6 ms·
Study identifies main culprit behind lithium metal battery failure
- imulligan 7y agoThis serves as a follow up to India's discovery of a an Iron Ion battery that is literally cheaper than lithium and lasts longer...
- 6nf 7y agoNo it doesn’t sorry. The India battery only survives 150 cycles and the iron batteries are heavier than lithium.
- uponcoffee 7y agoYou can say the same about various miracle drugs before they under go trials. Iron might be the future for some energy storage applications (e.g. home batteries) but can't compete for other applications (e.g. Automotive).
- neximo64 7y agoNot even sure how its a "follow up" as it has nothing to do with the Iron-Ion battery. Lithium is lighter & more energy dense and will take more chance. I think where you're coming from is likely something like this Lithium battery steals the press thunder from the Iron ion battery. It's likely the Lithium battery will be used in portable, vehicle applications and if it actually has any benefit the Iron would could be used to store surplus electricity for the grid.
- bigiain 7y agoIf they can get close to that doubling of the energy density of Li-ion they're claiming, that'd make a _big_ difference to the electric passenger flight space. Possibly a game changing difference. Way more significant I think than doubling electric car range (or halving electric car battery weight/cost).
- oppositelock 7y agoSo, avgas has about 45 MJ/kg energy density, lithium ion batteries have 0.5 MJ/kg. Aviation engines are maybe 30% efficient, while electrics are about 90% efficient, so we've got about 15 MJ/kg usable versus 0.45 MJ/kg usable. Double the energy density of a lithium battery, and you're at 0.9 MJ/kg usable, versus 15. We're not there yet to propel airplanes with batteries, not useful ones, anyway.
- mnbvkhgvmj 7y agoNot for long haul jet flights anyway.
- fulafel 7y agoThe current planes fly enormous distances - 15000 km - without refueling. (And there is not a lot od evidence that even this is fuel mass limited.) There are a lot of 2000 km routes to be replaced, like most countries' domestic flights. But yep, it's not a solution for keeping our current flying habits. We will have to cut down on flying, a lot.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoIf you solution to a problem is “massive reduction in critically important infrastructure”, then you might not have a solution.
- fulafel 7y agoYou can call a lot of things "critical infrastructure" but it doesn't mean we can't phase out many of those those things in an orderly fashion. It just means dependencies we've added to our life, many of which are very recent. We have to make compromises, unless we prefer to lose the global warming battle. Humanity's benefits from cheap air travel are much less than losses from unchecked climate change.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago
- inflatableDodo 7y agoI wonder if you can make them 1D, so you have cells comprised of channels with a lithium whisker at either end, then you shuttle ions up the channel in between the whiskers and they can't get lost.
- mrfusion 7y agoWhy does the anode make such a difference? I always picture it as a little thing at the top of the battery. Does it actually make up a large part of the batteries mass? Isn’t the electrolyte where the energy is actually stored?
- teraflop 7y agoThe cathode and anode of a battery are not just the little metal terminals; they are the sites where the electrochemical reaction takes place, and where the energy is stored. Even in an old-fashioned alkaline battery, they run the entire length of the cell: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alkaline_battery#Chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alkaline_battery#Chemistry (For one thing, the surface area of contact between the electrodes and electrolyte is a limiting factor for how fast the reaction can proceed, and therefore how much current the battery can produce.) In a lithium-ion battery, the cathode and anode are typically constructed out of many stacked layers, separated only by a very thin layer of electrolyte.