5 ms·
The real crimes are: 1 - non-mandatory labeling. What does a given port support? What about a given cable? 2 - the name "USB4 Gen 3×2". Honestly I have nev
by gumby 7y ago
The real crimes are:
1 - non-mandatory labeling. What does a given port support? What about a given cable?
2 - the name "USB4 Gen 3×2". Honestly I have never had the faintest idea what any of the various absurd names invented by the USB IF might mean. Superspeed? High speed? USB 3.1?
- adtac 7y agoSomeone for the love of god, please introduce the USB committee to the concept of semantic versioning. Stop this Gen madness.
- wtallis 7y agoSemantic versioning as it usually applies to software is a bit awkward for numbering the USB specs. The challenge is that USB has two largely orthogonal features that need to be described: link speed, and everything else that has been layered on top as the standard has evolved (power delivery, OTG, etc.) USB 1.1 supported low speed (1.5Mb/s) and full speed (12Mb/s). USB 2.0 added high speed (480Mb/s) but didn't make it mandatory; you can have a USB 2.0 compliant keyboard that only supports low-speed or full-speed operation. USB 3.0 did the same thing with the introduction of SuperSpeed (5Gb/s). What they should have done was keep making point releases on the 1.x, 2.x etc. specs when they added things like On The Go and Power Delivery, but keep the major version number representing the maximum supported link speed. By that scheme, we would have all 3.x devices capable of 5Gbps and no more, and what's now being introduced as USB4 would be more like USB 6.5 (if the minor version numbers were kept in sync across the speed grades). But this would deprive many companies of marketing opportunities, and instead force them to advertise USB 3.x support years after USB 4, 5 and 6 come into existence.
- jobigoud 7y agoThey had the right idea by using a different symbol set for protocol vs ports with USB A B C. Maybe they could use greek letters for speeds.
- ytch 7y agoThe "×2" label is really confusing. I am a little disappointed that they still use it after "USB 3.2 Gen 2x2". if a device/motherboard has 2 of such port, either "2 of USB 3.2 Gen 2x2" or "USB 3.2 Gen 2x2x2" will looks like a joke.
- javagram 7y agoThe ports are supposed to be labeled using friendly customer names like “SuperSpeed USB”. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_3.0#USB_3.2 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_3.0#USB_3.2 See “USB-IF recommended marketing name” * 5 Gbps transfer rate: “SuperSpeed USB” * 10 Gbps transfer rate: “SuperSpeed USB 10/Gbps” - applies to both Gen 2x1 and Gen 1x2. * 20 Gbps transfer rate: “SuperSpeed USB 20 Gbit/s”
- gumby 7y agoI think the quotation marks should go around the phrase "friendly customer names". I have never been able to differentiate between "Full speed", "high speed" and "super speed" though I guess they are each different from "low speed. Of course there are several speeds all labeled "SuperSpeed+"
- javagram 7y ago5Gbps, 10Gbps, and 20Gbps seem like pretty clear names to me.
- garaetjjte 7y agoAnd then you connect two devices labeled with "SuperSpeed USB 10 Gbps"... and it turns out that only 5 Gbps works, because one device was Gen2x1 and the other Gen1x2?
- candeira 7y agoThe name needs a 1 in it too. Maybe "USB4 Gen 3x2 1st Class", so people can answer "yes, I guess?" when you ask whether it's USB 1.
- makecheck 7y agoLately it seems like it would be most efficient to introduce the optional syntax from some modern languages. How about: "U?S?B?".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shawkinaw 7y agoContrast with the recent naming scheme change for Wi-Fi, which IMO went from overly technical and wonky to quite reasonable. Wi-Fi 5 is followed by, of all things, Wi-Fi 6!
- sixothree 7y agoBut how will I know if it's wifi 2x2 gen 2 superspeed?
- burnte 7y agoOh, it's very simple. USB 3.0 was renamed to 3.1, but that was confusing, conflicting with USB 3.1, so it was rerenamed to USB 3.2 Gen1, so that people understood that 3.0 was ACTUALLY the first generation of USB 3.2 But that caused problems with USB 3.1, which was faster than USB 3.2 Gen1, so it was renamed USB 3.2 Gen2, so that it crystal clear was faster than USB 3.0/3.1/3.2 Gen1. But that caused problems with USB 3.2, because 3.2 is just two lanes of USB 3.2 Gen2, so 3.2 was renamed to USB 3.2 Gen2x2 so people knew it was TWICE as good as USB 3.2 Gen2. The problem now is that USB4 eliminates all that clarity, so right now the big marketing push is to clarify it as USB 3.2^2 Gen1: The Reckoning. To resolve the conflicts of historical naming with USB 1 and 2, those will be renamed USB 3.2 Gen √0 and USB 3.2 Gen √-1/pi.
- pizzazzaro 7y agoThat's utter baffling madness! I wish that was some kind of joke instead of actually being a semi-serious explanation most of the way through.
- Dylan16807 7y agoYou got some of that mixed up. First there was USB 3.0. Technically the standard included older speeds, but people called the new one "3.0" and all was good. Then 3.1 came out. But what about the poor manufacturers with 3.0-speed ports? Well, someone decided they could call those ports "3.1 Gen 1". And it was all downhill from there. 3.1 Gen 1 became 3.2 Gen 1, and now becomes USB4 Gen 1. They added more "Gens", even ones where the word "generation" makes no sense. Now the number tells you nothing about speed, and there are two separate nomenclatures for speed that are both confusing. And I'm still not sure if they did or did not ever implement Gen 1x2... (It being USB4 instead of USB 4.0 is another stupid poke in the eye on top of everything else.)
- dbtx 7y ago> being USB4 instead of USB 4.0 is another stupid poke in the eye This. I wish to nominate the lot of it for BJAODN
- piotrkubisa 7y ago> 2 - the name "USB4 Gen 3×2". Honestly I have never had the faintest idea what any of the various absurd names invented by the USB IF might mean. Superspeed? High speed? USB 3.1? It's so fast, so consumers have enough time to spend additional 2 seconds to pronounce the whole "3x2", "Gen" or other marketing gibberish. Not saying about good connotations of SS abbreviation (as in superspeed logo) in Europe, especially in Poland. /s Jokes asides, but what is a reason of using 3.1 name for USB-C connector? It is very, very different how it looks, how it can transfer power than early rentangle-shaped connectors of 3.0's. And now again, USB-IF serves now the same drama again with ambiguous name. I'm glad I am techie guy, but I believe 80% people will end with question what they really need to connect device with their laptops. I wish we could completely drop "superspeed"/"gen 2" and use way simplified name. Such name should not follow the naming that WiFis has now, like WiFi 5 or WiFi 4, because even if we include identifier for people more interested in technical name (standard), like WiFi 5 (802.11ac), it still ends with situation you actually have portion of information, because 802.11ac operates on various powers and streams, i.e. WiFi 5 (802.11ac Wave2; 4 streams @ 1024-QAM), which is way different how it works than former example. However, I really like the quite recently introduced naming like: AC2600 or AC5300[0]. When I someone mentions "WiFi AC 2.6k", it tells me a lot more about given device for a techie person and consumer. Also, let's take a look like we query data from databases, the AC2600 could be an unique indexed column (even a primary key!), it falls below of group within defined standard, has various parameters etc. etc. On the contrary to WiFi, USB type is easily identifable by parameters like possible power delivery, data transfer and connector type (shape, size). Why USB-IF can't introduce similar naming that are clear for everyone to recognize? USB standards are not the same as an iPhone, they do not need any fancy name to be better than previous generation. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac // Actually, I really got used to 802.11a/b/g/ac naming when it , it has really rooted into my brain, so it's very hear from me speaking WiFi-5.
- piotrkubisa 7y agoEdit is not available now, so I have to reply to myself: // Actually, I really got used to 802.11a/b/g/ac naming (when those standarts had very distinct features), it really has rooted into my brain, so it's very hear from me speaking WiFi-5.