10 ms·
Like a lot of business methodologies, the principles are sound - but eventually they turn into cargo cults around a meta-process that only exists to feed itself
by legitster 7y ago
Like a lot of business methodologies, the principles are sound - but eventually they turn into cargo cults around a meta-process that only exists to feed itself.
The exact same thing is happening now with 'Agile' where big corporations are switching to sprints and hiring scrummasters, and renaming departments - mostly as a way to stay hip and cool. But at the end of the day, there is no business framework that will replace good judgement and discernment.
- ahsteele 7y agoYour thoughts on agile development are spot on. Eventually "agile" will become a bad word snickered at the same way waterfall is.
- colechristensen 7y agoAt least "waterfall" never existed, it was invented by people to describe something somebody else was doing. The design-build-test cycle necessary for physical products where the build and test phases can take days, weeks, or years was being used for software where build/test can take seconds or at most hours -- faster design cycles are beneficial and lots of folks used to engineering things got stuck with really long cycles. You don't need a management framework to accomplish those faster cycles.
- paulmd 7y agoIn most cases what you need is management permission to move quicker. Everyone says they want to be agile, but doesn't want to invest in the tooling (unit and integration tests, build servers, etc) that would let you be agile, so you end up with agile overlaid over the waterfall methodology, which does absolutely nothing.
- derekp7 7y agoFortunately with cloud and open source tooling, there isn't anything to buy. And management is already excited about cloud because they read it in CIO magazine and their buddies mention it on the golf course. The only thing needed is training on proper usage of the tooling. But that can come about organically when companies accidently hire a few competent engineers.
- ahi 7y agoThat's my organization. Most of the actual work doesn't go through either process because the engineers know if they start discussing things in the sprint planning a manager will pick it up for a multi-year "investigation".
- bmj 7y agoI would argue that management often doesn't truly understand "Agile" beyond "software engineers should operate this way." In my organization, the engineers are willing to be disciplined with Agile practices, but product management has no interest in real planning that would achieve a manageable backlog across releases. Instead, they change release scope numerous times, and nearly every release cycle runs long because we never finish what we start--by the final iteration we are working on entirely different stories than what we groomed in iteration #1. To them, "agile" means "do what we want whenever we want it."
- shandor 7y ago> "do what we want whenever we want it." Isn't that quite well in accordance of Agile Manifesto's "Responding to change over following a plan"? Sprints and backlogs and grooming, all those sound they're straight from the Scrum Book. And while I understand that for many Scrum == Agile, actually it's not. Note that I'm not saying anything about what's the best way to do software. Only that "responding to change" sounds very much agile.
- projektfu 7y agoThis sort of thing happens all the time. The Japanese-style quality movement had many different fads (for example 5S) but most of the top denizens said that there are some basic universal facts about quality but every organization has to develop their own system that works. Consultants can help you do that but you can't follow a textbook and make a company. By contrast, the American quality movement has always been filled with charlatans and fads like "Zero Defects". Do Americans want religion and not mastery? Who knows. I see Scrum a lot like I see Six Sigma. They take some of the processes you see from a successful team and they turn them into gospel for managing all teams. Sometimes they try to apply these processes to the rest of the company in places where they don't make sense. They create a bunch of certification levels so that they can claim you can't just learn it from a book. They make a bunch of money but leave their clients in a strange place.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> At least "waterfall" never existed The waterfall paper criticised a process that did exist and still does exist in some companies - it didn’t make it up.
- coldcode 7y agoBut people dragged the diagram out of the paper to create the idea that waterfall was a good thing. Boyce actually made fun of the idea.
- chrisseaton 7y agoYes I know - but the point is it did exist. What were they naming and making fun of if it didn't even exist?
- falcongod082 7y agoThat's what happens to everything that management gets their hands on. Agile is slightly different though, it was corrupted as a concept and commodified long before the big guys decided to embrace it.
- blfr 7y agoThis is the managerialist dream. To replace employees' judgement and competence with a process and management methodology. That way everyone is just a replaceable cog in their beautiful machine. It never works.
- bitL 7y agoOne could argue that mathematicians tried the same since Bourbaki? A set of mechanical rules in logic to describe everything...
- tacostakohashi 7y agoWhat is it about software development that keeps on attracting these "methodologies"? Why don't doctors or lawyers or commercial pilots have people coming along with a methodologies for doing their jobs? I have a few ideas, but I still feel like there's more to it than I quite understand.
- nullspace 7y agoCan't speak for lawyers or commercial pilots, but doctors absolutely have "methodologies" or processes. And processes that each individual hospital dept sets up last for years. They're usually different across depts and hospitals though.
- tonyarkles 7y agoOh man, our provincial health region recently went through a “Lean” transformation. Talking to people on the inside, it had some positive efficiencies come out of it, but it also resulted in some pretty terrible negative consequences. For example, medication shortages in rural areas, because they figured it would be better to send it to areas that needed it Just In Time. Except... some of those areas only get weekly deliveries, or worse. Similar story with diagnostic medicine. Smaller laboratories shut down because they were redundant, and then lead times for blood work etc go up because of travel time. We used to have a provincial bus/courier system in place, but the govt shut that down because it was losing money, and the health care system suffered for it. Last I heard, rush samples between major centres are currently being shipped by 3-hour taxi cab rides.
- colechristensen 7y agoThe cargo cult happens at small startups too. >meta-process that only exists to feed itself I like to think of it like an evolving idea passing through people. The methodologies evolve to take advantage of certain human characteristics which aren't always positive and often revolve around controlling others and perfectionist order. People get sucked in by the enticing promise of better but only if we change the process here and here which leads to an enormous amount of time talking about how you're going to talk about how you're going to do your work.
- Retric 7y agoSome processes also end up becoming the new norm. A few professional certifications went from being fads to mandated by law.
- Accujack 7y ago"professional engineer"
- hindsightbias 7y agoMy assumption today is that every Wharton, Haas and Harvard MBA comes with at least one semester of “Microservices will solve all your IT problems”
- falcongod082 7y agoThey are almost right, Microservices absolutely bring all of your IT problems to front and center.
- omarhaneef 7y agoOur sigmas go to 7!
- zhte415 7y agoAnd where do your sigma shifts go? 1.75?
- jedberg 7y ago> The exact same thing is happening now with 'Agile' I'd say that it started happening about 10 years ago. Even then companies were hiring for scrum masters and all that other crap.
- trentnix 7y agogood judgement and discernment Otherwise known as leadership. Certifications and systems and methodologies can make good leaders better, but I can't say I've seen an example where they've turned a non-leader into a leader.
- falcongod082 7y agoMaybe an example of good leadership, but not an example of leadership. You don't need to earn leadership these days, you can purchase it or be born into it, especially at a large corporation.
- falcongod082 7y agoYou're not abstracting far enough, "business" is the cargo cult. All the derivatives are simply expected.
- crispyambulance 7y agoThere's some really sound ideas in six-sigma as well as the other practices that evolved from manufacturing like Lean, Kanban, TQM, etc. These approaches work, for real. The problems start when they become excessively dogmatic, or as some say cargo-cultish. These systems are intended to help people solve problems in an orderly way, they're not a replacement for common-sense judgement, and original thinking (which, <gasp>, is STILL NEEDED). Sadly, the personality types that tend to go into supply-chain and manufacturing (and that's where I happen to work) tend to be frequented by rigid-thinkers who crave process and prescriptive "checklist" approaches. Whatever new thing these people take up, it's eventually ends up as a turgid mess of dogma.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoAs a mentor once told me --there's no protection from being a moron.
- JackPoach 7y agoRegarding 'agile' and 'kanban'. It really amazes me how many highly intelligent people truely believe that you can solve very complex problems by splitting them in subtasks or stages and simply dragging cards across the board. It's no more intelligent than believing in faith healing.
- hamilyon2 7y agoActually it amazes me how many highly intelligent people do not realize benefit of visualization every little detail of work being done (because planning is hard), checklists (because people forget), communication and shared vocabulary (because projects can be huge and involve a lot of people). Not to mention control of execution, because projects are late one day at a time.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoWhere I work, we are rigidly agile because the policies surrounding it are so strict there's no room to actually be ... agile.
- ubermonkey 7y agoThis is interesting to me, because I work in a "methodology" business -- except in our field, everyone understands that properly implementing Earned Value Analysis requires the combination of: - Good people, who know what they're doing; - Good processes, that support those people; - Good tools, which enable the processes There's been no effort (of which I'm aware, anyway) to turn this into a cargo cult. EVMS complex, and takes a lot of work to implement, but it has real & demonstrable benefits on large-scale projects. So it gets to stay a "real" thing and avoid the weird cargo-cult transformation that's plagued other ideas.
- soapboxrocket 7y agoThe goal is to make sure you are gone before the title roll back around to the original titles. I worked in a aerospace firm and the took all the R&T (Research and technology because development was done by production) titles and changed every single one with innovation. Then about 8 years later, they rolled all of them back, killed all innovation titles and put R&T back into the titles. Net result, not much as most of the same people were in the same positions.
- bitwize 7y agoI was frustrated at work about whether our "Agile" practices were really agile, and then the Rick Sanchez voice in my head spoke up: "Look, Morty, nobburpody gives a shit how 'agile' you are, or whether 'stories' actually meet the qualification for user stories, or whatever other horseshit you can think of. No one gives a shit about quality, either. All that really matters is that you make the ink on the bottom line black and make your boss look good. You could literally be shoveling out buggy shit with waterfall and no one will complain as long as you meet those criteria. Don't like it? Tough titty, motherfucker! Welcome to wage slavery! Now swallow your food pellet and get back to work, those giant capstans aren't going to turn themselves."
- mo1ok 7y agoA mantra sort of appeared in my mind watching agile fall apart and fail at a large fortune 50 company - "there is no replacement for leadership."