7 ms·
Google begins penalising domain leasing
- bencollier49 7y agoHow would Google differentiate between a subdomain or folder that I use on my website for a different purpose, and a leased subdomain? Given that they're describing this as "penalisation", and not just "treating the subpart as its own entity"?
- turc1656 7y agoIt's possible that the description Google used is a bit misleading. Meaning that they might actually be doing what you said - splitting out the subdomains as their own entities and the natural effect of this is to have a separate ranking, thus looking like they got penalized for using the subdomain but really they were just reclassified.
- pizzapill 7y agoI've had a small stint into SEO in 2012 and Im pretty sure that Google treated Subdomains as their own entity back then. I would be suprised if this changed in the meantime.
- turc1656 7y agoIf it was completely decoupled back in 2012 then there wouldn't be any advantage to leasing the subdomains or Google being peeved by it enough to take action. I suspect what is more likely is that the subdomains were separate but not completely unrelated/correlated to the primary domain. Google likely assigned a certain amount of value to the mere fact that it came from the core domain. I think that is what changed here.
- luckylion 7y agoSince this also affects leased directories, not just subdomains, there's probably more to it. Afaik, "normal" subdomains haven't been affected the same, only those that were leased out.
- Implicated 7y agoI spent a lot of time in the blackhat SEO world prior to 2014 or so... I can assure you that subdomains reaped a bountiful reward from their association to the main domain. They certainly weren't equal but they got more than a little (trust/authority/ranking - call it whatever you want) help from their parent domain. To the point that this was the case: If I bought a brand new, never used .com and built 500 pages of spammy content and linked those pages/content from thousands of other super spammy pages... that domain is de-indexed within 2 weeks and the pages never really ranked/got organic traffic worth the cost of the domain name. If I built those same pages on a subdomain and linked them in the exact same manner but the parent domain was very strong - the pages would rank and traffic would flow steadily, indefinitely. (As long as the parent domains footprint/linking was large enough to absorb whatever penalty that my spammy pages brought). It's still happening today where people buy up domains that are established with good link profiles - go to archive.org and download the sites old content, re-host it and keep it alive. Then they build spammy subdomains on the parent domain - profit.
- pizzapill 7y agoI've read that in multiple docs back then but since you observed this it could've been false. The rationale I had for it was that there are many sites with completely independent subdomains or technical resources like asset being served by subdomains. Buying established Domains and scraping old content does not rely on Subdomains. Affiliate, ads or your own product can be placed on the TLD. I dont doubt you tough and I think I will try it sometimes. Old school fun
- thefj 7y agoSeems like the misleading description is from the article, not Google. After following the links I got to this tweet that agrees with your theory. They're trying to detect if the subdomaon content is independent of the main site. https://mobile.twitter.com/googlewmc/status/1161725709926182912 https://mobile.twitter.com/googlewmc/status/1161725709926182...
- celeritascelery 7y agoMaybe I just don’t understand the issue here. What is wrong with sub domain leasing?
- bencollier49 7y agoI assume that previously, Google's ranking algorithm would attach a score to a domain name, and by leasing out subsections of the site, the sub-owner would get an artificial ranking boost. So now perhaps the Googlebot notices if a subsection of a site is radically disconnected and treats it as an independent publication.
- criddell 7y agoThat's not really a penalty then.
- dazc 7y agoIt's a manipulation of search results.
- chatmasta 7y agoI'm confused. Does this affect the ranking of sites like alice.github.io or bob.netlify.com? Does it penalize github.io and netlify.com? Both?
- pluma 7y agoI think github.io is explicitly registered as a shared second level domain (similar to co.uk), which also ensures browsers don't allow cookies spanning multiple subdomains.
- chatmasta 7y agoRegistered with whom? How does one register their website like that?
- jsty 7y agoSomeone might want to correct me on this, but I believe most use the public suffix list: https://publicsuffix.org/ https://publicsuffix.org/
- jwatt 7y agohttps://publicsuffix.org/submit/ https://publicsuffix.org/submit/ is one place.
- tialaramex 7y agoThe Public Suffix List. There are two halves to the list. The first ("ICANN") half are suffixes that work like a TLD from the perspective of the DNS registry. Nominet handles registration in .co.uk or .org.uk or .net.uk the same way another country might choose to handle their whole TLD. The rest is names whose registered owners do the same thing as a registry for the public or some subset of them, like Blogger or a cheap bulk hosting site where you don't pay for a name. PSL listing has a variety of effects. Don't do it hoping to achieve one of them and then being disappointed by the others. Do it because you have a real public suffix. For example many browsers won't let Cookies escape a suffix, so company A.some.example and companyB.some.example can't share cookies if some.example is on the PSL. Let's Encrypt name quotas care about the PSL so companyA.some.example certs wouldn't share quota with companyB.some.example. DMARC won't work on a public suffix, but HSTS preloading does.
- ohashi 7y agoNow could they penalize all the paid links that are 'sponsors'? Apache Foundation and many others are even in on it. They specifically say they are selling a do-follow link. Look at the companies at the bottom buying them: https://www.apache.org/foundation/thanks.html https://www.apache.org/foundation/thanks.html LeoVegas Indian Online Casino Online Holland Casino Start a Blog by Ryan Robinson The Best VPN Top10VPN PureVPN HostChecka.com HostingAdvice.com Web Hosting Secret Revealed It's just paid links. Apache isn't the only one doing it, a lot are. I'm glad they are getting money, but it's paid links pretty openly on super highly ranked pages.
- 2_listerine_pls 7y agoWhat do you mean by paid links?
- dstick 7y agoCompany X that wants to rank high for a keyword pays Company Y with a highly trusted website (in the above example, Apache) to place a link to their website with a variation of the keyword as the anchor text. They pay for the link, Google's algorithm boosts their position in the search results for the targeted keyword.
- iampims 7y agoNot too dissimilar from google’s business model…
- dazc 7y agoIn the UK, there are thousands of local sports clubs that have links to their sponsors. You can buy these links for small sums of money. This is the same as your apache example in theory but the intention is different, it's a clear attempt to manipulate rankings while the apache links are just a side benefit. I doubt microsoft and such would care either way?
- ohashi 7y ago
- AlexMuir 7y agoI'm often searching information on auto parts and Google's results are quite literally 100% webspam. Here's an example - The entire first page is the same provider squatting domains: https://www.google.com/search?q=scrambler+50cc+parts+format%3Apdf&oq=scrambler+50cc+parts+format%3Apdf https://www.google.com/search?q=scrambler+50cc+parts+format%... Wiring diagrams in Google images - literally every result is webspam in the same format split across squatted domains. https://www.google.com/search?q=mazda+miata+wiring+diagram+stereo+pin&tbm=isch&source=univ&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjrgYyl8KrkAhVso4sKHXwfBtUQsAR6BAgJEAE&biw=1440&bih=728 https://www.google.com/search?q=mazda+miata+wiring+diagram+s... These aren't even particularly niche searches, nor is it hard to detect that all these sites are the same.
- gregschlom 7y agoCurious what did you expect of a query such as "scrambler 50cc parts format:pdf"? Why the PDF filter? You expect that some companies are publishing a parts catalog in PDF format? The query just seems odds to me, and so the garbage results don't seem too surprising
- aspaceman 7y agoActually about 2 years ago this is precisely the query I would have chosen too. You could always find a parts catalog, service manual, that sort of thing scanned and posted online. PDF (used to) select for the scanned documents. Used to be my main usage of google was finding service manuals for auto and electronics. Nowadays the spam just pretends to be a pdf cause we used to always search for them.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> You expect that some companies are publishing a parts catalog in PDF format? Don't them all? Once you get to niche products, there are even web stores out there that only list their parts in PDF.
- ska 7y ago> You expect that some companies are publishing a parts catalog in PDF format? It's really common in some areas. This at least used to be a very effective search pattern.
- Animats 7y agoDoes this include sites hosted on Google Drive, Google Spreadsheets (yes, you can host a site on Google Spreadsheets, by putting HTML in a cell), Google Docs, etc.?
- ehsankia 7y agoBut are those spreadsheets/docs indexed by and show up on search results?
- luckylion 7y agoYeah. site:docs.google.com finds approximately 4m results.
- ehsankia 7y agoI see, but I assume Google has custom ranking since I never see them show up in any search result, they clearly aren't getting Google.com's rank score.
- luckylion 7y agoAbsolutely. Subdomains may get some extra credit, but they still need incoming links. "Leased" subdomains and directories don't come naked, they usually get lots of links from the main site, often site-wide in header/navigation, sidebar or footer. Since the publishers get paid for leasing out the subdomain and linking to it, you could argue that they are essentially selling links. That's apparently not what Google is saying though, because they'd penalize the sites selling the links, too, and only the leased out subdomains/directories have been affected, the rest of the sites are still ranking as they always did.
- OrgNet 7y agoOnly 329 results for me. Google is always "over-estimating" result count estimates (it does say there is about 4m results, at first)...
- unreal37 7y agoThere is some significant disagreement that Google is in fact doing anything here. There's somebody who wants them to do something, but Google themselves seem to say subdomain leasing is OK. [1] [1] https://medium.com/@loish/a-response-to-danny-sullivan-and-google-about-white-label-sites-in-the-search-results-25d0dc2931f8 https://medium.com/@loish/a-response-to-danny-sullivan-and-g...
- buboard 7y ago“Google fixes problem it created itself”
- chiefalchemist 7y agoPenalise is the wrong concept here. What The Google is doing is getting smarter and that intelligence is being applied. Call it a correction if you need a name for it. Long to short, Google just wants to be human [1], but it wants to do that automatically and at scale. It seeks to reflect what a human would approve or reject. If you look at the history of SEO / the search algorithm this is the nature of the progression. Obviously. These sites aren't being penalized. Hiding in a blindspot and being discovered is not a penalty. It's simply reality; a reckogning; a day that only the naive would believe was not coming. [1] Actually, Google wants to be you. The attempt to personaling search is Google wanting to recommend to you if you could recommend to you.