10 ms·
How do black holes destroy information and why is that a problem?
- stochastimus 7y agoThis was actually a really accessible description for a layperson. Thank you.
- soulofmischief 7y ago> Think of mixing dough. You’ll never be able to unmix it in practice. But if only you could arrange precisely enough the position of each single atom, you could very well unmix the dough. The same goes for burning a piece of paper. Irreversible in practice. But in principle, if you only knew precisely enough the details of the smoke and the ashes, you could reverse it. This was a nice description of entropy.
- maxheadroom 7y agoTo save you the read, the summation is in the second-to-last paragraph: >As you have probably noticed, I didn’t say anything about information. That’s because really the reference to information in “black hole information loss” is entirely unnecessary and just causes confusion. The problem of black hole “information loss” really has nothing to do with just exactly what you mean by information. It’s just a term that loosely speaking says you can’t tell from the final state what was the exact initial state.
- JDEW 7y agoI think the article is already quite concise. Moreover it is nicely written and explains a current open problem in physics from first principles. A summary like this is useful if the underlying article is bloated and clickbait-y but in this case potentially detracts a reader from a good article. As featured on the front page a few days ago [1]: knowledge without understanding is meaningless. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/24/douglas-adams-was-right-knowledge-without-understanding-is-meaningless https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/24/dougla...
- jinushaun 7y agoIt’s the opposite of well written and concise! The writing style is very much like someone talking, full of sentences that are too long or too short.
- raphaelj 7y agoThat's because it's a direct transcript of the Youtube video above.
- CathedralBorrow 7y agoFor what it's worth, I think the summary is useful.
- hyperpallium 7y ago> The important thing is that all evolution equations that we know of are time-reversible. I've heard this before, but it's so surprising to me, when one of the simplest mathematical operations - addition - is not reversible. e.g. if a+b=4, you can't infer the values of a and b (beyond their linear relationship). This non-injectivity is a kind of summarising, with less information, where more than one state maps to one. So "evolution equations" (reality) are not like addition; state changes never summarise.
- myaccount80 7y agoIt is not reversible because you’re ereasing information. If you want to have a reversible addition you are not allowed to destroy the information. The same happens if you apply the standard AND operator to two bits because the output is only one bit, therefore it is impossible to figure out the two input bits. To have a reversible AND operator you can define it like this: f(x1, x2, b) = (x1, x2, b XOR (x1 AND x2)). E.g: f(1,1,0) = (1,1,1). From this output you can get back to the input. This way you can implement a NOT gate as well, and all others gates. At the end you can implement addition using bits and your summation becomes reversible :) You can see that with this definition we are not ereasing any information, hence it becomes reversible.
- codernyc16 7y agoYou’d have to do that for all results, not just one. This is basically what an event sourced system does: you store all the events and fold your state, so you can “play back” to any point in time. You could theoretically reverse from the end, but I haven’t seen it done.
- ailideex 7y agoDo they destroy information? Last I checked they don't: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/29175/why-is-information-indestructible https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/29175/why-is-inf... Maybe there is some recent development I am not aware of an Susskind is wrong though. More: - https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/450326/why-is-the-information-paradox-restricted-to-black-holes https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/450326/why-is-th...
- ben_w 7y agoThat’s why it’s a problem — the two best tested laws of physics contradict each other.
- ailideex 7y agoWhich law of physics say information must be lost in a black hole? AFAIK if information is lost in a black hole it will also violate the second law of thermodynamics - so really you have many many laws saying it cannot be lost - and Hawking temporarily claimed it will be lost in black holes before recanting and saying it won't. So ... I don't quite follow. I mean this title is as concerning to me as something that claims the earth is flat.
- sohkamyung 7y agoI believe the 'No-hair theorem' is closest to a 'law' that says Black holes destroy information [1]. If it is true, then when you throw anything into a black hole, information about what you threw in (whether it is a chair, a star, a planet, etc.) is 'lost' as to the outside world they all yield the same observable parameters of the black hole. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-hair_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-hair_theorem
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIANAPhysicist, but couldn't information be radiated away? When you have a particle and antiparticle annihilating, the information about what collided and when is carried away by the radiation from that annihilation event; nothing remains at ground zero to be inspected. As matter traverses the accretion disk and falls towards the event horizon, couldn't information about it be radiated away? As an observer, you could definitely tell whether somebody threw a planet or a planet-sized bunch of paperclips into a black hole by observing the accretion disk as it happened.
- graycat 7y agoQ. At time t1 = 0, we know the state of our system. Then we send a photon into an atom. Assume the atom absorbs the photon by having an electron move to a different energy level. Some time later, at time t2, the electron returns to where it was and emits a photon. As I understand, t2 - t1 is random, with exponential distribution, and independent of everything else in the universe. So, at time t2, we cannot recover the state at time t1 or even know just when t1 was. That is, the reversible time evolution equation of state at time t2 can't tell us the random time t2 - t1 or t1 so cannot recover the state at time t1 -- at time t2, we just do not know just when or how we got to the state at time t2. So, the time evolution equation is time reversible but the event of the emission of the photon is not time reversible. This thought experiment seems to conflict with the OP. Where am I going wrong?
- evanb 7y agoThe final state wavefunction, which you need to recover the initial state, contains an exponentially decaying distribution of different t2s. The final state wavefunction is not "here's a definite t2"---that requires measurement.
- someguy12342 7y agoIt is a bit more difficult to see this because you are describing a continuous time process, however, the answer is that yes you would be able to to figure out the time t1 given you knew had a snapshot of the whole system through the time evolution equation. Perhaps your confusion stems from the fact that the time t2 is observed, and it seems like you can't go back after that. An easier to grasp manifestation of this problem is that if you find Schrodinger's cat dead you can't tell if was always dead or if was dead only after your experiment. The reason is because that's only with the narrow knowledge of that cat being dead (maybe the would call this the cat state subsystem). It might be unsatisfactory to you, but in the theory of quantum mechanics, if you knew the state of everything (say the room, measurement apparatus, and so on), then you would be able to trace back to whether the cat was alive or dead. The moral is that the measurement looks irreversible if you look only at the system you are observing, but overall, people accept that there is a overarching greater space (the "environment, universe" where everything is just a unitary operation in motion according to the time evolution equation [1]). To be clear, the time evolution equation only admits reversible solutions. So with full knowledge, of say, the room and measurement apparatus, it would be possible to deduce the original state of the cat. https://www.quantiki.org/wiki/church-larger-hilbert-space https://www.quantiki.org/wiki/church-larger-hilbert-space
- misja 7y agoIsn't this resolved by the holographic principle? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle)
- platz 7y agoRequires string theory
- GuB-42 7y agoYes, but it introduces other problems. And most importantly, it hasn't been successfully tested yet.
- throwaway_law 7y agoAre there even proposed experiments to test this? My layman understanding of the Holographic Principle is an object falling into a blackhole has it's 3D information copied onto a 2D surface/perimeter (event horizon) and that 2D information can tell us everything about the energy that continues to exist within the 3D volume of the blackhole. Fractal Mathematics suggests it is possible right? In other words we can infinity extend the perimeter of a shape while maintaining the same volume, but what are the proposed experiments, if any, to observe this phenomena in nature for quanta?
- marcosdumay 7y agoThe Holographic Principle shares with String Theory the problem that it is a generic name for a huge number of theories, some that have been falsified already, some practically impossible to test, and some just out of reach.
- chasd00 7y agoman, watch the PBS YouTube channel SpaceTime. They're short, informative, and very well done. they dedicate a handful of episodes to getting you ready for Hawking radiation. https://youtu.be/qPKj0YnKANw https://youtu.be/qPKj0YnKANw
- stallmanite 7y agoSeconding that recommendation. The clear explanations allowed me to grasp several concepts that I've been trying to understand for decades, for example the "one-electron universe"
- dharmab 7y agoI love their dedication to building up over multiple episodes instead of dumbing things down every time.
- westurner 7y ago"Why Quantum Information is Never Destroyed" re: determinism and T-Symmetry ("time-reversal symmetry") by PBS SpaceTime https://youtu.be/HF-9Dy6iB_4 https://youtu.be/HF-9Dy6iB_4 Classical information is 'collapsed' quantum information, so that would mean that classical information is never lost either. There appear to be multiple solutions for Navier-Stokes; i.e. somewhat chaotic. If white holes are on the other side of black holes, Hawking radiation would not account for the entirety of the collected energy/information. Is our visible universe within a white hole? Is everything that's ever been embedded in the sidewall of a black hole shredder? Maybe even recordings of dinosaurs walking; or is that lemurs walking in reverse? Do 1/n, 1/∞, and n/∞ approach a symbolic limit where scalars should not be discarded; with piecewise operators?
- acollins1331 7y agoSimple: the laws of most physics say you can look at something now and work it backwards. Once it falls into a black hole the previous state of what falls into it isn't able to be derived from working backwards because it just fell into a black hole. This isn't rocket science! (Maybe eventually though)
- mannykannot 7y agoI do not think the issues raised here are so simple that you can answer the question without mentioning entropy, which, at first sight, might appear to show that information loss is routine.
- dchest 7y ago... because it just fell into a black hole That doesn't really explain anything.
- acollins1331 7y agoI said simply!
- danaliv 7y agoI’ve heard this idea a lot and it always strikes me as one of those things that’s technically true but wildly off base. I get that the equations are mathematically reversible. Presumably we’re more interested in the world than we are the math though, and in real life almost nothing can be worked backwards. There’s a lamp on the dresser for example. How did it get there? Go ahead and run the kinematics in reverse and tell me which of the infinite solutions is the truth.
- mherrmann 7y agoShe also has a music video about Schrödinger's cat: https://youtu.be/I_0laAhvHKE https://youtu.be/I_0laAhvHKE
- vectorEQ 7y agomv universe.info /dev/null i see no issues there
- Ultimatt 7y agoThis is literally what the holographic principle addresses... https://youtu.be/B2ksDczJOAs https://youtu.be/B2ksDczJOAs Leonard Susskind has enough accessible vids and lectures to give a conceptual idea of how it works out.
- platz 7y agoAlso see Black hole Firewalls - with Sean Carroll (speaking at 20:25) and Jennifer Ouellette https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8bhtEgB8Mo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8bhtEgB8Mo which explains the paradox and several different competing theories at a high level.
- ropiwqefjnpoa 7y agoShe must be a teacher at Professor Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters.
- ricardo81 7y agoPerhaps this is why we perceive time to be going in one direction. The fact that a black hole exists in our universe means that there is only that direction.
- nice1 7y agoYou should not believe everything you read.
- cellular 7y agoA black hole is not a singularity. If that were true, they would ALL emit the same Hawking radiation pattern.
- maffydub 7y ago(I am not a physicist.) One thing I've struggled with around black holes is what it means for anything to fall into a black hole. From a reference frame outside the black hole, observing an object falling into the black hole, don't we observe time slowing down as the object approaches the event horizon? In this reference frame, does it ever cross the event horizon, or does it just asymptotically approach it? If it doesn't cross the event horizon, how can anything ever fall into the black hole? (From the reference frame of the object falling into the black hole, my understanding was that the event horizon shrinks away from you as you approach it.) Please correct/inform me!
- jadams5 7y ago(also not a physicist) I think you're correct that objects falling into a black hole never cross the event horizon from our reference frame, but at the same time the light from the object red shifts towards zero energy as it approaches the event horizon as well.
- maffydub 7y agoThanks! Does the fact that the light red shifts towards zero energy mean that the information has been lost, or just that you can't observe it _at_the_moment_? If the black hole then shrinks due to Hawking radiation, what happens to the object that _never_quite_fell_into_ the black hole? If it hasn't yet fallen into the black hole, presumably its light becomes slightly-less-red-shifted once more, meaning that you can observe its information again?
- ww520 7y agoThe object has physically fallen through the event horizon and long disintegrated but the imprint of its falling toward the event horizon is slowing down to the outside observer. The falling object emits photons along the way which are what the observer sees. These photons of the falling object shining toward the observer have to travel greater and greater distance in the warped spacetime as the object getting near the event horizon so the photons appear to slow down. The spacetime is being "stretched" (warped) more as getting closer to the blackhole. The event horizon is at the point where the spacetime is "stretched more than" the distance the photons can travel to come out.
- openasocket 7y agoThe other major example of a time-irreversible operation/object is much more mundane: the collapse of a wave function. I've never been able to find a decent layperson's explanation of what the wave function collapse really means, and why physicists seem to have no issue with it being time irreversible but seem quite concerned with black holes
- KSS42 7y agoPhysicists do have a problem with it. See : https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/08/the-problem-with-quantum-measurements.html https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/08/the-problem-with-q... Sabine Hossedfelder also discusses it in her book Lost in Math. Two books on the subject are reviewed in the Booklab podcast, episode 20: http://booklabpodcast.com/booklab-020-what-is-real-and-beyond-weird http://booklabpodcast.com/booklab-020-what-is-real-and-beyon... Featured Books:What is Real? by Adam Becker; and Beyond Weird by Philip Ball. Quantum physics has been with us for more than 100 years – but what is it actually telling us about the world?
- garmaine 7y agoThat’s because physicists do have a problem with it, and not all believe the wave function collapse is real.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoIt is a problem. Quantum mechanics, as it's normally taught, basically has two components: 1. Schrödinger's equation, which governs how the wavefunction (or quantum state) evolves in time. This equation is time-reversible: given a state at time t, you can calculate what the state was at time t-T. Technically, that means that the "time evolution operator" is invertible. All the information about the history of how system's state is contained in the present state. No information is ever destroyed. 2. Observation. A quantum state looks like a_1 * psi_1 + a_2 * psi_2 + ... + a_n * psi_n, where psi_i are all the possible states of the system and a_i are complex numbers called "amplitudes." When you observe a state (I'm obviously leaving out some mathematical details here, so anyone with physics knowledge please forgive me), you observe it to be in one of the possible states, psi_i, with i between 1 and n. The probability of observing it to be in state i is proportional to |a_i|^2. This operation destroys information, because the state collapses to psi_i, and all the amplitudes, a_j, j≠i, are lost. You can no longer reconstruct the previous state of the system. I think most physicists who "seriously" think about quantum mechanics do not believe that step 2 above actually happens. It is a simplification of a much more complicated process called "decoherence." In order to understand decoherence, you have to change your perspective on what observation means. If you treat the observer as a system governed by Schrödinger's equation, which interacts with the system that's being measured, you find that the observer becomes entangled with the system under observation. The observer ends up in a superposition of states, each of which has observed a different outcome. It appears to each state of the observer as if there has been wavefunction collapse, but there actually is a larger quantum system containing both the observer and thing being observed, in which no information has been lost. The theory of decoherence and the "many-worlds interpretation" began to be developed in the 1950s by one of Wheeler's students, Everett. Somehow, it hasn't really made it into undergraduate physics yet, and most physicists can get by without thinking too deeply about what observation means. You can do most calculations assuming wavefunction collapse happens.