6 ms·
This is horrible. So right now, in order to get access to data for a certain person, you need to hack your way through a few of the potential services he is usi
by csomar 7y ago
This is horrible. So right now, in order to get access to data for a certain person, you need to hack your way through a few of the potential services he is using and drive from there.
1. The data might have things like IDs (ie: Crypto exchanges).
2. You can use that data to ask for more data. If you got a copy of his passport, now you can ask for more with this new piece.
3. Looks like some people still store passwords in plain text or don't mind exchanging that over email. This means some of these service might reveal a password to you.
4. With that, you can start hacking into other accounts. You also have loads of knowledge about the person, so you might be able to guess his password.
5. Now you have access to his email, dropbox, banking details and maybe even lock him out.
Right about time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobra_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobra_effect
- davidhyde 7y agoOne of the major goals of GDPR is to discourage firms from retaining personal data in the first place. It did not used to cost them anything so they kept it regardless of its use. Now that there are big risks to keeping it these firms have to think twice about it. This "cobra effect" is one more reason NOT to retain personal information in the first place.
- testvox 7y agoAnd yet other laws require the collection and retention of sensitive user data, in particular any service that allows for transmission of large amounts of money (crypto exchanges were a good example).
- aforwardslash 7y agoThat is well covered within GDPR scope. Retaining data to fulfill legal obligations is allowed. One common related example is invoice data.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoBut then "just don't keep the data" is not an effective response to these attacks of requesting someone else's data.
- rusk 7y agoYes, it requires people to be trained in this area to make these judgements ... imagine that!
- nameismypw 7y agoHow well is that turning out? You can't rely on people to get it right 100% of the time. I definitely wouldn't.
- johnisgood 7y agoI signed up to a crypto exchange, then I requested removal of my account and data and they said they cannot delete my data. Guess what? I had zero transactions, the account was new, etc. They are legally obliged to keep almost nothing for 7 years. How lovely. At least they were open about it, right? Some will just tell you they deleted your account when in fact it was just a soft delete. Screw these places. I, for one, hope that Bisq will become popular.
- rusk 7y agoYou don’t have to get it right 100% of the time, you just have to look like you’re trying.
- btown 7y agoNot to mention anything that requires the provision of real-world goods and/or services. If a data protection law ever had sufficient teeth and regulation to cause Uber or Seamless to force a user to type their credit card information and home address every time they wish to make a transaction, it would be wildly decried as paternalistic by the public. And those companies are equally vulnerable to this type of social engineering. GDPR identity verification as a service would be an amazing thing to have. Articles like [0] bring up a sad irony: in order to verify someone's request to delete their information, you need to obtain information from them in an unusual way that you may not have built infrastructure to easily or automatically delete. [0] https://www.braze.com/perspectives/article/gdpr-compliance-data-subject-identity-verificationgdpr-compliance-data-subject-identity-verification https://www.braze.com/perspectives/article/gdpr-compliance-d...
- rjzzleep 7y agoI'll let you in on a secret. For government institutions which in general have huge amounts of information about you and are notoriously bad at security. They don't even get fined with the GDPR. The worst that can happen to them is bad press. So the institution that has all the healthcare data of all German citizens can not get fined under the GDPR. Same with any other KdöR https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C3%B6rperschaft_des_%C3%B6ffentlichen_Rechts_(Deutschland) https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C3%B6rperschaft_des_%C3%B6ff... EDIT: weird, any explanation for the downvotes?
- efdee 7y agoWe had a mayor fined for sending out election mails to a list of subscribers to list intended for other purposes. Not exactly "big government agency" but it still counts. The downvotes are probably because you failed to cite the laws that exempt government agencies from the GDPR.
- krona 7y agoIt's fairly well cited all over the internet that the EU commission and other European institutions claim they are exempt from the GDPR, after they were found to be in breach of the legislation it created.
- PeterisP 7y agoI've heard of local GDPR complaints and enforcement actions (no fines yet, in administrative proceedings) against various state agencies, municipalities and also hospitals, so it does apply to state institutions at least to a certain extent. They have it a bit easier with the reasons for processing, as usually there's an existing law that mandates (and thus allows) the data processing they do, so they usually don't need consent, but the other requirements should apply. Why wouldn't GDPR apply to german KdöR? I'm not aware of any exemptions in GDPR that could apply to them; governments can make specific local exceptions for national security, defense, judicial process, etc needs (https://gdpr-info.eu/art-23-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-23-gdpr/) but Germany shouldn't be able to simply exempt all their KdöR. One thing is that in some jurisdictions public institutions can't be required to pay fines to the regulator (because transfering money from one gov't pocket to another doesn't make that much sense), however, you can still get an administrative ruling forcing them to change their policies, and if your rights have been violated, then you're entitled to compensation, the "can't be fined" only applies to stuff they'd owe the regulator, not regarding harmed individuals.
- buboard 7y agoWhich i agree should become a new habit. Yet the mandatory right to access doesnt help
- jakear 7y agoThis does nothing to discourage keeping data around. A company does not care if they, while following best-effort GDPR practice, release data to a hacker that causes harm to a user. They can simply hide behind the GDPR legislation to say “we did nothing wrong, the law is broken, we were trying our best, we accept no liability”
- AstralStorm 7y agoThey are still liable, the waiver is not acceptable under EU law for personal data. How big a liability it is, is to be decided in a court of law.
- pluma 7y agoDisclosing data to an individual because you make no attempts to verify their identity is in itself a GDPR violation. As far as the GDPR is concerned it doesn't matter whether you were hacked or whether your employees recklessly exposed information to individuals. The only difference is scale and scope.
- pluma 7y agoI'm not sure why everybody here seems to think that sites need to fork over all date they have on store via e-mail if a registered user requests it via e-mail. A site could easily be compliant by answering general questions (this is what kind of data we have, this is how we collect it, this is what we need it for, this is our legal basis) via e-mail but requiring data exports to be performed via the site itself. The GDPR actually encourages sites to provide automated self-serve data export mechanisms. The entire point of being able to request a copy of your data is data portability. "But what if the user never signed up?", I hear some people ask. Why did you collect their data in the first place? If you collect sensitive data like that described in the BBC article, you better have explicit consent and if you have explicit verifiable consent, you should be able to verify a request is made using the same identity that granted the consent (be it an e-mail, a phone call or a signature). So just ask for that again. Also, if you can't easily comply with a data request because the data is so sensitive and the identity can't easily be verified, you can still explicitly say so. Describe the kind of data you have and offer to delete it, then offer whatever form of authentication is adequate given the level of sensitivity of the data in question should they still demand it. I'm not sure why some people seem to think this is particularly unreasonable. Just because it isn't code, doesn't mean you have to reinvent authentication from scratch. Think of how you identify someone before you agree to store their data. You already do that for all other business processes, why should data requests be any different? EDIT: Also if you figure you can't easily verify someone's identity after you took their data, that sounds like a good reason not to take their data in the first place. And that's the entire point of the GDPR: minimising personal data. The GDPR makes personal data toxic and that's intentional. Just like toxic substances you need special precautions for handling and storing it, and you probably want to avoid both unless absolutely necessary.
- gowld 7y agoThis is not a problem with GDPR. This is a problem with organizations (companies and governments) treating publicly data as private keys.
- SamuelAdams 7y agoMoreover, it's a problem with the current state of "identity" as a whole. Most of the data received in the article - passports, addresses, phone numbers, credit cards - does not change very often. Some documents expire, but even then it could be valid for another 3 - 10 years. We need to move to a system that allows rapid expiry of PII data. Then it will not matter if someone is able to social engineer this data from all these companies. By the time the data leaves the companies HQ, it is already out of date and therefore impossible to use with new services.
- astrobe_ 7y agoI've heard that in Japan, stamping with your personal stamp is accepted (and perhaps sometimes even required?). They have made electronic gadgets that store their stamps as images so that they can directly sign (stamp) an electronic document (using a specific input device). I think we should have something like this, but with a personal certificate instead of an image. Of course I guess it requires some logistics (lost/stolen stamps, expiration dates, perhaps the stamp should be activated with fingerprints...).
- PeterisP 7y agoSee the examples below in discussion with personal certificates and signing keys embedded in gov't ID chipcards of certain European countries, Estonia has this for more than a decade already and now many more countries have something like this.
- hrktb 7y agoIsn’t this equivalent to stamping PDFs with your signature like we do elsewhere ? Also the stamp has to be registered to have legal value, which makes it tough to change. But your idea of signing with the result of some personal certificate is very nice. It can be checked by crypto, different everytime, and wouldn’t matter how it is signed, if it’s easy to reproduce the content etc..
- tom_mellior 7y agoInteresting that you consistently refer to the target as "he" as if women weren't a major target of this kind of campaign.
- dgzl 7y agoSome people refer to hypothetical people in stories as the same sex as the person describing the story. I'm not positive, but I imagine the parent is also a "he". I don't consider this important at all, and I think you're being pedantic.
- tom_mellior 7y agoI guess I agree it's a form of pedantry, but once you're a bit used to reading singular "they" (and it's hard to escape nowadays) you get used to it, and the opposite starts looking weird. Also, it's pedantry that seems to actually be socially beneficial: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/aug/05/he-she-or-gender-neutral-pronouns-reduce-biases-study https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/aug/05/he-she-or-ge... (I don't agree with everything being done for "gender-neutral language", especially in German. But this particular case is simple and useful enough in English.) For whatever it's worth, the reason this tripped me up here was that I had to read the original post several times because I thought that "he" was referring to the attacker (as in the featured article), not to the target. Re-reading it now I don't quite see why I was thinking that.
- dgzl 7y agoI use non-specific terms like "they" as often as I can, largely because I don't want my audience to be tripped up with superficial distractions. I don't read into other people's wordings with contempt unless I know for certain they're being malicious. I think the saying goes something like... Don't attribute malice where ignorance would suffice...
- ghostpepper 7y agoYou could equally have praised the OP for not stereotyping.