9 ms·
> "What’s all but vanished is the correlation between how much companies borrow and how much they invest." I think the better question is: Under what condition
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
> "What’s all but vanished is the correlation between how much companies borrow and how much they invest."
I think the better question is: Under what condition(s) would not investing be a wise and sustainable business decision.
The first answer that comes to mind is: a monopoly. If you dominate your market you have little fear of competition over taking you. You don't need to invest.
The second answer that comes to mind: being a member of a cartel; where competition is feigned for appearances. Again, the need to invest is minimal as normal market forces have been subverted.
- asdf333 7y agoanother reason is that they do not find good uses of capital so they give it back to shareholders to deploy elsewhere. you could just be out of good ideas
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoOr the definition of "good" is so stringent that it's hard to satisfy so you just give it back.
- devoply 7y agothere is also a term called bleeding the pig... where you load up a company with a lot of debt and eventually the company goes bankrupt... guess who doesn't lose out though. buybacks are taxed at a capital gains tax rate, whereas dividends are subject to ordinary income tax.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoAre there that many companies bleeding the pig? Possible. But how likely?
- throw0101a 7y ago> ... whereas dividends are subject to ordinary income tax. Not in Canada: > Unlike many other countries, dividends from Canadian based companies are eligible for a somewhat convoluted set of calculations that can fondly be described as the dividend gross up and tax credit system. The basic rationale behind this system is that dividends are paid by corporations after the taxman has already taken his cut. Therefore, if dividend payments were fully taxed in the hands of the investor as well, it would equate to a double taxation. * https://www.fool.ca/13-steps-to-financial-freedom/step-8-the-great-dividend-tax-advantage/ https://www.fool.ca/13-steps-to-financial-freedom/step-8-the... * https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dividendtaxcredit.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dividendtaxcredit.asp It's slightly convoluted, but if you have investments in taxable accounts, then there's a bit of advantage in them than simply interest. Though capital gains in Canada is only taxed at half of one's marginal rate as well.
- Scoundreller 7y agoRight, but this means, for Canadians, dividends paid by non-Canadian corps are taxed as regular income. Stocks to do buybacks instead of dividends are more valuable to us.
- akavi 7y agoIn the USA, dividends on stock one has held for more than a year is taxed as long term capital gains. The tax advantage of buybacks is they allow the shareholder to choose when the taxes are incurred, not how they’re taxed.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoPerhaps. But that's not a sustainable business model. Numerous like-companies out of ideas? Then plenty of C level, leadership, and management is overpaid. The fact that they benefit for these stock buybacks only makes matters worse.
- skybrian 7y agoIt's not literally "out of ideas". It's that your ideas don't require all that much money to implement compared to the amount of money coming in. Ideas for improving efficiency might pay for themselves quite quickly, putting you further in the hole. A nice problem to have. Maybe shareholders should benefit? (Side note: what does "sustainable" mean here? Usually that involves some kind of steady state, not growing indefinitely, which is always going to have limits.)
- geohotter 7y agoSure, shareholders should benefit in cases where too much money is coming in. However, isn’t the problem that the “money coming in” in this case is debt, not profit?
- skybrian 7y agoOh, I don't know but I can speculate. First, you'd hope they have profits, or they wouldn't be able to pay the bondholders? The question is, where do the company's future profits go? I guess you could think of it as being a bit more like a bank? A bank provides a service to its depositors, holding their money and paying a little interest. A company does something similar for its bondholders, at higher risk than bank deposits but lower than stocks. The company is for some reason deciding it wants to expand into the "provide a service to bondholders" business. It's a bit weird to talk about "providing bondholder value" but that's basically what they're doing, by staying in business, paying the interest, and rolling over the bonds. Stockholders get a one-time windfall when a company expands into this business, as the company for whatever reason doesn't actually need the cash. It's a bit weird to borrow money from bondholders for this purpose, but you could think of it as doing things out of order. Instead of borrowing money to grow the business, they grow the business first, then borrow the money. Less risky that way! You might also think of it this way: maybe some investors are looking for less risky investments. They would rather have bonds than stocks. Companies are responding to that. Maybe we should be worried about companies being more bank-like? Life is uncertain. Why are they making guarantees they might not be able to keep? We've been this way before with banks chopping up mortgages to make "safe" investments.
- nemonemo 7y agoOr, when a better investment opportunity is on the horizon. If an economic recession serious enough to affect good companies is looming, and if some savvy people with capital know it coming by the data or instinct, they might hold off their investment until the time comes so that the can "invest" or acquire those good companies at a better term.
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoIf that were the case, why wouldn't the companies just hold onto the cash, wait for the recession, then use the cash reserves to buy back their stock on the cheap?
- nemonemo 7y agoI was answering to the comment (paywalled by the article), and I believe a few companies do hold onto the cash when they see the opportunity, but probably not many would have the gut or the data.
- formercoder 7y agoThere is record private equity dry powder right now. Money is on the sidelines waiting for asset prices to come down and investors are only buying recession safe assets.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zamalek 7y agoThe third answer is that debt is risky. Economy crashes? You're toast. Stock market crashes? You're toast. The first rule of investment/saving is to nuke your debts. Stocks are, effectively, debts. This makes complete sense to me. It's a conservative (the unpolitical kind) approach.
- RhodesianHunter 7y agoNot really. Debt at low interest rates is pretty low risk. The first rule of investment is to deploy your capital where you will realize the best returns. If you can make 6% and have borrowed at 3% then paying down your debts would be foolish.
- prirun 7y agoI think this works as long as you have income to pay off the debt and actually are paying off the debt. But isn't it a problem when: - you're only paying the interest and rolling over the debt; that only works with declining interest rates - your income goes down for whatever reason and you can no longer make the debt payments - you think "I'll just sell the stock" I accumulated, but that may not be possible if the stock price is declining. If your income goes down, your stock price is probably also declining at the same time, but you still have those debt payments to make.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 8ytecoder 7y agoMore importantly it’s a question of who is better equipped to deploy capital - executives or investors? Intuitively it feels like the stock market was supposed to operate with buybacks and dividends. I invest money in exchange for shares. That money is deployed. Profits made. And slowly returned back to the investor. The investor deploys it elsewhere and the cycle begins. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-24/would-corporate-america-be-better-without-stock-buybacks https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-24/would-...
- senderista 7y agoSo what about leveraged buybacks?
- chibg10 7y agoThe company can't sell shares it doesn't own. Think of it like a startup founder borrowing to buy out someone else's equity. If interest rates are near zero, it may make sense to borrow cheaply now to buy back stock that the company can then sell later when it actually needs an influx of capital (presumably when interest rates are higher and the stock has risen a bit). It's essentially a financial bet on the company's future prospects. The market isn't perfect but if companies are really mortgaging their future to provide shareholder returns today, that would seem to be something easily noticed when analyzing the company's financials... thus weighing on future profitability and acting as a counterforce to the boost from the buyback.
- tomatocracy 7y agoThey are a rebalancing between the portions of the business funded/owned by debt and by equity claims where the portion funded by equity claims has grown significantly out of balance as a result of interest rates (and thus discount rates) falling substantially. Because there are large parts of the market who don't invest across the capital structure (ie they only buy debt or only buy equity), this can still lead to better allocation of capital.
- IllogicalLogic 7y agoIt seems C-level execs across industries believe buying back stock with profit/debt to unlock performance bonuses is a win-win. This kind of stupidity is why I'm bearish on Apple. Companies should never prioritize financial engineering over R&D imo. The company & shareholders will eat the disastrous consequences of this asinine thinking when the market next adjusts 30-60% and everyone realizes they were wasting money buying back stock at all time highs.
- coralreef 7y ago- Apple is spending more than ever on research and development. - R&D account for 7.9% for its revenue this part quarter. - Apple is now on pace to spend $16 billion in R&D in 2019 as it preps for life after iPhone dominance. https://www.imore.com/apple-spending-record-amount-research-and-development-it-searches-next-thing https://www.imore.com/apple-spending-record-amount-research-...
- jquery 7y agoApple may be spending a lot on research but they've recently become too obsessed with mobile profits over holistic prosumer experience. I don't think I'm the only heavy Apple user considering leaving the reservation if they choose to focus on mobile consumption above everything else. If they don't fix the MPro[1], I've lost one of the major reasons I use Apple products at all, I thought the agreement was I pay Apple a nice fat 30% profit margin and in return they ensure I'm using the hands-down best computing devices on the market. The Airport Extreme disappearing is another disappointment. https://blog.pinboard.in/2016/10/benjamin_button_reviews_the_new_macbook_pro/ https://blog.pinboard.in/2016/10/benjamin_button_reviews_the... (not replacing my 2013 MPro until they fix all the issues with the current generation that I'm forced to use at work)
- kmlx 7y ago“they've recently become too obsessed with mobile profits over holistic prosumer experience” “For the first time since 2013, iPhone sales did not account for at least half of Apple’s revenue” i’d say that AAPL has been focusing on services more than anything else lately.
- whenanother 7y agothis is literally a ponzi scheme and a tax avoidance scheme rolled up into one. I wouldn't be surprised if money is being laundered in this scheme as well. borrow a billion dollars and buy back a billion and 100 million dollars in shares, who's going to notice the 100 million that got slipped in?
- dangero 7y agoCan you explain who should notice the 100 million and won’t? I’m not following.
- ISL 7y agoNot investing is a wise decision when there is nothing available at a reasonable price. Berkshire Hathaway's cash position is evidence of exactly that. There's nothing good on sale right now. My own opinion of the state of the market is similar -- while I haven't been looking hard, I haven't found a solid value investment with a margin of safety in at least two years.
- legulere 7y agoAlso in mature markets where the amount of innovation you can get is tiny compared to the amount of money you need to invest to get it.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI can see a third answer for why but is for a more extreme version of buybacks - going private. If they feel that they are getting far too much quarterly earnings short-termism as opposed to long term vision.
- konschubert 7y agoIt may also be that you realize that your shareholders know better how to invest the money than you do. If, as a company, you feel that the thing you’ve been doing won’t be relevant in the future, you can either try to do new stuff, or give money back to shareholders so THEY can do new stuff.
- HashThis 7y agoA way the wealthy can rig the economy: 1) Right now, the richest 10% own 84% of all stocks 2) Public companies take out huge loans in corporate bonds 3) Do stock buy back to raise the price of stock 4) The wealthy shift into privately companies with a bigger precentage of their wealth 5) Workers with their 401k are trapped in public companies, brecause of Accredited Investor laws, they can't invest in private companies. 6) Workers with their 401k are left with only public companies. The companies are forever heldback by servicing that debt. 6) Workers lose out of stock price gains.
- aeternus 7y agoIf you are confident in this scenario, then rollover your 401k into an IRA, enable options trading, and buy puts or short the companies that you believe took on too much debt. No need to be an accredited investor.
- cryptica 7y agoThis is not a good idea because with shorts you need to time the market correctly... Irrational markets can survive for years and shorts cost premiums, especially those with a distant expiry date. If you're not a stock analyst with inside info, you will not be able to get the timing right.
- aeternus 7y agoIf you are concerned about timing it right, or macro-economic swings, simply purchase a corresponding long position in an index fund / S&P 500. Options do cost premiums, but shorts typically do not. You can however even recover the option premium with a similar strategy by selling a matching option on the index. You can construct a trade that will make you money assuming your assumption is correct (that that company will underperform the market).