4 ms·
The actual consequence will be Chinese sellers using US warehouses and drop-shipping from there. Others send over a container with each ordered good and slap a
by Scoundreller 7y ago
The actual consequence will be Chinese sellers using US warehouses and drop-shipping from there.
Others send over a container with each ordered good and slap a local post’s label on it.
Possibly that local post’s label is attached in China and the container just gets dropped off at a USPS DC by the private freight forwarder.
It’s already fairly common.
Overall, a few more US jobs, and maybe more USPS revenue for what are now domestic shipments.
Edit: OR these buyers Shift to Amazon, which can deliver for less than USPS can via private courier, and pool every more items per delivery.
- 0xffff2 7y agoIs that a problem? Seems like if they do that then it's US domestic mail, playing by all the same rules (and high rates) as any other domestic mail item. Competing with Chinese shippers would look exactly the same as competing with anyone shipping out of LA/Oakland/Seattle.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt’s just not going to be a boon to US drop-shippers, the Chinese ones will still have a lower cost of operations by dealing direct and almost 100% Chinese labour costs.
- mistermann 7y agoYou seem to be completely overlooking the fact that it is way cheaper to ship an item from China to a specific location in the US, than it is to ship the same item from within the US.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt’ll be good for the USPS (or maybe not if people just order off Amazon and they deliver), but the benefits to US jobs will be oversold.
- mistermann 7y agoI haven't really heard jobs being a part of this discussion at all, the reasoning and the rhetoric has been about leveling an clearly unfair playing field. The USPS will certainly make more revenue, and in turn they should be able to pass that on by reducing shipping costs for people shipping from within the US. For companies drop-shipping from China, regardless of whether the person running the business is in the US or in China, the impact is the same. But for US based businesses that inventory items and ship out of the US, this change would be a big advantage.
- Scoundreller 7y ago> The USPS will certainly make more revenue Maybe. The main benefactor may be Amazon people switch to them. They have the lowest domestic shipping costs (presumably, since they’ve implemented their own in-house couriers). The actual cost of USPS of delivering a package is kinda complicated. If USPS is going by your house every day, how much do their costs go down if they have 1 less package to drop off? Dividing total costs by packages delivered doesn’t tell that story.
- mistermann 7y ago> Maybe If prices are raised as significantly as suggested, you think they'll only maybe make more revenue? If the sales completely stopped, or there was a mass exodus (eventually) to Amazon there may not be an increase, but this seems fairly unlikely in the short term. > If USPS is going by your house every day, how much do their costs go down if they have 1 less package to drop off? Dividing total costs by packages delivered doesn’t tell that story. Of course, but we're discussing revenue.
- Scoundreller 7y agoAmericans should pray that USPS doesn’t only worry about the short term.
- 7y ago
- m463 7y agoBut won't there be import duties on the goods from china, sales tax consequences for goods in the US, and regulations that will have to be met?
- kevstev 7y agoI think most will agree that is a "fair" competitive advantage. What myself and I think most find problematic is that the USPS is actually subsidizing Chinese packages inbound to the US, to the point where its somehow cheaper to send from China than domestically. That may have made sense at some point when China was still in its embryonic phase of development, but they are well past the point where this is necessary or desirable.
- dev_dull 7y agoThe fact it went on this long is the confusing part to me. Why didn't anybody come and say "Hey! This is weird. Let's stop this" before 2016?
- Scoundreller 7y agoA certain someone has a real hate-on for China?
- mjevans 7y agoProbably a combination of Politics, not-rocking-the-boat (generally), and a question like yours. With globalization increasing as it has in the past few decades a lot of the old shipping and carriage agreements become counter productive.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI think the way this happened certainly looked like (petty)"Politics" and "not-rocking-the-boat (generally)". I'm sure most would expect "Globalization" as an idea that was generally in the air would have influenced those who took the actions here as well as the people allowed those actions to happen (which had to include quite a number of US officials). The thing is that definitely involved a huge amount of money flowing in various directions and so I tend to believe a portion of people making this and allowing this to happen were considering the interests involved also. Especially, some people (small US operations) were screaming about this from the start, why it was hard for them to be heard is worth considering.
- hnick 7y agoThis is common in Australia and there are some problems. Any faulty goods purchased here are to be returned to the merchant (rather than manufacturer) and some of them make this very difficult by providing a local sender but a foreign 'return' address. I'm pretty sure it's not strictly legal, but it's too annoying in most cases to fight it. It also gives them a local business address so they can advertise local shipping but a lot of the time you have to wait for the next cargo shipment to come in so something that should take a few days now takes a week or two. This can be helped with reviews but we all know how those get gamed now with sellers flooding reviews or shutting down and starting as a new account. These are both differences that arise from a business not having a real local presence, but just the bare minimum presence 'for show'. Luckily, most of them are fairly inept and make themselves obvious on eBay by pasting Australian flags and Koalas all over their store pages :)
- sidlls 7y agoThey'll have to raise their prices to accommodate the additional expenses, unless their plans include selling at a loss to eliminate competition.
- dev_dull 7y agoLord help any industry that attempts “dumping” with today’s president.
- jsonne 7y agoYes this is what most of us do anyways. We have the manufacturers deliver directly to a 3rd party logistics company that then packs and delivers the individual products here in the US.
- Kadin 7y agoNothing wrong with that. If a Chinese company wants to ship things over in bulk, break them up here in the US and ship them via the USPS, more power to them. They'll need to incorporate in the US, pay taxes in the US, probably rent space in a US warehouse, and generally play by the same set of rules as a US company that buys stuff from China and imports it for sale would. I'm all for having a level playing field; the UPU rates were anything but.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI think the air/sea container will arrive in the US and go straight to the USPS DC, bypassing the US incorporation, US taxes, and US warehouse. They will pay higher USPS rates, but that’s about it.
- m463 7y agoWouldn't that also have sales tax and product liability consequences?