11 ms·
Shift to electric vehicles will radically change auto factories
- pmorici 7y agoThese estimates about when electric vehicles are going to take off all seem naively conservative. The total world wide vehicle market is just under 70 million units a year. Tesla alone has guided for sales of 400k vehicles this year. If they roughly double their output on average each year they will be close to 20% of the total worldwide output in 5 years.
- benrbray 7y agoSure, but that ignores other factors like safety, infrastructure, and winning over public opinion. In my opinion, there's also the question of whether we really want to further cement America's dependence on cars. We could be investing this money / effort into laying down bullet trains, expanding public transportation, and reforming zoning laws to make future cities more human-friendly.
- pmorici 7y agoThe top three safest cars ever tested by the NHTSA are all Electric. Tesla alone has been doubling the number of deployed charging stations every year and there are a handful of other entrants building out networks as well. Every home owner with a garage has the infrastructure needed to charge an electric car (aka: a wall outlet). I've not yet met a single person who after riding in a Tesla Model 3 doesn't want one.
- mavhc 7y agoHere in uk about 20% of garages aren't built straight onto the house, which was annoying when I was searching for a house to buy.
- arethuza 7y agoWhen we were looking at houses a couple of years ago in the UK one thing that I always noticed is that almost nobody seems to use their garage to hold cars - 1 house out of the 20 or so we looked at had a car in it - the rest were full of miscellaneous stuff.
- rypskar 7y agoIsn't it possible to get electricity to a detached garage in the uk? My garage is 10 meters from my house, but I do still have two circuits from the house to the garage
- mavhc 7y agoProbably, but expensive to have to have a trench dug. It does seem rare for people to use their garages for cars. Half the time they're too small to get a car in and a human out though.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>The top three safest cars ever tested by the NHTSA are all Electric Because the people making electric cars know the buyer demographics and know those people have enough money to justify paying a premium for that thereby making it a marketable feature. Nobody is wasting the money putting tree-trunk A-pillars and foot thick doors in a Chevy Aveo competitor because protection against something that's less than a once in a lifetime event for most people let alone the vehicle is not high on the priority list of those buyers.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoThat would be nice, but America is unusually rural for a developed country, and that affects the culture even in the cities in a big way.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI doubt you would be able to restrict personal transport again. Anyone with relatives outside the immediate vicinity probably wouldn't want to rely on public transportation. And even if so, let's be honest, having your own vehicle gives you many opportunities and public transport is often inconvenient.
- GVIrish 7y agoIt wouldn't be that personal vehicle ownership would be banned, it would just be drastically reduced. In its place there'd be far better public transportation options, maybe better fractional car usage options, bicycles rideshares, etc. Many people would still need cars, but instead of every family needing two cars, many could just have one. Then even for the people with cars, they might not drive as many miles on average with the new options open to them. Obviously it would be easier to reduce car ownership in denser areas so that's where the bulk of the shift would happen.
- adrianN 7y agoChanging cities happens on a timeline of decades. We need to get rid of ICEs running on fossil fuel completely until maybe 2040, 2050 at the latest. That is, if we manage a linear GHG emission reduction starting yesterday. Electric cars are the only option that can be rolled out fast enough. Of course we should start the transformation away from car dependence at the same time, just don't expect meaningful effects until after ICEs are already obsolete.
- rapsey 7y agoExponential increase of output from a single manufacturer for 5 years is naively optimistic to put it mildly. Scaling manufacture (ignoring if demand even exists) is very difficult and expensive.
- marvin 7y agoThey've been able to do it up until now, with >50% CAGR per year since 2010-ish. The question is whether you can naively extrapolate this mathematical growth when approaching established manufacturers in volume. Tesla has up until now been an excellent example that a billion-dollar revenue business can be built much faster than 100 years ago.
- sveme 7y agoThat would require a doubling of production capacity each year. Currently they have two factories (?), next they'll need to have four, then eight... The whole company would have to scale accordingly. That's just not feasible. And I don't believe there has even been a hardware company in the world with exponential growth over an extended period of time.
- pmorici 7y agoThe factories haven't been operating at 100% capacity. The US factory in Fremont for example is in the process of putting in a new line to produce the Model Y, demand for which should be similar to the Model 3. That alone will enable them to close to double output. Then there is the China factory that is opening in a month or two they built that in ~9 months and they are planning to break ground on a factory in Europe next year.
- rgbrenner 7y agoToyota needs 50 factories + joint ventures + contract facilities to deliver 10m cars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Toyota_manufacturing_facilities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Toyota_manufacturing_f... You just said Tesla will deliver 13m in 5 years..
- emptysands 7y agoLess parts should also mean a more productive manufacturing process.
- pwagland 7y agoI like Tesla more than most, I have one myself… however you can't be suggesting that three factories will outproduce 50? That would be some massive gains in efficiency! It seems unlikely that the factories are currently operating at about 10% efficiency.
- 7y ago
- rgbrenner 7y agoThat's naively optimistic. Take a look through the number of vehicles manufactured by Toyota: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Toyota_vehicles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Toyota_vehicles Each one of those represents a market segment that Toyota serves. Where is Tesla's equivalent: minivan, yaris, rav4, tacoma, etc? You don't really expect some soccer mom who buys a 30k minivan to buy a model X for 80k+? And I guess, the construction worker can pile his materials in the front trunk on the X too? I mean we only have 4 cars to pick from here.. And consider all of the places worldwide that Toyota sells to.. from rich countries to poor countries. They rely on infrastructure that is available globally to everyone, no matter your living situation. Even if you live in a poor country with little infrastructure and intermittent electricity, you can still get gas for your Toyota. You might find this comparison silly... but you just said Tesla will produce 13m vehicles in 5 years.. making them 20% larger than Toyota, the worlds largest manufacturer.
- pmorici 7y agoSure is, you can haggle about whether it will be in 5 years, 8 years or somewhere in between but I think Tesla growing as big as Toyota is almost inevitable. In 5 years Tesla will be producing at least 7 models including 2 cars (S & 3) , 2 crossover/SUVs (X & Y), 1 sports car (roadster), 1 pick-up truck, 1 semi-truck.
- clouddrover 7y agoI don't think Tesla will get as big as Toyota. Toyota is the second highest selling car company, and they're a close second to Volkswagen. Volkswagen Group will be the biggest electric car company in a few years because they're spending the most money on it: https://europe.autonews.com/automakers/vws-91b-spend-evs-outpaces-investment-rivals https://europe.autonews.com/automakers/vws-91b-spend-evs-out... Volkswagen's current and soon to be released battery electrics are the VW e-Up!, VW e-Golf (though this is being discontinued), VW ID.3, SEAT Mii Electric, SEAT el-Born, Skoda Citigo iV, Skoda Vision iV, Audi e-tron, and the Porsche Taycan. Future Volkswagen battery electrics are the VW ID Crozz, VW ID Roomz, VW ID Buzz, Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo, Porsche Macan electric, Audi e-tron GT, and the Audi e-tron Q4. Volkwagen's roadmap is bigger and broader than Tesla's can be simply because Volkswagen operates at a larger scale.
- vkou 7y agoAnd in 35 years, they will sell more cars than there are grains of sand on all the Earth's beaches. Curves that look exponential turn out to be sigmoidal. Expecting them to grow to a bigger manufacturer than Toyota in five years is laughably unrealistic.
- navigatesol 7y ago>Tesla alone has guided for sales of 400k vehicles this year. Which they are unlikely to achieve this year. We can now finally see the year-over-year numbers (the ones that Tesla were telling us were 100s of % growth, due to new model launch a year ago), and those numbers might be down (ie no growth). But as an industry, EVs will keep taking market share. They just make sense.
- lnsru 7y agoI miss mentioning more capable production robots in this article. They are already destroying jobs today. In another 5 years robots will do even more tasks than today. Just look at the production line videos on YouTube for different cars. Vehicles made using less parts will unavoidable lead to factories without humans. Maybe couple bored to death guards will stay.
- ccorda 7y ago> The Center for Automotive Research and other firms focusing on the impact of new technology on the auto industry don't expect electric vehicles to account for more than 10% of the sales market until the late 2020s. That's when electric vehicles could start to shake things up. Consider California [1], where it'll likely cross that in the next few years. 2015 | 1.7% 2016 | 1.9% 2017 | 2.6% 2018 | 4.7% 2019 | 5.6% Or Norway, where it is already at 48% [2] Both have higher gas prices and subsidies that help with TCO comparisons. But EV costs have lots of economies of scale yet to achieve. Hard to imagine it takes 10 more years for the rest of the country to catch up to California. [1] California New Car Dealer Association report Q2 19 https://electrek.co/2019/08/19/tesla-sales-electric-car-market-california-alive/ https://electrek.co/2019/08/19/tesla-sales-electric-car-mark... [2] https://insideevs.com/news/357526/june-2019-plugin-sales-norway/ https://insideevs.com/news/357526/june-2019-plugin-sales-nor...
- rgbrenner 7y ago> Hard to imagine it takes 10 more years for the rest of the country to catch up to California. At that rate, California won't surpass 10% until the mid-2020s--maybe 2024/5. Remember, it's already 2019 and in a few months, it'll be 2020. Late-2020s is only a 3-4 years past the mid-2020s.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIs is reasonable to think the rate of change will increase?
- flyingfences 7y agoTo some extent, for some time. Consider the adoption bell curve; I think California has moved from the "innovators" stage to "early adopters" but the country as a whole has not. Consider also what the saturation point for electric cars will be in the near/medium term - I doubt that the other end of the bell curve is 100% adoption.
- 7y ago
- torginus 7y agoI'm afraid of the future with regards to electric cars. The simplicity and efficiency of current designs means that any further improvements in car quality are pretty unlikely, save for battery improvements. This suggests that electric cars of the future will be like the smartphones of today: containing largerly the same, or equivalent components with very little to differentiate between them, which means the competition largely boils down to price. And low prices can be only achieved through economies of scale, leading to a winner takes all situation.
- rmason 7y agoA major point of difference between car manufacturers will be software. Yes software will eat the car industry! Tesla and Silicon Valley have a huge advantage right now. But don't bet against Detroit, they will catch up because if they don't it's the ball game. Also I've been predicting for some time that there will be a renaissance in car manufacturing. There's already a company in Italy selling a 'sled' complete with batteries. You get six people in a garage in Detroit that are good with carbon fiber and they can become a car manufacturer. I bet there are lots of under served niches not being filed.
- hvidgaard 7y agoMy professional opinion is that Tesla seems to have an advantage because other manufactures do not invest in software properly. The moment one of the big manufactures embrace proper best practice software development and security (i.e. pay for it), that manufacture will gain a significant advantage.
- bluGill 7y agoCar manufactures have been doing ECUs for years. That is software that needs to work without bugs or it will destroy the engine. You never hear of bugs in them (it happens, but you don't hear of it) because they have figured out best practices that are unknown outside of cars and aviation. VW emissions was not a bug, it was intentional.
- edh649 7y agoThis is true of the powertrain for vehicles, however there are still many many other parts which go into a car. Most human jobs are in final assembly, needed here due to the tight spaces and complex customisations in each different vehicle, which will not change in electric vehicles. There are plants out there where the electric vehicle model is produced on the same body shop, paint, and final assembly lines. The same steps are taken just with different parts/different dimensions.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoExactly, the article falls into a common trap, assuming too much automation and job elimination due to tech. Looking at Tesla, they tried and failed to very heavily roboticize their factory, when in reality humans are fairly cheap for some manual tasks, and skilled laborers are becoming less frequent.
- magduf 7y agoThe only thing that happens in car factories is the engine is bolted into the car. Engines aren't made in those factories, they're made in separate factories. Changing to BEV cars just means you ship in an electric motor and battery and bolt those into the body instead of an ICE. The only significant difference is having to deal with safety concerning the higher voltage of a battery pack, but that's not very hard (and the battery probably isn't charged before assembly anyway).
- GarrisonPrime 7y agoGood point. But if autonomous vehicle fleets arrive I suspect that will no longer be as true. As more and more people decide to forgo owning a vehicle and just summon autos as needed, the market demand for a variety of different makes and models will decrease considerably. And autonomous fleets will likely want to standardize as much as possible, to make repairs simple and cheap. Ultimately only a fraction of designs may be needed of those on offer today, and the more standardized the options the more likely those will become automated.
- simon_000666 7y agoEverybodies super paranoid about job loss in auto manufacture. If we all move to electric cars, the charging infrastructure is going to need to be massive. In cities, we will need chargers by every parking space and in towns/villages every house will need its own charger. The building, installation, and maintenance will be far from trivial for all these chargers. Also, battery production, car battery refit, and recycling will become industries in themselves. I'm not convinced that people are thinking about all these feeder industries that will benefit from the adoption of electric vehicles. I don't think these jobs will go away, just mutate into something else.
- Merrill 7y agoTrue, but since this is a Detroit News story, the real question is whether these will be United Auto Workers union jobs?
- draw_down 7y agoRight, something tells me manufacturers won’t miss the opportunity to get rid of unions.
- ghobs91 7y agoSame goes for solar panel/roof installation, backup battery installation, burying power lines to improve storm resilience, etc. There's no shortage of infrastructure that needs to be built to modernize our system. Trying to artificially protect jobs in one industry while there's a huge labor shortage in much more productive things like infrastructure modernization or housing construction seems like the antithesis of an efficient market.
- mr_overalls 7y agoAgreed. In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, my family lived without electricity for two weeks. We depended on our gasoline-powered truck to procure food and water, transport an ailing grandmother for medical care, and generally survive. If we and others had depended on the existing electrical infrastructure to power our vehicles, we would have been completely screwed. A chaotic, uncomfortable situation would have become truly dangerous.
- PorterDuff 7y agoIt seems to me that any fundamental change in a product line will result in job loss at this point in time, this is on top of a fewer-parts-in-the-car issue. Cleansheet chances to redesign the supply chain and assembly system gives you the opportunity to modernize (ie. simplify and automate) while you're at it. It's also an excellent opportunity to out-source or in-source depending on the facts of the matter. 52 card pick up.
- auiya 7y agoI think it's still super premature to assume society will all just shift to EVs, considering the advances being made in zero emissions synthetic fuels, and the utter stagnation in advances for battery tech. Even Porsche who just released an amazing EV to much fanfare is investing heavily in this research, and should it be properly industrialized, it has potential to be highly disruptive to the EV market. All the infrastructure is already there, and altering an existing ICE to run on 100 octane-equivalent synthetic fuel is trivial. If you think big oil is just going to sit idly by and watch the entire transportation industry abandon them, you'd have to be quite naive.
- auiya 7y agoEVs are by no means a panacea, and synthetic fuels are an awesome maturing tech that can go a great deal further to reduce our green house gas emissions, while not requiring an entirely new supply chain infrastructure be built to accommodate. Even Bill Gates has thrown lots of money into Carbon Engineering in Canada to further develop synthetic, carbon neutral fuels. https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a15355097/audi-makes-synthetic-gasoline-using-zero-petroleum/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a15355097/audi-makes-synth... https://www.carmagazine.co.uk/car-news/tech/synfuel-synthetic-fuel-for-cars-and-how-it-works/ https://www.carmagazine.co.uk/car-news/tech/synfuel-syntheti...
- thegabriele 7y agoWhere i can find something about your statement "altering an existing ICE to run on 100 octane-equivalent synthetic fuel is trivial"? Also, is it fully true that the infrastructure is already here (ie, a gasoline pump could be converted to a synthetic one) ?
- woodandsteel 7y agoWhat the article gets right is that the ev revolution is, after decades of wishes and slow progress, finally taking off. It is also right about the great changes it will bring to the auto industry. What the article gets very wrong is the timeline. It says,"The Center for Automotive Research and other firms focusing on the impact of new technology on the auto industry don't expect electric vehicles to account for more than 10% of the sales market until the late 2020s" No, that's all wrong. The big shift is going to start to happen around 2023 when battery prices will fall low enough that ev's will start to have sticker price parity with ice's. Ev sales will explode, slowed down only by how fast production can be increased. By the end of the 2020's they will be over 50%.
- sunstone 7y agoThe shift to electric autos will reduce their cost a lot and also therefore the economic foot print of the auto industry. At the same time though, many other forms of transportation will become economic that were not economic in the past and this will create many new jobs. You can see this starting already with electric bikes but that's just the first obvious sector. It's difficult to say exactly how things will turn out in terms of total employment but the result will certainly be better than just assuming a decline in autos and no other innovations with the new technologies.