9 ms·
Leaked Brexit Document Predicts 'Catastrophic Collapse' of U.K. Infrastructure
- Havoc 7y ago>and does not reflect the preparations spearheaded by Johnson that are now underway. All the more reason to be alarmed. The guy seems like a complete loose cannon - more likely to cause additional chaos that help. Really starting to wonder whether this isn't one big geopolitical campaign to short an entire country.
- mr_sturd 7y agoExactly what Farage was doing on the night of the vote.
- arethuza 7y agoJacob Rees-Mogg's father actually wrote a book called "The Sovereign Individual: The Coming Economic Revolution and How to Survive and Prosper in It"
- inflatableDodo 7y agoAnd also, 'Blood in the Streets: Investment Profits in a World Gone Mad'.
- persistent 7y agoEver read "The Shock Doctrine"? It lays out how the rich cause and exploit catastrophe to consolidate and strengthen their holdings. https://www.amazon.com/Shock-Doctrine-Rise-Disaster-Capitalism/dp/0312427999 https://www.amazon.com/Shock-Doctrine-Rise-Disaster-Capitali...
- pan69 7y agoNaomi Klein and The Shock Doctrine on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3B5qt6gsxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3B5qt6gsxY
- pojzon 7y agoThere can only be a single supreme economic power in Europe. It won't be UK. This idea is at least 70 years old and takes adventage of democracy flaws.
- mooreds 7y agoAh, you mean Germany? I am not sure the Russians will like that very much.
- jimnotgym 7y agoHow much could he have changed it in 3 weeks anyway?
- Havoc 7y agoThe future course...a lot presumably especially if it's with intention to cause harm.
- cybersnowflake 7y agoThe EU and the British establishment will do everything they can to punish the UK for their insolence. All the more reason it was a good idea to #Leave. Better to take whatever lumps that come now.
- trilila 7y agoAgreed. The eu is basically a german/french dictatorship. The thing is, once the uk recovers after the leave event, many other eu countries will follow suit.
- don_neufeld 7y agoThey won’t recover, that’s not how trade works.
- beaner 7y agoEU is more than just a trade agreement and there is nothing preventing trade agreements between the UK and the EU from being developed post-brexit.
- jashmatthews 7y agoAfter leaving, the UK will be in a weak negotiating position. Recession is almost certain, and even using an existing trade deal like CETA as a basis will take multiple years to negotiate because of the current UK red lines, like controlling their own immigration policy. Canada had to adjust their immigration policy for several EU countries to get CETA. The UK will be over a barrel and will have to make major concessions. Whether you're pro EU or not this situation is a total balls-up.
- don_neufeld 7y agoExactly. This is going to go extremely badly for the UK.
- 7y ago
- creaghpatr 7y agoPolitical opposition leaked a scare document? Welcome to politics.
- te_chris 7y agoIt’s a govt risk assessment document, not just “politics”. Assuming you’re a brexiteer....what exactly is the positive case for brexit now? Because no one I can hear is making it, merely saying it has to happen, like a visit to one’s in laws that destroys the economy and fractures society.
- throwaway122378 7y agoThe positive case for brexit is no longer being a part of the EU.
- throwaway122379 7y agoPlease elaborate as to exactly why that is a positive?
- rusk 7y agoHey look, there's plenty of negative things that could be said about the EU … it's not inconceivable that Brexit could even have been a good thing. An economy the size of the UK could have been an effective counter-balance to some of the more hegonmistic aspects, if it were still a "friend". If the whole thing hadn't been hijacked by the regressive factions, and they weren't slowly going round in circles giving 2 fingers to everybody … but that's not what has happened. The Brexit that is unfolding is an unmitigated mess for everybody in the UK bar the elite financial hawks who stand to benefit from it, and it will be a mess for Ireland, and it will especially be a disaster for Northern Ireland. You know who it won't be a disaster for? The rest of Europe …
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- te_chris 7y agoCan’t do disaster capitalism without a disaster!
- rusk 7y agoOne of the key proponents of Brexit, Jacob Rees-Mogg, his father literally wrote the book on disaster capitalism [0] … funny that! [0] https://www.amazon.com/Blood-Streets-Investment-Profits-World/dp/067162735X https://www.amazon.com/Blood-Streets-Investment-Profits-Worl...
- sleavey 7y agoA peculiarity: the "south east" is the area most typically associated with the Conservatives and their voters, who have been in power for the past 9 years and who have driven most of the Brexit rhetoric. The south east is also nearest the Channel Tunnel and ferry ports to the continent, and so their food, drugs, etc. will suffer the least delay, least spoilage, etc. in the case of a "No Deal" Brexit.
- esotericn 7y agoI think that's over-egging it a bit. You can drive from Dover to almost all of the mainland UK in 8 hours. The Scottish Highlands will take a bit longer. It'll be a problem, but I doubt being close to the port will make a difference.
- martin8412 7y agoI mean.. If the people crossing the border at Dover are as slow as the average person passing the British border, then the backlog will be all the way from Dover to Inverness
- esotericn 7y agoThe backlog relevant for those importing goods would be on the French side?
- onlingyding 7y agoWell they'll also have to put up with 30 miles of lorries as ports are overrun. I'm sure through all the chaos though, people won't connect the dots.
- mft_ 7y ago> the "south east" is the area most typically associated with the Conservatives and their voters No it's not. Look at a political map of England by geography - everywhere is Conservative, apart from areas associated with major cities, their surrounding areas, and a few small patches. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_United_Kingdom_general_election#/media/File%3A2017UKElectionMap.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_United_Kingdom_general_...
- Simulacra 7y agoIf true, would this not point towards avoiding such unions in the future?
- kaybe 7y agoThis close interconnection of countries is one of the main points and goals of the EU. We should always remember why it was made, coming out of two horrible wars and after hundreds of years of smaller wars - not (only) to make life a little easier, not to redistribute money and not to boost economies, but to make wars impossible as much as can be done by interweaving their economies and citizens. In regards to this point, project EU has been highly successful. We're now far enough removed from these wars and most witnesses dead that we have to actively work on keeping the memory and reason alive. Our thoughts and dreams seem to become smaller somehow, lately. I hope it will not take another massive disaster to change that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ealexhudson 7y agoNo, it just points to a. Having a reasonable exit process (the default of two years makes no sense) and b. The public having the patience to understand 40+ years of cooperation can't be rolled back in a matter of months.
- throwaway122379 7y agoThe 2 year window and article 50 was an addition from UK ironically Also they did not have to lodge the article 50 letter when they did, they could have spent years preparing and figuring out what it is exactly they want to accomplish. Finally the EU gave an extension twice now for them to figure out what they want, instead of doing that UK govt doubled down on stupid.
- Asooka 7y ago> UK govt doubled down on stupid Seeing all that happen, I'm convinced we should abolish voting. Instead of voting for prime minister, etc. they should be chosen at random from the general population the same way we do jury duty. Monte Carlo government. It can't be any worse than the current government and since it's random selection you can't have the process corrupted.
- beaner 7y agoHaven't we seen from the steele dossier that these things can essentially be made up, outdated, or inaccurate, and then be leaked to a salivating press to push an agenda? I feel like this is a tired plot by now. There's no reason to take this seriously without more context and input from the counter-perspective.
- untog 7y agoSo because one leaked document is controversial (and last I checked the Steele dossier isn't confirmed to be all that inaccurate) we should disregard all leaked communications? That feels like faulty logic. Should we have dismissed Watergate because it was based on leaked information?
- beaner 7y agoThe problem isn't that it's leaked, it's that it's taken as true without further regard, despite changes since then or even untruths contained within, because it is what some people want to believe to be true. The "leak" aspect makes it seem secretive and therefore more revealing, when in reality it likely lulled from inaccuracy.
- untog 7y agoNone of that is true, though. It's taken as the only evidence we currently have. The government is free to dispute it, to disown it, and to publish its own contrary information. Still waiting.
- jimnotgym 7y agoDespite changes since when? When Boris took over 3 weeks ago? You are joking, surely?
- jfk13 7y agoScaremongering headline; I thought NPR was better than that. The document doesn't "predict" any such thing. It considers a number of worst-case scenarios of things that could happen, but that's a far cry from predicting that every worst-case scenario will actually come to pass.
- DanBC 7y agoThis isn't the worst case scenario document. That hasn't been leaked yet.
- save_ferris 7y ago> A government source told the Sunday Times: "This is not Project Fear — this is the most realistic assessment of what the public face with no deal. These are likely, basic, reasonable scenarios — not the worst case." One of their sources indicates that these aren't just a worst case scenario, though.
- alkonaut 7y agoIt’s called “base scenario” as far as I understand. The document is said to be outdated though.
- dx87 7y agoThe article says these aren't the worst case scenarios. >this is the most realistic assessment of what the public face with no deal. These are likely, basic, reasonable scenarios — not the worst case."
- spsrich2 7y agoProject Fear hard at work I see. Nobody believed it before, but by all means keep pumping this out if you are getting paid for it!
- mettamage 7y agoSince the vote was so close, why not do another referendum on doing another referendum? You can organize this with one referendum, which is: 1. Would you like to do another referendum on leaving the EU? A) Yes B) No 2. Great-Brittain should leave the EU A) Yes B) No If people still want Great-Brittain to leave, then they bought themselves some time and otherwise this whole brexit thing has been resolved.
- sleavey 7y agoYou joke, but asking the uninformed public to vote on such deep constitutional matters was what got the UK into this mess. Barely anyone in the public was qualified to give their judgement on the merits of continuing inside the EU versus the concept of being out of it. The question was then morphed by the Leave side into "do you think we should stop immigrants coming to the UK?", with the consequences we can all see now.
- burtonator 7y agoIt's like voting over whether vaccines work or not... Some things should be left to experts. This is the major criticism of direct democracy.
- dionian 7y agothings as important as democratic representation and national sovereignty should require the support of the people, they can be informed by experts, but should not have their decisions made by experts when it comes to peaceful self-determination
- sleavey 7y agoPossibly, but if the public were really to be trusted to make decisions on national sovereignty they should not have been asked to decide between the status quo and some abstract, undefined future outside the EU. One of the biggest problems with Brexit was that it meant so many different things to that 52%.
- throwaway9kls 7y agoAs bad as a hard Brexit would be for the UK, it it probably necessary at this point, if for no other reason than to give the hard-core Brexiteers exactly what they want The way that Hitler was defeated was that Berlin was pounded into rubble that put paid to the revival of stab-in-the-back theories that followed WW1. Japan was defeated by two nuclear bombs that replaced any hope of resistance with fear of obliteration. Bin Laden killed in his pajamas, and his body was dumped in the ocean: an ignominious end to a man who claimed to take divine inspiration for his acts. The supporters of these ideologies had to experience the shame of total defeat, and see no hope, before they moved on. A hard Brexit, while causing some pain for the British public, may well be the medicine needed to show its most fanatical supporters the error of their ways. Otherwise their resentment will fester for decades longer.
- pjc50 7y agoI'd agree with this apart from the cost to other people being completely unacceptable.
- renaudg 7y agoDo not underestimate the power of cognitive dissonance, and Brexiteers' ability to shift all of the blame to the EU ("See ? They're starving us now ! Good thing we voted to leave"). This has already begun.
- madman1027 7y agoCan't even mock America over trump.... We have our own now.
- SkyMarshal 7y agoAnyone manage to get the source doc? Seems it’s behind a paywall.
- leke 7y agoI think they predicted this a long time ago, and have been stockpiling, in case of such an emergency. Some things of course, you can't stockpile up on. It's going to be really interesting to see what happens to the UK as it will influence the politics of other EU countries, and the future of the EU, a lot.
- buboard 7y agoJust a reminder though, economic predictions are known to sometimes be wrong. And calm your tits everyone, this is such a contentious matter. Both sides don't know what the future will bring, it's probably neither a disaster nor a panacea. At least it hasn't been so far, despite being known as a definite inevitability for 3 years.
- ulisesrmzroche 7y agoI dunno. If I was British, I’d be hanging on to my nuts reaaal tight or maybe look into selling the left one
- repolfx 7y agoIf you were British, you'd remember that these are the same people who assured the population that simply voting to leave would trigger a massive recession that'd destroy half a million jobs in the best case, before leaving actually happened, just due to "uncertainty". They were completely wrong. Not just wrong by magnitude, but wrong in the wrong direction. The economy boomed. This sort of report was written by civil servants who hate Brexit and want it to die, for ministers who hate Brexit and were looking for reasons to cancel it all together. It has no credibility, simple as that. Many British people do remember this, and have watched for the last three years as their political leadership mendaciously manipulate things as hard as they can to try and avoid doing what they said they'd do. That's why polls show "no deal" to be significantly more popular than, for example, the opposition party taking over.
- drcongo 7y ago> The economy boomed. Citation needed? How about this: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/brexit/2019/03/21/economic-performance-since-the-brexit-vote-slowed-gdp-growth-lower-productivity-depreciated-pound/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/brexit/2019/03/21/economic-performan... "Relative to G7 countries, however, the UK has slipped from having the highest growth rate in the G7 before the vote, to the lowest now (OBR 2018)." "Worryingly, the gap between output per worker in OECD countries and the UK has widened since the referendum" "On referendum night, the pound fell from a high of $1.50 to $1.33. This is the single biggest drop in the daily exchange rate since the 1970s among the four major currencies of the world. The sterling depreciation was expected by some to spark an export boom, but this has not happened." "The fallout of higher import costs has to a degree fallen on UK workers in terms of lower earnings now and in the future through fewer skill development opportunities." "Purchasing power has gone down. On average, real wages have been flat since the referendum. Nominal wages have risen, but below the previous 2% norm (ONS 2018). Consumer prices have risen to reduce real wages. Inflation rose sharply after the referendum and remained high till recently." "Overall, the real economy shows signs of productivity and real wage stagnation, which has taken the UK much lower than other high-income countries since the Brexit referendum." Lucky us eh! With our booming economy! Personally, I've found that running a business working almost exclusively with charities and non-profits, that since the vote it has been much harder to get our clients to spend money.