9 ms·
Evolving “nofollow” – new ways to identify the nature of links
- nakedgremlin 7y agoSo... this is pretty much saying they will now analyze all links now, irregardless of "nofollow". Previously they outright ignored "nofollow".
- xg15 7y agoSeems so. They note at the end that they still respect rel=noindex and of course robots.txt though.
- yyyk 7y agoNitpick: There's no such word as "irregardless". Escorts myself out
- illnewsthat 7y agoNitpick: there is such a word according to MW [1] [1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless
- yyyk 7y ago1. I only recognise the Oxford English Dictionary, not those upstart Americans ;-) 2. Even the Americans say (from your link): "Irregardless was popularized in dialectal American speech in the early 20th century. Its increasingly widespread spoken use called it to the attention of usage commentators as early as 1927. The most frequently repeated remark about it is that "there is no such word." There is such a word, however. It is still used primarily in speech, although it can be found from time to time in edited prose. Its reputation has not risen over the years, and it is still a long way from general acceptance. Use regardless instead." That's doesn't read as accepting the 'word' beyond the most technical noting that some people use it.
- Jach 7y agoDictionaries are historians of usage not legislators of language. At least in English, where we have no equivalent to the "Académie française" (suck it, Jonathan Swift).
- howderek 7y agoThough it considers it "non-standard" the word also exists in the Oxford English Dictionary: https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/99668 https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/99668
- apocalypstyx 7y agoSlightly tangential, but this comes to mind: We are not here concerned with so-called computer 'languages', which resemble human languages (English, Sanskrit, Malayalam, Mandarin Chinese, Twi or Shoshone etc.) in some ways but are forever totally unlike human languages in that they do not grow out of the unconscious but directly out of consciousness. Computer language rules ('grammar') are stated first and thereafter used. The 'rules' of grammar in natural human languages are used first and can be abstracted from usage and stated explicitly in words only with difficulty and never completely. --Walter Ong [Orality And Literacy]
- amelius 7y agoFor every word in existence, there was someone who used it first.
- wahern 7y agoI don't think it's that simple. There's a chicken & egg paradox at play.
- decasteve 7y agoAre you trying to start an inflame war?
- Kimm0n0 7y agoNot enough signals when everything is tagged "nofollow"
- zonidjan 7y agoIt actually sounds like they've already been analyzing all links, regardless of "nofollow". Which is not surprising in any way.
- gpm 7y agoQuestion that wasn't answered: Should user generated content links, that may or may not be sponsored (suppose the site owner neither knows nor cares), be marked "ugc" or "ugc sponsored" or "ugc nofollow"?
- Deimorz 7y agoI think just "ugc" from Google's perspective, but they mention that you can use "ugc nofollow" for other services that don't understand "ugc".
- wolco 7y agoUgc: It's basically someone I didn't know posted this. Treat it as neutral. Sponsored is someone paided/trade for this. Treat it as distrustful. Both is someone I don't know posted this and I made money. Treat as fake-
- akersten 7y agoI don't plan on implementing these, and neither should you, unless they get added as part of an official HTML specification. Maybe they are, but I don't see them on this list of link types [0]. Until they get formally specified, to me this is just Google doing Google things and fragmenting the web. [0] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Link_types https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Link_types
- Spivak 7y agoI mean we collectively did this to ourselves by letting browsers be super permissive about invalid markup. The only reason that Google is able to do this is because things that don’t know what rel=“usg” means will silently ignore it.
- amelius 7y agoThey would have found another, probably less elegant, way to do the same thing. E.g. they'd put the extra info in HTML comments.
- zonidjan 7y agoOh, hi Microsoft. <!--[if gte IE 6 ]><![endif]-->
- the_pwner224 7y agoYou're confusing forward-compatibility (ignore markup with tags you don't recognize, which is awesome) with accepting invalid markup (which is stupid).
- magicalist 7y ago> unless they get added as part of an official HTML specification. Maybe they are, but I don't see them on this list of link types [0] Extending link types is in the html specification: https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/links.html#other-link-types https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/links.html#other-link... > Extensions to the predefined set of link types may be registered in the microformats wiki existing-rel-values page [http://microformats.org/wiki/existing-rel-values#HTML5_link_type_extensions http://microformats.org/wiki/existing-rel-values#HTML5_link_...]. where "may" is defined in the usual way (they aren't in there, but the page hasn't been updated for over a year, so I'm not sure if anyone cares about it anymore after already adding so many extension values). It's common to have user agent (in this case googlebot) specific rel values.
- michaelbuckbee 7y agoNofollow has and it's interpretation have always been interesting. Professional SEO's analyze sites as to their "link profile" the number of nofollow, follow, anchor'd, raw etc. type URLs that point to your site. Consider a super-spammy site that eschews any like but a "follow", well that's weird - that may be an indication they're a spammer. So while this (quite likely correctly) states that "nofollow" links have not search rank weight, it's not the entire story.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoIt's the crisis of the hyperlink: It's diminished to the point where Google is afraid of losing it's previously dominant signal for good. Personal publishing has moved almost entirely to platforms that `nofollow` links. And commercial sites do whatever it takes to avoid linking anywhere but back, deeper into their own site. There have been some cases where I think people are behaving somewhat irresponsible with "nofollow": the German Wikipedia, for example, does it to all outbound links. That's understandable from a spam-fighting perspective. But, if search engines actually implement it draconically, it deprives the search index of vast amounts of collaborative filtering. I actually just checked, and couldn't find nofollows on either HN or Reddit links. Are they somehow setting them via some method other than the actual link tag? In any case, I was going to suggest that nofollow makes sense for the "new" queue, but it wouldn't hurt and possibly help to remove it once user generated content has reached certain milestones, i. e. user karma, or hitting the front page.
- kylecordes 7y agoA related source of great frustration: put some good stuff on the web. Lots of people link to it but almost entirely from social media platforms where every link is a nofollow. Somebody else working on gaming the system with SEO makes a less valuable and useful thing, but obtains (by subterfuge or diligent direct asking) some non-nofollow links. Your high-quality content will be outranked in search results by the other less-high-quality quality content. A reasonable improvement to this, to reinvigorate the hyperlink: social media platforms could stop using nofollow for links put in by users who themselves have built up a degree of reputation.
- alxmdev 7y agoIt really does seem hard to get visitors these days, even for original niche content. The first page of Google search results is half social/video/news carousels instead of genuine long-term content, and a lot of the other links point to repetitive articles published by generic big-name websites that never really add anything new.
- 7y ago
- Hitton 7y agoNot sure that many sponsors will be happy to keep sponsoring the content if they'll get "sponsored"(pretty much nofollow) link.
- vntok 7y agoSeems like a net win.
- Dylan16807 7y agoIt's not a win, it just means nobody will use that tag.
- buro9 7y agoI run large forums and mark my links "nofollow". I see no reason or benefit to me to change to or add "ugc". It's not clear that there's any benefits for me. And it's vague enough that I don't know that there are not downsides. Seems best to do nothing.
- kazinator 7y agoComplete agreement. Furthermore, bad actors out there will abuse "ugc": they will mark terabytes of robot-generated content as "user-generated". It will not be possible to rely on it as an indication of organic content or anything of the sort. Search engines won't be able to use that for ranking, for instance.
- wolco 7y agoThis change is not for you. This change allows them to treat facebook/twitter/reddit links with weight if the other signals are present.
- kazinator 7y agoIf I know that I'm traversing and processing facebook/twitter/reddit links, doesn't "nofollow" already indicate user generated content? (Even if some "nofollow" links do not do that, I can probably separate those based on their position in the documents.) If you're going to treat specific sites specially, then go in all the way and be prepared to have your logic understand any/all aspects of their structure. Or else, don't bother.
- tylerl 7y ago>> "...no reason or benefit..." I donno, seems legit to me. Adding "nofollow" just means "I'm not accountable for this" -- it's overloaded to mean both "My site is linking here but I didn't vet it first" (the UGC version), versus "This isn't actually me, it's an advertiser borrowing space on my site" (the sponsored version). Your site/forum might want "credit" for being a sort of attention aggregation hub without necessarily taking responsibility for all the content your users post -- you may want a softer middle ground if such a thing becomes available. But in the advertiser version you're just renting out page real estate; your relationship with those links ends the moment the ad is displayed. Giving you a way to differentiate between the two could let you benefit from ranking and placement that more appropriately takes your user content into consideration while better filtering out noise from ad content.
- dwheeler 7y agoI appreciate nofollow and ugc. I run a site with user-generated content, and worry about spammers over writing the site with junk content. Having a way to indicate that the link is from someone else is useful for eliminating the incentives for spammers.
- wolco 7y agoNofollow made sense but if everyone is using it for all links there is no value in it and the tag should be ignored. I like the change it allows them to ignore nofollow for facebook/twitter/reddit or smaller sites that nofollow all links.
- tyingq 7y agoI'm pretty sure google has already been treating some nofollow links as if they weren't nofollow for some time now.
- treve 7y agoI'm curious if any attempt was made to submit this as a standard inclusion to the IANA link relations registry: https://www.iana.org/assignments/link-relations/link-relations.xhtml https://www.iana.org/assignments/link-relations/link-relatio...
- burtonator 7y agonofollow is 15 years old? Holy crap I'm old!!!
- zonidjan 7y ago"Do more work so that we have more info. No, it doesn't give you any benefit."
- Jaruzel 7y agoFrom the Article: rel="nofollow": Use this attribute for cases where you want to link to a page but don’t want to imply any type of endorsement, including passing along ranking credit to another page. This means the meaning of 'nofollow' is changing? That seems a horrible idea. Previously 'nofollow' meant exactly that - "don't follow this link please googlebot", now it will mean "follow this link, but don't grant my site ranking onto the destination." - Thats a VERY different use case, I can't see all the millions of existing 'nofollow' tags being changed by site owners to any of these new tags. Surely a 'nogrant' or somesuch would be a better option, and leave 'nofollow' alone.
- 9588 7y agoIt makes organic indexing impossible, there is no point making your own website like this. Its even insulting calling hardworked content spam.