8 ms·
The Risk of Weak Online Banking Passwords
- n1000 7y agoI often wonder why not all websites (especially delicate ones like ebanking) do not show the number of failed login attempts since last successful login. That would raise awareness with users (ok, maybe scare some people) and give me some hints that my account may be under attack...
- overcast 7y agoThat's actually a great idea. Or how about a simple statistics email with a chart over time?
- rwmj 7y agoParticularly as they need to internally collect that information to comply with PCI (which requires financial orgs to lock accounts after 6 failed login attempts).
- askafriend 7y agoThis is the type of thing that sounds like a good idea in isolation but would be terrible in aggregate and over a long period of time.
- atoav 7y agoEven better: just show the last logins (both successful and failed). This way it also gives you a positive feel of security, because you can also see if e.g. a family member logged in etc.
- cat199 7y ago> (ok, maybe scare some people) This is probably why. The signal/noise ratio of people freaking out about 'their account being hacked' or 'bank xyzs terrible security because so many people hack my account every week' would probably completely overwhelm the security benefit. E.g: '10 failed logins? why are you letting other people try to log into MY account???' etc. Only way I could see this working is with industry wide support and a mass awareness campaign, and even then people would be annoyingly confused. (possibly worthwhile though)
- segmondy 7y agoUnless you have a very unique login, you are going to often seen login attempts. Common names such as john, john123, john234, johnq, qjohn will happen more often especially for a big site. This will probably give rise to support calls to the bank...
- choward 7y agoThen you'll learn that your username is one that's under attack and that it's even more important to have a strong password. Put some useful documentation on the login page that explains it. What's wrong with that?
- segmondy 7y ago2FA and be done with it.
- levythe 7y ago2fa is not magical. It makes an attack require more complexity, but it's not an "and be done with it," solution.
- lazzlazzlazz 7y agoHave you seen how severely 2FA drops the rate of unauthorized accesses? It's incredible. What have you seen that moves you to hedge on the value of 2FA?
- u801e 7y agoFor one thing, the SIM swap attack [1] [1] https://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/sim-swap/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/sim-swap/ In general, relying on a second factor whose security practices aren't the best, could actually compromise security compared to having a strong and unique password. I personally wish that more banks would support 2FA authentication using a username/password in combination witH TLS client side certificates.
- patio11 7y agoBecause this would result in tens of millions of calls to the CS team to the general effect of "OMG someone is trying to hack my account!!! Do something!" to no purpose and decrease the adoption of a technology which materially increases per-user revenue and decreases per-user costs.
- jxcl 7y agoSo my understanding is that ultimately the bank is responsible for any loss on my end as a result of someone breaking into my bank account, therefore I don't really care if my banks don't follow best security practices. I guess it's probably more complicated than that, so perhaps someone more knowledgeable can expand on what I can expect to happen if someone steals money from my bank accounts because of one of the vulnerabilities in the article?
- inetknght 7y ago> So my understanding is that ultimately the bank is responsible for any loss on my end as a result of someone breaking into my bank account, therefore I don't really care if my banks don't follow best security practices. Remember that when you need to take a week off of work to deal with your bank after a breach zeroed your account. Remember that when you can't pay your bills during that time and miss a car/house payment.
- cascom 7y agoSeems like another checking account with a month's worth of expenses in it could be a prudent idea.
- rzzzt 7y agoUnless it is also broken into...
- Aloha 7y agoOr a month worth of cash.
- koolba 7y agoMultiple accounts are a must. If you’re smart about it, you also won’t set up any kind of electronic transfer between them. Otherwise if one is hijacked the crook could initiate an ACH from the other accounts.
- stordoff 7y ago
- peterwwillis 7y agoI was trying to remember wtf the name of the new MFA standard that Chrome supports was, and it took me 10 minutes of Googling to find it (U2F[1]). If a security nerd can't even remember the name of the thing that's supposed to replace passwords, regular users will never figure it out. You want to get rid of passwords? Stop allowing users to manage them. Make a browser plug-in support U2F, make it auto-generate passwords for sites, make it manage them internally. When you go to login to Chase, the browser will fill in the login details, after it has verified this is the Actual Real Site and not a phishing site. All access to this auth data will be based on a master password entered into the user's browser at start-up. To reset an individual site's auth creds, the site can send a re-auth e-mail to the user. When the user clicks through, they can use the site's preferred verification process to show they are the real user. The browser can then generate and save new auth details for the site. At no time did the user ever enter a password, but strong authentication data is still being managed independently per-site, the user can still reset any given site's auth details, and the user only has to manage one strong password on their client machine at start-up time. They can also use U2F with a second device for MFA. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_2nd_Factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_2nd_Factor
- laken 7y ago> Make a browser plug-in support U2F https://krypt.co/ https://krypt.co/
- Avamander 7y agoOr countries could solve the issue for their citizens instead of making everyone invent their own, like Estonia and quite a few other european countries have. By providing a physical card (or SIM) that allows people to log in where they want.
- JoshTriplett 7y agoMany people will not want "help" from a government to authenticate and logging in to a non-government site.
- yboris 7y agoThank you for the PSA -- I just changed my old insecure password!
- whatshisface 7y ago>even if your bank offers multi-factor authentication as part of its login process All of my banks have security questions. This protects me by combining a password with some other passwords that are public information and that I can't change.
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoOr possibly even replacing the former with the latter.
- NickBusey 7y agoYou by no means have to give your real information. I recommend using something like Bitwarden's passphrase generator so all your answers are things like `concise myth bird`. This way they are A: actually secure, and B: easily pronounceable, so that just saying "a bunch of letters and numbers" to a phone tech shouldn't work as I've heard people complain can happen when using normal passwords (e.g., c9b21s1qzs) for these fields.
- maccard 7y agoMy banks "security questions" were my DOB and my country of birth - verified against my passport. Not really much help.
- seandougall 7y agoHey, at least those are immutable and memorable facts. Not great from the standpoint of adding security, certainly, but I'd rather have that than things like "who is your favorite band", which I'll have no hope of reproducing five years from now, and which will only serve to lock me out of my own account.
- stordoff 7y agoInaccurate but plausible is the advice I've been given for these. My bank insists on a "memorable name" (was formerly "mother's maiden name" - I confirmed it didn't have to be accurate), so I use one that was basically picked out of a hat, which has no connection to me or my family.
- un_montagnard 7y agoI have a bank account whose username is a number and password is also a number. Good thing is you need to click on a randomly distributed keypad to input your password. /s
- jrimbault 7y agoMine too. Which is also my employer (you can find out who that is easily). ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Since both number are sent (separately) via physical mail, all you'd have to do to get them would be to wait around in front on the mailbox when the postman come, ask him he's got mail for Mr X, repeat for a few days until you get the monthly report sheet, on this document will be the first number. Now go online, ask for a new password. Wait around the mail box for the new password to arrive. The mailman will just think "oooh Mr X is such a good person, always saying good morning". Chances are the victim doesn't have any alarms set up on their phone. I have alarms set up.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoNot just weak passwords, but reusued ones (which to me is an equal sin)
- darkhorn 7y agoThen why there is no law for 2FA in the banks? In Turkey all banks must provide 2FA for logins. It is required by law.
- dredmorbius 7y agoKrebs has covered this previously; oligopoly service providers. See his excellent, if depressing, 2018 exploration of banking security, "What Is Your Bank’s Security Banking On?".[1] Sadly, the industry is dominated by a small handful of banking platform providers. Four, Fiserv, Jack Henry, FIS, and CSI, serv over 80% of the market. Bank regulators, responding to Krebs, said that "small to mid-sized banks are massively beholden to their platform providers, and many banks simply accept the defaults instead of pushing for stronger alternatives." This is not a good situation. Digging further into the matter, I turned up a set of publications by Experian -- the credit rating agency which hasn't been breached ... yet -- on risk and fraud, including credential compromise.[2] One of these mentions in. passing that the typical person has "about 100" service-based accounts.[3] That's not all that far off the count of 700 accounts HN users have reported having.[4] ________________________________ Notes: 1. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/03/what-is-your-banks-security-banking-on/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/03/what-is-your-banks-secur... (HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203482) 2. Stealthily hidden around Experian's website, though this search presently lists several of the beter ones: https://www.experian.com/innovation/thought-leadership/fraud.. https://www.experian.com/innovation/thought-leadership/fraud.... (https://web.archive.org/web/*/https://www.experian.com/innov... https://web.archive.org/web/*/https://www.experian.com/innov...) 3. "Upcoming fraud trends and how to combat them: Ebook" https://www.experian.com/innovation/thought-leadership/upcom.. https://www.experian.com/innovation/thought-leadership/upcom.... 4. packet_nerd reports that here, though I recall an earlier mention as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19488899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19488899
- mikestew 7y agoThere at least used to be in the U. S. (Haven't worked in that space in ten years, and haven't kept up.) Worked on a 2FA system just as such a law was going into place (too lazy to look it up; call me on it, and I'll take the five minutes.) Woo hoo, do I want to go Ferrari or Lambo? Banks are going to have to use something, and ours is hardware-free and works on any browser. "Wait a minute...what? Match-the-picture and security questions are going to count as '2FA'?! Are you fucking kidding me?" I still work for a living, and drive something Japanese, not Italian. I have no idea what current status is in the U. S.
- umvi 7y agoGood thing my bank artificially imposes length restrictions so that my password is exactly between 8-12 characters
- nesky 7y agoThis aggravates me beyond belief. I have more secure passwords on random sites/accounts than I do on my financial accounts. Why do banks insist on restricting character limits to 12 - 20 characters?
- outworlder 7y ago> Why do banks insist on restricting character limits to 12 - 20 characters? Because they are not hashing your password, therefore it needs to fit in plain text in their database column.
- citiworse 7y agoCitibank is even worse. I use a password manager and have used a 20+ character password for years. Every now and then, as happened a few months ago, they change the website in a way that breaks long passwords. So even though my password manager entered it correctly, it rejected my password until I had to reset it.
- seandougall 7y agoSame. At least they fixed the issue (years ago, to be fair) where you could log into your Citibank account and tweak the URL to see other customers' data...
- choward 7y agoMy favorite is when they truncate it without telling you. It's a better UX though!
- mikeash 7y agoMine silently truncates to 8 characters and does a case insensitive comparison. Good thing they have all the liability....
- BjoernKW 7y agoBanks unfortunately often have deplorably backward as well as arbitrary password rules such as: "Your password must not be longer than 8 characters and must not contain any of these characters '@', '&', '/', '('." ...
- Scoundreller 7y agoUp until recently, a big Canadian bank only allowed 6 character passwords, and mapped whatever you typed into 6 numbers (e.g. Aa-Dd = 0).
- perl4ever 7y agoSome financial institutions have rules like that for user names. Like, it has to contain a number even if your name is unique, etc.
- nesky 7y agoWhy doesn't Google or Apple have 'explain like I'm 5' explanations of how their password managers work? I don't use either service but this is a MAJOR opportunity to encourage their users to use a password manager and subsequently make their users more secure online. I'm a big proponent of using a password manager and if I even remotely mention using iCloud Keychain or Google's password manager, people have zero idea what I'm talking about.
- matt-attack 7y agoI agree. It’s odd that an article this technical goes on to recommend (or at least enumerate popular) password managers, but doesn’t mention Apple’s own KeyChain. It’s built into all iPhones and MacOS computers for god’s sake. I personally don’t use any 3rd party password managers. I find KeyChain to work amazingly. There’s even a FireFox plugin that supports it.
- WorldMaker 7y agoA problem is that most users are likely in a mixed computing household, such as using an iPhone and a Windows Desktop. It would be a lot easier to suggest to some of my family, for instance, to use KeyChain if they had a good Windows client. (With the recent modern iCloud update in the Microsoft Store, I could even see this possibly happening, as opposed to the many years where iTunes for Windows was an afterthought.)
- neighbour 7y agoWhat FireFox plugin is that? I've been looking for a solution to this for ages.
- tfha 7y agoKeyChain is not an open standard and is not easily interoperable with other strategies or products. You shouldn't build best practice out of a single company's walled garden.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 7y agoHonestly I'm more worried about remembering my username...13 digit numeric sequence. Nice one Mr Bank. Trying to fight my way back in after emigrating put a lot of worries at ease. Voice printing, secret code words, security questions, 2FA, passwords...omg just let me in. Nobody's getting in there...I just hope I don't lose access.
- black_puppydog 7y agoMy bank (BNP) opted to force me to click on big clear text buttons instead of typing my login code. And yes, it's a six digit numeric code. So the username is a clear text field, and you could read my code from 5m away without zooming while I login. Should I ever get scammed on this account, I'll claim that their security BS must have been the entry and let them try and disprove that.
- skunkworker 7y agoI'm still annoyed that one of my banks, only offers 2 factor though email & sms and doesn't offer TOTP. Does anyone know if this is a PCI thing or is it just bureaucracy?
- crgwbr 7y agoI’ve spent a good bit of time reading PCI requirements and I can’t think of anything that’d prevent using TOTP or Yubikey type devices. My guess is that they don’t implement it because they don’t think anyone would use it. Honestly I can’t say they’re wrong either—I’d love to use a Yubikey on my bank accounts, but I can’t imagine anyone else in my circle of non-programmer friends/family doing so.
- Rafert 7y agoWith WebAuthn it doesn't have to be a USB fob - it can be built into your device too.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI had a colleague who always knew, to the quarter, how long he had been working there. During the quarterly password changes, he'd increment the numbers ;)
- ryanthedev 7y agoChase doesn't allow special chars. Lmao.
- jobigoud 7y agoMy bank has a "helpful" mobile app secured by a 6 digit code. The worst part is that some sensitive operations like adding an external wire transfer target and changing transfer ceilings can be done from the app and only from the app.