8 ms·
The Amazon Is Not the Earth’s Lungs
- abainbridge 7y agoNot least because lungs take in oxygen and output carbon dioxide. I guess while the Amazon is on fire it acts a bit like lungs.
- bestouff 7y agoWell from the point of view of your body, your lungs bring oxygen in and take carbon dioxide out.
- abainbridge 7y agoHa, nice one! So if the Amazon is like lungs in this sense, where is it bringing the oxygen in from?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mikepurvis 7y agoReleased as waste via photosynthesis when it breaks apart CO2 in order to use the carbon to build plant matter?
- partialrecall 7y agoIf I recall my bio class right, the oxygen in the CO2 goes into the production of carbohydrates. The oxygen released as waste comes from split water molecules (photosynthesis requires both CO2 and H20.)
- zamfi 7y agoPhotosynthesis releases as many O2 molecules as it takes in CO2 molecules. It also uses water and produces sugar. I’m not sure if the released oxygen comes from the water or the carbon dioxide but it doesn’t much matter! Edit: looks like it comes from the water. Cool!
- Xixi 7y agoPhotosynthesis: 6CO2 + 6H2O → C6H12O6 + 6O2 In English: 6 carbon dioxide molecules and 6 water molecules become 1 glucose molecule and 6 dioxygen molecules. So for each CO2 molecule in, there is one O2 molecule out. Now it's entirely possible that some of the O in O2 comes from the H2O molecules. At most half of it if I know how to count up to twelve. Edited for clarity.
- partialrecall 7y agoIt definitely doesn't matter, but I recall my bio teacher getting quite pedantic on this point. It's moderately interesting trivia I guess.
- mikepurvis 7y agoAnd then the glucose is what becomes the building block for cellulose, lignin, etc, right?
- Xixi 7y agoAnd amino acids [1], and anything organic synthesized by plants, through many many intermediary steps. But I am neither a biologist nor a chemist, so please do not take my word for it, I may be wrong. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amino_acid_synthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amino_acid_synthesis
- zamfi 7y ago> At most half of it if I know how to count up to twelve. I thought so too, and this would be true if the reaction happened exactly as the equation describes. But it turns out there are a bunch of intermediate steps. The first set is pure hydrolysis: 2H2O + light + depleted energy carriers -> 2O2 + 2H(+) + filled energy carriers (that include 2H) That oxygen is excreted and ends up in the atmosphere. Then, there’s the transpiration process that takes in CO2 and makes sugar and water again: 3CO2 + filled energy carriers (that include 6H total) + 6H(+) -> C3H6O3 + depleted energy carriers + 3H2O So really what happens is this: 6CO2 + 12H2O -> C6H12O6 + 6O2 + 6H2O All the O2 output comes from the 12 H2O input. The 6 H2O output are recreated with half the H from the input 12 H2O but oxygen from from half the 6CO2 input, while the other half of the CO2, combined with 12 H from the 12 H2O input, make the sugar. Fascinating stuff. One upshot: all that crap about the water molecules being the same molecules the dinosaurs swam is crap. Any water that’s been through photosynthesis is reconstituted on the molecular level!
- this_was_posted 7y agofrom the air that it takes in, just like lungs do
- JadeNB 7y agoDuplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20928439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20928439 ? (I don't know which one should stay.)
- amflare 7y agoThe above link is a paragraph and a click-through link. This is the actual article: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/08/amazon-fire-earth-has-plenty-oxygen/596923/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/08/amazon-f...
- dang 7y agoChanged from https://blog.longnow.org/02019/09/01/the-amazon-is-not-the-earths-lungs/ https://blog.longnow.org/02019/09/01/the-amazon-is-not-the-e.... Thanks.
- imvetri 7y agoPlease refrain promoting deforestation
- slackfan 7y agoDid you actually read the article, or are you just kneejerking to the title? Because it's quite-anti-deforestation in there.
- jdashg 7y agoTitles are important, and titles can be irresponsible.
- keawade 7y agoThe article does not promote deforestation. > Losing the Amazon, beyond representing a planetary historic tragedy beyond measure, would also make meeting the ambitious climate goals of the Paris Agreement all but impossible. It discusses a misconception that has been propogated lately. > The Amazon is a vast, ineffable, vital, living wonder. It does not, however, supply the planet with 20 percent of its oxygen. > As the biochemist Nick Lane wrote in his 2003 book Oxygen, “Even the most foolhardy destruction of world forests could hardly dint our oxygen supply, though in other respects such short-sighted idiocy is an unspeakable tragedy.”
- CodeWriter23 7y agoCharacterizing 6% of the oxygen supply as “more or less zero” (as the author does) seems to signal approval of deforestation to me.
- rootusrootus 7y agoWhere did you get that? I think you misread that paragraph from the article. The author did not equate 6% to zero.
- wutbrodo 7y agoLet's leave aside how ludicrous it is to ignore the author's half-paragraph of passionate description of deforestation as tragedy and read the tea leaves to determine he's a deforestation fan, and ignore how absurd it is to criticize a factual claim on the basis that it hurts or helps a narrative: you're not even reading the article's claims correctly. > The Amazon produces about 6 percent of the oxygen currently being made by photosynthetic organisms alive on the planet today. But surprisingly, this is not where most of our oxygen comes from. In fact, from a broader Earth-system perspective, in which the biosphere not only creates but also consumes free oxygen, the Amazon’s contribution to our planet’s unusual abundance of the stuff is more or less zero. The Amazon produces 6% of oxygen produces by photosynthetic organisms. The proportion of total oxygen produced by these organisms (let's call it P) is relatively small enough that the Amazon's contribution, 0.06*P, ends up being negligible.
- vadikkiev 7y agoThis is a very big problem that makes us think. thank you
- js2 7y ago“Does the Amazon provide 20% of our oxygen?” discussion from a couple weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20789771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20789771
- chisleu 7y agoThis is a great point. An important aspect of this is that most of the Amazon's deforestation is land owners developing their land and adding to the agricultural sectors of South America. If we want to stop them, we need to stop the excessive consumption of these goods. This doesn't just mean stopping over eating, it means changing what you eat and paying more for goods sourced locally. Unfortunately, that means from countries with higher labor costs and higher taxes because of higher subsidies. It's a hard sell for most consumers. How do we accomplish that?
- ajmurmann 7y agoFrom what I've read most of the agricultural production in Brazil goes directly or indirectly towards beef and biofuel. So cutting down on beef consumption seems like a great step. I personally have cut down my meat consumption dramatically, but how can we move that further as not only a society, but a species? If I stop eating beef, but nobody else does, nothing is won. If the US cuts down on beef consumption, other countries will be happy to buy the now cheaper beef. Collective action problems are a problem...
- sp332 7y agoAmerica banned beef imports from Brazil a couple of years ago. Leather could still come from Brazilian cattle though.
- icebraining 7y agoStupid idea: tax meat and use the money to purchase tracts of farmland in the Amazon and such places, preventing them from being explored. That would reduce the drop in prices, by increasing the cost of productive land.
- input_sh 7y ago> ...but how can we move that further as not only a society, but a species? The answer is simple, the execution is hard and will piss a lot of people off: start treating red meat as a luxury item, and slowly introduce taxes on top of its price, like we do for alcohol and tobacco. Nothing drastic of course, just a few cents extra every half a year or so to make people reconsider their eating habits again and again. But if we're talking about the US specifically, that's not even necessary. Just removing subsidies that are already handed out to the meat industry will achieve the same result.
- childintime 7y agoRelated: the fires in the Congo, Africa, this week resulted in bad air-quality in the northeast of Brazil. That made the national news. Sadly it's not only the Amazon that is cutting down on trees. Besides the fires in Africa, Canada was also in the news some time ago. Apparently that prompted the Canadian government to put up a page to deal with the issue: https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/our-natural-resources/forests-forestry/wildland-fires-insects-disturban/deforestation-canada-key-myths-and-facts/13419 https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/our-natural-resources/forests-forest...
- JonCox 7y agoNot anymore it isn't.
- alexcroox 7y agoOne Strange Rock, a nature documentary hosted by Will Smith (stay with me) actually goes into this in some detail and I would definitely recommend a watch. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7651892/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7651892/
- lelima 7y agoI saw it, a bit skeptic about Will Smith but the production is high Quality, I suppose with Will the show is pointing younger generations.
- cheez 7y agoIsn't he 50 years old?
- mc32 7y agoHaven’t watched it myself but often times these kinds of documentaries use voice actors to read the script and lend a good voice to their content. James Earl Jones, Leonard Nimoy, etc.
- derrasterpunkt 7y agoHe is not just voice acting, he is presenting. And a lot of astronauts (Chris Hadfield is the only one I can remember right now). I haven’t finished watching though.
- vfc1 7y agoIt might be that burning down every living tree would not make a dent in the oxygen supply, but having the earth temperature go up 5 degrees would kill most phytoplankton, and that would end the oxygen supply (eventually). This type of articles is the last thing we need right now, it all piles up on the narrative that the consequences of climate change are really not that bad and there is no real urgency in doing anything about it. Especially if that implies a change of behaviors like eating less meat. Nobody wants to give away their cheeseburgers as Elizabeth Warren factitiously says, this how you make headlines and get elected for office, tell people what they want to hear, stay away from the truth.
- partialrecall 7y agoAdherence to the truth is more important than adherence to a narrative. Promoting a good cause by allowing falsehoods to spread may seem helpful in the short term, but in doing so you're building a house on a foundation of sand. When you promote trivial falsehoods instead of calling them out, you allow your opposition to be the one who calls out those falsehoods, and thus undermine your cause. When somebody on your side says something well-meaning but wrong, you should be the one to call them out. In doing so, you deny your enemy the opportunity to do so.
- jstummbillig 7y agoThis is incredibly naive in a reality, where the POTUS can contradict himself on social media – with traceable evidence dating back often not more than a week – and absolutely nothing coming of it. Right now, when it comes to public opinion and action, volume clearly beats a good signal/noise ratio. This is not an isolated issue, this happens all around the globe. Populism is on the rise. Simple beats true. Yes, you can argue this is not the way it is supposed to be, but it is how it is. But if you really care about making a change for the better, then this is most definitely not the time for deliberate narratives. You might have the peoples attention, but not their patience. If you want change, do not squander it.
- partialrecall 7y ago
- dejaime 7y agoThis feels like a simple strawman. The problem is called global warming, not global deoxygenation.
- stinos 7y agoThis feels like a simple strawman. Maybe feels like it, but the argument being attacked here is just the false 'amazon = world's lungs' claim, not something else, not global warming, so I don't think it qualifies as strawman according to it's definition? (Plus note that the article specifically mentions burning down the amazon is a tragedy)
- wutbrodo 7y agoStrawman of what? The article isn't titled "there is no problem with deforestation, go nuts". The first paragraph describes the hypothetical loss of the Amazon as a "planetary historic tragedy beyond measure", and says that it'll make the Paris climate goals impossible to reach. None of this contradicts the premise of the article, which is that a commonly-held and - expressed belief about the Amazon's role in our oxygen supply is not supported by the science. Strawman doesn't mean "talking about a different topic than I'd prefer".
- gnusty_gnurc 7y agoSome are motivated to hyperbolize about the wildfires in Brazil in order to craft a narrative that Bolsonaro is ushering in the apocalypse. There’s wildfires in Bolivia but no one is blaming socialism (Evo Morales). https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/02/bolivia-evo-morales-wildfires-chiquitano https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/02/bolivia-evo-mo...
- Carioca 7y agoBrazilian Amazon deforestation went up 222% in August, compared to the same time last year[1]. Bolsonaro has a very anti-conservation agenda. He has: - Appointed a climate denialist conspiracy theorist as his foreign minister [2] - Appointed as minister for the environment a man convicted of forging documents in favour of mining companies [3] - Contradicted the National Institute for Space Research, responsible for satellite tracking of deforestation, when it published preliminary data that showed the increase (as it had done every year), then fired its director[4] - Then went on to blame the fires on conservation NGOs [5] This is just off the top of my head (I'm Brazilian), links provided are just the first search results from reputable sources in English. Happy to provide more info to anyone who needs it. That said, I have no love for Evo nor do I know the specifics of the situation across the border, but Bolsonaro is terrible for the environment and the world should be concerned, not in the least because 58.4% of the Amazon is inside Brazil's border. In contrast, 7.7% of it falls within Bolivia 1: https://www.dw.com/pt-br/desmatamento-na-amaz%C3%B4nia-em-agosto-cresce-222-em-rela%C3%A7%C3%A3o-a-2018/a-50350187 https://www.dw.com/pt-br/desmatamento-na-amaz%C3%B4nia-em-ag... 2: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/nov/15/brazil-foreign-minister-ernesto-araujo-climate-change-marxist-plot https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/nov/15/brazil-foreign... 3: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-politics-minister/brazils-incoming-environment-minister-found-guilty-of-improper-conduct-idUSKCN1OJ2VE https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-politics-minister/... 4: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-environment-job/brazil-space-research-chief-to-leave-job-after-bolsonaro-deforestation-spat-idUSKCN1US20H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-environment-job/br... 5: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/21/jair-bolsonaro-accuses-ngos-setting-fire-amazon-rainforest https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/21/jair-bolsonaro... [edited to add size of Bolivian Amazon]
- asplake 7y agoNews just in: the metaphor is not the thing
- wutbrodo 7y agoThe article isn't nitpicking the metaphor, it's saying that the factual claim underlying the metaphor (ie that the Amazon provides 20% or some appreciable amount of our oxygen) is false. If you click the link at the top of the page, it takes you to an article that you can read. I recommend doing so before commenting on a post in general
- siliconunit 7y agoThinking that exposing the objective truth to the general public is always the best course of action is at best naive and can at times lead to tragedy... You can do this to a greater extent if your nation is small and has a high amount of highly educated citizens (ie Scandinavian countries) that are able to understand implications and distinctions and place limits to their personal volition for the sake of the community. Tell to Joe down the road that the recycling truck at times dumps everything together for technical reasons and you will dramatically diminish the care and effort to properly separate waste.
- autokad 7y agoI thought the Amazon was called Earths lungs because of how it sucks moisture from the ocean across land. (Please correct me if I am wrong) its my understanding that the area would be quite dry, but the plants manipulate the atmosphere with particulates to draw in water from the oceans and create precipitation across the continent. I thought it was this 'sucking' that gave its name 'earth's lungs'. I also dont like the focus on Co2. that's not the only way the world cools, warms. the water being converted to gas, to water, and gas again takes up energy and cools the planet. beyond c02, if the Amazon were to go away, I think the earth would get warmer to some extent.
- rafaelvasco 7y agoDoesn't mean we shouldn't care; It's amazing how people always view things with a negative and destructive not-my-problem mindset; Humanity in general right now is much more destructive than constructive; We must always strive to make a positive impact for others and for the entire planet, leaving things better than they were before us, not the contrary;
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]