12 ms·
Jaguar and Audi SUVs Fail to Dent Tesla’s Electric-Car Dominance
- pandapower2 7y agoFeels like anyone going head to head with Tesla is in for a hard time. It must be very hard to compete with the cachet of Tesla and the speed with which they improve their vehicles.
- 7472697374616E 7y agoAnd compete with the vast network of superchargers Tesla's already established for themselves...
- threeseed 7y agoElectrify America is rolling out their own supercharger equivalent. And in fact will soon have more 350kw chargers than Tesla.
- colordrops 7y agoReally? I haven't seen one yet.
- clouddrover 7y agoHere's one: https://www.engadget.com/2018/12/08/electrify-america-350-kw-ev-chargers-california/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/12/08/electrify-america-350-kw... Ionity is installing 350kw chargers in Europe: https://ionity.eu/en/design-and-tech.html https://ionity.eu/en/design-and-tech.html And so is Fastned: https://fastnedcharging.com/en/blog/post/fastned-opens-its-first-350k-w-ready-fast-charging-station-in-the-united-kingdom https://fastnedcharging.com/en/blog/post/fastned-opens-its-f...
- marvin 7y agoDo any of these actually operate near 350kw with any production cars yet? Anyways, it's a good thing for the whole electric vehicle ecosystem that multiple charging options become available. That multiple companies are competing on charging infrastructure is excellent!
- clouddrover 7y ago> Do any of these actually operate near 350kw with any production cars yet? Not yet. The Porsche Taycan is launching with 250 kw charging (with 350 kw charging to come in future) but I haven't seen any information on its charge curve. The Tesla Model 3 can charge at 250kw to about 20% state of charge and then it progressively drops off.
- mgoetzke 7y agoWould that just be locations or actual stalls ? Because the number of actual stalls I most often saw here in Germany from e.g Ionity is limited to 2. Which is a no-go for me.
- iddqd 7y agoTesla owners will have access to both networks.
- clouddrover 7y agoMaybe. Compare the Mercedes EQC to the Tesla Model X. The EQC is quieter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13mNkRtdK84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13mNkRtdK84 The EQC has more sophisticated headlights: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZMNkMadYTQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZMNkMadYTQ And the EQC has voice control (although they really need a better triggering phrase than "Mercedes"): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTew1D5Tk8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTew1D5Tk8 I think Tesla's main problem now is that the major car companies will be releasing multiple EVs across multiple brands year after year. It's going to be difficult for Tesla to keep up.
- booi 7y agoPeople have been saying this for 5 years now and Tesla didn’t even invent the electric car. Also... who complains about how loud a Tesla is?
- clouddrover 7y ago> who complains about how loud a Tesla is? People who have driven in a Mercedes EQC.
- virgilp 7y agoI.e. the Mercedes CEO? Also for the other two.... really? Who t.f. wants voice control in their car? Better lights are nice, sure... but it's a minor improvement (most people drive most of the time by day, and even by night, all car lights are "good enough". I paid 2K EUR to get better lights in my car, and they're great when I have to use them, but even I wouldn't have picked my car based on this criteria.... I even hesitated to give the extra money!)
- clouddrover 7y agoThe EQC also has better fit and finish and is cheaper than the Model X. Compare UK prices for the EQC: https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/mercedes-benz/eqc/specs https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/mercedes-benz/eqc/specs And the Model X: https://www.tesla.com/en_GB/modelx/design?redirect=no#battery https://www.tesla.com/en_GB/modelx/design?redirect=no#batter...
- fgonzag 7y agothe porsche taycan seems like the ideal electric car honestly. If the price is not that ridiculous it'll probably be my first electric vehicle.
- martin_bech 7y agoI myself was waiting for the Taycan, its looks stunning, and is very impressive, but on pure specs, its actually the same size as a Model 3 Performance, and a little slower... So I just ordered a Model 3 Performance. I currently drive a Model S.
- ulfw 7y agoHow is that even remotely similar? Wow
- martin_bech 7y agoThe Model 3 Performance and the Taycan? They are about the same size, 0-100, top speed, range, charge rate etc etc. I'll admit that the Taycan will be very nice looking, but it will also be about twice the price, if going for the same performance.
- ulfw 7y agoYou know, cars aren't just about performance numbers. Or nobody would buy a Rolls Royce over a Golf GTI.
- adrr 7y agoYou don't buy a Porsche for 0 to 100 performance as there are better cars on the market for that. You buy a Porsche because you want the fastest track cars that will best any other car on the Nurburgring. The Taycan will be the fastest production electric car on the Ring.
- martin_bech 7y ago
- lovemenot 7y agoLonger term, expect Tesla's stronger EV competition in global markets from another EV-native. One based in China.
- icelancer 7y agoThis is definitely the most likely scenario. This has wider implications beyond car delivery, of course. If Chinese EV cars are acceptable to American consumers, then a lot has happened between now and then which is going to have serious impact on global trade.
- leeoniya 7y agosaw this recently: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TP9kokeyxGU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TP9kokeyxGU seems like they're aiming for Model S level pticing, too.
- MarkSweep 7y agoAccording to the article, they have less range than a Tesla Model 3 and cost substantially more. That seems like a hard thing to sell.
- threeseed 7y agoThey aren't competitors for the Model 3 but rather a Model Y. And not sure why people are so obsessed with range. It's the megapixels/megahertz spec nonsense again. People don't buy ICE cars based purely on MPG but also for exterior/interior design, quality, comfort, brand, support, seating capacity etc and most importantly what the car says about you as a person.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 7y agoPeople buy ICE cars knowing the petrol delivery infrastructure means they'll never run out of gas on a long trip. People are wary of short range electric vehicles because they might not find a charger in time, or the chargers they do find might be in use, and then they'll be stranded.
- gibolt 7y agoRange anxiety is definitely a thing, especially if you've never driven an EV and have heard it exists. The issue is a non-issue for most Tesla buyers who have home charging. The situation will hopefully resolve itself unquestionably in the next 2-3 years.
- onion2k 7y agoHome charging isn't an option for a lot of people who don't have a garage or a driveway. We're going to see a lot of "electric petrol stations" being built very soon - it's already happening... https://fastnedcharging.com/en https://fastnedcharging.com/en
- threeseed 7y agoTerrible article: 1) It's only about the US. 2) Tesla's big seller is the Model 3 which isn't a competitor for the Audi e-tron and I-Pace. And given the size difference probably isn't a competitor for the Model X either. 3) No one is claiming to be a Tesla killer since no one really has direct 3, X, S, Y competitors. The existing car companies are all off doing their own thing e.g. VW ID.3 (hatchback), Hyundai Kona (mini-SUV), Renault Zoe / Chevy Bolt / Nissan Leaf / BMW i3 (small-car) etc.
- varjag 7y agoThey are aimed at the same crowd who buy models X&S, and they didn't have much a dent yet here in Norway as well.
- threeseed 7y agoAnd Tesla is definitely still beating them. But it's more than a little disingenuous to compare cars from different segments.
- varjag 7y agoI'm not sure if we can talk about segments here. The Audi for example aims squarely for the same premium SUV owners. That they didn't make them larger I suspect is the result of inferior technology. With increased mass and air drag the already modest range would have become laughable.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoThe Model 3 is cleaning up in Norway, but the new contenders are absolutely "making a dent" with respect to S&X sales. Both the e-tron and I Pace are individually outselling S&X combined to date in 2019. This is likely due to pent up demand, but it does show that Tesla's absolute domination of the US market hasn't played out in Europe. If you're interested in widespread EV adoption, this is probably ideal. It's concerning to me that Tesla may have so much mind share that even genuine competitors once they arrive will struggle to sell enough to be profitable. In which case, the steady state will be legacy auto makers doing the bare minimum as required under emissions legislation. In the EU that's probably ok, but not in the US. Norway 2019 sales for reference: Model 3: 10976 VW Golf: 6533 Leaf: 5441 BMW i3: 3671 E-Tron: 3114 I-Pace: 2372 IONIQ: 2168 Zoe: 1775 Model X: 1344 Model S: 969
- King-Aaron 7y agoI wish consumers would take a liking to station wagons again. SUV's are terrible.
- jansan 7y agoGermany has traditionally been a station wagon country. Although SUVs are everywhere now, you still see more station wagons. As I see it, SUVs are used as a status symbol and they have the advantage of an elevated driving position. Station wagons are generally used by people who "do stuff", who have to transport things or drive long distances. It it the car of the practical thinkers. Station wagons are also driven by salesmen who have to travel a lot, because station wagons tend to have a lower fuel consumption due to their smaller drag area. This is especially relevant on our Autobahn, where the higher speeds make aerodynamic drag pretty noticeable. So yes, for practical reasons station wagons are great. I love mine.
- acd 7y agoOne could make a mix between station wagon and suv. All it requires is height adjustable dampers. Elevation is a classic status symbol think castle locations. Upper class started driving elevated cars SUVs and middle class want to move up in status.
- petre 7y agoIt's been done: the Audi Allroad. But it's plagued by damper issues.
- jansan 7y agoDough de Muro called it the "second worst car ever manufactured in the entire history of the automobile" :) Actually, many upper class cars have height adaptable dampers. I know of one wealthy forest owner who bought the (at that time) super luxury Mercedes 500CL (W215) because the adaptable dampers also made it a great offroad car.
- kenhwang 7y agoThat's an interesting interpretation of the data. To me, it looks like Model S/X sales have noticeably dropped since the introduction of the Jaguar and Audi. I don't think there will be a singular Tesla killer, but rather, Tesla is increasingly going to be attacked by all sides: Hyundai/Nissan/GM on the mass market side, Jaguar/Audi/Mercedes/BMW on the luxury side, and Porsche on the ultra luxury high end. The Model 3/Y is currently positioned in the premium segment between mass market and luxury. That's sorta Honda/Toyota territory; I think they'll need to bring out EVs for Tesla to be in serious trouble.
- radium3d 7y agoPerhaps the model 3 is cannibalizing s and x sales instead? It is much more modern and nearly identical in speed and has ample storage and comfort. The s is better if you need more space and longer range, x if storage is your need. I imagine s and x are a hard sell with the steering wheel UX being much more complex and confusing plus the similarities compared with the model 3 for a much higher price tag.
- kenhwang 7y agoWhat happened with the Model 3 in 2019 that would cause the drop off in 2019 sales? If anything, the Model 3 would've impacted sales from 2017-onward when it was introduced.
- gibolt 7y agoIt began selling in large quantities and more locales. Word of mouth, access to test drive, and the vast amount of internet/media hype, and nearly comparable performance could combine to reduce likelihood to buy above the 3.
- taneq 7y agoThey only started delivering Model 3s in any significant numbers around the end of 2018.
- 7y ago
- acd 7y agoToyota and Volkswagen will make more affordable higher quality main stream electric cars.
- icelancer 7y agoThis assumes those companies will solve the energy storage issue in a reasonable amount of time. I wouldn't be so sure of that. Tesla does a lot of shit wrong, but Musk is ahead of people RE: batteries and energy storage importance. I am reminded of Bezos saying that their headstart in AWS with no viable competitor for years and years on end is what catapulted Amazon to what it is today. Tesla has a shot of making that true with regard to batteries.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI'm not convinced. My prediction is Tesla will be a subsidiary of one of the big car companies within a decade, probably one of the laggards.
- icelancer 7y agoI actually think this is the most likely outcome as well.
- rjdagost 7y agoSerious question- what is Tesla's technological advantage with batteries? I always hear people say that Tesla batteries are above and beyond all competitors, and then I read articles like this which make me doubt that claim: https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-7364605/Test-reveals-range-Teslas-Model-3-90-miles-claimed.html https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-7364605/Tes...
- bryanlarsen 7y ago1. A Tesla goes about 50% further per KwH than an e-tron. 2. Audi had to scale back 2019 production of etron due to battery apply supply issues. It calls into question Volkswagen group's ability to make millions of EVs in 2022 as planned if they can't make 50,000 etrons in 2019. https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/audi-revises-production-numbers-of-the-e-tron-downwards/ https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/audi-revises-production...
- petre 7y agoThis is the first time I hear about the Jaguar I-Pace.
- serpix 7y agoJust saw one in the back country in Finland. Really deep in the sticks and on a small road. Was a great moment seeing it there. The electric revolution is coming along and unstoppably. Now would be a great time to get a career going in electrification. Electric installation / Solar power installation you name it, the demand will skyrocket.
- roel_v 7y ago"Electric installation / Solar power installation you name it, the demand will skyrocket." They go bankrupt left and right, just like solar manufacturers, because it's a race to the bottom. Race to bankruptcy it almost seems. I think it's a horrible market to be in right now.
- dagw 7y agoSolar power installation you name it, the demand will skyrocket. I work tangentially to that field and the problem is that the competition is fierce. Every old roofing company is now a solar installation company and a new solar panel company (reselling the same Chinese panels with thinner and thinner margins) is popping up every week. The only place I can see any margins is specializing in designing and setting up large industrial scale setups.
- paggle 7y agoTesla is only incidentally a car company, it is primarily a battery company. If any of these competitors really scale up it will be because Tesla chose to sell them the batteries.
- mikl 7y agoIt'll be a few more years before you can realistically start talking about failure. No one reasonably expected the old car companies to leapfrog Tesla in a year or two. This is going to be a long battle for market share. It'll take a while for the "newcomers" to get the consumer trust in their electric cars that Tesla already enjoys.
- lazyjones 7y agoWhat I'd like to know is how much money they're losing per car sold on these models. Jaguar have acknowledged that they're deeper in the red due to higher than expected i-Pace costs. If they have negative margins on these cars, perhaps they don't really want to sell more than the budgeted 10K/year or so.
- mothsonasloth 7y agoEx Jaguar employee here: The I-Pace is a great car however they can't produce enough of them for demand (the waiting list was around 8 months when I left and was growing). The tooling in most of the factories is still configured for ICE and they are now repurposing some of the car factories in the midlands to be dedicated to electric vehicles. EVs are still luxury market focussed, even with my salary I couldn't afford an E-Golf, unless I leased it.
- skellington 7y agoUh no, there is at least a six month supply of i-paces at US dealers now because nobody is buying them. The i-pace is actually quite nice, but terrible efficiency and no charger network makes it a tough sell.
- BrentOzar 7y ago> they can't produce enough of them for demand (the waiting list was around 8 months when I left and was growing) > there is at least a six month supply of i-paces at US dealers now Both of those could have been true at different times: dealers ordered large allocations of them thinking they'd dent Tesla's market, then the ex-Jaguar employee left, and as the i-Paces arrived, they simply didn't sell. That sounds logical with my own experiences with those - the early reviews sounded like Jag had really nailed it, but when I saw my first i-Pace in person, man, no way was I gonna buy one. It's just flat out not attractive, which is a shocker for Jag.
- mikestew 7y agoIt happened to Nissan with the first-gen Leafs. Couldn’t make them fast enough, until the early adopters ran out and Leafs started to pile up on dealer lots.
- Finnucane 7y agoWhy do they need to 'kill' Tesla? The long-term potential market for electric cars is presumably large enough for a number of competitors to exist in it. If it isn't, then it's going to be hard for anyone to make money at it.
- llampx 7y agoMy cynical side says that if they manage to kill Tesla, they can go back to the leisurely pace of updates that suits them. Say hello to 100km batteries being standard, with 300km and 400km packs sold as premium extras.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]