3 ms·
The important part about implementing something like the great firewall, or how Iran runs the Internet (All ISPs need to be downstream of the government-run ASN
by walrus01 7y ago
The important part about implementing something like the great firewall, or how Iran runs the Internet (All ISPs need to be downstream of the government-run ASN), is that you need cooperation from the people with network engineering talent.
If all of them refuse to help implement your new internet censorship regime, it's a problem for any authoritarian government, just as much as if your police force stops following orders. You can start firing people and hiring replacements who will toe the line, but at a certain point you're going to end up with second and third rate talent, and correspondingly shoddy ISPs.
Talented network engineers such as those who have the equivalent of 'enable' on the twenty largest ISPs in HK can choose to go elsewhere and work in free countries. There's sufficient demand for their skills that refusing en masse to cooperate is not an incredible risk for them.
I work in the field and try to teach junior NOC people that there is such a thing as ethics in network engineering. Just as there is in any other professional field where people rely upon critical systems. This means, among other things, don't try to MITM your customers' traffic (Kazakhstan, recent incident comes to mind), don't get into intrusive DPI, don't fuck with neutrality of content, and absolutely never cooperate with anything that slightly resembles the great firewall. The combination of modern technology/human tracking systems plus full autocratic state control of ISPs could result in something that would be the wet dream of east germany's Stasi.
- whatshisface 7y agoChina doesn't need Hong Kong network talent, they have plenty of Chinese network talent. The same people who built the system to oppress their contrymen can build it to oppress semi-foreigners.
- walrus01 7y agoThat is probably true, if they accelerate a full political takeover and removal of HK autonomy. If HK autonomy is gone, all bets are off. At least the HK network engineers don't have to be complicit in it. Come to Canada and build something as awesome as PCCW [1]. [1]: https://www.peeringdb.com/net/1451 https://www.peeringdb.com/net/1451
- just_steve_h 7y agoI'm grateful for walrus's comment. And yet I feel they are in the minority. We are long past time for real professional ethics in our professions. If we are so bold as to claim the title "engineer," where are our obligatory professional standards? Our licensure? Our - gasp - liability? If a structural engineer designs a bridge in a way that ignores established best practices, and the bridge fails and causes injuries, the engineer is held responsible. Why are our professions different?
- walrus01 7y agoI am far from a professional coder - but I am pleased to see that a growing number of English language universities which offer 4-year bachelors of computer science degrees are making an ethics course a mandatory requirement for graduation. The principle is the same: If your job functions at layers 4-7 in the OSI model, don't create software that does something terrible with personal data for financial gain, and if your job concerns OSI layers 1-3, don't fuck with the Internet. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/01/harvard-works-to-embed-ethics-in-computer-science-curriculum/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/01/harvard-works... https://www.cbc.ca/radio/spark/the-spark-guide-to-life-episode-five-ethics-1.5191015/why-computer-science-students-are-demanding-more-ethics-classes-1.4812742 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/spark/the-spark-guide-to-life-episo...
- asfarley 7y agoIn my experience, people committing ethics violations would not have been stopped by taking an ethics course... it's not an information problem
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoYou’d be surprised how many idiots/uninformed people are out there that really didn’t know X was wrong when it was obvious to most of us. But an ethics course is mostly CYA for the company.
- Aeolun 7y agoIf a professional Engineer designs a wall. Lets say, a huge land wall across the border of a country. Do we say that engineer is unethical, and that he should never have participated?
- matz1 7y agoIt's hard to believe that they can't find highly qualified professional who willing to help. The thing with ethics is everyone has ethics, its just their ethics might be different than yours. Given the right pay/benefit I'm happy to work on those
- topkai22 7y agoI don't think a code of ethics would stop this behavior, at least if derived from the existing rules governing PE societies. The relevant ethical rule that for the (US) National society of Professional Engineering is "Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public." As much as I despise the great firewall and the associated surveillance state, reasonable people can conclude that such measures are in fact in support of "safety, health, and welfare of the public." Ethics in this area are not as concrete as say physical construction, where punishments for a flawed building design or implementation date at least to the code of Hammurabi and seems fairly consistent across cultures. Norms and ethics around surveillance and the role of the state are far less universal. An ethics review board from mainland China could come the conclusion that not creating or implementing these features would be unethical. I do think that engineers should do exactly as you recommend, but I also doubt that our shared sense of ethics are universal enough to get the outcomes we want.
- inimino 7y ago> If all of them refuse to help implement your new internet censorship regime Then you fire all of them and hire new ones with different values. The reason it's a problem if your police force stops following orders is the same as if the military stops taking orders: there's a command and control structure that can operate autonomously and topple your government. It's a little bit unrealistic to think of all the network engineers in HK somehow overturning government policy by refusing to act. They have no collective power because they have no collective structure outside of the companies they work for. The most they can do is sabotage or blow the whistle, and ultimately if there is no political will to go against the status quo then all this will eventually prove futile anyway. I hope you teach them also that there's no avoiding politics, and there's no avoiding ethical responsibility for doing nothing even when nothing you can do seems to have a chance.