8 ms·
British Airways pilots ground planes in unprecedented 48-hour strike
- privateSFacct 7y agoAnyone know standard time working per month? I thought these major carriers had pretty cushy hours / benefts - (ie, 80 hrs / month, good flight and other benefits).
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoHookers make good money too.
- chrisjshull 7y agoI don’t know, but does it matter? If an employee group understands how much they are worth, and can get more benefits commensurate with that worth, then I applaud them.
- viraptor 7y agoAt some point it does. If they're being underpaid, that's one issue. If they're aware that they're currently irreplaceable and able to effectively hold the company hostage, that's a different one.
- pgodzin 7y agoWouldn't someone irreplaceable be underpaid until they are compensated enough such that they could be replaced for that amount?
- viraptor 7y agoIt depends what's the availability of replacements. For example if almost all pilots are employed, you won't get more pilots until they're trained. Paying more than another company just moves the problem temporarily, not solves it. Similar to what happens with expensive cities which don't expand. The prices keep raising and there will still be people who can afford to pay for a long time... until the larger environment either changes or collapses.
- pgodzin 7y agoSure, but those kinds of structural issues are the airline's problem. BA's pilots are underpaid if they are so in demand, and BA would have to pay a lot more to poach pilots from other airlines.
- viraptor 7y agoIf they're underpaid, sure. (And I would assume they are) But that was the original question - what are the working conditions? If they were paid $1M a day (of course they're not), would you still say they're underpaid just because they're in demand? What about $300k a year? What about $200k? This article doesn't say what the pay / demand is. Another one (https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/sep/08/ba-pilots-to-strike-from-midnight-in-dispute-about-pay https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/sep/08/ba-pilots-t...) mentions BA proposing an increase that would bring "some" over £200k a year. I'm sure that's cherry-picked for PR and doesn't show the whole distribution, but it's at least one number.
- pgodzin 7y agoIf they were paid $1M and could get more then they are still underpaid and there is sufficient demand. There is no absolute number at which they are no longer underpaid, it is completely relative to how much demand there is and how much companies are willing to pay for that demand.
- viraptor 7y agoIf the airlines and pilots existed in isolation then maybe. If they were paid 1M, I'd think they're overpaid and the tickets should be cheaper instead. There definitely is a threshold compared to all other salaries / cost of living / economy where the pay would become irrational - regardless of demand.
- mikekchar 7y agoWouldn't someone who is replaceable be overpaid until they were compensated little enough such that no-one else would work for that amount? I'm not sure if you subscribe to the notice that it's OK for the worker to max out their compensation while it's not OK for the owner to do so, but I think it's a pretty common stance. Admittedly, the reverse is also true (as I'm hoping to point out). Ideally, I would hope that negotiations were conducted in a way that is mutually beneficially to both parties. I'd rather we didn't resort to getting as much as we can at the expense of the other party. Of course in a dog-eat-dog world, what can we expect? All of those bastards on the other side are going to do it to us so let's do it to them first. But is there an advantage to living in a world that isn't dog-eat-dog? Is it possible to encourage a society where neither side "does it" to the other and neither side thinks of the other as "bastards"? I really, really hope so. (Possibly not related to your actual position -- your words just made me think of that)
- pgodzin 7y agoI think both parties try to maximize/minimize for their own benefit, which is healthy and is exactly what determines the market for compensation. Inherently any gain by one side is at the expense of the other, there is no avoiding that aspect. Either than $X is paid to the pilots or it goes elsewhere in the business. I'm not sure what a non-dog-eat-dog world would look like and how it would be able to persist without heavy incentives to take advantage.
- baddox 7y agoI don’t see much of a problem as long as the company is still making a profit. The striking workers could strike until they’re receiving all the company’s profit, at which point it would be as if they’re receiving the actual value of their labor. Not that crazy of an idea.
- viraptor 7y agoOr they don't know when to stop and bring the company down: https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/blame-unions-hostess-bankruptcy-james-sherk/ https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/blame-unions-hostess-b... Maybe the company was failing anyway. I'm not saying they shouldn't strike. Just that we don't seem to have clear numbers to tell if they should or not.
- listenallyall 7y agoThis is a ridiculous statement. The "actual value" of the striking workers (pilots) labor is "ALL the company's profit?" Nobody else -- mechanics, flight crew, reservations agents, IT staff, marketing, execs -- deserves a piece? What about investors -- by definition, nobody invests in a company designed to not return a profit.
- rosser 7y agoPer another comment in another thread [0] it's not only not a ridiculous statement, but a little bit how things actually work, at least in the US. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20915781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20915781
- listenallyall 7y agoThe point of the article is that yes, the scenario where pilots can claim all airline profits is ridiculous, because is it sub-optimal for everyone -- pilots, passengers, and certainly investors. It also never argues that pilots are "delivering value" equal to the airline profits. Only that the pilots are in a position, due to regulation, to claim those profits, because they can shut the airline down (a power that flight attendants, mechanics, reservation agents, etc don't have).
- scatters 7y agoWhat if that employee group are upper management?
- claudiawerner 7y agoOf course they should have the right to strike too, and they do.
- travisjungroth 7y agoUsually whatever hours per month you see for pilots is just flight time, and pilots work more than that.
- _s 7y agoDepending on which country (ergo the Aviation Org i.e. FAA/CAA/EASA/CASA) is designated the home base for the company; the amount of hours flight crew are allowed to fly and be on standby is legally restricted, and so is the minimum pay they should be given.
- bronco21016 7y agoThe 80 hrs/month figure is really more related to pay. Pilots and cabin crew typically are only paid for the time the door is closed on the aircraft. Real hours spent at work and away from home are far greater. I think measuring by days away from home is a more accurate description of how much flight crew work. It depends a lot on where one works and the type of flying they’re doing but it ranges from 12-18 days/month of being on the road working. Flight benefits vary as well but they’re almost always space available and with load factors in the US creeping upwards the value in those benefits has slowly been eroding away. Hard to plan a vacation when you have almost no idea when you’ll get there.
- privateSFacct 7y agoAgreed on flight benefits in US. If flying alone can JS, but with family that doesn't work. Wasn't sure if the Euro market had more standby availability. That said, pilot pay goes up to about $400/hr at Delta as an example including profit share.
- ilaksh 7y agoIt would be really interesting to know what the actual profits are and what percentage currently goes to the pilots versus executives and operational costs etc. Google says they reported $2 billion in profit. Say $300 million was given to 1000 pilots. That would be $300,000 each. They probably got something like a few thousand pounds pay increase and are feeling like it's not adding up. I'm routing for the pilots.
- DrJokepu 7y agoBritish Airways Plc is a publicly traded company, so you know, a lot of this information is publicly available: https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/01777777/filing-history https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/01777777/filing-h... Look at the account filings. Not sure if they will break down how much they pay pilots altogether, but there should be data about executive pay and employee wages and salaries. I’m also rooting for the pilots, by the way.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- relue271 7y agoI’m in favor of pilots, and flight personnel in general, being paid handsomely. The last thing the public needs is flight personnel being disgruntled about not being paid enough. I want the peace of mind that the people making my flight happen are incredibly happy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- barry-cotter 7y agoAnd yet revealed preference suggests that people shop for flights almost exclusively on price. If you feel like paying an extra hundred or five for happier employees that’s a fine personal preference but people who act like that aren’t a significant enough market segment to be worth catering to.
- wayanon 7y agoPretty amazing to be on a 6 figure salary and still strike.
- tehjoker 7y agoThe fundamental unfairness of employment is that your masters skim off the top of your labor's true value and give you less than you are worth to line their pockets. The pilots are within the bounds of fairness to demand up to the full value of their labor.
- listenallyall 7y agoI am not taking sides in this dispute, I am sure the pilots do have some valid grievances. However "the full value of their labor" cannot be realized without a) planes to fly, b) a system for taking reservations, assigning people to seats, and collecting revenue, c) a maintenance staff to keep the planes functioning and safe, d) flight scheduling, purchasing/leasing gates at hundreds of airports (many international), financing fuel purchases, and much, much more. Obviously, flying planes is a valuable skill. But without the enormous support system that the airline itself provides, pilots would have little opportunity to realize that value.
- spraak 7y ago> Obviously, flying planes is a valuable skill. But without the enormous support system that the airline itself provides, pilots would have little opportunity to realize that value. Then you're over-identifying what the value of their labor is. If what they need to do requires the support of others, don't factor the input of others into "the full value of their labor". I.e. if the total value of the airline is X, and the value the pilots provides is P, and the value that all the other employees provide is N, where N + P = X, then the full value of the pilots labor is still P, not X. So I take it to mean they're wanting to get 100% of P.
- listenallyall 7y ago>> N + P = X It's much more complicated than that. One of the beautiful things about business, or any cooperative effort, is that the sum of the group/company is worth more than the sum of value of individual effort. 2+2=5, if you will. The problem, when it comes to human nature, is that once the total value is determined (market cap, annual profit, ROI, etc), individuals tend to over-estimate the value of their individual contribution. It is not just airlines. Uber drivers say they provide the rides, there would be no service without their effort. Uber says nobody was paying you to drive before we launched our platform. Both are correct. Foxconn employees say we're building all these damn iPhones, no other facility or workers can produce at this volume. Apple says if we didn't design and market such a popular product you'd have nothing to build. Again, both are correct. A film director says, look, the movie I made grossed $400 million -- and the studio replies, which you could have never made without the $100 million budget we risked, up front.
- _Understated_ 7y agoGenuine question here... why is this on HN? It has nothing to do with software, hardware or even tech of any kind!
- kerng 7y agoInteresting business news are always appreciated.
- goatinaboat 7y agoHow unions operate in high-skill industries is absolutely relevant here. We can learn a lot. Hollywood unions are also relevant.
- Jaruzel 7y agoFrom a summary of the issue I heard on LBC (UK radio station) a couple of days ago, this all stems from when the pilots agreed to a pay and pensions cut several years ago when BA was in financial trouble, and now that BA (and it's new parent company) is now back in profit, they want an inflation adjusted boost to put their pay and pensions back to where they should be.
- t0mas88 7y agoYes that's basically what happened at BA. Some other airlines did the same around 2009, but in a more pilot friendly way. For example at KLM the pilot's pay decrease to help the airline through the crisis was combined with a big increase in profit sharing bonus. At that time there was no profit to share, but now everyone is happy with the big bonuses.
- philjohn 7y agoPrecisely this ... the problem in the UK media is this is being portrayed as "Evil high paid pilots holding the company hostage and ruining your holiday!".
- repolfx 7y agoBA was in financial trouble partly because their unionized staff are paid far too much. Putting their salary back "where they should be" (a novel concept) would just cause them to be unaffordable again. As will going on strike for 48 hours. Basically BA is toast as an airline. They can't break their own union and are steadily being ground down by airlines with more flexible work forces.