8 ms·
Malcolm Gladwell's famous 10k hour rule isn't holding up in new research
- 1123581321 7y agoThe title is incorrect as it is Anders Ericsson‘s research, Ericsson did not find that time necessarily led to mastery (that is a popular misunderstanding) the study quantified practice, not deliberate practice, and despite all that did find a correlation between unqualified practice time and mastery, among other factors.
- itcrowd 7y agoSorry, but you're wrong about the deliberate practice part. The study's name even reveals it and a cursory reading of the text will clarify it: "The Role of Deliberate Practice in the Acquisition of Expert Performance" [emphasis mine].
- 1123581321 7y agoNo need to apologize. I was referring to the new study, not Ericsson’s, and mangled my comment. It should read: “The title is incorrect as it is Anders Ericsson‘s research, Ericsson did not find that time spent necessarily led to mastery (that is a popular misunderstanding). The new study quantified practice, not deliberate practice, and despite all that did find a correlation between unqualified practice time and mastery, among other factors.” Thanks for catching it.
- jplayer01 7y agoSo I shouldn't bother with anything. Good to know. Thanks for that info. If practice doesn't mean anything what even is the point of anything?
- delish 7y agoOne of the debates I'm surprised to have with my friends is: some of them will parrot Gladwell-style advice (truisms that claim to come from science). I will say, "That didn't replicate." They'll say, "Well it's a good idea anyway." And then I'll say some long thing about how when you're giving someone advice, you should hold yourself to a higher standard, not a lower one. Especially if you're an institution.
- inimino 7y agoIf you're competing in an area where other competitors spend 10k hours before they compete, you better practice. We didn't really need a study to tell us that, but people feel it adds something to say that science has "proved it". That's why if you point out the study was BS, it doesn't matter, because it was just a supporting detail for the point they wanted to make anyway. Practice.
- delish 7y agoNot quite to disagree with your main point: > because it was just a supporting detail for the point they wanted to make anyway. The people who make arguments whose evidence is just a supporting detail for the point they wanted to make anyway are common--some are some of my friends, family and coworkers, but I take what they say a lot less seriously than I do people who have high standards for evidence. >We didn't really need a study to tell us that Perhaps not, but we can ask for studies on what kind of practice, how much and how old you are when you practice et cetera. Yes you "have to practice." But you can be interested in how to practice well, and one way to know that is good studies (i.e. not dubious ones).
- inimino 7y agoMost of the best advice is simply telling people what is already obvious to everyone but them. There's not a lot of evidence needed, and adding more won't help if the person isn't ready to hear it. In "reasons why people misallocate practice time", akrasia ranks above the lack of research studies by about a mile.
- knolax 7y agoIf you're competing in area where other competitors spend 10k hours practicing then maybe you should make sure that those 10k hours are actually giving them an advantage. If not you now have a 10k hour time advantage over them.
- insickness 7y agoIt's fine if you are simply looking for inspiration, but non-scientific claims (i.e. unfalsifiable claims) can mask other important differentiators of success. Perhaps practice alone won't deliver success in whatever field you choose; there may be a genetic component that might indicate you should choose a different area of focus. Perhaps the type of practice is more important than the amount of hours you put in and the focus on the hours is counter-productive.
- throwaway99755 7y agoIt’s the reverse. You should bother with “everything” because you could have a secret talent.
- sitkack 7y agoI feel like there is a Dunning-Kruger homomorphism with the Gladwell 10k "rule". There are mastery inflection points at 20, 100, 500, 1000, etc. hour marks (ish). It really seems like the Gladwell conjecture is that people that do a thing for love|money, do a thing a lot.
- itcrowd 7y agoCouple of points here: 1) HN is supposed to link to the original report about the research, which is done by the Guardian (linked in the first sentence!) here [1] 2) "Anders Ericsson [original study author] said the new paper actually replicated most of their findings." 3) Gladwell pushed the 10k rule to the point of breaking, by that I mean he extrapolated way beyond the original research. Gladwell's point may not hold up (as the title reads) because he pushed it too far, he drew his own imaginary conclusions that make for a nice story. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/aug/21/practice-does-not-always-make-perfect-violinists-10000-hour-rule https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/aug/21/practice-doe...
- mkl 7y agoPoint (1) might be because we already had the Guardian article on HN last month, discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20753311 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20753311
- mdorazio 7y agoSerious question: which of Gladwell's various truisms and rules have actually held up to research? I've seen a lot of criticism of his pop science books over the years without much talk about what he actually gets right.
- zamfi 7y agoPerhaps the silence is telling.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoWell, to play devil's advocate here, this article's reason the 10,000 Rule is not true is because it doesn't make experts. However, he never said the 10,000 rule would create experts. He said it would create proficiency. It's become a major theme in society (especially online at places like Reddit) where someone misunderstands a statement, and then promptly attacks or disproves it, instead of asking the person for clarification first. If there is one thing I've learned over the years is people tend to be well intended, and by asking for clarification, one has more of an opportunity to learn than shutting it down immediately. At worse you've learned where they're coming from, which imho is more valuable than the initial statement itself.
- Marazan 7y agoProficiency? What? He says "Researchers have settled on what they believe is the magic number for true expertise: 10,000 hours" True expertise is not mere proficiency.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoThere are also statements of him saying he never said it makes an expert. Maybe he's lying?
- mindfulplay 7y agoHe has put words on paper that confirm. He garners attention and speaking fees. He has no incentive to speak the truth or actually help people gain expertise. He is almost a fraud. I can't believe I paid for his crappy book. I feel like an idiot. His "story" about the Korean airlines and the general conclusions he draws borders on the racist and superfluous.
- sjosund 7y agoWhile they are talking about quantity of practice, they aren’t discussing the quality of it. I can certainly imagine that there are better and worse ways to practice and am curious if anyone has seen some studies on its effects?
- iandanforth 7y agoOne of the other key papers in the book in which the original finding was published ("The Psychology of Abilities, Competencies, and Expertise") was the role of increasingly skillful teachers. If you don't have a series of progressively competent teachers who are all good at providing motivation you also won't see the kind of performance increases that lead to professional status.
- schaefer 7y agoEricsson has gone so far as to dedicate an entire six-page section in his 2017 book [Peak] to a discussion of [Outliers]'s popularization of the catch phrase "the ten thousand hour rule". In the section he lists three reasons why this phrase is misleading, and one way in which it is accurate. The central theme of [Peak] is to review what things all experts have in common, irrespective of their varied fields: these being a habit of deliberate, purposeful practice and mental maps. [Peak] Peak: Secrets from the new science of Expertise by Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool [Outliers] Outliers by Malcom Gladwell
- Jerry2 7y agoGladwell's most famous book, 'The Tipping Point', suffered a similar fate. It was largely predicated on the 'broken window theory' [1] which too was proven not to be valid [2]. After his book 'David and Goliath' received numerous bad reviews for oversimplifying things and pinning causes on things that don't make sense, Gladwell lashed out at his critics and basically said that his books are not written for experts. [3] Almost all of Gladwell's books are written in a style that categorically states that the subjects of his writing have a predetermined cause and effect. He doesn't leave much to chance, uncertainty or some other unknown cause. Everything is certain. His stories and narrations always imply a cause. That's the real secret of his writing. [1] https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2016/11/14/the-tipping-point-broken-window-theory/ https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2016/11/14/the-tipping-po... [2] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/sorry-malcolm-gladwell-nycs-drop-in-crime-not-due-to-broken-window-theory-12636297/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/sorry-malcolm-glad... [3] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/sep/29/malcolm-gladwell-david-and-goliath-interview https://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/sep/29/malcolm-gladwe...
- wglb 7y agoTo me Tipping Point is a kindergarten-level version of Chaos Theory. It was so bad I could not finish it. He is a fair story teller but is closer to opinion than non-fiction. He says if his books are too simplistic for you, don't read them. I am also likely to tell friends and family to not read them.
- wodenokoto 7y agoChoas theory? No, it is about marketing. It is about what makes one message be heard, and another not.
- pjscott 7y agoAll of this is unsurprising, given Gladwell's process: 1. Take research findings in psychology, sociology, etc., all fields which are having big replication problems. 2. Pick out findings that are surprising enough to write a pop-science book about. These are less likely to be true -- that's why they're surprising. 3. Oversimplify for popular consumption, sound very confident, and omit things that don't fit the story. (This makes for a much better read, as epistemically sinful as it may be.) Each step makes good commercial sense, and I can't hate him for it, but the resulting books are unlikely to be Actually True.
- chillacy 7y agoWait this study is from 1993? Anyways it seems obvious that the relationship between hours in and performance starts to get skewed at top percentages of human performance. Doing well in the NBA requires a lucky draw of genetic height / strength as well as practice. But a lot of deliberate practice will probably make you better than your neighbors at pickup games.
- knolax 7y agoGladwell had a chapter in his book Outliers called "Rice Paddies and Math Tests" where he claims that "Asians are good at math" because rice is hard to grow. The man is obviously an intellectual sham.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- james_s_tayler 7y agoWhat I took away from that chapter was two things. First was that Asian children, at least those who speak languages that function this way, grok the concept of addition faster than their Western counterparts because the counting systems are extremely regular, so they pick up on the patterns easier because 11 isn't the arbitrary "eleven" instead it's simply "ten one". Second was success in math is in part a function of perseverance. Impossible problems were given to groups of kids and something like the American kids gave up after 9 minutes on average and the Japanese kids gave up after 14 minutes on average. My memory is fuzzy on the details but that particular metric correlated really well iirc. Been a long time since I read it.
- knolax 7y agoImplicit in the premise of the chapter is that categories such as "Asian" and attributes like "better at math" exist objectively. Gladwell never defines Asian, instead shifting between definitions that rely on nationality (cherrypicked test scores from a number of well-off Northeast Asian countries), language (where he brings up the Chinese counting system used only in some but not all Asian Languages), and ethnicity (where he compares Asian-American children to other American children, many of whom share little to no commonalities with the former two groups). He uses the classic tactic of generalizing these three groups as one through the nefarious concept of "culture", which is poorly defined and can not objectively measured. He then makes the claim that "Asians" are "better at math" without backing up the point with anything other than cherrypicked standardized test scores. Aside from that, he only shows vague correlations without ever proving causation in any rigorous way. Even if the Chinese counting system leads to a faster understanding of arithmetic, Gladwell does not prove that this leads to significantly better math performance. Likewise, he simply claims without any solid proof that growing rice is more difficult than wheat (what units do you measure that in?), or that this increased difficulty would actually provide enough pressure to create a "culture of perseverance" (again, what objective units do you measure that in?). Individual claims in Gladwell's writing may be true, but they never connect together in any rigorous way to prove the claims he tries to make.
- mrburton 7y agoIf this doesn't educate people on how important sales and communication is, then nothing will help you see the light. ;) Honestly, those who are excellent communicators will be able to persuade people in masses to follow what they preach. I find this extremely interesting. Now is the 10k hour rule flawed or not? I have no idea. I tend to focus on what works for me vs. the masses. We're all different.
- kiba 7y agoIf Gladwell is communicating false or misleading information, then we need to know about it rather than give a collective shrug. People will believe whatever Gladwell wrote, and that wastes everyone's time.
- ErotemeObelus 7y agoOf course it doesn't! Practice does not make perfect. Practice makes PERMANENT!
- FuckButtons 7y agoNo shit, Gladwell knows one thing, how to sell a hokey idea to the credulous.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoOne of my favorite outcomes from this was Dan Mclaughlin's attempt at becoming a pro-golfer[1] which he called "The Dan Plan". What I found really interesting was that how you practice is so important and how we often get it wrong. When I think about things I've picked up mastery in over the years and things which eluded me, I see a lot of similarities. Mastery for me comes from varying the activities, not from rote repetition and "muscle memory." [1] https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NH2YUq2AJEgJ:https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/08/the-dan-plan/536592/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-b-1-d https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NH2YUq...
- simonh 7y agoOn how to practice, I read once about the difference in the ways good amateur pianists practice and how top professionals typically practice. The amateurs will practice all their scales and pieces from start to finish by rote every day. The Pros identify the specific scales and short sections of pieces they hit problems with, and focus almost all their practice on those tricky parts. As a result they get as much as 10x or 20x or more utility from the time they spend on it.
- MPSimmons 7y agoI have to wonder if the difference is because the latter is the better practice, or because they have already done the basic practice and don't need to do it anymore. In other words, is it necessary to go through the rote work of practicing basics before becoming a pro? I would guess the answer is yes. It would be far more telling to track many people, from beginner through their musical (in this case) careers, and determine who became pro and who didn't, and what their practice was like throughout.
- jjeaff 7y agoYa, it seems like practicing the difficult parts would just be a natural progression for anyone who is good enough that the easier parts are simple to them.
- 7y ago
- sysbin 7y agoI'm skeptical if some mastery of skills need an order of events in life that's fundamentally important. I assume youth is another important factor in the equation. The 10k hour rule is too hopeful for everything but I can see it working for many skills.
- cookie_monsta 7y agoPeople trained in the "hard sciences" seem to place a lot more rigour on numbers than the social sciences can really accommodate. Much of the scientific method can't really be applied to humans in a longitudinal study so there's going to be some leeway and larger scope for variation than when performing tests on inanimate objects or lab rats for example. We all know this at some level. Nobody expects to be a mediocre violinist at the 59th minute of the 9,999th hour and to be a master one minute later. To me the book read like an extended musing on folk wisdom such as "practice makes perfect" and that famous Coolidge quote about persistence. Obviously talent, genius and education are factors, but persistence and determination are huge.
- thewileyone 7y agoThe point Gladwell was trying to make is that the more you practice, the better you will get. The degree how the practice affects each individual will differ and there are no guarantees, but you will better off practicing than not.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoThat's actually not the point, according to the man himself in his interview on freakonomics. He said that the point was more about the support needed to become an expert. Separately, the research he based this on is about deliberate practice. If you're not going to practice deliberately, you might in fact be better off not practicing at all. """MALCOLM GLADWELL: The 10,000-hour stuff that I put in Outliers was really only intended to perform a very specific narrative function — or not narrative function, but argumentative function. To me the point of 10,000 hours is: if it takes that long to be good, you can’t do it by yourself. If you have to play chess for 10 years in order to be a great chess player, then that means that you can’t have a job, or maybe if you have a job it can’t be a job that takes most of your time..."""
- iamwil 7y agoThis study only interviewed 13 violinists. That's not a large number to invalidate.
- AstralStorm 7y agoAnd Gladwell interviewed how many?
- iamwil 7y agoMy comment is not meant to be a defense of Gladwell. Just that this title is link bait, and this study is not conclusive.
- Expez 7y agoHere's the paper itself, freely available for once, if anyone else wants to take a deeper dive: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.190327 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.190327
- mindfulplay 7y agoHe is a hack. Full stop. He is nearly a fraud.
- the_watcher 7y ago> The adage was given a scientific basis when journalist and author Malcolm Gladwell wrote about the 10,000-hour rule in his 2008 bestseller, "Outliers." Malcolm Gladwell declaring something based on cherry-picked anecdotes does not give anything a "scientific basis". While Gladwell (very) often drives me crazy (he's a walking, talking Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect machine), I find Outliers to be his best book. You just have to reframe it mentally as "mastery generally involves a whole lot of practice, here are some stories illustrating that". Even when I vehemently disagree with his conclusions, he really is an excellent storyteller.
- Quanttek 7y agoBecause people in this thread are (as usually) unable to read the article before commenting, here the relevant excerpt: > But according to a new study published in Royal Society: Open Science that attempted to replicate the findings of the original, practice alone doesn't account for mastery. In the study, deliberate practice only accounted for a quarter percentage of the skills difference, which doesn't account for what makes someone an expert. > Brooke Macnamara, a psychologist at Case Western Reserve University, and researcher Megha Maitra interviewed three groups of 13 violinists, each rated as less accomplished, good, and best. The violinists were told to keep a diary to log practice hours, and those hours were then tallied. While the less accomplished violinists had logged an estimated 6,000 hours by age 20, the good and best had both logged around 11,000 hours. > That is to say: The good and best violinists saw no huge difference, as opposed to the not so good violinists, who didn't practice as much. The implication: practice didn't account for all the differences in performance. And the abstract: > We sought to replicate Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Römer's (Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Römer 1993 Psychol. Rev.100, 363–406) seminal study on deliberate practice. Ericsson et al. found that differences in retrospective estimates of accumulated amounts of deliberate practice corresponded to each skill level of student violinists. They concluded, ‘individual differences in ultimate performance can largely be accounted for by differential amounts of past and current levels of practice’ (p. 392). We reproduced the methodology with notable exceptions, namely (i) employing a double-blind procedure, (ii) conducting analyses better suited to the study design, and (iii) testing previously unanswered questions about teacher-designed practice—that is, we examined the way Ericsson et al. operationalized deliberate practice (practice alone), and their theoretical but previously unmeasured definition of deliberate practice (teacher-designed practice), and compared them. We did not replicate the core finding that accumulated amounts of deliberate practice corresponded to each skill level. Overall, the size of the effect was substantial, but considerably smaller than the original study's effect size. Teacher-designed practice was perceived as less relevant to improving performance on the violin than practice alone. Further, amount of teacher-designed practice did not account for more variance in performance than amount of practice alone. Implications for the deliberate practice theory are discussed.
- paulsutter 7y agoThis quote is the best explanation for Malcolm Gladwell: “We’re obsessed with things like coherence, consistency, neatness of argument. Readers are indifferent to those things” - Malcolm Gladwell
- sinuhe69 7y agoThe funny thing is that Guardian got the central idea totally wrong: "the related idea of "deliberate practice" — or pushing your skills over long hours " No, deliberate practice is not just long hours practice. Deliberate practice is deliberately finding your weakness and practice to fix it, to improve it then move on. Merely more practice will not improve one's skill much after a certain threshold. What matters is not how long or how many times did you do a certain thing but how often did you do it correctly and what you learned from the experience. Thus comes the second important part of effective training: a great teacher.