8 ms·
Speaking from the perspective of someone looking to hire: It doesn't make for a good impression if I see anyone other than the original author with the same obv
by userbinator 7y ago
Speaking from the perspective of someone looking to hire: It doesn't make for a good impression if I see anyone other than the original author with the same obviously distinctive style of site showing pretty much a subset of the info I can already see from your GitHub account, except the latter doesn't require JS to view.
If I'm looking at someone's personal site, it should look personal --- not "I cloned someone else's I found on GitHub and changed the names and details to mine."
- jldugger 7y agoI mean, it depends. I hire SRE/Devops and I really don't care that much if you used someone else's theme, or paid someone to write one for you and credit them. In fact, it'd be kinda neat to find someone who bought a theme. That's just good specialization and collaboration skills. And my own website is basically the Pelican generator default with a different color selected. Far more damning is the placid update schedule. Try not to put dated content on your front page if you're putting a website in front of manager's faces.
- tehlike 7y agoAgree. I paid some for a template i liked(not for my personal site but same lotic applies). Best 50$ ever spent.
- whycombagator 7y ago> Speaking from the perspective of someone looking to hire: It doesn't make for a good impression if I see anyone other than the original author with the same obviously distinctive style of site > If I'm looking at someone's personal site, it should look personal --- not "I cloned someone else's I found on GitHub To me that seems petty and I feel you'll end up isolating a good portion of the talent pool. Anecdotally, I can only recall a handful of personal sites that appeared to be truly personal (by your definition) and not all may have been. For whatever reason this reminds me of: https://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/67e0hl/whenever_i_get_a_stack_of_resumes_i_throw_half_of/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/67e0hl/whenever_i_ge...
- zapzupnz 7y agoPetty though it may be, if it's true, if it's sufficiently widespread, then it's a reality with which we must be able to deal.
- rgoulter 7y agoJudgements like "I'd expect dev to write it themselves" come across as arbitrary. I think there's no shared context wherein interviewers / job-applicants have the same set of assumptions. Especially since "I'd expect a dev to not rewrite everything themselves, and leverage what's already available" is just as reasonable. There's not exactly a specific "right answer" about whether you need a personal website, what it should look like, or how it should be written.
- abhinuvpitale 7y agoIt's actually a better thing to have a template to start with and then customise it to reflect what you want it to show.
- xwdv 7y agoExpecting a dev to reuse code for a personal website is not reasonable. A personal website is not a software development project. It is not something to use to evaluate a developers technical skills. When you have a real project on the line, then you will see the real skills come out. For a personal website, I’d expect a developer to give a fuck enough to develop something on his own.
- Ragib_Zaman 7y ago> Judgements like "I'd expect dev to write it themselves" come across as arbitrary. I feel like this depends on the type of dev. If you write C code for microcontrollers then who cares, but if you do web dev then using a generic template not authored by you seems like a bad sign, no?
- ChickeNES 7y ago
- andre-m 7y agoWould you mind sharing what company you're hiring for so that I can actively avoid it?
- ChickeNES 7y agoAgreed! If I were a founder and learned that someone in HR was using such arbitrary judgement, they'd be the one looking for a new job. By their standard they wouldn't hire someone like Fabrice Bellard: https://bellard.org/ https://bellard.org/
- vntok 7y agoWhy not? Seems like he coded his personal website himself without an existing template.
- userbinator 7y agoExactly. His accomplishments aside, that's the type of personal website that says "I don't really do web design, but I still made a page" --- obviously if you're hiring a web developer then plain nonstyled HTML would be a bit surprising, but someone in a non-web position showing such a site would definitely be seen positively: It indicates honesty and modesty.
- samplatt 7y agoI'm a salaried software/database guy for the last 10 years. I ceased programming for personal pleasure before github was invented and haven't done anything more complex than a minor tool on my own time in years. My personal website is a wordpress blog we've I've dumped some photos of the hardware stuff I do as a hobby. I'm curious to hear how this factors into your views on what to look for when hiring people?
- cortesoft 7y agoOnce you have a certain amount of experience, I don't think a person's website is going to matter anymore.
- onion2k 7y agoWith the exception of frontend developers. There is an expectation that you have a good personal site regardless of how much experience you have if your job is to push HTML, CSS and JS. Its a showcase for what you can do when you're not constrained by a product or a client.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoI am a web dev and I hire web devs. It's never crossed my mind to evaluate them based on personal sites. (My own personal sites are unstyled html!)
- JDiculous 7y agoIf your definition of "frontend developer" is designer, then sure. Otherwise for any dev with experience, this is a dumb expectation. Part of a dev's job is to use the right tool for the job, and there's no sense in wasting time reinventing the wheel. (I say this as someone who used to overengineer my own personal websites with the hottest tech stack of the week, but am now in the process of throwing it all away for a simple WordPress site.)
- onion2k 7y ago
- funkaster 7y agoSpeaking from the same perspective: I don't really care. I rarely look into github repos, unless they mention something during the interview/screen or sounds interesting in the CV. Even then, I spend a small amount of time there (less than 15 min). The noise-to-signal ratio for github/gitlab links is really high. source: I've been a hiring manager for large companies (and a few startups) in SF for the last 8 years.
- TrackerFF 7y agoWell, I'd argue that using templates as a base is OK. Especially if it's just gonna be a page containing your portfolio - looks more presentable that just a plain github account. Using templates can be free, or low cost, compared to writing everything from scratch yourself. There are other things I'd rather be doing in my spare time.
- crabasa 7y ago> Speaking from the perspective of someone looking to hire Doesn't it friend in what you're hiring for? I'm not sure a backend developer should be expected to craft together a great website. And even if you're hiring for the front end, I've found that being proficient at a11y or building React apps or designing elegant CSS doesn't really predict your ability to execute on a professional profile site, which is essentially a marketing tool. Disclaimer: I'm working on a tool for developers [1] in this vein. [1] https://fizbuz.com https://fizbuz.com
- jvagner 7y agoAll these HN news comments are formatted identically, too...
- nurettin 7y agoWould you be impressed by some out-of-place text, an animated SVG and a shade of purple as theme? I could randomize the parameters and make a lull-recruiter-as-a-service. "Is your website too bland? Did you just git clone someone else's repository? Concerned about job prospects? Do not fret!"
- injidup 7y agoThere are more software careers around than those involved with banging out html and CSS for the adtech industry and it's subsidiaries.
- meuk 7y agoSo you're basically judging the book by its cover? You don't care about the content at all? That only makes sense if you're hiring a frontend developer. Many people who are excellent programmers hate frontend development, and will happily use a theme or clone a repo if they can avoid frontend work that way.
- skrebbel 7y agoSpeaking from the perspective of someone also looking to hire: if you think reusing open source work to accomplish a goal is a great way to avoid wasting time on originality points, then get in touch.
- pankajdoharey 7y agoAnother static site generator. Being an emacs user i based mine off of org-page by forking it. Perhaps other can fork this too or just go ahead and use Jekyll?
- Santosh83 7y agoNot wise, unless the candidate's site happens to be an explicit showcase of their professional skills and intended to be such.
- raxxorrax 7y agoHm. I might share my personal site with you (I don't operate one anymore) but certainly not my github account. I agree with the site would need a personal touch, but not every programmer is a web developer. There is quite a bit of specific knowledge required to set one up. That might be different if you hire web developers of course.
- pdpi 7y agoOn the flipside, developers are not designers. "I took a decent pre-existing design and didn't try to fiddle with it too much" is a Good Thing, surely.
- L_226 7y agoWhen going for a haircut, would you rather have your hair cut by a person with an immaculate haircut, or by a person who has noticeably not had their hair cut in a while?
- BrutalLioness 7y agoProgrammer =/= Web Developer It's amazing how many people forget that there are gainfully employed programmers who've never touched a line of JavaScript. We need websites too.
- tracer4201 7y agoI probably wouldn’t take the time to build a personal website at all, but if I did, the website is just a means to facilitate communication of whatever core message I want to convey. Personally I think a strong engineer is resourceful. I’m not saying this Git repo should be cloned by everyone or anyone, but in solving real world problems, I don’t expect my team to reinvent logging, dependency injection, or basically any other undifferentiated piece of work unless we have a strong business or technical reason to justify why it wouldn’t be undifferentiated. To me, the website is similar maybe unless I’m trying to show my web and visual design skills.
- just_myles 7y agoI see where you are coming from if this person is a designer.
- groundCode 7y agoThere’s also something to be said, from a recruitment point of view, to having everyone’s site look the same. It eliminates one bit of unconscious bias. In a way, it can help anonymise each person, which can make for a different (perhaps fairer?) hiring process.
- davvolun 7y agoSo you're saying you wouldn't want to hire someone who put in the absolute minimum effort to meet the desired functional requirements without wasting time/money? I think the functional requirements in this case are to impress someone who doesn't code, an HR person, etc. Because a qualified programmer manager shouldn't be particularly impressed with any personal homepage put together in a reasonable amount of time for the sole purpose of impressing a hiring manager. There's places where it's worth it to "think outside the box" and then there are places that -- well, there's a reason we have boxes, because they work well for what they're designed to do.