11 ms·
China’s liberalization and structural reform drives growth
- Merrill 7y agoI would have thought that that the "one child" policy played a large part, since it allowed a larger investment in fewer children by parents and society. This, coupled with an educational system that is able to spot talent and develop talented children, has produced a dramatic increase in China's human capital, without which liberalization would be ineffective. The US had a similar emphasis on developing talent in the late '50s and '60s after the Sputnik shock.
- justicezyx 7y agoCannot be further from truth than this. The timing doesn’t Evernote align...
- oska 7y agoCompare the crude birth rate since 1920 for Thailand and China on this Gapminder chart [1]. You'll see that Thailand started with a birth rate higher than China's. In 1967 they were at around the same level at which point they both simultaneously started trending down. Thailand maintained a smooth curve down to its present level which is lower than China's. China's downward curve was interrupted in 1979 (introduction of the One Child Policy) when it curved upward for a bit. So, despite all the myth-making, China's One Child Policy was an authoritarian disaster that did not reduce births beyond their already downward trend. In fact, it disrupted the already established trend. [1] https://www.gapminder.org/tools/?from=world#$state$time$startOrigin=1920&endOrigin=2018;&entities$show$country$/$in@=chn&=tha;;;;&entities_colorlegend$filter$;;&marker$axis_x$zoomedMin=1920;&axis_y$which=crude_birth_rate_births_per_1000_population&zoomedMin:0&zoomedMax:50&scaleType=linear&spaceRef:null;&color$which=country&spaceRef=entities;;;&chart-type=linechart https://www.gapminder.org/tools/?from=world#$state$time$star...
- dade_ 7y agoLast year in Shenzhen, a young man walked up to me and excitedly said, "My name is Will, lets get rich together!"
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoAnd he wasn’t just scamming?
- Tigah_pawszzz 7y agoAs someone from China I kinda feel like we are a developed country when I learned I am making more than my peers in UK #GameIndustryPeasant
- yocheckit 7y agoMy experience with China is that certain parts are 100% first world, but other parts are 100% 3rd world, with many places inbetween. Whereas the difference between the poorest & richest Brit while significant is nothing compared to the difference between the poorest & richest Chinese.
- alienallys 7y agoWell it's because UK population is 66mn while China population is 1400mn. UK was the oppressor and had all the riches in the world. Infact I feel so bad w.r.t to UK despite conquering, looting so many countries some significant percentage of population lives in poverty.
- lkrubner 7y agoThere is a simple counter-argument to this: “It is telling, however, that China is using its long-term planning and robust implementation capacity not to entrench state capitalism, but rather to advance economic liberalization and structural reform.” Right, but whatever the plan might be, it clearly isn’t working, since the economy continues to slow. 50 years ago China clocked 8% to 10% growth a year, now they feel very lucky if they can get 6%. And this is a truly incredible thing for anyone to write: “The fruits of this approach are irrefutable. In the last decade, a number of Chinese private financial and tech giants have emerged that, unlike their state-run counterparts, have managed to establish themselves as global leaders in innovation.” So, according to this, it is actually a sign of success that more and more large Chinese firms feel they need to export capital because they no longer see good investments at home. And that’s success?
- WoodenChair 7y ago> Right, but whatever the plan might be, it clearly isn’t working, since the economy continues to slow. 50 years ago China clocked 8% to 10% growth a year, now they feel very lucky if they can get 6%. I think your comment is quite incorrect, and shows a lack of knowledge of Chinese history. 50 years ago (1969) China was going through the "cultural revolution" under Mao which was absolutely devastating for its economy. In the 1980s China began economic liberalization under Deng Xiaoping and that was when its economy began growing tremendously. So, there is a direct connection between liberalization and growth. Of course no growth of 8-10% is sustainable over many decades, and it's likely they are simply reaching a new equilibrium.
- lkrubner 7y agoNo, for God’s sake, no, the Cultural Revolution was not devestating to the economy. Where did you read that? During the worst year of the Cultural Revolution, China still managed to grow 8%. Large scale civil rights violations are not automatically bad for the economy. The German economy grew dramatically during the Holocaust and the best decades for the USA overlap with the mass murder of the Indians and the savage oppression of African-Americans. In China, the Cultural Revolution killed 30 million people, but it did not slow the economy.
- roenxi 7y agoChina has a population of more than a billion people, the 3rd largest landmass controlled by a single sovereign entity. The only question is how they managed to fall so low that they weren't a competitive superpower. It is entirely possible that we don't know what the reason for China's rise is over the short term. I wouldn't trust any article written in English to understand the ins and outs of China's special economic zones, special administrative regions and historical norms and customs. It is very likely that governance is connected to their success and it is also unlikely that the government is wholly responsible for their success. The situation is complicated. Even deciding if they have achieved 'success' is complicated; I'm not envious of the people who live there.
- throw0101a 7y ago> The only question is how they managed to fall so low that they weren't a competitive superpower. Well, first of all, they had two thousand years autocratic Imperial rule. This was overthrown in 1912, but then came the Japanese invasion, then WW2, then a civil war. The civil war ended up being won by a somewhat anti-intellectual group of people (the Communists) who had all sort of economic backwards programs (not to mention social upheaval by sending intellectuals to "re-education" camps). As for the reason why things remained static during the Imperial rule: this was actually the norm for most civilizations. If you look the world in 1600, just before the invention of the telescope, Western Europe, the Ottoman's, the Mughals ruling in India, and Imperial China, weren't too different. The non-Europeans were actually ahead of the Europeans by some metrics. Once the Scientific Revolution was embraced by the Europeans, and generally rejected by everyone else, the Euros left everyone else in the dust. The real question is: why were the Europeans the only ones to embrace it. The book Intellectual Curiosity and the Scientific Revolution by Toby Huff explores this question. Highly recommended.
- numakerg 7y ago>The real question is: why were the Europeans the only ones to embrace it. I haven't read Huff's book so here's my stab in the dark. Europe has a lot of mainland coastline and the Mediterranean, which favors the formation of many small nation states and trans-Mediterranean trade. Among a large number of diverse and competing states, political, military and social ideas are more likely to be employed somewhere, and if successful, will rise to prominence within the local trade cluster by the process of natural selection. If you have a large number of independent nation states, many of which import products and ideas from the far East, one of them is likely to put together a new military innovation that gives them an edge in warfare. Since the area sees frequent competition, other nations will quickly come into contact with the new technology and be forced to adopt it, or risk swift decline. A period of rapid innovation in metallurgy, chemistry and navigation (to name only a few) would develop a political culture that values technological development over traditional ideals. I guess this would increase the demand for scientists/intellectuals and engineers. The total fund allocated by the political elite towards academics either through patronage or universities would increase the number of scientists in Europe. Ease of communication through mail channels and access to wider array of materials, both developed due to the increased volume of trade, would allow more scientists, to do more complicated research and exchange ideas more easily than ever before.
- ztratar 7y ago"Yet this process of economic liberalization and structural reform is also uniquely Chinese, insofar as it has emphasized local-level competition and experimentation, which in turn have supported bottom-up institutional innovation. The result is a kind of de facto fiscal federalism – and a powerful driver of economic transformation." I'm not entirely sure what this means. The article that is referenced by the author is behind a pay-wall, and doesn't explain it in the top paragraphs. How has the Government encouraged this local competition? By all means the examples he gives are all technology companies that have primarily benefited from 1) copying US tech companies strategies, 2) stealing their IP, and 3) not having to substantially compete with US companies because of tech restrictions, the Great Firewall, etc. None of that is economic liberalization in the slightest.
- kristianov 7y agoRegarding Chinese economic liberalization, it's mostly happening in the country and villages. I would recommend you to read Steven Cheung. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_N._S._Cheung#Selected_books_for_general_audiences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_N._S._Cheung#Selected_b...
- i_am_proteus 7y agoYes, but that IP theft is more often done by local entrepreneurs (moving the factory out from under a foreign company) as it is the state.
- adinobro 7y agoThe article does not do a really good job at explaining what the government it doing but basically it is: 1. Creating competition between states/cities (Beijing vs Shanghai) which has similar advantages to the free market EVEN if both groups are part of the government. This tries to reduce waste and puts natural pressure on companies (including ones that are state owned). 2. Encouraging close proximity (like silicon valley) by using grants, lower taxes, etc. This encourages lots of companies in the same industry to be close together and often in the same building. This encourages transfer of ideas and staff between companies. (economic development zones) 3. Limiting the number of economic development zones so that they are not all over the place. To just ignore anything that Chinese companies have done and say it is all stolen or copied is rather biased. Alipay and WeChat are probably the easiest example to look at. They both started very different (WeChat was just a copy of What's App, which is a copy of MSN messenger, which is a copy of AOL messengers, which is a copy of IRC which is a copy of netsend, which is a copy of telegrams, which is a copy of smake signals, etc... - everything is based on what came before it) Slowly based on competition with each other they have stolen each other features and now do basically the same things. Forget about America (Facebook keeps copying features from WeChat). Hope this helps to explain what the article does not explain.
- RavlaAlvar 7y agoJust in recent years China has decided to tighten its grip on private corporation, it's clearly i the government doesn't have any Desire for structural Reform and further economic liberalization.
- RavlaAlvar 7y agoAlso, we shouldn't forget that since the economic reform of 1978, China has adopted the policy of intentionally escalating wealth inequality. Please do not forget billions of worker/farmer in China still live in a third world condition, so that the upper 10% can live their bourgeois life.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoMaybe you meant millions instead of billions?
- hungryhobo 7y agoThe way you framed it is a bit disingenuous. The reasoning behind the policy is that the government recognizes that China back then severely lacked any modern industrious knowledge. In order to quickly catch up, China decided to pour all its resources into a couple provinces that either had existing industrious base left over from foreign occupation or had strategic locations. As well as sending the best people over seas hoping to gain whatever knowledge necessary to kick start the economy. And it's not like the government simply forgot about the billions of farmers, one of the top priority for officials are poverty alleviation. It's a key kpi for any promotion within the government. Now you could argue the implementation is not perfect, but given the situation back then I agree with this policy, and I'd be interested to hear how you would approach this differently.
- RavlaAlvar 7y agoI am not saying Deng's approach is bad. I am just trying say that we shouldn't forget that a huge truck of China GDP comes from the exploitation of the workers. Now that the level of inequality has reached the moon, I am curious to see what they will do next. Especially in the age automation and increasing trade war tender, manufacturing WILL leave China. Many in the US blame the rise Trump on the lost blue collar jobs. Imagine the same situation in China, but with majority of population being blue collar worker. Let's also not forget about corruption in China. It is true that elimination of porvery is an important goal set by the central state. But how the local official achieve their target KPI is abhorrent, e.g. forcing low income family out of the city, manipulate the definition of poverty etc.
- 40acres 7y agoSolid article, I’ve underestimated the liberalization of the Chinese economy, especially in regards to technology and advanced manufacturing. Anyone know what the proverb means?
- ninju 7y ago> "On a journey of a hundred miles, 90 is but halfway" The closest I could find (via googling) is this saying - "Walking 100 Miles: Stopping at 90 miles, is the same as stopping half-way" which means being 90% done with something is the same as being 50% done - you're not done! https://www.orientaloutpost.com/shufa.php?q=walking+100+miles:+stopping+at+90+miles+is+the+same+as+stopping+half-way https://www.orientaloutpost.com/shufa.php?q=walking+100+mile....
- whenchamenia 7y agoIts basically an akward (in english) rephrasing of the common "the last 10% is the hardest" concept. Also with the implied value proposition that a job 90% done is at best worth 50% of a finished one.
- INGELRII 7y ago(I'm just an interested amateur who reads a lot so take everything I say below with a grain of salt. I also leave things out for brevity) Deng Xiaoping (1904–1997) should still get credit for most of what is happening now. China had multiple paths it could have followed when Deng took over, but he was a clever fellow. He made several gradual alternations to rigid socialist and Marxist doctrine and authoritarianism that separated Chinese communism from all others others. He was able to keep hardliners at bay. 1. He declared that: "Socialism means eliminating poverty. Pauperism is not socialism, still less communism." Before Deng all communist countries justified poverty and suffering of the masses as necessary part of struggle towards communist utopia. Deng threw this rationalization away. He essentially adopted the same measure stick to success as capitalism. 2. Deng recognized stuff that worked outside government. 18 households in Xiaogang Village started land reform after a serious drought in secret in 1978 and it started to spread. It was against government rules and even against party doctrine. Instead of prosecuting people Deng endorsed it. Successful land reform has been the starting point for other successful Asian countries as well (see Studwell's "How Asia Works"). 3. More meritocracy and checks and balances within the communist party. Before Deng, China was always gravitating towards typical strong man communist dictatorship. There was one dictator on the top and power and orders flowed downwards. Deng adjusted the rules. Government officials were moved to work in different regions from where their personal contacts were (and opportunities to corruption were reduced). Princelings still got into powerful positions but talented newcomers also had a change. There was clear movement towards meritocracy and accountability within the communist party. After Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 Deng's power started to wane and hardliners gained more power. The momentum of his institutional reforms has carried on but there is constant erosion. The current leader Xi seems to be a typical strongman who tries to get more and more power to himself and his inner circle and this may end all momentum for China that Deng Xiaoping created.
- baybal2 7y agoChina has a cheap and easy, but hard politically recipe for growth: let loose of some state companies, industries and instantly record a net benefit from increased productivity. And China still has lots and lots of state companies to put on the market, so they are nowhere near the end of the runway. The problem is that all what is left is so much entrenched with vested interests, touching them is a political bloodbath.
- anonu 7y agoWestern society rose to prominence because of a few values: respect for property rights, intellectual property and personal freedom. America is far from perfect but was based on these ideals. It's maybe a simplistic view of the world and East vs West... But the recent HK protests can be rationalized through this lens. I think respect for intellectual property and human rights will determine whether China continues it's march forward or not...
- dragonsh 7y agoWestern societies rise to prominence is due to acceptance of scientific temperament with a balanced moral view looking beyond religion and tribal mentality. They challenged the established religious groups and tribal rules. Traveled across oceans and built global trade. Property rights and all you described are just means which are just subservient not the main reason. China is moving forward due to the same scientific temperament, may be need to supplement more moral education to build a balance. But that's a normal process given it took out 1.4 billion people out of poverty and making them one of the largest middle income economy and slowly moving towards developed. You can see an example in India where all values you described are part of its constitution (probably the only nation where there is a chapter on human rights in its Constitution) and government proclaim to protect it. Still has one of the highest poverty levels in the world. India needs more scientific temperament to come out of its religious tribal mentality and need more science education. The problem you described of Hong Kong is its own making where people accepted living in prison cell size house and rely on get rich quick scheme when China was closed which doesn't work anymore. So it's just paying the price of its own choice.
- alienallys 7y agoWestern countries rose to prominence because they were built on Slaves, Colonies and Industrial revolution which was byproduct of World Wars. The India you're talking is India who got depleted, sucked, trampled country after 2 centuries of British hegemony. Stop your illogical and thinly vieled racism to justify why countries like India are the way they are like.