5 ms·
How many deaths from diarrheal diseases or pneumonia could be prevented with, say $4 Billion dollars? Well, the people of Palo Alto, after a few tragic suicide
by fortran77 7y ago
How many deaths from diarrheal diseases or pneumonia could be prevented with, say $4 Billion dollars?
Well, the people of Palo Alto, after a few tragic suicides-by-train, want the people of California to pay tens of billions of dollars to put Caltrain underground through their town. (The number of deaths of children in Palo Alto from the train pales in comparison to the number of deaths to children from gunshot wounds on the other side of 101 and across the bay....)
https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2019/04/25/popular-but-expensive-train-tunnel-proposal-splits-palo-alto-council https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2019/04/25/popular-but-e...
- squirrelicus 7y ago1) https://launiusr.wordpress.com/2012/02/08/why-explore-space-a-1970-letter-to-a-nun-in-africa/ https://launiusr.wordpress.com/2012/02/08/why-explore-space-... 2) the diarrheal diseases generally don't need much money at all. 16oz water, fist of salt, three finger pinch of sugar. Unfortunately, the adults in charge of those children tend to remain ignorant even after the Western doctors tell them about the cure. So money won't do anything for that. You can't force a Madagascan to stop dancing with family corpses, ya know.
- jdietrich 7y ago>So money won't do anything for that. You can't force a Madagascan to stop dancing with corpses, but you can persuade them that it's uncouth and old-fashioned using perfectly ordinary marketing techniques. The norms of a society can be changed with remarkable speed if you write a big cheque to people who change social norms for a living.
- nostrademons 7y agoDoes this actually work cross-culturally? My understanding of advertising is that it relies very heavily on building associations between the product being advertised and existing positive social norms. The reason truck commercials in the U.S. always feature scruffy broad-chested men driving shiny vehicles across wide-open rugged terrain is because in the U.S. we have this cultural mythology about the frontier and conquering nature and we associate manliness with this (and with facial hair, muscles, etc.). And this works because there's already a shared cultural norm that's been built up over centuries, which most of the people who develop advertisements are familiar with and can mine for ideas. When I visit my in-laws in Taiwan, the advertisements look very different (although somehow the skinny-but-buxom-blonde has made its way over there too, despite representing basically 0% of the female population). In a past life, my primary job was getting people to click on search results faster, and my secondary job was making sure Google stayed in the press for positive reasons. A lot of this was data-driven, but when it came to adapting changes to individual countries, we'd always defer to the local teams. Google.kr looks different from Google.ru, both of which look different from Google.com, and in many cases these differences were simply because a competitor had gotten to the local country first and that's what the population had become accustomed to.
- jdietrich 7y ago> Does this actually work cross-culturally? With a degree of care, yes. Major marketing and advertising agencies are perfectly au fait with these challenges, because they're responsible for multinational brands. A company like Coca-Cola or Procter & Gamble is very used to selling products to consumers in radically different cultural contexts, as are the agencies they employ. Marketing within the US is meaningfully cross-cultural - the connotations that sell a Ford F150 will fail hopelessly if you apply them to a Toyota Prius. There are very few brands and messages that will work in every cultural context, which is why marketers are acutely aware of the importance of segmentation. Just telling people to change their behaviour is rarely successful; you need to surmount some very complex cognitive, emotional and social obstacles to change. The marketing industry has an extremely deep, sophisticated and powerful set of tools and skills in this respect. They spend all day, every day thinking about how to facilitate behavioural change. We're used to thinking of that practice as essentially amoral or evil - they persuade us to max out our credit cards, they convince us that smoking is cool, they peddle junk food - but the same skills could be used for good if only the right people decided to hire them.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThat sounds a bit like marketing for marketing. I do think marketing agencies actually did loose a lot of influence in recent years. 15 years ago nearly everyone could hum the latest jingle from the newest ads and influence was indeed profound. But these times are long gone. Today there are many channels for cutural exchange that don't transport marketing messages.
- chrisweekly 7y ago15 years ago, western culture was substantially more monolithic, with much more centralized distribution channels, in comparison to the increasingly balkanized and fragmented niches that abound today.
- amelius 7y agomarketing -> education
- redis_mlc 7y ago- Palo Alto homeowners mistakenly believed for years that the new HSR would be buried so that the noise wouldn't affect their property values. It's a kind of mass delusion thing, since you're looking at $2 billion/mile or so - Mountain View, an adjacent city, just went througn the same calculus wrt tunneling and found it just as breathtakingly unaffordable - Atherton was mentioned in the article or comments, which is hilarious. They have a city lawyer who's mandate is to not change a single thing. - When I say "city", I mean approx. population 40,000. So they don't have billions to throw around, although the York family did help Santa Clara City (pop. 10,000) spend $1.2 billion for their football stadium. :)
- nostrademons 7y agoNit: Santa Clara City has a population of 116,000.
- fortran77 7y agoThe $4 Billion figure was the cost to Palo Alto, that they thought they could make up with increased "property values" and taxes. They expected the People of California to pay another $20 Billion or so to complete the work. All for their precious snowflakes and property values.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThe tunnel isn't to prevent suicides. It's to enable running six trains per hour. With the tracks at street grade as they are now, this causes traffic issues and increases the risk of train and car collision, which cause massive delays.
- xyzzyz 7y agoYou can run trains on a viaduct above intersection, or the other way around. You don’t need to put a train in a tunnel. Railways in major European cities typically run more than 6 trains per hour, and they rarely are all underground.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThat's the option that will likely be used. They haven't decided for sure that the trains will run in a tunnel, only that the residents prefer it for obvious reasons.
- fortran77 7y agoNope. That and "property values" are the reason why the people of Palo Alto want it. Which is why it's relevant to the topic of "what can we spend money on to save lives." Here's a community of wealthy people most of whom will say they're for "social justice" who want to take billions of dollars of taxpayer money to _maybe_ save a few lives. https://padailypost.com/2018/06/02/tunnel-idea-is-still-alive-as-city-narrows-down-list-of-rail-crossing-options/ https://padailypost.com/2018/06/02/tunnel-idea-is-still-aliv... > Councilman Greg Tanaka said the tunnel option would reduce suicides and air pollution, though city Chief Transportation Official Josh Mello expressed doubts about the city’s ability to pay for it.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Which is why it's relevant to the topic of "what can we spend money on to save lives." The money is not being spent to save lives like you had originally claimed, so it is totally irrelevant to that topic. It is being spent to increase train frequency, which requires grade separation. The options for grade separation are building a tunnel or building overpasses. Within the context that one or the other option must be chosen, the options have pros and cons relative to each other, one minor point (brought up in passing by one city council member) of which is suicide prevention.