3 ms·
"even at a theory level, it imagines people as rational actors" There is a whole field of economics ('behavioural economics') that explicitly doesn't make this
by rahimnathwani 7y ago
"even at a theory level, it imagines people as rational actors"
There is a whole field of economics ('behavioural economics') that explicitly doesn't make this assumption.
- sprafa 7y agoThat’s the only scientific part about it but afaik it still only applies to micro not macroeconomics. To quote Charlie Munger: “it economics is not behavioural, what the hell is it?”
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoPolitics. Economics is persuasion. It's about some people telling other people how they should act "because". It's not descriptive or empirical, and never has been. The more honest economists will tell you it's considered part of moral philosophy.
- arethuza 7y agoI can recommend the book "Licence to be Bad: How Economics Corrupted Us" by Jonathan Aldred - it makes a pretty strong case that the way economics has influenced politics over the last few decades has had a pretty strong negative impact on society: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/43267091-licence-to-be-bad https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/43267091-licence-to-be-b...
- Nasrudith 7y agoMoral philosophy is a part of it and how it is often used but not all of it. It is possible to be objectively incorrect and it becomes rapidly apparent. Use fixed universal prices regardless of location and you /will/ have problems. The Soviets tried unsuccessfully to do a value calculation for their existence. Economics points out for instance that stopping smuggling without offering an alternative serves as a subsidy for the successful smugglers. Doing the math to point out that say a deflationary currency would eventually become worthless as a currency is likewise objective.
- longdelay 7y agoBehavioral economics is just a branch of psychology. A collection of trite rules of thumb relating to how people tend to act in certain "economic" situations. It makes for good reading in the Harvard Business Review.
- MiroF 7y agoIs this true? I've tried to find more depth than this and have admittedly struggled in the past
- longdelay 7y agoIt's really true. When you understand this, it makes you realize how shallow and empty so much of economics really is. Macro investing literature is what you should read if you want to understand the economy. It's less focused on high level concepts and more on specific data points and how they relate to and impact one another.
- jevgeni 7y agoNo, it's not. longdelay has their own interests and thinks that adherence to those interests defines the value of a branch of science for everyone.
- disgruntledphd2 7y agoSo, what became known as behavioural economics was 100% started by two psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. While they investigated new topics (i.e. economics), their methodologies were 100% within the standard practice of social and cognitive psychology at the time. They were then awarded the Nobel Prize for this work. Now, not everyone in the field came from psychology, but a lot did, and the methods used in behavioural economics are essentially indistinguishable from those used in psychology. For references, Thinking Fast and Slow is probably the best source, as one of the original authors describes their research program.
- jevgeni 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- acchow 7y agoThe problem is that this is basically all that behavioral economics is good for.