8 ms·
So many comments here along the lines of "So what, they're making an efficient use of capital." That's missing the point. So much of the argument behind the 201
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
So many comments here along the lines of "So what, they're making an efficient use of capital." That's missing the point. So much of the argument behind the 2017 tax cuts and the Fed's low interest rates was that they would spur real investment (that is, investment which increases productive capacity or improves productivity) that would benefit everyone, mainly through jobs. If all this extra money is just resulting in a more tax-efficient way for companies to give money to their shareholders, which in reality is a small slice of the populace, highly skewed towards the wealthy, it's certainly worth it to call bullshit that these governmental moves that everyone ends up paying for only end up benefiting the wealthy.
- Justsignedup 7y agoidk how this is a surprise. Companies have been going based on speculation. Using buyback they are skyrocketting their value, which is why this used to be illegal. And tax cuts cannot be used as a justification for adding more departments, because tax cuts are uncertain year to year, so best to base your business on known variables. So they take the tax cuts and then create more value. How could you expect them to do anything else?
- digsy 7y agoMaybe the educated folks on HN couldnt expect anything else. But most people believed the current Administrations reasoning, which was that the tax cut would benefit them by stimulating the economy (eg trickle down economics), which to educated people was obvious BS.
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoIt's debatable whether most people believed it. It was an argument bandied and a bunch of politicians passed a law. It was not put up to a popular vote (like you would see with Propositions in California). All we can really say about the beliefs of Americans is captured by a recent CBS News Poll: > Far fewer think the middle class (31 percent) and homeowners (25 percent) have been helped. More Americans think those groups have been hurt rather than helped by the new law. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/2019-taxes-most-say-new-tax-law-helps-corporations-and-the-wealthy-not-middle-class-cbs-news-poll-finds/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/2019-taxes-most-say-new-tax-law...
- whatshisface 7y agoWhat are the investors going to do with that money? Any answer other than "put it under a mattress" would lead to either consumption growth or investment growth. Even if they are putting it under a mattress, that would just lead to consumption or investment growth at a future date.
- ummonk 7y agoNo, it can lead to asset growth (look at stock market and real estate returns) without any increase in consumption or investment.
- sokoloff 7y agoI think you misunderstood the main point of @whatshisface. If a company buys back shares from an existing investor (EI), EI now has cash and is likely to either spend that money (if they're a retiree selling shares for income) or reinvest that cash into some other investment. It's very unlikely that they're going to keep that new money in cash or a savings account.
- spease 7y agoThat doesn’t necessarily create jobs or trickle down. If billionaire A buys stock in billionaire B’s company that provides an automated web service, money may change hands but the workers may not see any difference in salary. Maybe they need to spin up a few additional cloud instances to handle a new business area, but that won’t meaningfully impact Amazon’s workload. Or suppose they buy a painting from another billionaire for $20 million - did that really create any jobs or middle-class wealth?
- sidibe 7y agoWhat's the alternative? The company that has decided it's not worth using the money just creates a pile of unused cash or starts spreading into new businesses to get better returns on it. You can argue against the tax implications of buybacks vs dividends but either corporations give profits back to investors or they will just have to continue to grow bigger and bigger, which I think the same people hate even more than buybacks.
- jdc 7y agoHonest question: don't pension funds also own a big part of the shareholder pie?
- Lazare 7y agoCorrect.
- mrfredward 7y agoSay a company buys back 2 billion in stock, rather than investing it in new equipment. Does that reduce the amount of money invested in the economy? The answer depends on what the investors who sold do with that money. If they invest it somewhere else, then the company's decision doesn't reduce the amount invested in the economy. I don't believe private investors decide they'd rather buy a yacht than invest their money just because a company bought back shares. More likely, the share buyback just moved money from a mature company to growth stocks or startups, which is exactly what should happen in a healthy economy. Put another way...should Dinosaur Oil Inc use their profits to build another refinery even when they don't think it makes financial sense...or should they buy back stock, make their investors happy, and then be in a more vulnerable position when the investors turn around and fund Shiny Solar Inc?
- foota 7y agoIf that's the policy goal would it not be much easier to just build programs to support startups and entrepreneurs?
- sokoloff 7y agoTake the converse construction. "Let's raise taxes on companies and wealthy individuals so the government can get into the winner-picking business of investing in startups and entrepreneurs." I would personally object to that policy.
- foota 7y agoIt doesn't have to be "winner picking" you could have some policy like subsidizing private sector business loans for small business, coupled with additional small business tax breaks (maybe payroll tax breaks as well?). This would accomplish the goal of encouraging small businessess without the government having to evaluate small businesses on their merits.
- jaredklewis 7y agoWell I guess that depends on how successful you imagine the government would be at running such a program. If it is in the US, my intuition is that it wouldn't be very good.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> it's certainly worth it to call bullshit that these governmental moves that everyone ends up paying for only end up benefiting the wealthy If these companies made a large one-time dividend, would that be preferable to share buybacks? On one hand, we have tax treatment. Dividends produce revenue now; share buybacks, only on the disposal of the shares. On the other hand...I don't see another hand. Share buybacks should be specially taxed at the corporate level. Either way, companies returning money to shareholders is preferable to pursuing boondoggles. (I'd argue 100% of the buyback tax revenue fund basic research, but we know that's presently politically unrealistic.)
- ksdale 7y agoEvery share they buy back is being disposed of by someone else, who is paying tax on their gain. The tax rate across all of the payees won’t be as high as it would be with a dividend, but it’s definitely not a tax free event.
- tomatocracy 7y agoBuybacks and special dividends are economically equivalent. Buybacks allows individual investors to either sell or hold. The majority of investors would usually prefer to hold at a given point in time (or at least would prefer a choice of when to realise their gain), so unless the sum is so big that a buyback is not practical, it is usually preferable from an investor perspective as it lowers average friction costs. In some jurisdictions buybacks may also be more tax efficient for some investors than special dividends (and this may be especially true for senior executives who make the decision on which to do), but that's not the case everywhere or for all investors (some may have a tax preference for dividends).
- tryptophan 7y agoI think you're failing to see the larger picture. Buybacks are the correct option for these companies, because otherwise they would be burning money on stupid projects or acquisitions. The money goes back to shareholders, via higher stock prices. They then need to put this somewhere, and many just buy more stock. Stock valuations rise(lowering expected returns), and this causes more sophisticated investors to leave the general public markets and look for opportunities elsewhere... resulting in the 'real investment' that you want. Large, established, public companies are NOT the right vehicle for this investment to happen through. Also, you need to read through the fake news headlines a bit. The top 10 companies are responsible for a disproportionate amount of these buybacks. Smaller companies probably have ways to use the extra tax cut money. Apple may not have needed lower taxes, but pretending like all companies are in Apple's fortunate financial position, and hinging your argument on that is like arguing that lotties are the best use of money because you won the lottery.
- greesil 7y agoIt seems like he is seeing the bigger picture.
- dd36 7y agoWe need progressive corporate taxation.
- knowaveragejoe 7y agoDo we? Ideally corporate tax would be 0%, and the people actually pocketing cash out of the company entirely would be taxed.
- sova 7y agoYou mean embezzlement should be taxed
- knowaveragejoe 7y agoThe other reason this is a smart move for companies is that it gives them another tool for the upcoming recession that they can leverage to raise capital, should they need it.
- Lazare 7y ago> So much of the argument behind the 2017 tax cuts and the Fed's low interest rates was that they would spur real investment (that is, investment which increases productive capacity or improves productivity) that would benefit everyone, mainly through jobs. Sure. Do we have any reason to think that's not working? When an investor makes a successful investment, and the company becomes very profitable and has spare cash they can't find a productive use for, and give it back to the original investors... ...what do you think the investor is going to do with it? 1) Look for another good investment (something they have a track record for doing) 2) Pile the money up in a big pile and have a bonfire, as they literally have no other ideas for what to do with the money. 3) Something else? 1 is the obvious answer, yet you seem to be the answer must be 2 and can't possibly be 1, but you provide no reason to think so, the linked article provides no reason to think so, and you don't even seem to have realised 1 is a possible outcome. Further, you seem to be implicitly assuming that a company management who are not professional investors and who don't think they can find a good use for the money will still do a better job of making investments than the firm's investors, who are. Is there a reason for this?
- TAForObvReasons 7y agoYou're talking past the point. The ultimate selling point which the OP was emphasizing is an increase in jobs. Investing in automation, which is literally how many companies used the freed up tax reserves, is a net decrease in labor demand and therefore a net decrease in jobs, so the argument that this is increasing labor demand is BS. And yes, creating 50 jobs that automate away 1000 jobs is a net loss of 950 jobs. Even if those 50 happen to be in tech or other industries that you benefit from.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> creating 50 jobs that automate away 1000 jobs is a net loss of 950 jobs Keeping 950 jobs that are technologically uncompetitive is a good way to create a crisis down the road. Let's not confuse the investment and automation debates.
- deleted 7y ago
- prostoalex 7y agoUS corporate debt markets are fairly mature, so the investment and cash influx events are decoupled. It’s not like modern large companies get paid on Mondays and allocate capital by Tuesday. Companies can always sell more bonds or shares when they have a major investment coming, the stock / bond buybacks buy time, improve credit standing and create a cushion for that future investment event.
- mycall 7y agoCould all this stock buyback cause an acceleration into the company merger trend (or the opposite)?
- wj 7y agoUnemployment is down to 3.7% I believe. So a benefit has probably been more jobs.
- tathougies 7y agoA majority of Americans hold stock via retirement plans and such. Unfortunately the government systematically preventa many people from investing their money
- dmix 7y agoIf they are buying it from investors what do you think the investors are doing with that money then? That borrowed billion doesn’t just then disappear into the ether. It gets reinvested.
- qaq 7y agoIs 401k really something that only small % of the populace has?
- dragonwriter 7y agoAny given increase in average investment yields translates into a much smaller percentage increase in total income for most workers with 401Ks than it provides to people whose primary income stream is investment income.
- sokoloff 7y agoYou mean like people who saved in their 401(k) for 30 years and are now living off it?
- dragonwriter 7y agoPeople who are living exclusively on 401k income are, by far, a minority of people with 401k’s, yes.
- qaq 7y agowhy does it have to be exclusively 401k?
- dragonwriter 7y agoBecause people whose support comes from other sources have the income-boosting effects of anything that bumps investment yields reduced in proportion to their non-investment sources of income. Yes, a lot of (especially the upper income segment) of the working class has some investments, particularly in retirement accounts; this doesn't mean they generally see the same income benefit as major capitalists from policies that boost investment yield.
- raiyu 7y agoWhen you go to McDonald's and see the picture of the burger on their over head menu does it look like a reheated microwave Patty or a juicy burger? Of course it looks like a juicy burger even though you know full well that's not even remotely what you are going to get. How would the tax cut pass if they didn't pass it off as a juicy burger full well knowing that they were going to give a microwaved burger instead. Trickle down economics doesn't work.
- conanbatt 7y agoBastiat warned centuries ago about the dangers of nominal money. If the companies borrow money and do nothing with it, they are not provoking scarcity of any kind, they are storing bits of a bank account still, doing nothing at all.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoIt was obvious then and should be even more obvious now that it was bs, just like saying reducing taxes gives the govt more tax over time because the economy grows. This is used as an excuse but it's been shown yet again this is not what happens in reality.