11 ms·
Fridge Condenser Fans – Old and New [video]
- leetrout 7y agoI thoroughly enjoyed that. We all have anecdata that “things aren’t made the way they used to be” but it’s rare to see something explained the way this was. A product of our race to the bottom.
- icegreentea2 7y agoI think the video makes a clear argument to the increase of number of severity of failure modes in the more modern part, I don't feel that it does a great job at a lot of things. So both designs likely have a life limiting factor of oil. It's clear that the older design will have a longer life before running into oil related issues. However, he still needs to modify (punching a hole in the housing) the motor to oil the unit. He makes no affordances to the modern unit for doing so. While it might be a pain to have to re-oil more frequently, it's still likely to be an action that occurs on a multi-year basis. At that point, the difference between re-oiling every other year, and every 10 years feels pretty academic. He discounts the ~6W of energy savings. It's true its not a lot - especially if you take the perspective of - 'let's try to save 6W of power from a 1970's fridge'. However, modern units consume the order of 200W, so an increase of 6W is a 3% increase in energy consumption. Maybe you can justify that for a single component, but how would you justify that across the board? Do wish they used better caps though.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's 3% difference in energy consumption, at a cost of replacing a fridge much earlier. Fridges being replaced more often means fridges being made in much larger quantity, which eats up all potential energy savings and then some.
- Spooky23 7y agoThe energy argument is valid, but I think the trade off is a result of poorly thought out regulation. For a water heater, there is an energy guide as well as a durability guide. The good/better/best ratings help the consumer make an appropriate decision. Energy star should be similar. I’m not interested in saving $4/yr in electricity if that means buying a new appliance in 4 years, but I have no way to evaluate the quality of the device.
- icegreentea2 7y agoThat's a reasonable wish. I imagine the usual thought is that warranty periods should provide a reasonable proxy for durability information, but I also understand that it's a pretty imperfect proxy.
- Spooky23 7y agoI'd argue that OEM extended service plans are the real proxy, at least for a service call. Look at Apple as an example, two years is the max service plan for an iOS device. That's the lifetime of a battery. For Dell/HP laptops, they will have 3 year warranties with up to 5 years of extended, but usually exclude the battery and often exclude the screen.
- djmips 7y agoI agree with all your points; it's what I was thinking along while watching the video. I also don't accept that hypothesis that in general newer designed motors fail earlier than older motors. I don't even accept it for being told that these two particular motors chosen at random. Will the newer motor in this video will fail before the older design in this video? Perhaps but I'd like to see some real evidence.
- daniel-cussen 7y ago> At that point, the difference between re-oiling every other year, and every 10 years feels pretty academic. You missed some stuff. It was one oil change for 50 years, not 10, and second, whereas the old fan would stall and heat, but not burn out, when it failed, the new fan would fail irreparably if oil ran out. And it would fail without warning. The type of failure mode is important here. And that's just if the oil runs out. Of course, being crap in an egalitarian way, it is designed so that the capacitor would fail, or the fuse would blow, or the IC's would short, or the windings would burn out, all at precisely the same time. It's mean-time-between-failure engineering.
- ProfessorLayton 7y agoI was recently in the market for a new refrigerator to replace a newish Samsung fridge where ice built up around the condenser fan, eventually causing it to freeze still, and spoiling all my food every ~3mos (Avoid Samsung appliances if you value your sanity) — It came with the house so no real cost on my part aside from the annoyance. Now I have a perfectly adequate Whirlpool fridge, but the condenser fan is obnoxiously loud. It seems to have one setting, off and turbo. I’ve resorted to taping acoustic pads to the back of the fridge — and no joke, some hardcover books backed up against the back of the freezer (They aren’t noticeable and don’t take up a significant amount of space). This helps a lot, but the thing is still louder than I’d like. I’ll probably leave this fridge with the house as well.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoI have the same damned Samsung fridge/freezer. It did the same freeze fan bullshit. Its also why I built my own IoT network, with Tor for network-to-network transport. It sent everything to a dashboard on my domain. https://hackaday.io/project/12985-multisite-homeofficehackerspace-automation https://hackaday.io/project/12985-multisite-homeofficehacker...
- MetallicCloud 7y agoI must have the same model Samsung fridge as you. Every 3 months or so I need to pull it apart and defrost the fan. It's super annoying and apparently very common in that model. I don't think I'll be buying Samsung again.
- ruffrey 7y agoI have a ~2014 GE Profile counter depth fridge that freezes every 3 months like clockwork. Incredibly annoying for a $3000 appliance. It should be illegal.
- userbinator 7y agoThat's the evaporator fan, and not all fridges have one. The condenser gets hot, not cold, and is outside the fridge. It almost always has a fan. The evaporator is inside, and the part that gets cold. Ice buildup may indicate a humidity problem.
- alliao 7y agoI have a whirlpool top loader laundry machine, just under 20yrs old, couple of months ago it failed, and the part is a plastic sacrificial part and it's obviously designed so it'd sacrifice itself to save the more expensive motor. I loved it, $5 part later (or $75 in New Zealand because New Zealand) it is back up and running again. I loved all the old American white-ware, they were built with respect to consumer nowadays not so much.
- grecy 7y agoMy family still uses the clothes dryer Mum and Dad bought 39 years ago.
- war1025 7y agoTwenty years ago I was entering 5th grade (damn, time flies). In my mind manufacturing quality hasn't changed significantly since then. Has it? I though that's when the offshoring of all manufacturing was already in full swing?
- alliao 7y agoI suspect being in New Zealand, this was older stock... I'll try and find manufacturing dates but I vividly remember at the time we had 2 choices, a more sensible sized one by Whirlpool that was already made in Korea, or the bigger one but still made in USA; needless to say we opted for the USA model. We actually had whirlpool fridge and washing machine in the late 70s and early 80s and was really impressed with them, hence why when we migrated to NZ we still seek out this brand. I still have a double door whirlpool fridge that's made in USA, just over 15yrs now too; though I can see it's going to leak some refrigerant soon with a copper rust spot on the line to an Embraco motor...sigh
- exhilaration 7y agoFYI - our dishwasher died and we called a local appliance repairman, unaffiliated with any manufacturer. He told us it couldn't be fixed and suggested we buy a Whirlpool to replace it. So that particular brand seems to command at least some respect.
- chomp 7y agoYes but refrigerators back then were around $2-3000 in modern currency (for a no frills ice box). You can get a cheap fridge now for like $90 (mini fridge). Much of our modern lifestyle was created by accessibility of home appliances like washing machines, refrigerators, and air conditioners, and that accessibility was driven by companies making things cheaper (but easier to break). You’re free to buy appliances like the stuff that used to exist. They are found in the commercial realm, and you’ll still be spending about $3000 for a no-frills entry level fridge.
- mauvehaus 7y agoI looked into commercial ranges, not because I actually intend to purchase one, but because I'd gotten spoiled cooking on one and got curious if it was even feasible to get one. For those of you who haven't cooked on one, one huge perk is that you can get a low simmer with the heat spread fully across the bottom of the pan, not just in the center. It turns out, however, that the standard depth for a commercial cooktop is quite a bit larger than the standard depth for a domestic one. Having worked (briefly, a long time ago) at a chain bakery, I vaguely recall the fridge being a very different size than a domestic one. Sure, you're free to get commercial gear, but you aren't just paying more for the appliances: you're going to be paying to renovate your kitchen to fit them.
- nkozyra 7y agoCompletely ignorant on this, but ... how does this differ from a decent home-grade gas range? Does it not depend heavily on the cooking vessel?
- S_A_P 7y agoCommercial ranges get hot. Fast. In a big surface area. My father in law was a higher up at a major food company that sounds like a major network equipment manufacturer. He put a commercial kitchen in our barn. It has roughly double the width and 30% deeper than a consumer cooktop. It has 6 eyes and will bring 3 gallons of water to a boil in less than 10 minutes. Preparing a meal in it cooks in a matter of minutes. We use16-20” skillets on it and there is no issue with hot spots. I don’t have the numbers but I wouldn’t doubt if it had triple the btus of even the best home model. The oven is gas and convection and cooks about 30% faster than a standard electric oven. The whole experience is just faster and larger scale. If you have the room and a father in law to pay for it I highly recommend buying one!
- whalesalad 7y agoThe noise that my brand spanking new high efficiency Samsung fridge makes is completely unbearable. It’s not the fan, but the compressor itself. I’ve tried coating the entire compressor compartment with dense material, like you would find in a nice car audio installation, to no avail. The fridge is in an alcove on top of a dense rubber mat, designed to absorb sound. There are foam acoustic pads on the wall behind the fridge. Doesn’t matter what I do, the damn thing is obnoxious. Worst part is... it’s well within “spec”. I had lots of ear problems as a kid culminating w/ surgery and ironically my hearing is hyper sensitive, as opposed to being worse off. My wife thinks I’m nuts to be so annoyed by the sound (she hears it, though) and technicians who come out say the same. Fuck I hate this fridge.
- newnewpdro 7y agoHave you considered coupling a chunk of dense material to the compressor? Something like a block of scrap iron hanging off the side of the compressor housing affixed with a tightly fitted robust hose clamp. I've seen numerous differential housings on automobiles over the years with such sinks hanging off their mounts to eliminate some harmonics or other harshness that would otherwise enter the cabin.
- esnible3 7y agoIs it possible to even find out the rated noise level before purchase? I feel like every 'fridge and air conditioner should print this up front with the capacity and voltage. Noise level is the main thing I look for in an appliance with a compressor.
- epistasis 7y agoFor heat pumps the noise rating is often published, and I would hope air conditioners are similar. Purchase of consumer products is so difficult, especially with the huge variety of model numbers. Though I'm fairly unsatisfied with the latest iteration of Apple laptops, I do appreciated the very limited number of models, which at least allows fuller evaluation.
- pas 7y ago
- csours 7y agoI think there are a few problems here: 1. Durability is hidden, cost and features are apparent. I can see on the box what features the OEM claims. I can see on the box what it costs. I cannot see the common failure modes on the box. 2. People want appliances that are durable and repairable, but often end up replacing them before end of life of the product, or destroy them some other way (cell phones). 3. Survive the warranty. Unless there is a resale market for the product, the only durability requirement is to survive the warranty. 4. Efficiency (on some metric). The linked video discounts the increased efficiency of the newer fixture, but that's not how product engineering works. If the product has a goal to be more efficient or lighter, then everyone has that goal. Lighter may mean less durable or less effective overall, but more portable or useful.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoRe 2. and 3., resale market is enabled by durability. If a product still has plenty of life in front of it but I want to get rid of it anyway (e.g. to buy a newer one), there's a good chance someone will be willing to buy it off me, whether to use it or to strip it for parts. Manufacturers don't make money off secondary sales of used products anyway, so the pressure to make products barely survive the warranty is always there.
- icegreentea2 7y agoThe question revolves around how do we ensure that companies that optimize to maximize long term customer value do not get undercut and out-competed by companies that optimize to maximize short term customer value. And it's a very challenging thing to do, since most human's natural instincts are to apply hyperbolic discounting models, while companies have to operating on... non-hyperbolic discounting.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoCreate incentives for (or simply mandate) longer warranty terms. In Germany, anything you buy has a 2-year seller's warranty, plus a presumption that any issues occurring within the first 6 months are a manufacturing defect unless the seller proves otherwise. Turning that into a 5-year warranty on large appliances would be relatively trivial and immediately provide an incentive to make long-lived products.
- kappi 7y agoanother interesting thing I found recently is that lot of water dispensers don't dispense chilled water, just room temperature water. They don't mention that.
- Nition 7y agoI have a totally unsubstantiated theory that a big chunk of the stress of modern life comes from this sort of thing. People own more appliances and gadgets than ever, but for each one you're expected to worry about planned obsolescence, often high maintenance, and treat them as fragile. A world where everything is always threatening to fall apart around us. Compare with life 100 years ago. It wasn't like this. The maintenance instructions alone are often ridiculous - you'd probably be spending 100% of your free time on maintenance alone if you followed what every manual actually recommends for everything in your home. And it's impossible to know what's actually important and what's just covering their ass legally. Like, my garage door manual says to wipe it down every two weeks - what? No-one's doing that. But the idea that you should be doing all this stuff still contributes to stress, even if you try to ignore and it just get on with life until your stuff finally breaks or explodes. Or things require more work due to fragility, like non-stick pans you can't scrub clean. Or things are just cheaper or fashionable but they don't work as well, like touch buttons instead of knobs on cooktops. Or things just get broken because they're made of cheap plastic. Warranties are a joke. Two years on a fridge? It should be 15. 10 years on aluminum window frames for your house? It should be 50. And the waste from all these obsoleted appliances is ridiculous on its own. There is a case for not overengineering things that users will want to throw away and replace anyway, but larger appliances rarely advance so far that you can't at least sell your old working one to someone (the most recent true obsolescence I can think of is CRT TVs). I'd vote for a law that says all major appliances must have a 10+ year warranty, with minimal maintenance performed. And maintenance recommendations should be displayed alongside the product.
- jjoonathan 7y agoThe latest trend I've observed is straight up not honoring the warranty. In the span of 2 years, I had a $300 fitbit, a $700 acer monitor, and a $300 TCL TV fail, all within their warranty period. All three companies flaked, all with a dubious excuse, correctly gambling that I wouldn't care enough to take matters to small claims.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- spectramax 7y agoWe need to do something about this. If I buy a washing machine, I have NO idea how much cost cutting has gotten into it - in fact, companies spend way too much money in marketing, shiny stickers, features and IoT bullshit than things like oil bushings that this video is talking about. We need a review website that hires these experts that take things apart, and expose the shitty practices and cost cutting that has taken place so that the consumers are more informed. Kind of like a more formal version of AvE (Youtube fame). And that kind of review methodology needs to get so popular that no manufacturer can escape it. What's capitalism when every one is cheating, lying and depending on the ROI of their marketing budget? Competition disappears, innovation stops and shiny things propel. If you go and buy an dishwasher from Miele, you bet your bottom dollar they are not gonna cut corners like this - because industrial grade equipment needs to last and live up to the daily abuse or its credibility is lost. In consumer market, there is way too much marketing noise than objectivity. Watching this video makes me livid and angry.
- jklehm 7y agoI think you have your answer already. If you want reliability you pay for it by buying the commercial/industrial version that commits to specs upfront and outlines the cost of maintenance for the life cycle of the device. Not saying what the consumer focused side of these businesses is doing is right but there is a work around with defined costs out there.
- maratd 7y ago> If you want reliability you pay for it by buying the commercial/industrial version It is frequently very difficult to find the commercial/industrial version, even when you're in the know and actually want it. I'm typing this on a "Pro" laptop. Marketing sticks "commercial grade" on pretty much everything. You have to know which brands service commercial and what their commercial lines are. That's not information that's always easy to find.
- jklehm 7y agoAgreed! Documented specs for any every manufactured good would be amazing.
- markbnj 7y agoAbout 10 years ago my parents gave us a Sears horizontal freezer they'd had in their garage, and had no further use for. It's now around 55 years old and still running with all the original parts. I don't know what the thing would cost in current dollars if built today to the same standards. I don't even know if you could build it today to those standards, or that it would make sense for anyone to pay for a freezer that will last a half-century. But I would like to think so.
- chrismorgan 7y agoHave you compared its power efficiency with equivalent recent hardware? Watts turn into dollars quickly—even as little as 1 W more all the time is 8.76 kW over the course of a year, which, picking an arbitrary electricity price of 20¢/kW, is $1.75 a year.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoWhat is the cost of decommissioning soon-to-die hardware like this? Right now companies arent required cradle to grave handling, so quick disposal is prioritized. There is no such thing as away, so watch what we put there.
- Paperweight 7y agoThat's a really good point. Companies being required to buy back their products when they die should align the incentives to solve the problem, which is essentially one of unhandled economic externalities. Has anything changed in Europe since these kinds of laws have been put in place? In Canada, we have a fixed environmental disposal fee slapped on certain classes of electronic products. I wonder if that fee actually makes the problem worse because it makes high-durability manufacturers subsidize their planned-obsolescence competition!
- cr0sh 7y agoOne big concern would be freon recovery, for old refrigerator, freezer, and HVAC systems.
- swills 7y agoI would love to see how the fan in a Miele or similar brand compared.
- 01100011 7y agoBased on my recent experience of removing the beater bar on my Miele vacuum, I'd bet that Miele is not substantially better. I had pretty good feelings about my German engineered, $600 vacuum until I saw the insides. Lots of cheap plastic waiting to break, and it was much less serviceable than I expected. My dad used to work for a janitorial supplies distributor and I occasionally got my hands on commercial vacs. Those were generally built like tanks. Don't get me wrong, I like other features of my vac, like the HEPA bags with the flap that closes when they're removed, but I don't think of Miele in the same way now.
- whenchamenia 7y agoI'd suggest an ancient Kirby, or if you have some extra funds, a new one. I love ours, and it is bomb-proof, if a bit heavy.
- Tepix 7y agoSmall differences can make a huge difference. Like a bit of plastik that's 1mm thicker in important spots. Or picking electrolytic capacitors with extended lifetime.
- aeyes 7y agoThey don't have a condenser fan, the whole back of the refrigerator is covered by passive heat exchange tubing.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIt’s the same for our AEG fridge/freezer.
- JackFr 7y agoA few years ago my children's hamster escaped. We couldn't find him for days. I figured he had made it outside somehow cause we didn't see him or hear him or see any droppings. After about 4 days though, there was an off smell in the kitchen. We tore everything apart, emptied every cabinet, pulled the stove out from the wall, moved the refrigerator, etc. and still could not find him (or any evidence of him.) We scrub everything and out it all back. But the next day, smell is still there. Then it occurs to me that the refrigerator back panel has holes to vent the fan. I shine a flashlight and see some fur. Bingo. I take the back off the fridge, but I still can't reach him. At this point its not clear to me what's killed him. I get some tongs to grab him but I see he's stuck. I wiggle his body free and pull him out, and immediately the fan starts arts spinning full speed and I nearly retch. The point of the story is 1) R.I.P. Jordan the hamster, and 2) The condenser fan was basically held in place for 4 days without burning out - very impressive as far as I'm concerned. (This was a very old refrigerator BTW)
- userbinator 7y agoThe condenser fan was basically held in place for 4 days without burning out As the video mentions, this is a deliberate design decision for safety and robustness --- the motor is designed to survive being stalled indefinitely without damage. It's known as "impedance protected", because the impedance of the winding is such that it will never draw enough power to burn itself out. The downside is low starting torque, which is why they're only used for things like fans. (I was referring to the older shaded-pole motor; the newer one might blow the fuse instead, which is still OK from the safety standpoint but definitely not robustness.)
- jpollock 7y agoThe engineers who design fridges aren't evil. They do things for a reason. So, we're left with questions. Questions: 1) what is the cost difference between the two fans? 2) what is the average first-owner lifespan of a fridge? 3) how long will the fan outlive the fridge in the first-owners house? 4) how big a supply is there of the new fan? Is it in use on more appliances? 5) does a 60% reduction in power draw result in a fan with a longer lifespan? 6) is resale something people care about, or are appliances fashion?
- mrguyorama 7y agoHow much does the fan cost to buy second hand or from the manufacturer to replace? It looks like it's a few screws and a single plug and you can have your fridge run for another 5-10 years
- pontifier 7y agoWe're in the uncanny valley of manufacturing now. In not too many years you'll be able to download a schematic of that old motor, and have one made for you on your desktop.
- dehrmann 7y agoFor anything more than a solid plastic or metal part, I doubt it. There's too many materials, the precision needed is too great, and mass production almost has to be cheaper.
- otakucode 7y agoThere would definitely be a market for 'open source appliances' I believe. Appliances built to last, based on modular design, and with full documentation available along with plenty of hooks included to permit third party creation of modifications and enhancements. Basically, applications as a sort of durable platform. Want to be able to connect your oven via wifi and see an image of what's cooking or get a food of its current temperature? That sort of thing could be added a little addon card or module, etc. Of course, most businesspeople would look at that and say 'sure, even if you come to dominate the market, what THEN?' and not like the lack of a built-in way to force people to buy new product. But eventually you would expect there to be one person who would be satisfied with making a few hundred million dollars over a decade even if that shrinks later on.
- paule89 7y agoI hate planned obsolescence. Period.
- bsaul 7y agoIt's weird that repairability (either right to repair, or simply technical feasibility) has been a huge topic for at least 10 years in cars, mobile phones, home appliances, etc. And yet i haven't seen any end-user product really advertising it. Worse, the trend seems to be even more toward cheap black boxes that you'll change entirely whenever they break. As another example of things going the wrong direction: a few months ago i saw a video about a Tesla test, and the car's engine refused to start. The owner had to turn it off and on again so that they could start the engine and begin the test. As a software engineer, that made me feel so bad... Is there any solution toward better quality products, aka : having the benefits of cheap electronics and advanced functionalities, but with the longevity and ability to repare and customize of the old mechanical technology ? Is it a business model problem ? a technical one ? a supply chain / pricing one ? marketing ? I keep wondering.
- Tepix 7y agoApple is super successful with un-repairable products. With the latest iPhones they try to prevent you from going to a non-authorized repair service to exchange the battery, a part that is known to deteriorate after two years leading to decreased performance. Maybe people do not care because smartphones have been rapidly improving in the past. On the other hand when considering household appliances, Miele is able to fetch premium prices due to their perceived longevity.
- kube-system 7y ago> It's weird that repairability (either right to repair, or simply technical feasibility) has been a huge topic for at least 10 years in cars, mobile phones, home appliances, etc. And yet i haven't seen any end-user product really advertising it. 99% of people don’t want to repair their appliances. They either “don’t want it to break”, or want it to be repaired by someone else. A product labeled “commercial grade! 10 year warranty!” will always massively outsell a product labeled “user serviceable! Schematics included!”
- leonroy 7y agoI purchased a commercial freezer for our home basement. We feed our dog raw and a shelf fully loaded with frozen cubes of meat can weigh a considerable amount. I was skeptical that a consumer grade plastic freezer could hold the weight so I picked up a Williams A400 Commercial Freezer: https://www.williams-refrigeration.co.uk/products/cabinets/amber/A400 https://www.williams-refrigeration.co.uk/products/cabinets/a... About £1800 retail, fortunately I found one on eBay for considerably less. Firstly the thing weighs a tonne, it’s noisy, and it also requires a large ventilated space all around otherwise its efficiency drops through the floor. We ended up having to point a pedestal fan at the rear of the unit to keep the compressor and radiator cool. Service costs were high at £90 just to have someone look at it and replacement parts a minimum of £120. So whilst it can be serviced it isn’t cheap. It also ate 4-5x as much electricity as a consumer freezer of similar size. What you get when buying a commercial freezer or appliance is a device that can take a beating and can be serviced. They cost nearly an order of magnitude more over the course of their lifetime vs their domestic counterparts. So yeah they’re well made but at a very high price.
- adrianN 7y agoI wouldn't consider a freezer that consumes several times the energy to be well-made.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoDifferent design goals. A commercial freezer is designed to be able to freeze a larger volume / weight of goods more rapidly, with the doors being opened more frequently. So they'll necessarily have a larger cooling capacity, which means a higher capacity compressor, fan, and heat exchanger. I think the parent commenter would have been better off with a regular chest freezer of an appropriate size.