13 ms·
Wunderlist founder wants to buy his app back from Microsoft
- hobofan 7y agoGiven how unrealistic reviving Wunderlist is (almost everyone of the original employees is working on other things inside Microsoft or has left), this ought to be a PR stunt, right? He might as well start from scratch at this point.
- nixpulvis 7y agoI think it speaks to how companies buy teams not products most of the time, and it's often tragic for the app itself.
- danieldk 7y agoOr alternatively, they buy a competitor to sink it before they become too powerful or falls in the hands of another larger competitor.
- kjksf 7y agoThis might provoke strong responses from hacker / programmer crowd, but... Relatively speaking, building a small team of capable engineers is much easier than getting a business, especially in a competitive space like TODO lists, to 13+ million users (their numbers in 2015 at the time of Microsoft acquisition).
- jchw 7y agoI don’t know why this should be controversial. Plenty of good products fail and shoddy ones succeed. It’s clear engineering merit is not the primary factor in success.
- o-__-o 7y agoI find the complete 180 to be true. Very easy to get a business into a competitive space, but it’s hard to build a capable team of engineers. If you have both money and a solid idea to generating revenue (business plan) then you have solved both problems easily, relatively speaking. Engineers come together with the universal language.. money. Something startups don’t have.
- nvrspyx 7y agoThey said getting a business to 13million+ users, not getting a business into a competitive space alone. The point is the users are where the money is and getting to that many users is the most difficult part, neither gathering a group of engineers nor entering a competitive space.
- o-__-o 7y agoLike Lyft? Throw money at customers and they come flocking. Same with engineers. It’s making that model profitable that’s the hard spot
- nikhilbagadia 7y agoI think he is quite focused on Pitch at the moment to start from scratch.
- Paraesthetic 7y agoProbably has a big non compete with Microsoft after the acquisition though.
- slightwinder 7y agoWunderlist the app was never a great example of technical prowess. From the first day it just was marketing and simplicity. Today they likely would start from scratch anyway, the old app is now decade old or so. The real worth is all in the brand. Bringing back a somewhat beloved app, innovate it a bit here and there, this will bring them some attention and money, maybe enough to sell it again some years in the future.
- bnt 7y agoI tried to use To Do this summer and gave up after a few weeks. Across Windows and iOS: notifications mostly don’t fire, apps kept reloading content every time I opened them (aka no cloud = no functionality). In the end, I gave up and just resumed using a combo of Reminders and Notes.
- reaperducer 7y agoI had a similar experience, but without the Windows element. I paid for Wunderlist, but dropped it because it evolved into something more convoluted than I wanted. I went back to the stock iOS apps. I didn't even know what Microsoft ate Wunderlist. I guess that's why I got an e-mail about Wunderlist out of the blue after I hadn't used it in what seemed like years.
- noego 7y agoMicrosoft has a directly competing product, so I don't see why they would ever want to sell Wunderlust. They would essentially be creating their own competitor, in return for a fraction of the money they had paid to acquire Wunderlist earlier.
- paggle 7y agoNot to mention that even the full purchase price of $100-$200m doesn’t make the Microsoft CEO even raise one eyebrow one millimeter.
- Barrin92 7y agothen again I doubt that the microsoft empire stands or falls with a to-do list app and it might just be good PR to sell it back instead of letting a well-liked product rot given that they're on an alleged "we love the community" campaign now.
- earenndil 7y agoGood PR--sure. $100M worth of PR? I don't think so.
- taksintikk 7y agoDid he sign a non-compete? Rebuild something new/better.
- vxNsr 7y agoPossibly but it for sure expired at this point. The reason not to rebuild is because Wunderlist is great as it is. It is feature complete, I cannot think of a single new feature I would want to add to it.
- sergiotapia 7y agoThis is what the guy from meh.com did. Sold his woot com to some large corporation saw they turned it into junk and he launched meh.com
- duxup 7y agoI gotta think that's the standard operating procedure and part of the deal for getting bought out ($$$) is the founders can't run off and just clone it.
- vxNsr 7y agoPlease make this a reality. To-Do is a joke compared to Wunderlist. It suffers from the same fate as all MS-built iOS apps: random logouts. I can't convince anyone to use MS apps because the first time they get logged out after an update they just stop using the app.
- baddox 7y agoThat sounds like an infuriating and interesting bug. Any idea what would cause that across Microsoft iOS apps? Do they just aggressively timeout sessions?
- valleyjo 7y agoIf it's a work or school account it can be related to cache lifetime settings your admin sets on the accounts. At my company it's set to an infuriating two days, so every Monday I have to log back in with 2FA again...
- vxNsr 7y agoThat's ridiculous. Apps should stay logged in for as long as the app is installed on your phone or until you log out/change the password. This is actually for personal accounts. (Specifically family)
- umeshunni 7y agoIt's not just ToDo and not just on iOS. I'm a heavy OneNote user and I can't get OneNote on the web to stay logged in more than a day.
- discreditable 7y agoAnd God help them if they somehow have a work/school and personal Microsoft account and don't remember which one they used.
- chris_wot 7y agoThe company I now work for has decided to separate out admin accounts in Windows. Fair enough, except it's not like a Unix system where you can quickly context switch. Trying to administer Office 365 with two separate Office 365 accounts is an absolutely nightmare!
- dash2 7y agoGod, I wish Skype would buy their app back.
- mandeepj 7y agoDid he sign a return policy? :-)
- seapunk 7y agoI think that it's a good sign that we see more and more founders who publicly admit that their creation is not between good hands after acquisition. Let's hope Microsoft makes this thing happen.
- duxup 7y agoCall me cynical but if they wanted it to be in good hands ... maybe don't take the money and run? Dude in one way or another cashed out and now wants to have his cake and eat it too. We get so many "founder sad about how things turned out after it is sold". If the founder hands over the keys IMO to some extent they're "responsible" for what happens next.
- seapunk 7y agoEvery founder has personal reasons to accept to be acquired, example here: https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/1170645721843982336 https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/117064572184398233... Also I don't think you are cynical. Don't take the money and continue to push the product seems to be a better solution, especially for users. I just appreciate that founders are more transparent about the fact their service is failing after being acquired. And yes, they have a big part of the responsability, but according to me it's a better signal than just heard the typical story of celebrating an acquisition, join a tech giant and remain silent. I like to see that people keep the bounds with their product even after this. Also it's more honest for other entrepreneurs in the same situation that becoming rich will be at the expense of your creation.
- dade_ 7y agoI am still awe at how bad MS is at making Windows apps. To Do is a poster child. I think Visio uses less RAM, is extremely laggy, slow to load, crashes many times a week and has awful layout for pen input.
- vezycash 7y ago>I am still awe at how bad MS is at making Windows apps. They've gotten better at being bad. Before, apps crashed but at least they were full featured, had two or three ways of doing the same thing - so you could get shit done. Now, stuff from MS is generally slower, still crash prone, looks fancy but is bare-boned, updates remove the few useful stuff and replace em with half baked alternatives or nothing.
- kweinber 7y agoYesterday HN had a front-page article about how making your app do less was the key to making it more useful. This is a meme I’ve never understood.... how is it more “useful” if it is less “full of stuff to use”. When people equate streamlining experience with feature removal you get this kind of frustration.
- zapzupnz 7y agoI'd understand the reasoning if the removed features could possibly make more sense in a separate app or some kind of optional add-on module, or if perhaps the point is really about the user interface not being overwhelming — and yet Microsoft manages to take apps with perfectly straight-forward user interfaces and twist them until the one or two features that an app has are uselessly hidden behind one or two hamburger menus.
- gilrain 7y agoYou don't usually have to tell this to an adult, but: no backsies. Your can't have your cake and eat it too. You can't sell your company and keep it too. Basic.
- ThomPete 7y agoWell tell that to Skype :)
- true_religion 7y agoYeah, that’s why he wants to buy it back. They will get their money back.
- adventured 7y agoMicrosoft would get a fraction of their money back. The former owners wouldn't pay more than 10-25% of what they previously sold Wunderlist for, at this point.
- mrieck 7y agoThat's why this feels like a publicity stunt to shame Microsoft. If you've made millions of dollars from selling something - I don't feel like you have the right to shame the buyer especially if you're only offering 25% back. He should have kept the offer he made private.
- CJefferson 7y agoMicrosoft paid 150 million for it, of which the VCs I'm sure got at least half. I can't imagine him offering anything close to that. I notice he hasn't said how much he will offer.
- phailhaus 7y agoHe's not trying to keep the money, the headline says it right there: "founder wants to buy his app back." Of course you can buy back something that you sold. They just don't have to sell it to you.
- oh_sigh 7y agoWhat's the point of buying it back, if he can just start another similar company and siphon off many active, disgruntled users? Yeah, you don't get to keep the already registered userbase, or the brand, but I think former users would flock to it if they knew the original people were in charge of this product. Is there something in the contract that they can't start a competing product within X years, but could do a buyback?
- chrisked 7y agoNo, they never signed a non-compete (https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/1170660715998449665 https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/117066071599844966...) Also building a brand is not too easy (https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/1170638459834458113 https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/117063845983445811...)
- Drdrdrq 7y ago>... but I think former users would flock to it if they knew the original people were in charge of this product. So maybe such tweet is how you let them know that something's cooking? Followed by "they won't sell it back, we'll build a new one!". We'll see.
- traderjane 7y agoCould it be that todo apps are kind of hard? What else explains the lethargic pace of improvements for Microsoft’s own todo app?
- vezycash 7y agoI don't know much about todos. But I know Microsoft. They're passionate about fucking up every good thing they own. My uncle once told me, Too many spoons in a pot makes the soup sour. Microsoft upgrades things to death.
- baxtr 7y agoI never understood why wunderlist was so successful. Any hints?
- hobofan 7y ago- Shared to do lists (e.g. with your partner/spouse) - Very good platform coverage of clients - Good UX I don't think the set of features is too impressive by todays standards, but at the time it was pretty appealing compared to the competition.
- steve_adams_86 7y agoSurprisingly (I thought anyway) WL was one of very few which support shared lists effectively. I bought Things for mac for myself and my partner at the time and was blown away when I discovered a $60 CAD To Do list app couldn't share a list. WL ended up being the best option by a long shot. These days I use Todoist which can also share lists nicely.
- beardedman 7y agoI would start using WL again if this happens. 100%. EDIT: I can't believe how much positive press MS To-Do has gotten. It's a featureless rip-off of WL that could have been built in a month.
- viach 7y agoI don't understand, why Microsoft is porting features from Wunderlist to their To-Do instead of just shutting down To-Do and add small shiny MS logo to Wunderlist? As far as I can see, WL is more feature rich and has better user base, no?
- albertshin 7y agoProbably grooming it for enterprise use cases/customers
- maklu 7y agoWunderlist still runs on AWS. To-Do runs on a Microsoft back-end, including all security features needed for their enterprise (O365) customers..
- viach 7y agoStill, moving product to new servers and improving security sounds to me easier than rewriting it.
- elehack 7y agoIt isn't just a change of server, it's an entirely different back-end infrastructure. To Do is a modern UI on top of Exchange tasks.
- yellow_postit 7y agoSpeaks in part to how much vendor lock in there is with cloud providers that this has been such an involved migration.
- vxNsr 7y agoThis would make a great case study for migrating a full stack AWS app to Azure. They're constantly trying to convince their customers to migrate to full stack Azure, here's their chance to prove it's doable. Dog food and all, I'm sure they'll find some pain points they could fix.
- johnchristopher 7y agoThere maybe a window opportunity in the todo space at the moment for a GTD oriented app. Look at thing that is only available for iOs. There's only NirvanaHQ coming close and it's not moving much at the moment.
- dannylandau 7y agoAlways been a huge fan of Wunderlist, used it for my iPhone development project, 1st time using a to-do list app and really loved it! Here is one guy hoping/praying it comes back!!!!
- wpdev_63 7y agoIt blows my mind that todo list app can be worth $200 million... Then again a chat app is now worth several billion... I don't have any idea of how this works.
- dtech 7y agoChat app is only worth that with a huge network of users, which is the real value. Anyone can make a chat app. Making a chat app with 100M+ users takes years of effort and luck.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoThere are other factors. Valuations in tech now depend on our current regulatory and financial environment: 1- Absolutely no real privacy regulation exists in the US, where people's information can be bought and sold freely. (I know there is regulation, but not real regulatory activity means it's de-facto unregulated) 2- There's no anti-trust activity and companies like microsoft, google and facebook can engage in anti-competitive behaviors of all types: buying competitors and closing them to reduce competition (it seems the case with Wunderlist), operate a market and be a participant in it while undermining other market participants using inside information, create a monopoly or oligopoly with no real regulatory costs (aside from a small % of earnings being taxed as 'fines'), actively conspiring to avoid competition for employee salaries, etc 3- Very low interest rates/net negative interest rates for capital holders with opaque and byzantine distribution of newly minted fiat. 4- Zero consequences for undermining democratic institutions by creating revolving doors between regulatory agencies and the companies they are supposed to regulate. 5- Regressive regulatory compliance costs While the ones who benefit from such an environment would like to make it seem this is the natural state of the economy, it isn't, it's a very new and very strange experiment. Also, while capital holders would like people to think that the current state of prosperity is caused by our current system of regulatory and financial application, these same people then agree that the greatest advancement in standards of living for the western world happened during the 1920-1960s, a time when the regulatory and financial systems were very different (like a 90% tax on earnings above $50 mill/year (in 2019 money)). So I'd guess we could advance just as well if not better with something more akin to what was then. I'm hoping our current conditions will not remain over the next 40+ years and some of these valuations will be more in line with traditional P/E ratios.
- bit_4l 7y agoIt sucks seeing MS kills Wunderlist. I’m always a huge fan of it. Simple, intuitive.
- thecleaner 7y agoAnybody using Remember the Milk for their todos ? I used it and loved it.
- BrentOzar 7y ago> Anybody using Remember the Milk for their todos ? I used it and loved it. Yes, have done for years, but they haven't really implemented many features over the last several years (despite the paid users renewal.) I always wonder if they're out on a beach somewhere just spending the revenue money on margaritas, but...I can't be upset with that. RTM just works, and it's still there.
- screaminghawk 7y agoI'm using one called "Out of Milk". It's great. Is that the one you mean or something else?
- thecleaner 7y agoI think the one you are referring to is a grocery shopping app. RTM is much more general.
- AdamGibbins 7y agoYes I use it daily, it's got some important distinguishing features compared to the competition like Todoist. For example start dates, do not under any circumstance show me a task until it's ready to start. Why Todoist haven't added this after all these years I've no idea, I have so many regular tasks that this is useful for.
- immigrantsheep 7y agoI've been using it since it came out ages ago :)
- amix 7y agoIf you are looking for an alternative todo app that is in it for the long haul, check out Todoist. We have been at it longer than Wunderlist (12+ years), and we will never sell out. As I like to put it, death is my exit strategy. For more thoughts about this, check out https://doist.com/blog/no-exit-strategy/ https://doist.com/blog/no-exit-strategy/
- larrik 7y agoHow well does the Linux version work?
- amix 7y agoThere are 2 unofficial and open source Linux clients: - http://todoistlinux.hakimouake.com/ http://todoistlinux.hakimouake.com/ - https://github.com/KryDos/todoist-linux https://github.com/KryDos/todoist-linux There are also various command line clients, e.g.: https://github.com/sachaos/todoist https://github.com/sachaos/todoist
- zwayhowder 7y agoThere is no official client, but their API is public and documented. I use Todoist https://github.com/sachaos/todoist https://github.com/sachaos/todoist as my daily driver. It has offline support and the integration with peco is sublime.
- input_sh 7y agoThird-party apps are great and all, but if you're using GNOME, add a Todoist account in Settings -> Online Accounts and use gnome-todo for a truly native experience.
- cweagans 7y agoI've tried this a couple times, but Gnome Todo crashes on launch whenever I have my Todoist account set up. You also miss out on the Todoist search functionality if you use Gnome Todo.
- 7y ago
- grizzles 7y agoThis is an odd form of public shaming. Satya ought to respond to him on Twitter that it's a deal if he'd be willing to pay 50% of the price they paid him for it. A shame back if you will.
- kossae 7y agoI loved Wunderlist, and after the announcement of the acquisition I went looking for alternatives. It turns out, I didn't _really_ need "sub-tasks" or collaborative comments on my TODOs. All I really needed was shared lists, dependable reminder push notifications, and perhaps some location-based/geofencing features. This is all covered by the stock iOS Reminders app. I use Fantastical as the 'GUI' instead of Reminders, but basically use my e-mails CalDAV server (Fastmail) to manage my lists now, and have retained the reliability and subset of features that I needed. It's been great so far, and it's virtually free as part of your standard email/calendar service (Gmail/Calendar, Fastmail, etc.).
- preek 7y agoIf you are looking for something more sustainable (free software), with the same client for desktop and mobile, please check out organice: https://github.com/200ok-ch/organice https://github.com/200ok-ch/organice It’s using Org syntax, but has a mobile friendly interface. Synchronization is done using Dropbox or Google Drive, so you can also have shared projects and todos. The app is written in React and Redux, has a AGPL license and has a free public instance at https://organice.200ok.ch https://organice.200ok.ch
- thedudeabides5 7y agoHow much do y’all think they would let him buy it back for? $10mm?
- chad_strategic 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20750140 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20750140
- demarq 7y agoThis behaviour will hurt microsoft in the long term in negotiating future deals. Founders often have very emotional connections to their company
- quickthrower2 7y agoWhat if he just builds a new app from scratch? Would probably be cheaper, but he'd have to be careful to show no design or copyright has been infringed.
- alexlin 7y agoThe tweet from Wunderlist's Christian (https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/1170615663326638081 https://twitter.com/christianreber/status/117061566332663808...) reminds me a lot of Taskade YC S19 (https://www.taskade.com https://www.taskade.com) and what they are trying to do in the productivity and collaboration space.
- helenax 7y agoSame feeling with the founder. It's pity to see Wunderlist go. Transferring all the details from one todo app to another can be very annoying, not to mention the extra efforts to get used with a new app. Glad to find TickTick! The data transfer is super easy. It's kind of an all-in-one toolkit, while still remains clear and simple to use. Not sure if I would switch back to Wunderlist even if they purchase it back ;) https://ticktick.com/ https://ticktick.com/