15 ms·
Why Positive Cashflow Matters
- lemcoe9 7y agoBreaking News: Companies that make real profits have more flexibility.
- rafaelcosta 7y agoExcept Positive Cashflow != Profitability. ;)
- ismail 7y agoYep. I had a long debate with an accountant, regarding what I should primarily manage. Being bootstrapped I mostly manage cash-flow and made the mistake of saying “profit is made up”. That got him real worked up. My point was we derive profit. The actual transactions are in the cash-flow statement which does not lie.
- hisnameismanuel 7y agoAs they say... Revenue is Vanity Profit is Sanity Cash is Reality
- barrkel 7y agoYou can hang on to a lot of cash while making lots of promises, and bankrupt a company without spending a penny. I know you know, but it's a real problem with a lot of small operations getting their accounts done; they think they're in the black due to a bank balance, but when the accountant sees the books, things aren't so rosy.
- ProAm 7y agoAre you saying Negative Cashflow == Profitability then? ;)
- OJFord 7y ago+2 != 4 Neither does -2.
- nradov 7y agoUnder GAAP, profitability for complex businesses can be highly subjective. In some cases it may only become clear in retrospect after many years whether the business was really profitable or not.
- EBeache 7y agoIt continues to amaze me that these big companies are allowed to operate at a loss for years.
- pwinnski 7y agoUnder limited circumstances, depending heavily on what is causing the loss, sometimes this can be effective for very few companies. Of course, many people unrealistically believe that their circumstances apply, that the cause of the loss is irrelevant, and that it will be effective for them. Most are wrong. Losing money per transaction is dangerous. Making money per transaction but plowing the profits into expansion is less dangerous. The latter is what Amazon did. The former is what too many companies are doing, not seeing the difference.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- privateprofile 7y ago>> Losing money per transaction is dangerous. Is that not just a form of dumping, and should therefore be illegal/regulated? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy)
- pwinnski 7y agoThere is theoretically a scenario in which a company might temporarily lose money on each transaction due to scale, but over the long term manage to lower costs so that each transaction is profitable. Even that, I'd say it's dangerous to count on that, but it's not completely impossible. I think that's different from dumping, which I consider to be a more deliberate attempt to outlast a competitor.
- eru 7y agoDepends on what 'should' you mean? From a moral point of view, anti-dumping laws are counterproductive. Their prime use is to sue companies that have lower cost than you.
- reilly3000 7y agoThe traditional defense of negative cash flow is that excessive cash means that resources are idle that could be working towards growth. This makes sense in winner-take-all markets, where getting marketshare fastest means establishing a semi-monopoly and ensuring years of profit. I think there is some validity to that thinking, but there is an implicit assumption that one could choose to step on the brakes on growth at any time and resume positive cash flow. For many firms, that is simply not the case. The firms in that position are more desperate for growth, and in my opinion the most dangerous to all. When backed into a financial corner they make comprises that harm their customers or the ecosystem as a whole. Therefore, I think it’s crucial to distinguish strategic cash burn vs unsustainable business model. Metrics like negative return on ad spend (ROAS) are decent indicators.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> This makes sense in winner-take-all markets, where getting marketshare fastest means establishing a semi-monopoly and ensuring years of profit. I think the rest of your point is sound, but growth is important in all markets, regardless of any opportunity to monopolize. Forgoing investment in growth is an opportunity cost for any company in any market.
- PopeDotNinja 7y ago> I think it’s crucial to distinguish strategic cash burn vs unsustainable business model The only thing I don't like about the idea of a strategic cash burn is that I'd much rather see a strategic cash dividend or share buyback. Any company can hire someone who will find a way to justify spending assets for some potential ROI, and it's pretty easy to spend a company right into bankruptcy.
- ethbro 7y agoIn tech, it feels like negative cash flow is valued partly for it's ambiguity. With positive cash flow, your valuation becomes easier. With negative cash flow, you're either (a) strategically burning for growth or (b) unsustainable. But you can pitch as to why it's one instead of the other. Which gives a lot of wiggle room for "early stage unicorn magic" tales.
- tarr11 7y agoAlso from avc.com: "the 40% rule" [0] "I have never seen growth and profitability so nicely tied together in a simple rule like this. I’ve always felt intuitively that it’s OK to lose money if you are growing fast, and you must make money and increasing amounts of it as your growth slows. Now there’s a formula for that instinct. And I like that very much." [0] https://avc.com/2015/02/the-40-rule/ https://avc.com/2015/02/the-40-rule/
- aidenn0 7y agoThat's an interesting rule, but doesn't account for companies running at negative gross profit. SaaS companies can have non-negligible COGS since they have (virtual or otherwise) server costs. If (for example) your AWS bill is higher than your revenue, no amount of growth is likely to make that healthy.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> SaaS companies can have non-negligible COGS since they have (virtual or otherwise) server costs. Is payroll not in that COGS equation?
- mikeyouse 7y agoCOGS typically includes payroll for employees whose labor is directly tied to production but doesn't include 'overhead' employees and other categories like rent / legal / sales / marketing. The best way to think about it: "If we had 0 sales, would this expense still exist?" If it wouldn't exist, it's COGS.
- colechristensen 7y agoYour AWS rates will go down with increased usage and at any time you could switch your engineering goals from features to performance. If you are growing fast then the savings you can make this quarter will be negligible in a year but the added features won’t. It often makes lots of sense putting tech cost efficiency near the bottom of your priorities when you are growing fast and human time is your limiting resource.
- lutorm 7y ago"Positive cash flow puts you on (sic) control ..." Applies to individuals just as much as companies.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI think people are very different than companies in this respect. An individual would want to have savings (in the form of pension - e.g. 401k - and invested savings), while a company's mandate is NOT to store significant amounts of money to derive capital interest from it.
- phkahler 7y agoCompanies can sit on cash. Some investors will probably start making noise about it though.
- novaRom 7y agoCurrently it's also a bad idea because of the negative interest, at least in many parts of the world (Europe, Japan), and probably US soon.
- lutorm 7y agoTrue, but it's similar in the sense that both can leverage credit but then become dependent on their creditors, and that having a significant chunk of cash in your assets gives you freedom to do what you think should be done (invest in new facilities, etc.) A quick google reveals that Apple supposedly has over 200 billion in cash reserves...
- eru 7y agoApple's case is partially a tax arbitrage.
- ProAm 7y ago> while a company's mandate is NOT to store significant amounts of money to derive capital interest from it. See Apple [1] [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/29/apple-now-has-tk-cash-on-hand.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/29/apple-now-has-tk-cash-on-han...
- H8crilA 7y agoOne sign of a bubble: traditional valuation principles are abandoned because "this time it's different". See Nifty Fifty, 2000 dotcom, 1920's crash, 2015 Chinese A shares, ... . It usually requires a new generation of people to enter the market because most people learn only on their own mistakes, not on other people mistakes. This article talks about what negative cash flow means for the company. But what does it mean for the investor? A company that cannot go cash flow positive is worth zero - the value of the company is max(all future cash flows discounted by the interest rate curve, 0). The max(, 0) comes from the concept of the limited liability company.
- ummonk 7y agoEdit: misread max as min, nvm.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 7y agoForever?
- gizmo686 7y agoDoesn't said company still have assets? At some point, the company can just dissolve and liquidate its assets. Assuming the assets are worth more then the companies debt, this leaves something to distribute to shareholders.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Someone 7y agoIf the company hasn’t been cash flow positive over its lifetime, it is unlikely that the assets will be worth more than the debts. Investments in machinery almost invariably depreciate significantly the moment they are bought, and salaries paid to personnel, electricity to power the lights in your office building, money spent on legal, etc, all lead to zero assets. It can happen if most of the assets are products the company made, and the company can produce them below market value, but then, why would it have have products in store, and not sell them? There are exceptions, but they’re easily recognized. On the one hand there’s seasonal demand: companies growing Christmas trees, or producing umbrellas, hockey skates, etc. On the other hand, there’s companies with long production times such as whiskey distillers or factories building nuclear plants.
- gnicholas 7y ago> I could go on, but I suspect you get the point. Positive cash flow puts you in control versus the capital markets. I guess that's why VCs generally don't encourage this sort of behavior.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoIt’s also why it’s not terribly uncommon for stock to dip a bit after getting the books in the black.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 7y agoI really hate this modern way of doing business where being successful means your company implodes after losing five billion dollars a year for ten years rather than imploding after losing a hundred million dollars a year for five years. Aside from being, you know, crazy, aren't there laws about charging customers below cost in order to fuel expansion and grab market share?
- botswana99 7y agoMan, this kind of B.S. wisdom from VC gets me pissed. Do you think in all the thousands of boards meetings he has sat on that he ever recommended getting cashflow positive? The whole VC model is burn baby burn until you can get big a flip of the asset. This kind of articles come out during a down market when the VC go from 'we will make billions' to 'cut your burn rate so I can see sell the startup you worked on for the past few years for pennies on the dollar.' Everything VCs write is warped by their capital distortion field. Beware
- awwstn 7y agoUSV invests in early stage companies. They don't really have incentive for those companies to need late stage capital, which will dilute USV and/or cost them money to maintain their position. If this post said "Burn as much as you can, you can always raise more" you'd undoubtedly have had an even more negative take on it. So is your position just that VCs who have backed wildly successful businesses can't offer any useful advice on how to build a wildly successful business?
- dsalso 7y agoLate stage capital could mean an exit or at least some cashing out.
- paulsutter 7y agoFalse. VCs really want to build a fast growth enduring company. That’s very hard to achieve, but it is what they want. > The whole VC model is burn baby burn until you can get big a flip of the asset.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- taneq 7y agoWell yeah, but if they can’t have a unicorn then they’ll advise you to staple a horn on your horse rather than investing in a stable and some oats.
- pontifier 7y agoI once read about a simple AI strategy for multiple games that has stuck with me. The strategy at any point was to make moves which increase the number of moves available to the AI. When making decisions now, I often step back and think about what types of decisions will give me more opportunities to make more choices. This often involves increasing the funds available to me. Funds without encumbrance are better than a debt of any kind though... and venture capital is just a different kind of debt.
- eru 7y agoIn some situations, curtailing your options can be good. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precommitment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precommitment
- pontifier 7y agoInteresting. I can see how that could be effective due to our natural tendancy to over value immediate utility. It makes me wonder what sort of evolutionary advantage that sort of willpower breakdown provides... If any.
- streetcat1 7y agoHis advice does not apply to you (as a founder). He is diversified, so the outcome of one company does not really matter. You are not diversified, so only you know what best.
- gweinberg 7y agoWell, you'll need positive cash flow sooner or later if you want to stay in business. But the advantages the op attributes to positive cash flow are really advantages of having money in the bank. The only advantage to having a slightly positive cash flow is that it makes you feel good. If your cash flow is slightly positive but your key people are getting stock options or whatever as a nontrivial part of their compensation, you are actually losing money.
- hef19898 7y agoDidn't that happen to Uber when all the RSU from before the IPO vested? Or with Amazon around 2017 after the stock jumped by a factor of more than five and they gave put too much RSUs in the years before?
- thiago_fm 7y agoHe's using the term cashflow in the wrong way. You can have positive cashflow as long as investors are investing in your company, but that doesn't mean your business is going anywhere or that you make a profit.
- sokoloff 7y agoWhat you say is true, though unlevered cash flow from operations is what is typically meant rather than cash flow from operations plus cash flow from financing.
- qubex 7y agoComing from the manufacturing sector, the idea that anybody could fail to have an instinctive terror of negative cashflow... horrifies me.
- imtringued 7y agoA lot of companies would be fine with 5-10 million in funding and organic growth. However investors don't want to manage thousands of small profitable private companies. They want fast growth and then exit quickly in a bang. This means a lot of companies get 3-5 times more funding than they need, then generate a nice profit but not enough to pay back the excess funding and finally shut down.
- MichaelApproved 7y agoWhy would they shut down if they generate a nice profit?
- ses1984 7y agoRight, if they can't pay back funding, they haven't made any profit yet.
- hef19898 7y agoSame here. But wasn't there a statement (on Uber?) on a previous thread her jokingly talking about cash flow after funding? That being said I know more than one manufacturing company from experience that gave shit about cash flow. Result, so, have been predictable.
- Mrnobody2b 7y ago"You can also prove that you have a business model that can generate positive cash flows, which it must at some point as a stand alone entity."
- navigatesol 7y agoSilicon Valley: We don't want these silly MBAs coming out here and telling us how to run our businesses with their dated teachings. Also Silicon Valley: Hey guys, did you know having positive cash flow is a good thing?