9 ms·
Let’s assume you believe a recession is coming. What’s your investment strategy to protect yourself? Two recessions ago (2001-2002) i invested in REITs through
by jedberg 7y ago
Let’s assume you believe a recession is coming. What’s your investment strategy to protect yourself?
Two recessions ago (2001-2002) i invested in REITs through the stock market. It worked really well and I doubled, but it turned out I just got lucky with exit timing because they were pump and dump schemes and I got out coincidentally just before the “dump”. I even got a payment from the class action lawsuit against them a few years later.
So, what’s an actual sound strategy if you think a recession is coming?
- jonstaab 7y agoI don't know anything about investing, but I keep thinking that if I had extra cash I'd short Google :D Seriously though, anyone with experience have opinions on this?
- rglover 7y agoI'm not an experienced investor but I'd highly recommend these books (ignore the titles, they sound cheesy but the information is great): Warren Buffett's 3 Favorite Books (light technical): https://www.amazon.com/Warren-Buffetts-Favorite-Books-Intelligent/dp/0982967624/ref=sr_1_7?keywords=warren+buffet+investment&qid=1565024674&s=gateway&sr=8-7 https://www.amazon.com/Warren-Buffetts-Favorite-Books-Intell... Warren Buffett Accounting (heavy technical): https://www.amazon.com/Warren-Buffett-Accounting-Book-Statements/dp/1939370159/ref=pd_bxgy_14_img_3/146-4556005-4124231?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=1939370159&pd_rd_r=c233f8d8-cd22-40e2-a976-2c7912510c7e&pd_rd_w=f8hkP&pd_rd_wg=F2tTg&pf_rd_p=a2006322-0bc0-4db9-a08e-d168c18ce6f0&pf_rd_r=Z3R0TJA4E07E76AQS86D&psc=1&refRID=Z3R0TJA4E07E76AQS86D https://www.amazon.com/Warren-Buffett-Accounting-Book-Statem... Podcast by the guys who wrote these: https://www.theinvestorspodcast.com/ https://www.theinvestorspodcast.com/
- TomGullen 7y agoIsn't the obvious answer cash/gold? Timing is everything though, recession incoming could 6 months, 18 months or 10 years away. And depends on your investment goals (EG if you're in your 30s and have it in a pension best let it be).
- nostromo 7y agoIf you think you can time the top, invest in gold and bonds. ... but that's probably a dumb thing to do. Instead I'd recommend staying in the market at all times, and diversifying. A good one is Ray Dalio's All Weather Portfolio: https://www.etftrends.com/fixed-income-channel/remember-all-weather-portfolio-having-killer-year/ https://www.etftrends.com/fixed-income-channel/remember-all-...
- Brushfire 7y agoMove into cash, so you're ready when the market drops.
- formercoder 7y agoAssuming a recession is definitely coming, soon, buy triple levered S&P 500 shorts. You better know exactly when "soon" is though.
- VikingCoder 7y agoThe market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
- alecb 7y agoDefensive ETFs (consumer staples, health care, utilities) along with diversified bonds. Investors also tend to migrate toward dividends during a recession. Note that health care is not as safe given the political climate. A few funds from the above to consider: VDC, FUTY, BLV, BND, VIG
- H8crilA 7y agoProper strategic asset allocation. There are strategies that work no matter what happens, such as the Ray Dalio's All Weather Portfolio: https://www.portfoliovisualizer.com/backtest-asset-class-allocation?s=y&mode=1&timePeriod=4&startYear=1972&firstMonth=1&endYear=2019&lastMonth=12&calendarAligned=true&initialAmount=10000&annualOperation=0&annualAdjustment=0&inflationAdjusted=true&annualPercentage=0.0&frequency=4&rebalanceType=1&absoluteDeviation=5.0&relativeDeviation=25.0&benchmark=VBINX&asset1=TotalStockMarket&allocation1_1=30&asset2=LongTreasury&allocation2_1=40&asset3=IntermediateTreasury&allocation3_1=15&asset4=Gold&allocation4_1=15&total1=100&total2=0&total3=0 https://www.portfoliovisualizer.com/backtest-asset-class-all... The standard approach of 60/40 stocks/bonds is not enough if you can't stomach 30% losses. And don't even think about going 100% stocks if you can't stomach 50% drops.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoYou probably thought this was obvious, but I just want to clarify for others what "works" means. It doesn't "work" in the sense of performing as well as, e.g., 100% stocks. It's actually not even close, for most start and endpoints. But if you buy at the top and want to sell at the bottom, this portfolio will not lose nearly as much value as stocks would.
- H8crilA 7y agoAll Weather works just as good as 60/40 (in the sense of returns) with way way less volatility. See my backtest link. It's also known as the risk parity portfolio. 100% stocks, while usually performing better, is not suitable for most investors. And yes that probably means you reading this comment. They will not be able to hold in times like 2008, they will sell instead of buying more. As "The Intelligent Investor" puts it: "Look into the mirror. That is the biggest risk you have - yourself.". I know I can't stomach 100% stocks (even 75% is very very scary) so I will probably never do that.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoI'm not sure whether I can or I can't. I guess I'll see. I'm in the fortunate position of having more than twice as much as I need for a very comfortable retirement already, and also of working for a company that hired and gave raises through the last recession. Knowing that even with a 50% decline I'll still have more than enough might make it easier for me to ride out the bad times than most people. The thing that's tough for me to stomach with the all weather portfolio is how much worse its results are in good times. If I had been invested in that since 2012 rather than my current asset mix, I'd have had only 33% as much growth as I have done during that period. Even backtesting against the peak in 2008, the all weather gives only about 80% as much growth to today.
- marktangotango 7y agoYou might want to look into "inverse short etf's". I personally don't invest in them because it requires a sizable position to make meaningful profit, and timing is very hard.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI understand what you're getting at, but this this horrible advice to the OP. Timing is not just "very hard", is extremely difficult, arguably approaching impossible depending on who you ask. I guarantee for the investor at the level of asking "What should I do in times of recession?" market timing IS impossible.
- saalweachter 7y agoWhat is your goal, when you say "protect yourself"? What is your timeline for your investment? Are you putting money in or taking money out? Do you want your temporary losses to be as low as possible throughout the decline, to make money on the decline, or to have the largest gains three years after the recession ends?
- maximente 7y agoto feel better or to perform better? feeling better: 100% cash. let the feeling of safety wash over you as the market continues to climb while you bathe in risk-free dollars (that are always depreciating due to Fed policy, but whatever). eventually, use your expertise in market timing to identify the hour the market bottoms out; scoop up assets at bargain levels. perform better: stay in the market, knowing that there are many more recessions ahead of you, that you can't time the market, and that time in market is by far the best predictor of long term performance. understand that if you aren't retiring soon, recessions are sort of like sales: the same companies still produce the same assets (Apple still makes hardware, ...), they're just valued less due to silly emotions. of course, if you're retiring soon or don't have outside income you may want to get out of stocks and into bonds, depending on your appetite for risk.
- goldenchrome 7y agoAs someone who has spent a long time researching personal investing, this is the correct answer.
- nostromo 7y agoDo people remember the "taper tantrum" or the correction in 2016? A curve inverted then (2016) too, and there was a lot of market volatility. There were even calls that "we're due for a recession!" https://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2016/02/03/the-yield-curve-inverted/ https://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2016/02/03/the-yield-curve-i... Then in 2017 and 2018 we saw record profits, low unemployment, and general economic gains all around.
- peteradio 7y agoAll while taking on massive governmental debt.
- vkou 7y agoThis is false. [1] The federal debt/gdp ratio has hardly changed in the past few years. The state + local government debt/gdp ratio has declined substantially over the last few years. The government, as a whole, is paying its debts down (Or not expanding them, as the economy expands around it.) If there's too much money sloshing around, it's not because Uncle Sam opened the checkbooks. It's because interest rates are near-zero. [1] https://www.usgovernmentdebt.us/state_debt https://www.usgovernmentdebt.us/state_debt
- reggieband 7y agoIn addition to this request ... my main concern lately is inflation. My suspicion is the next major North American crisis will be inflation. I see this already with housing prices in hot markets (SF, NY, Vancouver, Toronto) and the wages for high-tech workers in those markets. A good salary went from $150k to $500k a little bit too quickly, IMO (but maybe I'm just a grey beard and my sense of time is skewed). Given that the already low interests rates are likely on their way back to zero, and given China does not seem keen on continuing to fund the US through bond purchases (why would they if the US is engaging them in a trade war?), it seems high inflation is one possible result. What is the investment strategy in times of high inflation?
- Wellshit 7y agoGold, RE
- mrfredward 7y agoTo answer your question, if you're expecting a jump in inflation that others don't see coming, the key is not to own debt. Stocks can take a short term dip on inflation because it's bad economic news, but in the long run businesses will end up operating with proportionally higher revenues and expenditures, and as a result end up with proportionally higher stock prices. Real estate should go up proportionally (at least in theory). Gold sometimes jumps as people get into a "run for the hills" panic mentality. Debt, however, will be paid back in a now less valuable currency, so you'd be locked in to an inflation adjusted loss. Now to answer the question you didn't ask: most people who study the matter are more worried about deflation than inflation in the developed world, and making your whole investment strategy a big bet that economists, hedge-fund managers, and world leaders know less about the economy than you (and/or the pundits you see on TV) is usually not the way to go. Picking a boring mix of stock and bond index funds and sticking with it often serves people better.
- kitten_smuggler 7y agoBuying Bitcoin
- Izkata 7y ago
- datpuz 7y agoI'm in this boat. I've had too much cash sitting in a money market account for a couple of years in anticipation of a recession. I feel like the corporate tax cuts might have kicked the can down the road a little. It's a weird spot to be in and I'm still not sure what to do. I've lost a decent amount of money to inflation and opportunity cost. The feeling is as strong as ever but I know that macro trends aren't things anyone can accurately predict. I know there are better things I could do with the cash in the meantime, but I haven't done the research. I didn't really expect to be sitting on cash for such a long time. Would love to hear anyone's advice.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoFWIW people have been calling the top since as early as 2013. There is every reason to believe that there will be a recession tomorrow, but I also would not be surprised if this expansion extends into the early to mid 2020s. If you have this feeling now, and have had it for most of the current expansion, you might want to consider the possibility that your gut sense of whether there will be a recession is just broken, and whether you should stop listening to it. Because I guarantee you it's going to be telling you to get out of the market two or three years after the next expansion starts, and who knows how much money you're going to have left on the table by the time you're done with that one.
- datpuz 7y agoI've only been holding out since ~2017, but I definitely see your point. I know I'm probably being irrational by continuing to hold out, and I'm suffering a bit from the sunk cost fallacy. I guess I'm irrationally avoiding the situation where I held out for two years, only to buy in at the top, and look like a total doofus.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoI know a guy who is in a very similar situation, although he's been holding out since about '15. IMO, what looks smart is doing the thing that has the correct risk/reward tradeoff, even if you happen to lose the bet.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI don't know if "pimp and dump" was deliberate or a typo, but it's a beautifully accurate phrase.
- awinder 7y agoAll personal opinions and not advice but you can go topish to bottom and back to even on the 2009 recession in around 2 years, and that was a bad one. So if your investment horizon is in the +10 year range you can pretty safely just keep on trucking, dollar cost averaging will work it’s thing, if anything maybe buy the bottom with reserves.
- sp332 7y agoEveryone else is giving investing advice, so I'll throw in something different: pay off your debts. It's better to have some assets and some debts than it is to have no debts but low assets. But if you really think that your assets are about to decrease in value, you might as well use them now.
- granshaw 7y agoYup, if, say, you have a mortgage at 3.5%, paying principal off early is ~equivalent to a 3.5% risk-free rate
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe risk free rate is the interest rate you’re paying on loan minus interest that would be earned in a FDIC insured saving account (around 2.1% currently). Can use money market or high yield corporate bonds yields too. If you’re an educated, skilled professional who isn’t living a risky life, paying off a 3.5% mortgage is way too risk averse in my opinion. If you’re that worried, save 24 months of mortgage payments/expenses in a savings account, but if you’re not able to bounce back with even some income in 2 years (assuming you didn’t overbuy and aren’t paycheck to paycheck), then something has gone horribly wrong and you probably need to worry about more pressing matters than mortgage debt, like securing food.
- CPLX 7y agoIt’s even more favorable than that given the mortgage interest tax deduction.
- meritt 7y agoThat's irrelevant for the vast majority of Americans today due to the TCJA changes. It'll be interesting to see the final numbers when the IRS publishes the statistics, but it was estimated that 90% of households took the standard deduction in 2018.
- Someone1234 7y ago
- oarabbus_ 7y ago>So, what’s an actual sound strategy if you think a recession is coming? If you've made intelligent investments you believe in long-term, then the best strategy is to do nothing. Sit tight and wait it out, whether the recession lasts 1, 3, or 8 years.
- radcon 7y agoVanguard Prime Money Market (VMMXX) or Ally Savings account. My money will be in VMMXX just because I already had a Vanguard account open. Should get you ~2.2% return and getting your money out is relatively easy. IIRC you can even write checks against the account.
- webninja 7y ago+1 to the Vanguard money market fund. It’s been best in class for the last 10+ years.
- basch 7y agoLet's say your strategy is right and that if you could accurately predict a downturn, sell equity and buy REITs. The lesson to learn from last time is not to avoid REITs but to choose higher quality ones. Buy high quality US Core (USRT) and residential (REZ) and if you want to diversity further (REET) is 1/3rd global. Ive also left out ICF, REM, IYR. Blackrock alone has plenty of ways to stick your money in real estate.
- dharma1 7y agoWhy REITs before a downturn? Looks like USRT took a beating in the last crisis
- basch 7y agoI wasnt arguing it was a good strategy, I took part of the assumption that it was, as the premise. it was moreso that just cuz you got lucky and got in and out of a scam at the right times, that in and of itself doesnt invalidate the strategy itself. And like the other person commenting said, the 2008 crash was a real estate crash.
- kevinrpope 7y agoThe theory goes something like this: In a recession investors tend to have a "flight to quality", which usually means buying more government bonds, which pushes their interest rates lower. REITs tend to have relatively higher yields, so in comparison to government bonds, REITs become more attractive and their prices go up as well. In 2008 all real estate valuations were crushed due to the nature of the crisis, but real estate has historically been a pretty stable asset class in recessionary environments.
- dharma1 7y agoRight, perhaps real estate won't be such a focal point of the next recession (beyond a few bubble areas). So in terms of recession proof REITs - commercial or residential?
- 7y ago
- loeg 7y agoIt depends on your goals. Are you retiring in the next 5 years? If not, you mostly don't care. Odds are you aren't going to time the market perfectly and you might as well stay the course.
- OscarCunningham 7y agoBy the way, "recession" doesn't mean the same thing as "stock market crash". The definition of a recession requires GDP to go down for two consecutive quarters. Although there is some correlation it's still completely possible for GDP to go down while the market goes up. So even if you correctly predict a recession, you won't necessarily be able to predict the market.
- gnopgnip 7y agoCash, or gold would seem to be the answer but this is not the case. Invest a larger portion in bonds. Historically stocks and bonds are negatively correlated, and if stocks go down bonds go up, but at the same time both grow over time
- spectrum1234 7y agoSell stock to pay off debts. I just took out $50k from a ROTH IRA (all contributions not earnings so no penalty) to do this.