12 ms·
Considering that Google (search) still lists plenty of FTP results, many of which have been extremely useful to me, this seems like another move to bully the In
by userbinator 7y ago
Considering that Google (search) still lists plenty of FTP results, many of which have been extremely useful to me, this seems like another move to bully the Internet into what Google wants it to be. Will it start removing those results, effectively censoring another huge chunk of the Internet? It's already hard enough to find older/more obscure information, and FTP sites are more likely to be in that category.
Also, I can't be the only one who's absolutely sick of hearing that bloody "security" argument again. Yes, everyone knows FTP is plaintext, and so is HTTP. But drivers, which I'd say are a significant part of FTP use, are almost always themselves signed anyway, and I don't think malware is widely distributed via FTP either (I'm curious why FTPS/SFTP doesn't see to be indexed, or why they didn't decide to add that to the browser instead --- or at least I've never come across a search result that links to one.)
- CGamesPlay 7y agoFTP support is still a big attack surface for the client that has to be managed, regardless of wire security. But my gut reaction to reading this concern is actually: why do you think this is “bullying” and not “opening the door for a niche competitor”?
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoWhat big attack surface? The client? FTP is an ugly/stupid protocol, but it's not really complex (I suspect it's far simpler than HTTP).
- userbinator 7y agoI'm surprised the article claims there are still bugs, because one would think (hope) that a protocol over 30 years old with an implementation over a decade old should've received its last bugfix long ago and become truly stable by now.
- a_t48 7y agoCan you give an example of a piece of software of reasonable complexity (network/file handling, etc) that has solidified like this?
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoTeX
- jarfil 7y agoqmail
- kibibu 7y agoSqlite
- a_t48 7y agoThe other ones I might give a pass to as I can't find where the update history lives, but this is untrue - https://www.sqlite.org/changes.html https://www.sqlite.org/changes.html
- hedora 7y agoEverything in the openbsd base image.
- bartread 7y agoWhat? Like OpenSSL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbleed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbleed (I mean, I'm not overjoyed at the deprecation of FTP support because I used it just yesterday, but let's at least be honest here. The protocol might be decades old but the implementations aren't necessarily, and if they're being actively maintained there's always the possibility of introducing new bugs.)
- userbinator 7y agoIt was introduced into the software in 2012 That's not the "stable protocol that's been around for decades" situation that FTP is in.
- duskwuff 7y agoFTP has some pretty serious quirks. Active-mode FTP is probably the craziest one by modern standards -- the client opens a port and asks the server to connect to it to send a file. Needless to say, this is effectively unusable on the modern Internet. Its replacement, passive-mode FTP, has the server open a port instead; this configuration is merely incompatible with most load balancers.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoActive ftp is dead. I wouldn't be surprised if browsers don't support it out at least don't default to it since as you said it would break things for 99% of users. Running a server that's not configured properly for passive transfers is effectively a server that's useless. So if it would make someone sleep better at night I'd be fine with removing active transfer support from browser clients. Switch to filezilla if you're a power user or want to do some 1337 FXP tricks.
- dmix 7y agoIt's not much different than old versions of TLS.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoOh, absolutely! I said it was ugly/stupid from personal experience:) But it's a form of stupid that can be condensed into a single state diagram that would fit on half a sheet of paper, so I'm not super concerned about it.
- hedora 7y agoIn ftp, the ftp server is designed to act as the load balancer. (Just have the firewall point each port to a different IP.) Also, this enables linear scale out, since not all ftp data nodes (not sure what the correct term was) need to store all of the data that’s being served, and you can store multiple copies of each file. Come to think of it, I’m not sure why HDFS exists, given that you can just use a ftp server cluster for the same effect.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoBecause a 'niche competitor' is not really a competitor and would be invisible to almost everyone. And because sich a competitor would require extra work to use, so it would be unpopular.
- earenndil 7y agoFTP can be implemented in such away that it exposes no more potential for attack than html/http.
- clouddrover 7y ago> this seems like another move to bully the Internet into what Google wants it to be Bully them back. Don't use Google search and don't use Chrome.
- userbinator 7y agoEasier said than done, especially when most of the population doesn't care either because they're too young or too nontechnical; actually, I already don't use Chrome, but their search (which still shows FTP sites...) is, despite slowly getting worse too, still giving a wider breadth of sites most of the time. Bing and DDG help fill in the gaps.
- holri 7y agostartpage.com gives me better results than Google itself, because of the missing personalization bubble.
- snazz 7y agoReally? I find that their cache of Google results is very old on average, so new sites don’t appear for a very long time compared to Google. DDG seems to be better than Startpage on that front, but a Google takes the cake in result recency. Even my not-horribly-popular web site is indexed by Google within ten minutes of me publishing anything.
- laurentl 7y agoI switched my default search engine in FF to Qwant a few months back. You have to re-learn to formulate clear search queries (no magic pixie dust^H years of browsing history to help it read your mind) but I find that it mostly works.
- clouddrover 7y ago> Easier said than done It's real easy to do. It is not the case that you are dependent on Google search. You're imposing artificial limits on yourself. Break free of this limiting mindset.
- stiray 7y agoI would say that the reason is not FTP insecurity or anything else technical. They see no monetization in it as they cant put their ads in it, they cant track you (well this is wrong, they track you with chrome) and nobody is buying adwords for FTP. Why keeping it?
- jbverschoor 7y agoOn the contrary. It’s a data only with maybe a motd. plenty of space to put ads. Especially if you’re looking for a driver
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoThis is an amusing thread. FTP in the browser typically looks something like this https://imgur.com/20ooI9f https://imgur.com/20ooI9f Plenty of space for ads. HTTP is basically FTP with ads. Funny thought. Imagine if, to this day, the internet consisted of pretty much that. You go to ftp://nytimes.com and it just has a directory structure that consists of yyyy/mm/dd and the file names where things like statement-from-chinese-ambassador-to-australia.txt And maybe a directory named breaking-news Imagine if Twitter was a list of text files named yyyy-mm-dd-hh-mm-ss-username.txt Ha. Imagine if you had to upload a text file like this --- Please place an x between the brackets as desired [ ] Whopper Meal [ ] Super sized Whopper Meal [ ] Coke [ ] Sprite [ ] Eat-in [ ] Takeaway etc Name on card: Card number: Expiry: Card Security Code: Sponsored by Nike and the Ford Motor Company ---- Edit: changes 'threat' to 'thread' in first line, typo could have been confusing. Second edit: made list verbatim.
- ss64 7y agoYes but if one of those files was ADSENSE-one-wierd-trick.jpg Nobody would actually bother to download it would they!
- Jaruzel 7y ago> Funny thought. Imagine if, to this day, the internet consisted of pretty much that. That's pretty much Gopher. Another protocol that Chrome no longer supports.
- pmarin 7y agoThey can’t serve adsense from a FTP server.
- Ayesh 7y agoA rogue crazy-totally-legit-not-virus-ad-company.xyz can put movie.wmv.exe in the list.
- weinzierl 7y agoThere was a time when www was just a part of the Internet and we had www search and ftp search engines. The one I used to use was called "ftpsearch" and the only thing (besides the name) I remember is that it used to say "This server is located in Trondheim" on the front page. A quick web search turns out that it still seems to exist in some form [1]. Unfortunately it apparently doesn't really work anymore. Maybe it's time to bring ftp search engines back. [1] http://www.mi.uni-koeln.de/~jbe/ref/ftpsearch/ http://www.mi.uni-koeln.de/~jbe/ref/ftpsearch/
- OrgNet 7y agoFtpsearch.ntnu.no was the one I used to use
- t34543 7y agoI adored this service. I used it many, many times.
- webreac 7y agoXarchie for me
- dmix 7y agoI just hope this isn't like how Google basically killed off RSS when they killed off the best client that everyone was using (which I've still never heard a good reason why) which I believe played a role in the decline of everyone having a blog. And yes I know there's some niche support still, just as FTP will live on.
- jotm 7y agoIncredible how that happened. I used Google Reader a lot, adding any interesting blogs I would find. Now I can't find any of them again :/ I think I've got a list saved somewhere, but it was just so easy to go through Reader.
- scrollaway 7y ago
- elcomet 7y ago> everyone knows FTP is plaintext You mean no one knows that FTP is plaintext except a minority of users which happens to be on HN. Google is optimizing its browser for the majority, chrome is not a power-user browser. Maybe they'll add an option to enable ftp or something. > drivers, which I'd say are a significant part of FTP use I'm not sure how that's true. Every time I used FTP, it was not for drivers. All the drivers I downloaded were over http(s), from constructor websites.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Google is optimizing its browser for the majority, chrome is not a power-user browser. That is a problem. We have browser engine duopoly, and really everyone is doing whatever Google wants anyway. So as they're optimizing against power users, they're making the whole web much worse.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoCan you please explain to me why you believe optimising against power users is making the internet worse. I tend to agree with you, but would you mind fleshing this out a bit. Or, if you've written this before please point to it.
- danShumway 7y agoI'm not TeMPOraL, but to my understanding: Chrome is a duopoly, and Firefox tends to get forced in the same direction as Chrome over time -- it's not powerful enough to push the web as a whole in a different direction. If Chrome was not a duopoly, this would not be a problem. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with having a browser that's highly optimized for nontechnical users. However, because Chrome has such control, pushing technical users out of Chrome has the effect of pushing technical users out of the web entirely. By putting itself into a dominant market position, Chrome has put itself in the (unenviable) position of needing to be everything for everyone. In other words, if Chrome doesn't support power users, and if Firefox doesn't have the guts to refuse to make the changes they advocate for, then power users have no where to go. This is why monopolies and duopolies are bad even if the companies behind them are good. Its completely unrealistic for a single product to be everything for everyone, so single products by their very nature exclude certain users. ---- So who cares if power users abandon the web? This is a problem because historically, power users have been incredibly important for the web's development. They've been important not just in the sense that they've pushed the web forward technically, but also because the web was designed to be a democratizing medium. The web is designed to be a publishing platform where people can build weird things without asking anyone's permission. Even non-technical users benefit from this -- it's in their best interest to have lots of providers providing lots of solutions for publishing because (repeating what I said above) no one platform can be everything for everyone. A non-technical web that is optimized for ordinary people to the exclusion of power users is going to be less creative, less interesting, and less useful even for ordinary people. Whether or not FTP in particular is critical to that -- I don't know. I don't know enough about FTP to make a strong argument on that. I will say I have used FTP a lot as a consumer, especially when downloading packages, and I have used FTP on internal networks. I'm not an expert, but the arguments package maintainers make about why SSL is unimportant to FTP ring true to me. My understanding is that package signing prevents modification attacks, and that looking at request sizes is enough to identify resources even with SSL. As a policy, deprecating URL types that don't support encryption seems at first glance to be a really dumb move, and I'm not sure the security arguments justify it. But I'm not an expert. ---- I'm on Firefox, and I'm hopeful that Firefox is going to see a resurgence of usage pretty soon, particularly among power users. If Firefox refuses to deprecate FTP, I'm not so worried, since honestly I think it's probably in everyone's best interest for Chrome to do a few dumb things that make more power-users jump ship to Firefox. A lot of power users aren't willing to make the switch on ideological grounds; Chrome as a browser needs to get much, much worse to encourage them to use competitors. Thankfully, it appears that (especially recently) the Chrome dev team has been thinking the same thing.
- thrwyway9448 7y ago>Will it start removing those results, effectively censoring another huge chunk of the Internet? speaking as an evil overlord, the most illegal extension of Google's search monopoly would be to redirect those results through Google Drive in a way that forces users to go through Google Drive to see and access the full link or download any of its contents. By the way, Google, would you like me to apply as a product manager (I'm very evil), or are you still doing the don't be evil thing? Any Google product managers reading this, specifically, would you welcome me as your evil colleague, so we can do evil and wrong things together, illegally extending Google's monopoly and closing off the web and making it worse for everyone? Team fit is very important for me, I don't know if it's the right environment for me. Like I said my only requirement is a very evil workplace, with lots of evil colleagues who have the worst intentions and actively sneer at users. I'm like that - would I fit in?
- hos234 7y agoThey aren't evil man. They are just well programmed robots constantly searching for things to over-optimize. They hit their metrics every day and then plug into their charging stations. That's it. Give it a few years and they will deprecate Android for security reasons.
- thrwyway9448 7y agoisn't that just your guess though? Zealous over-optimization only gets you so far: illegally extending a monopoly requires active malice and disdain. Really removing users' choice. Forcing them to use your products. For example one of the things I would do as an evil product manager at Google is introduce active detection of Firefox - even if the user agent string has been set to Chrome to get me to serve unbroken pages. I would have engineers actively fingerprint Firefox, and if I figure out the user is using Firefox, serve them broken pages. (Even if it works perfectly well in Firefox if they pass my detection, and even if they identify as Chrome.) Would this attitude be a good fit for a product manager for Google? I'm really evil.
- gone35 7y agoIndeed; by the same "security" logic, why not get rid of HTTP too then? (Or SMTP, for that matter?) The point of "organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful" is to do precisely that: to organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful -- long tails included. But I guess for them it's not... (Also, I can't believe the Chrome team is so strapped it can't afford to support or harden the feature, as some in the bug tracker suggest [1]. This is Google we are talking about, not some tiny open source project!) [1] https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=333943 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=333943
- Avamander 7y agoThey don't have resources to fix cross-origin network request debugging either. It's quite sad.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIf I imagine I'm in a position as a developer / project manager / whatever working for Google trying to advocate Google committing resources to the FTP protocol in Google Chrome, I'm struggling to think of a way of promoting it that shows it will have a return on investment. How do you display ads while someone is accessing an FTP server? ftp://example.com/directory/file.extension can be a link in a website, where the website displays ads. I'm just imagining some people having a conversation that goes something like this: "The funding for this feature has been removed because we can't serve ads on a page like this https://imgur.com/20ooI9f https://imgur.com/20ooI9f " Edit: grammar
- amelius 7y agoChrome, being a browser made by an advertising company, could show ads on ftp directory listings.
- 19870213 7y agoIn that sense, it's somewhat strange that Chrome isn't already presenting us with ads in the tab-/addressbar and the menu. Perhaps some pop-ups from the bottom and sides as well while they are at it? The original free/shareware version of Opera had that too, and it wasn't that intrusive.
- marble-drink 7y agoThe drive towards "HTTPS everything" has merely caused users to forget what it is and therefore simply trust Google. Needless to say, this is exactly what they would want.
- t34543 7y agoI’m really unhappy with Chromes roadmap as of late. Particularly their effort to kill the URL. At one point Chrome was the gold standard and I think it’s gotten to their head.
- feanaro 7y agoI never considered Chrome the gold standard. They advanced the state of the art with their sandbox model and their performance advantage, but they are losing the advantage in the former and lost it in the latter. It was always painfully obvious (to me) that it's an extremely bad idea to trust an ad megacorporation with building a browser.