase in the hardness of counters as well as an increase in the APM necessary to properly wield certain units. For the first point, in SC1, if I had suboptimal army composition against my opponent, I would likely lose any battles that ensued unless my tactics were quite superior- but I'd likely due some damage in the process, at least. In contrast, in SC2, it always felt like a failure to properly anticipate army makeup would frequently lead to completely lopsided battles where my force might be completely annihilated without doing measurable damage to the opponent. This was aggravated by the second point. I'm not a professional player and my APM has never been amazing, and I'm fine with that. But the more complex required army composition put a higher emphasis on APM and in-battle tactics, especially with heterogenous forces and units, like blink stalkers, that really benefit from very high levels of micro. I'll be the first to admit that, when watching replays, the things that skilled players could pull off in SC2 was pretty amazing to see- but that didn't really help my playing experience. There result was a game that felt significantly more frustrating than SC1, even if my win/loss ratio wasn't actually all that different.
- Dylan16807 7y ago
- monster99 7y agoThe rise of internet enabled microtransactions and the masses bought drm laden games they didn't own like mmo's... Once the masses fell for mainframe/dumb client, companies now controlled the software and could insert bs monetization.
- mmonster999 7y agoThe rise of internet enabled microtransactions and the masses bought drm laden games they didn't own like mmo's... Once the masses fell for mainframe/dumb client, companies now controlled the software and could insert bs monetization. All game design has been effected since game companies took control of game software starting from 1997 onlward with the release of ultima online. The whole project was to undermine game ownership from the very get go. Here's the game industry gloating of it's great victory of the PC gaming masses: https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-04-01-making-piracy-and-preowned-games-problems-of-the-past https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2019-04-01-making-pir...
- chrisco255 7y agoI played StarCraft 2 for nearly a decade after it came out. It was always a solid experience. It is surprising that in all that time, there hasn't been a serious competitor to SC2 in the traditional RTS format. This article does a great job of breaking down why that might be. I mean, the mobile revolution did take some steam and excitement out of PC gaming for a while there. As the author points out, game devs tend to chase the trends and in some cases, they have to. I agree with the author's conclusion that the industry is missing out on a big opportunity. They remain to this day my most satisfying gaming experiences. And if they're done right and well balanced, people will play the same RTS for decades, so they have a lot of staying power.
- Fr0styMatt88 7y agoI remember when the iPad came out I was incredibly excited. This was surely perfect for RTS games! There was Command & Conquer: Red Alert Mobile, then.... The only other one I remember was an actually really good StarCraft clone by Gameloft (I forget the name). I always thought mobile would be great for RTS and then it just wasn't. Though when I think about it, the keyboard is pretty important and that kind of fast control is really difficult on a touchscreen, so maybe that explains the lack of 'classic' RTS games on touch devices.
- nlh 7y agoYou wrote exactly my thoughts! I was so excited for a new generation of touch-optimized RTS games when the iPad was released and I’ve been disappointed with the options. Do you (or anyone) know of any iPad games that fit the bill these days? I played Vainglory for a while but that’s not a RTS - it’s a MOBA (and was fun and worked super well on touch).
- Can_Not 7y agoSomeone else mentioned Rusted Warfare.
- Pfhreak 7y agoStarcraft is still very much around. But I suspect people went to mobas like League of Legends because they wanted a more social, team based experience and they liked playing a hero.
- ben174 7y agoAlso Microsoft is working on Age of Empires IV which will be huge.
- superkuh 7y agoI doubt it. Age of Empires 2 is pretty much the entire AoE scene left. And Age of Empires 2 definitive edition (AoE2DE) is coming out soon. And that'll only work if it accurately recreates the AoE2 experience with better graphics and slightly better interface. I expect any modern non-AoE2 AoE game to be just as bad as any other modern RTS. Even AOE2 DE was/is probably going to be requiring Win 10 just to force people to upgrade. MS is still MS.
- BuckRogers 7y agoNot an unreasonable request, Windows 7 is a decade old. Computers are tools and you need to keep your tools up to date, at least if you're not writing the code yourself to keep it secure and running.
- superkuh 7y agoNot unreasonable in general but there's absolutely no reason that AoE2DE needs to use DX12 and the Win 10 requirements that come with it. And there's a significant reason why they shouldn't. A large fraction of the player population is in countries without access to large purchasing power or modern computing equipment. If it requires 10 then a large part of the playerbase will simply stick with AoE2 AoC on voobly or HD on steam. So DE will only be new players or players in rich western economies. MS is showing they either don't care or don't understand the AoE2 scene.
- m463 7y agoI play older games, the ones without a forced online requirement or telemetry. I wonder if this colors the author's statistics, because he is getting his statistics from games that collect them. I have a library of steam games I downloaded then have been playing in offline mode for quite some time. free to play? (grind or pay) bah. I would love to hear people's suggestions for favorite offline games.
- blihp 7y agoMyth II was my favorite game of the era. There were also a number of community created scenarios created for it. Highly recommended if you can get you hands on a CD for it. Not sure how well it still runs (or not) under Windows but it still runs great on Linux under Wine. It lives on as Project Magma (http://projectmagma.net/ http://projectmagma.net/) but the scenarios that shipped with Myth II are what made the game for me.
- ebg13 7y agoWhile both great games (we ignore III), the Myth games were better classified as real time tactics, not real time strategy. There is no growth past the beginning of a campaign. There is only range, terrain, and formations (veteran survivor prowess notwithstanding) until your units die. Also carpet bombing, remote lightning, and phantom trow kick glitch attacks. I'm not crying, you're crying. To this day, though, I don't think a better pair of games has been made, and I will always be sad about Bungie abandoning the franchise during the Microsoft purchase.
- openfuture 7y agoI've been meaning to cash in on this for a while. Too bad that I overcomplicate everything I try to do and accomplish nothing... Anyway, great post! This guy is very right, hopefully we start getting good strategy games soon.
- azernik 7y ago> Some people from Relic split off to found Blackbird Interactive. They made a prequel to Homeworld which is apparently really good. They’re now also working on Homeworld 3. Said prequel is Deserts of Kharak, and is indeed quite good. Am replaying it right now, and despite being land-based and 2D rather than space-based and 3D, it still feels like the original Homeworld in terms of pacing and strategy.
- gmueckl 7y agoYes, they manged to carry over essential design elements into their land based setting: there are no stationary bases. You have a huge, unique carrier vehicle instead of a mothership. The harvesting mechanics are almost identical. The biggest difference really is the terrain. The game has an easier time shaping the challenges by making use of terrain. In space, breaking the uniformity of the map was more challenging and the original Homeworld series didn't do too well in that regard. Finding in-universe reasons to make space non-uniform is apparently hard. There are resource spots and regions which affected ship systems, but that's it.
- Havoc 7y ago>Said prequel is Deserts of Kharak, and is indeed quite good. I thought the missions were quite tedious tbh. I gave up after the 3rd case of "where is the last enemy unit on map" hunt
- sueders101 7y agoThe most popular, recently released RTS I can think of is Factorio. It seems like RTS game elements have been splitting into their constituent parts and forming a game around those.(e.g. production to Factorio, or combat to DOTA) It may be that way there’s a greater ROI on smaller/simpler games than building out all the components involved in an RTS game.
- FrozenVoid 7y agoToday gamers don't like to multi-task and Starcraft(and its clones) is a multi-tasking monster(scouting,economy, building, combat), so similar RTS which force multiple issues at same time are outfoxed by simpler game mechanic games where attention is more deeply focused and players can gain skills easier. Another factor is RTS are anti-casual, they don't forgive mistakes and only a tiny % of gamers can handle the stress of constant losing/failing, in context of highly demanding, multitasking heavy game. The genre doesn't accept game style variations either - a single cookie-cutter build order is the best one, the rest is suboptimal and loses you either time or money.
- wanderer2323 7y agoThe 'combined arms' approach where your 'macro' is turn-based and your 'micro' is real-time is doing very well in Total War franchise (briefly mentioned in the article). Turn-based aspect of settlement/empire management flows much better than real-time base-building aspect of the classic RTSes. Battles being fought in a separate real-time ux means that you can field thousands of troop models while micro-managing tens of 'squads' -- and you don't have to worry about strategic side in the middle of the battle. Both aspects are richer as a result of separation.
- Dylan16807 7y agoYou say "richer", I say "removes important difficulty". Part of what makes the genre interesting is balancing your attention between these different aspects. But more importantly, it's critical to an RTS that you can use micro to disrupt enemy resource gathering. If all unit movement is decided on a turn-based world map, you can't sneak around a distracted army to take out a strategic point. Micro still influences who wins a battle, but you have to have a head-on fight. A combat is stuck in one grid cell instead of having access to the entire world. (The hybrid design can make the macro richer. But troop movement and micro suffer a lot. It's not win/win.)
- matthewowen 7y ago> you can't sneak around a distracted army to take out a strategic point Sure you can. In civ for example, sail your fleet one way under fog of war, move your army another to suck in units. I would argue that sneaking based on "the human playing the video game was focused on something else" is a less compelling dynamic than sneaking based on "real" dynamics.
- Dylan16807 7y ago> Sure you can. In civ for example, sail your fleet one way under fog of war, move your army another to suck in units. That's not getting around a distracted army. Even if we ignore player focus, and pretend everyone can multitask perfectly, you're still losing options. You can't engage in a big fight on one side of a map just long enough for a flanking force to hit a critical target, then immediately retreat out of the main fight to avoid losses. With turn-based movement, that big fight is either unnecessary or it's likely to get your army crushed by the non-split-up force from lack of retreat options. And you can't dodge an intercepting force with most forms of turn-based movement.
- thefounder 7y agoWarcraft Reforged is about to be launched so it's not all lost
- hartator 7y agoI don’t have an answer either. Playing a lot of SC2 and waiting for Homeworld 3. 2022 ETA though. My main explanation is more recent strategy games have been a let down and as graphics don’t matter as much, players stick to old games discouraging even more game studios to try again.
- tomc1985 7y agoIt makes me sad to see no mention of Total Annihilation or Supreme Commander anywhere :( IMO both are far superior to Starcraft or even AOE
- willis936 7y agoSupreme commander was the first RTS I really sunk my teeth into. Planetary Annihilation is an excellent spiritual successor and still gets updates.
- yellowapple 7y agoI'd count Paradox's games (Hearts of Iron, Europa Universalis, Stellaris, etc.) as "real time" strategy; they're certainly not turn-based. And as far as strategy games go, they're nowadays the gold standard, IMO. Looking forward to Homeworld 3. Fingers crossed for a Linux-native version, but if not, then hopefully it's as Wine/Proton-friendly as Homeworld: Remastered (and more so than Deserts of Kharak).
- isostatic 7y agoTotal Annihilation holds a big part in my history. It was a great game for one thing, but annihilated.com inspired me to get into running a website. Thanks to TA and annihilated, I ran my own website based on a game (a Star Trek one), which at peak in 1999 was getting 2000 uniques a day. Taking USD cheques (like $40) from doubleclick into my UK bank in my school uniform in 1998ish was a unique experience. Thanks to that experience it drove me to where I am today. As far as actual RTS game play, Red Alert was best in my view. One disc for soviet, one for allied. Tanya, Dogs, and Tesla Coils. So many hours, so little to show for it.
- Sohcahtoa82 7y agoI liked TA much more than RA. The strategy felt deeper, plus I liked the idea of the Commander unit representing you on the battle field. Sending him into battle was a risky move. The D-Gun made him extremely powerful, but if he died, you lose. The nukes in RA were also just plain pitiful and not really worth the time to build.
- diydsp 7y agowe used to play TA at lunch...but cut it off abruptly after an hour.. . so we'd spend 55 minutes building up epic armies then send them to apocalypse for the last 5 minutes :) I tried to fire up my TA disk in a Win7 machine a few years ago, but the graphics came out all wrong :( any suggestions for reviving it?
- rangibaby 7y agoTry this patch: https://www.tauniverse.com/forum/showthread.php?t=43735 https://www.tauniverse.com/forum/showthread.php?t=43735
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoThere is also the spring project. http://www.springrts.com/ http://www.springrts.com/
- 3131s 7y ago
- isostatic 7y agoNot RTS, but certainly real time, and as old as the hills. Railroad Tycoon The sequels never really did it for me. Transport Tycoon sucked up the hours, but nothing really did it as much as the feel of that first game. Maybe it was the time — the CGA monitor (which couldn’t cope with Civilisation), no mouse of course. I did play it years later and it want the same. I doubt that feeling can be recaptured. It probably never existed - its a sepia tomes memory of a feeling from a different time with different expectations - but for some reasons the original Railroad Tycoon really stuck with me.
- mellab2 7y agoYou might want to check out Railway Empire, it’s considered a spiritual successor.
- yxhuvud 7y agoThe map missions in Railway Empire make it a lot less like Railroad Tycoon than what I'd want. What really made RT great was the open ended ways to succeed, while the very focused missions in RE too often forces me to build specific things in specific order. I really miss the freedom the map objectives in RT3 gave me. That said, it is a great game and it is one of the highlights of the railroad-building genre.
- mdavidn 7y agoIf you're looking for a modern derivative of Railroad Tycoon, you may enjoy Transport Fever. You'll find its demand-driven economy familiar, and staying solvent in the early game is tricky. Fever places a bigger emphasis on terrain—managing grade and turn radius to improve the speed (and profitability) of your vehicles.
- temporaryvector 7y agoI think this is a common enough sentiment. Your first games leave more of an impact and that feeling is often not really related to how good the game is. Just like comfort food, they're comfort games. I never player Railroad Tycoon, my first in that genre was Transport Tycoon Deluxe, but I feel pretty much the same way about it, and I'm pretty lucky that OpenTTD exists. Similarly there's a game called Star Reach (also known as Space Federation) that was the first strategy game I played. In retrospect, it was pretty bad, but sometimes I want to play a space game and not even much superior games like Masters of Orion or more modern games like Sins of a Solar Empire will satisfy the particular craving like Star Reach.
- Steven_Vellon 7y ago2004, 2006, and 2007 for Dawn of War, CoH, and SC respectively. More well known titles like Red Alert 2, Command and Conquer Generals, and Warcraft 3 were even earlier than that. Starcraft 2 was the last "AAA" RTS game that I can think of. Deserts of Kharak is probably the only RTS game I've played in the last 8 years that I really enjoyed. I tried CoH 2, but the micro transactions put me off. Eugen's Wargame series and Steel Divison had interesting and deep nuanced mechanics, but single player was very rough and the multiplayer player base wasn't big enough to sustain a good matchmaking experience. Personally, I think the main culprit is that MOBAs like DotA 2 and League of Legends are too similar in genre and won over much of the RTS player base. Anecdotally, most of the people I knew that were into SC 2 started playing League or Dota 2. Edit: I totally blanked out on the Total War franchise. That's definitely a staple of mine, and still playing Rome 1 and Medieval 2 mods to this day.
- russellbeattie 7y agoThe domination of StarCraft has always bewildered me. I really loved the Battle for Middle Earth games back in the day as they were much more slow paced than SC. I absolutely loved spending an hour in total silence frantically constructing a base or two with massive armies before sending them off en masse against my opponent(s) - usually a friend or two connected via a LAN so you could hear their occasional grunts and chuckles, before cries of dismay or triumph. So fun! Actually, when my son was little 10 years ago, we used to play Lego Battles on the Nintendo DS, which was a mini RTS and that was surprisingly fun as well! Definitely sad the genre disappeared.
- nestorD 7y agoBattle for Middle Earth 1 is definitely one of my favorite RTS, I love how the constraints on buildings played into the mecanics of the game (not a fan of the second one which was more classic). By the way, if someone is still playing out there, the dwarf hold mod was a great extension to the base game : https://www.moddb.com/mods/the-dwarf-holds https://www.moddb.com/mods/the-dwarf-holds
- pmoriarty 7y agoThe last RTS I really enjoyed was Total Annihilation, but recently I gave Factorio a try and got pretty addicted. Great game.
- eihli 7y agoHave you tried Supreme Commander? It's the spiritual successor to TA and is amazing. There's a community lobby, Forged Alliance Forever, that has a solid number of active players.
- AndyMcConachie 7y agoI've never actually played Supreme Commander Forged Alliance or any of the Supreme Commander titles. But I love watching gameplay of it. Gyle's channel on Youtube has some of the best replays around if you're like me and just like watching competitive RTS gaming. https://www.youtube.com/user/felixlighta https://www.youtube.com/user/felixlighta
- Kiro 7y agoShould I play 1 or 2?
- ThrowawayR2 7y agoNot 2; that's a whole different beast that was not well received. Play Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance, which is more or less v. 1.5, and widely considered to be the pinnacle of the series. The original Supreme Commander is not bad as well and interesting if you want to see the storyline that Forged Alliance sprang from.
- heelix 7y agohttps://www.faforever.com https://www.faforever.com is a community lobby/patch for SupCom:FA (first series). They continue to patch it and support the multiplayer lobby. SupCom 2 was hot trash. An attempt to make an RTS xbox friendly. Some of the worst voice acting in decades of gaming.
- 7y ago
- dwighttk 7y agoDon’t know if it counts but did anyone else like the close combat series? I only ever played the first one because the others were PC only. I’ve even bought a few of the later ones recently on GOG, but I can’t get them to run with WINE.
- denton-scratch 7y agoI've played a few of these; I think I liked the Battle of the Bulge episode best (pacier than the preceding episodes). The first was really slow-moving. A Bridge Too Far was annoying.
- GeneralTspoon 7y agoCC3: The Russian Front was amazing! It feels kind of like it fits into a separate genre of “digital tabletop war games” (due to the fact that you pick your units from a large roster using points, rather than build them in-game, and had a focus on campaigns where the balance of power swung back and forth). The demo of the British one (CC2 maybe?) was the one that got me into it. I think they were remade by another company a few years back actually - but I’d definitely throw money at a modernized take on a similar concept. Does anyone know other similar games?
- someexgamedev 7y agoI've heard the RTS genre described as three sliders. 1. Amount of control over units 2. Amount of control over a hero 3. Amount of control over building infrastructure By that definition, RTS is still alive and well. It's just that the particular position of those sliders has changed over time. We have MOBAs which set all the sliders to zero except the hero one. Mobile games like Clash of Clans and Clash Royale provide two more popular configurations. As for what happened to the classic RTS config many grew up with in the 90s and oughties? My best guess is snuffed out by shifts in game dev economics. AAA single player games only work on consoles (where the controller never played well with RTS) and the near-requirement for every PC multiplayer game to present as an esport raises the buy-in too high
- rs23296008n1 7y agoCan't believe no one has mentioned Factorio. Programmer crack.
- brunoTbear 7y agoThe fact that Homeworld wasn't mentioned until the last paragraph was a major case of "they had us in the first half not gonna lie" for me. Cannot wait for the sequel. I spent so many hours playing HW1. Great balance of macro and micro strategy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- farah7 7y agoI've been waiting for Warcraft 4 for 15 years now (can't believe it's been that long!). Warcraft III/Frozen throne are quite simply the best games that I've ever played, none have ever come close. I'd give honourable mention to Age of Empires/Rise of Nations. I think it was killed due to the success of World of Warcraft.
- Romanulus 7y agoYou're probably correct. Given the amount of mental energy you need to dump into a game to win against your opponent is high, albeit short lived. These bursts of cerebral fortitude can be exhausting and annoying if you are the loser (which there always will be one of). Given that risk to reward I can totally see why more gentile games like MMOs, Minecraft, hell even MOBAs have taken over. They are a lot easier to slide into (and out) at every skill level, which also equates to more money to the developers due to a lowering of the bar.
- pcdoodle 7y agoSame here. It has everything and more character than any other RTS ever made. The damn menu music puts me into Warcraft Meditation Mode. When playing on a CRT monitor the particle effect are "lickable". Major sense of accomplishment playing hard in single player too.
- alexgmcm 7y agoThey are releasing a remaster of Warcraft 3, no? I remember having fun with WC3 so I'll probably give it a try.
- BuckRogers 7y agoMy first RTS was the first RTS, Dune. Warcraft 3 is very late stage in the genre and I preferred Warcraft 2 far more. WC3 was a disappointment for me. The genre was mostly exhausted by that time. Today it's all about SC2 for a traditional experience but most people I know are playing League of Legends.
- Giorgi 7y agoWarcraft III was the start of RTS genre downhill, all that micromanagement of heroes made it pseudo-rts, it was probably where Blizzard got it's WoW idea.
- b0rsuk 7y agoI think it boils down to four things: - RTS games, since the first C&C, used an interface for selecting rectangles and pointing them at a single target. It scales extremely poorly. Innovations in this area have failed to catch on. Keyboard used for shortcuts only. Come on, we can do better than that. We have Vim. Action, range(movement key). Alternatively, the Kakoune way: selection first, action second. Either way games lack a fast way to select only certain types of units, and especially - to point them at targets of certain types. Harvest: Massive Encounter is a low budget tower defense games which allows you to set targetting priorities for each type of your tower, but RTS games need much, much more systems like that. Meanwhile Starcraft has been busy embracing and glorifying primitive user interfaces. It has its caveman charm, but - by design - it scales only by clicking faster. - RTS games were popular at a time when computers were predominantly used by nerds. RTS games appeal mostly to people willing to get better at a game. Publishers discovered less demanding games sell better. - RTS games are highly demanding to make from technical point of view. You get all the joys of pathfinding at large scale. Optimizations are very important. - RTS games are not that immersive. This is true for all "topdown" perspective games.
- b0rsuk 7y agoI just came up with a 5th: - RTS games work poorly on consoles. They need a precise input device.
- celeritascelery 7y agoThat is only true if Starcraft style RTS games.
- gmueckl 7y agoAs opposed to which other style/styles?
- real_escape 7y agoArcade. As the godfather of all RTS, Herzog Zwei, used. Gameplay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYfYrhT82RM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYfYrhT82RM
- Kiro 7y agoThey Are Billions is amazing.
- b0rsuk 7y agoAm I the only person missing the old C&C style games, before Generals? I'm not saying C&C:Generals was a bad game - it was quite popular - but from design point of view it was a Starcraft clone. They abandoned the old, quirky Dune2/C&C design with low count, remote harvesters, multiple factories which only sped up the rate of production, instantly deployed buildings, instant selling etc. These things had some flaws, but also advantages, and most importantly - they resulted in a different experience. I think C&C: Red Alert 2 was the high point of that design. Optimal action speed, counters that weren't too hard, varied units.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoI loved Generals the most, especially for it's rock paper scissors system where every unit, including the most powerfull and armored ones, had a few it was vulnerable against. But they made it too realistic so the gameplay and units were really slow so games can get long and boring after a while.
- drdeadringer 7y agoThis may be unpopular, but I enjoyed the entire C&C run right to the very end. This includes the first-person shooter stint along with the "mobile MCV" stint. Kane as a character holds a place in my heart and memory, as does Tiberium. Soundtracks and cut scenes were great too. May I enjoy this block of Memory Lane as much as I am able.
- efdee 7y agoI actually remember very much liking the FPS version.
- klingonopera 7y agoThat FPS was C&C: Renegade, and I absolutely enjoyed it too. It had all the cheesy dialogue and cliché elements that kinda gave C&C an 80s action movie flick flair, and I was really disappointed that it wasn't so successful. I think that the multiplayer parts weren't really refined enough to make it a hit... there was too much "base-building-components" for an MP game, I think they should've went with a "Battlefield 1942"-style of gameplay... holy crap, now that would've been awesome! EDIT: They were released around the same time, so there wasn't any blueprint for the BF1942 style of gameplay around at the time. I think making vehicles spawn for everyone and not tying it to your success is part of what made BF1942 so popular in the day. Of all the RTS games from C&C, RA2 was my favorite. Tiberium Sun was just a stone throw before my time, so when I played it, I was missing all the new elements from RA2. It's no fault of TS, just that I have already been "spoilt" by that time... Tiberium Wars was also pretty nice, though I only played some LAN skirmishes with friends, never the campaign. But from the looks of things, it was the last "real" RTS in the C&C series. The latest two RTS installments, RA3 and the last Tiberium one, already forgot what it's called, were just trash, IMHO. In the latter, the publisher (EA?) was obviously trying to kill two birds with one stone, i.e. make a game for both PC and mobile markets, and C&C was the guinea pig brought in. Obviously, the publisher had no idea what C&C is about and where its true value lies. That's some pretty bad management, actually, but that publisher is known for treating their consumers like replaceable goods, completely neglecting any artistic value a game might have and the therefore resulting fan-base/community like consumer-behaviour.
- caymanjim 7y ago> Blizzard had a long distraction with WoW, then they made Starcraft 2 followed by the MOBA Heroes of the Storm. They’re still insanely successful. Now they’re remaking their old games, recently releasing a HD remake of Starcraft 1 and are about to release a remake of Warcraft III. Blizzard went off the rails by dumbing down WoW steadily over ten years, appealing to the lowest common demoninator. Modern WoW is boring, unchallenging, and appears designed to provoke the least amount of whining by a vocal but dispassionate player base. If you look at a chart of subscriptions over time, it peaked with an expansion ten years ago, and has declined steadily since. This coincides with changes to the game that made it require less time, less thinking, and less skill. I imagine they felt they were broadening the appeal, but they turned off the players who made the game a blockbuster. If you removed people who still pay for it but don't play, or people clinging to nostalgia, the numbers would tank even more. I was surprised when they re-released the original game as "Classic WoW". While I don't know what the subscriber numbers look like, the servers are overflowing, and the player base is even more passionate than when it was released 15 years ago. I think the same thing happened with other recent Blizzard games. They went for mass appeal in a way that turned off the players who helped build their empire. Chasing the MOBA fad didn't work out for them. I'm glad they're going back to their roots. Maybe I'm just a crusty old gamer nostalgic for the past, but there are a lot of us out there.
- Ntrails 7y agoI am not sure I buy into this narrative so much anymore. The game is old and the original userbase has moved on. I am not convinced that WoW could ever have kept catching new players and retaining the old ones however they chose to proceed. The burst of excitement for Classic will last a while and then fade too. I think, at least.
- Mirioron 7y agoI think Classic will fade, because it's hyped up to be more than it really is. Old WoW was difficult, but part of that difficulty was that people just weren't as good at the game back then (or games in general?). Many people were already doing Molten Core just a few days after release of Classic.
- temporaryvector 7y agoMy take on this is that RTSs are generally unpopular because of their long feedback loop. In an FPS game, or even a modern MOBA, the decisions you take result in an almost immediate death (yours or the opponent's). If you're doing something wrong, you'll know pretty much immediately, rarely will you have to wait more than a minute between doing something wrong and getting punished for it. This also means that you tend to know what exactly you did wrong, maybe you shot too soon, maybe you aimed wrong, maybe you didn't jump enough, etc. In most game genres you go through encounters quickly: spawn, die, repeat until you get good. RTSs are almost unique among game genres in that you're forced to make decisions quickly but the results of those decisions don't become apparent for anywhere between 10 minutes to an hour. A single "encounter" takes a good chunk of your time and your reward for that time can often be that you get to watch for 10 to 15 minutes as your best laid plans are ripped apart and everything you've built up is methodically destroyed, and at the end of it all, you can't even be sure what is it that you did wrong because you made so many decisions without seeing their immediate result. Add to that the fact that most RTSs are pretty unbalanced at any level above absolute beginner. So in the end, you're left wondering if the other guy won because you built too many kbot factories too early, or because you didn't scout enough, or because he rushed you with Flashes and those are overpowered? Did the map favor him? How do you counter a Flash rush? All those questions crop up and are really hard to answer. This makes for a frustrating experience for new and medium-skill players alike. That said, I don't think RTSs got less popular with time in an absolute sense, I think they only got relatively less popular because gaming itself has become more mainstream. It is my belief that it takes a certain kind of personality to enjoy RTS games, which represents a certain percentage of the total human population, which is much less than the percentage of the population that can enjoy video games in general. As gaming became mainstream, the number of people enjoying RTSs stayed roughly constant, but as a percentage of all games it became smaller and smaller, thus it made no sense to keep developing RTSs. Multiplayer RTS has always been a niche genre that few people enjoyed, but when gaming was also niche it still made sense to make RTS games. Now, when it comes to the question posed in the article, why did Blizzard's RTSs, Brood War and later WC3, got popular and stayed popular? Some people will say is that it's because it's balanced, quick and varied, but Starcraft didn't start out balanced, and it didn't get balanced until map makers learned to make balanced maps. In a sense, Starcraft is still not really balanced because you can easily make a map where one race will dominate (just try to find an Island game anywhere on ladder and you'll see what I mean, for example). My theory for why Starcraft (and later WC3) succeeded where the others failed comes down to two things: Use Map Settings and Battle.net. I said earlier that few people enjoy multiplayer RTSs and I stand-by that, and if you spent any time on Battle.net in the early 2000s, you would see that most people didn't play Starcraft the way it was intended. UMS always had a lot more games going than regular Melee, and a large percentage of regular Melee was 7v1 computer or Faster Map Ever, No Rush 20 minutes or other things that changed the base mechanics of the game to make it a lot more forgiving. The amount of people playing actual, competitive 1v1s or 2v2s was tiny in comparison. So why didn't all those people who didn't really like RTS stuck around in an RTS game? Well because their friends were there, and all the other UMS maps were fun, if you got stomped in a bunch of 1v1s and got frustrated, you could go play some Bounds, or a Cannon Defense. Maybe an RPG or an Open RPG map, maybe The Thing, maybe Aeon of Strife for that early MOBA experience. Everything was available within that same game, and the best part was that all your friends were just an /f m away, later on even if they were playing Diablo 2 or WC3. It was pretty seamless, and other gaming services couldn't really compare until things like Steam and Xbox Live came about. You could stay in the game without ever touching the RTS portion of it, and I know a lot of people who did, and you could meet people and become friends without ever needing another method of communication besides Battle.net, all from within Starcraft (unlike most other gaming services of the time). Somewhat ironically, what made Starcraft (and later WC3) so popular are all the parts that weren't an RTS, it was a do-everything game that had a little something for everyone. All the balancing and the e-sports came later, after Starcraft had already gotten big enough and gained enough of an audience for people to learn to make balanced maps. Brood War was released in 1998, and the patches where they finally nailed the current balance came somewhere around 2001 (1.08), and by that time it was already pretty popular. I'm not sure Starcraft would have ever gotten to 1.08 without UMS and Battle.net. This got a little long-winded, because I've spent considerable time thinking about this very topic, but my main point is that RTS (particularly the competitive multiplayer kind) as a genre has always been niche and will remain a niche genre, and the wild success of Starcraft and its successors is specifically due to the fact that it had a lot more to offer than just RTS.
- bni 7y agoRTS works surprisingly great in VR. One of the best games I have played in recent years is Hidden Paths Brass Tactics. I really don't understand why this game didn't get more attention than it did.
- nestorD 7y agoSmall shoutout for 0AD which is a fully open source RTS in the style of age of empire and now very polished (my little brother, who was used to starcraft, is now playing it happily) : https://play0ad.com https://play0ad.com
- dainchi 7y agoIts worth mentioning that there’s still some active nultiplayer communities for older RTS games around. FAForever for Supreme Commander und Massgate for World in Conflict have been around for quite some time. www.faforever.com www.massgate.org
- bge0 7y agoSupreme Commander Forged Alliance: I have yet to find anything that comes close to the scope and joy induced by this game.
- willis936 7y agoYou should look into Planetary Annihilation if you haven’t already.
- everyone 7y agoTheres a really good community made client for 'Supreme Commander' https://www.faforever.com/ https://www.faforever.com/
- willis936 7y agoThis is pretty cool. Did they fix issues that caused games to crash after a few hours? Even loading up the state of a game that had been long would cause it to crash again. My guess is a memory leak.
- heelix 7y agoI suspect so. I play a lot of this and things are pretty stable. They did a lot of patching and reworking in combination with the original files. The reason for tying your steam copy of SupCom:FA to the FAF code is to avoid legal issues with the community patching using the original assets.
- neverminder 7y agoI like RTS games just as the next guy and I am also disappointed that cult franchises such as Age of Empires, Starcraft, Warcraft, etc stopped releasing new games. But I like Turn Based Strategy even more, franchises like Heroes of MIght and Magic, Age of Wonders, Civilization, Total War are my favorite and they are also consistently releasing new games all the time. Recently I've been playing Total War: Three Kingdoms. Total War is a hybrid game - adventure man is turn based, but battles are real time. I was both skeptical and curious about this approach, but when I tried it I liked it. Then I read somewhere the reason of why the creators did it this way - it's because controlling a huge map with 10+ armies, economy, diplomacy, etc real time would be impossible. So essentially TBS allows the player to go at their own pace which could be one of the reasons of why RTS lost it's popularity.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoIf you like the Civ and HOMM series, you might wish to try Endless Space 2 as well. It's perhaps the best TBS I've ever played, and I started with the original Civ. (Actually, before all that I played Might and Magic on my C64, but that wasn't TBS.)
- projektir 7y agoWant to chip in here, love Endless Space 2! It takes a bit to get used to but it's so fun to just play even if I'm not winning.
- larrydag 7y agoWarzone 2100 is my favorite RTS. LAN play a lot with my kids. https://wz2100.net/ https://wz2100.net/
- Dumblydorr 7y agoIt's too hard for most players. Dota and LoL have similarity in being real time, but you get the comfort to blame teammates for your loss and it's much slower paced. In starcraft, you are literally playing by yourself as fast as possible for the entire match, win or lose, no breaks for respawns or waiting, and you can lose in some spectacularly frustrating ways. Ever move command your army into theirs and lose it all? Ever hit yourself with a spell? Find their hidden tech or hidden base way too late? I love it but it's seriously a masochistic genre of gaming.
- clord 7y agoI blame the rise of more effective DRM and the removal/demoting of lan play in favor of hosted servers. All of my favorite RTS games were discovered while at a friends house. We’d do a quick copy and have an epic game session, creating a legend game that I’ve bought multiple times since. Studios should allow copying of games for some purposes like local multiplayer, but protect single player and internet content with IAP, so that the game spreads virally, creating a large market and a strong brand. This was exactly how many of the classics got started, but back then it was in spite of the studios intentions. I think a good rts could still spread that way but now players would welcome the IAP, as long as core mechanics are available and it’s not pay-to-level-up.
- tholman 7y agoLate to the party, but worth throwing the browser rebuild of tiberium wars out there. - https://www.adityaravishankar.com/projects/games/command-and-conquer/ https://www.adityaravishankar.com/projects/games/command-and...
- lucb1e 7y agoTiberian Dawn, not Tiberium Wars. TW is CNC3 and in 3D, TD is the very first one. For a minute I got excited...
- n_ary 7y agoFor AOE fans, AOE has a DE in Steam, pretty graphics for large screens and new music, though underlying game remains the same it seems. AOE-2 has a HD version for large screens, but DE with pretty graphics are coming this November(2019). Even though I haven't played games for years, coming back to AOE was nostalgic and last Friday I was lost in the game for 5+ hours, still as fun as ever. (: *DE - Definitive Edition
- helpPeople 7y agoStarCraft2 was very popular and had hundreds of thousands of people watching touries. But honestly the game had serious balance issues and IMO drove me crazy. I'm curious if other users stoped watching and playing as well. Protoss imba
- throwaway-1436 7y agoBlizzard cleaned it all up. Their games were so good no one even bothered to compete. I spent countless hours playing starcraft and warcraft. The other games didn't have the same addictive elements.
- BuckRogers 7y agoAgreed, it's a huge reason. Blizzard is the Nintendo of the PC space. Developers have noted for ages that competing on Nintendo platforms meant you had to match their 1st party titles. Which are held to a higher standard than others and don't get the reviews they deserve. There are few true competitors to the Mario games, Smash Bros, Mario Party, and Mario Kart for the same reason most people don't want to be compared to Blizzard's efforts.
- nlh 7y agoI posted something similar in a child comment but wanted to see if anyone had suggestions: I bought an iPad excited for a generation of touch-optimizes RTS games and have been...disappointed. I played around with some of the MOBAs (Vainglory, etc) but that genre isn’t for me. Are there any great (or even decent) iOS games that fit the RTS bill? I see a ton in the App Store that match the description but most just end up being free to play micro transaction gambling/monetization pits of despair, not actual RTS. Suggestions appreciated!
- twright 7y agoI have two: “rymdkapsel” is very in the category, no multiplayer but single player kept me occupied for a time. “Mini-Metro” I think is kinda in the category but with a lot more replayability. Neither have iaps but have a small upfront cost.
- nlh 7y agoSuper cool. Thanks for the suggestions! Will check them out.
- nyhc99 7y agoI never liked the move to really fast-paced, micro-intensive play. Real Time doesn't have to mean such a flurry of movement and clicking. From Starcraft on it seems like the genre has pushed more and more towards the micromanagement game. Heroes exemplified that in WC3. A battle with more, slower moving units and simplified commands makes for a more tactical match-up that's less about hotkeys and razor-sharp reaction time and more about the art of war. Does anyone know if there's a franchise out there moving in that direction?
- SteveNuts 7y agoThe total war series is pretty close to what you're talking about. The problem with your opinion is someone who _does_ do those things will always have an advantage over someone playing more passively.
- nyhc99 7y agoOh of course, but that added advantage can be minimized as the lag increases between the time you issue commands and the time you see results. You wouldn't want to eliminate that advantage though--all things being equal, you want the person who is more actively engaged to have a small edge. You just want the impact to be largely outweighed by broader tactical decisions.
- billfruit 7y agoThough this is a blog post, I thought the article was rather amateurish, and does not analyse the matter with the depth and precision required. I used to like rts while I was younger, but now I find them too gamified, in the sense there is too much of abstract ion. You give a building order and a fully built ship materializes in seconds. Each of your men-at-arms are having the exact same stats, personal lity and skills. Individual units are pea-brained. The number of units are too less to how historical battles actually happened. Sometime I thought paradox style grand strategy was the answer to these flaws. But playing them now feels like playing cashgrab mobile "waiting games", you essentially set something up and are just waiting most of the time for the clock to tick till the progress bar reaches 100%, that is, it had kind of ended up even more gamified. Perhaps there is a divergence in player interests, some want simulations with toy soldiers, while others want a competitive experience, and may be there is no easy way to cover both these aspects in a single game.
- ris 7y ago> What Happened to the Real Time Strategy Genre? Total Annihilation
- LorenPechtel 7y agoDoes he not consider Ashes of the Singularity a RTS game??
- senectus1 7y agoIt died on the alter that EA sacrificed C&C on. they milked that cow and then cut it up for meat.
- Andr1 7y agoUnfortunately the article doesn't mention Supreme Commander - Forged Alliance, which is a game still played today with more than enough players and some very good casters. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xny10Dvp_00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xny10Dvp_00
- JDiculous 7y agoAs someone who's favorite game genre is RTS and all-time favorite games are Warcraft 3 and Age of Empires 2, I've been wondering the same thing. I genuinely believe that RTS games are the most intellectually stimulating due to the incredible amount of strategy involved, and thus the most fun. Recently I went to a PC Cafe after having stopped playing games about 10 years ago. I started off playing CS:GO due to having loved CS 1.6 as a child, but I didn't find the modern version fun, and after an hour I was bored. Then I played a game of Warcraft 3, and next thing you know I spent the next month completely addicted to the game, watching professional commentaries and playing nonstop. It got to a point where I literally had to uninstall the game since it was taking over my life. The reason I think I found CS:GO boring was because it felt like there was little to no strategy. It's basically just a game of reflexes and hand-to-eye coordination, and you only control a single unit. Meanwhile I think I found WC3 so fun because there's so much to it - what buildings/units to make, whether to harass, rush, and/or turtle/tower up, scouting your opponents and adjusting to their strategy, when to expand, whether to creep / level up your heroes or go in for an attack, etc. It's like a game of chess on steroids, where your opponents' pieces are completely different (if they're a different race), yet somehow the game is remarkably balanced. I hate to sound like an arrogant old crank and my RTS bias is definitely clear, but I feel like most of the mainstream games today suck, and are of a lower intellectual bar. I can't understand the whole MOBA thing (eg. League of Legends) - I never got into DOTA because I always found it extremely boring, and I think it's just less intellectually stimulating (and also probably because the games are an hour and a half). I'm glad that WC3 and AOE2 are being remade and released this year (though unfortunately I'll probably have to opt out due to how easily I get addicted). I hope that more game developers will see this and try their hand at the RTS genre. As much as I love WC3 and AOE2, they certainly have their flaws as well. For example, I feel the beginning in WC3 is too slow, making buildings/units is a bit too slow, and I find it a bit too micro focused (particularly for orcs). But I absolutely love the RPG element of heroes, and it's probably one of the main reasons why I've spent more time playing WC3.