6 ms·
Because the advantages are obvious, what are the disadvantages of killing all mosquitoes?
by tomrod 7y ago
Because the advantages are obvious, what are the disadvantages of killing all mosquitoes?
- BurningFrog 7y agoIt's not even that. There are only a few mosquito species that can carry the malaria parasite. If we exterminate them, they will/can be replaced by other, hard to distinguish mosquito species. We now have the technology to do that, but aren't (yet) doing it, even though it kills over a million people a year. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/mosquitos-crispr https://www.wired.co.uk/article/mosquitos-crispr
- littlestymaar 7y ago> even though it kills over a million people a year. It doesn't actually. It kills around 400,000 a year, mostly because of poor medical infrastructure. That's roughly the same amount of death than the flue (a little more in average), and it kills really little people who have access to modern medicine. For a strange reason I don't get, Malaria is way more “popular” in the western world than other diseases like tuberculosis which cause much more deaths each year (4 times more deaths, less than a tenth of the media coverage).
- Something1234 7y agoIs there something more terrifying about maleria over tb?
- BurningFrog 7y agoI haven't counted myself, but UNICEF says it's over a million: https://www.unicef.org/health/files/health_africamalaria.pdf https://www.unicef.org/health/files/health_africamalaria.pdf Also "An estimated 300-600 million people suffer from malaria each year." I'd speculate that malaria seems more fixable than TB.
- littlestymaar 7y agoIdk where the discrepancy comes from, but I trust WHO[1] more than UNICEF on this kind of topics. About our ability to fix the issue: I agree with you, and that's why I really don't like the idea of something as extreme as eradication of a whole specie with gene drive for something that's mainly an infrastructure/underdevelopment issue in Africa. [1]: https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/malaria https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/malaria
- BurningFrog 7y agoOnly about 40 of the 3500 mosquito species are able to spread malaria, so eradicating those would very likely only result in the other 3460 taking over their habitats. Unless you're concerned with the survival of the parasite itself? I'm confused by infrastructure/underdevelopment argument. Malaria wasn't eradicated in the rich world through health care. We mass slaughtered our mosquitos until the problem was gone.
- littlestymaar 7y agoI'm not too much concerned about those 40 species. What I'm concerned about is the Sorcerer's Apprentice behavior. Gene drive is an incredibly powerful tool and we don't know what could go wrong if we tried to use it to wipe-out a specific species. Actually, the «Species» concept is a scientific model, but we know it's simplistic: inside a given species, not all the individuals have the same genes[1] (I'm not talking about alleles here) and we know that some distinct species can mate together and have fertile offspring [2], so we can't know for sure that the gene drive won't affect other species as well. It could even wipe out the entire family of mosquitoes. Using this kind of untested nuclear tool to fight a not-so-big issue that have been successfully fought everywhere but in Africa is not a responsible move, that's my point. Also: > Malaria wasn't eradicated in the rich world through health care. We mass slaughtered our mosquitos until the problem was gone. Anopheles Atroparvus (Western Europe), Anopheles Messae (North-eastern Europe), Anopheles Quadrimaculatus (Eastern-US), and Anopheles Freeborni (West coast) are still here[3], but you don't have malaria there anymore. We killed a lot of mosquitoes to get rid of malaria, but we didn't have to kill them all to eradicate the epidemics. The thing is: malaria doesn't come from the mosquitoes only. To get a malaria epidemics, you need a pool of sick people the mosquitoes bite and get infected. Once you fixed the epidemics, the mosquitoes aren't an issue anymore. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan-genome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan-genome [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beefalo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beefalo [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anopheles#/media/File:Anopheles-range-map.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anopheles#/media/File:Anophele...
- wetpaws 7y agoThis changes everything. 400k people a year is a penny change, I'm sure we can safely ignore them.
- littlestymaar 7y agoIt's not about the number in itself, it's about the causes: Gene drive enthusiasts say: “this is a dramatic issue which need extreme bio-engineering to solve it because we have no other solutions”. Whereas in reality, it's a concerning health issue (but much less concerning at a global scale than cigarettes or mere junk food) that's almost fixed worldwide with conventional means (health infrastructures, local mosquitoes elimination, bug nets, and there's even a pilot program for a vaccine with promising results) and would have been solved if Africa wasn't in such a poor shape in term of development. For the record, the whole western Europe is infested with Anopheles Atroparvus[1] which is a vector for malaria (and have been a source of many malaria epidemics in Europe in the past) yet there is no more malaria there nowadays, and in some places with high levels of water pollution it has even been considered an endangered specie and is slowly recovering. [1]: https://ecdc.europa.eu/en/disease-vectors/facts/mosquito-factsheets/anopheles-atroparvus https://ecdc.europa.eu/en/disease-vectors/facts/mosquito-fac...
- wetpaws 7y agoLess dead people is better then more dead people regardless of how you would look at this.
- alluro2 7y agoFor the sake of argument - what about more alive people, but with more dead animals / species and with failing ecosystems if something would not go quite as foreseen with crispr method? That question is becoming more and more important as humanity has such larger potential of affecting the rest of nature - how much more valuable is human life over everything else on the planet...
- jdsully 7y agoBecause we are tantalizingly close to eradicating it. The low death rate is a sign of success not a signal to stop.
- littlestymaar 7y agoI'm not talking about stopping or anything. What I'am saying is : 1- The malaria issue is depicted as bigger than it is nowadays, as if the western world has some kind of weird fetish about it. 2- Maybe using world-changing genetic engineering is not really worth it, as we already made huge progress toward the solution without using such a extreme solution.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoMalaria impacts swathes of prime tropical beach land useful for building vacation resorts for rich people. On the other hand, most people associate tuberculosis with Russian jails.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThere's still an issue with Zika and West Nile. And other unknown or future mosquito borne diseases.
- Scoundreller 7y agoFewer predators of mosquitoes (dragon flies? Larvae eating fish, bats). They eat nectar, so something else would have to take their place in pollinisation (probably no problem). Increased population of mosquito prey - livestock, humans. Overall, sounds like a risk worth taking.
- learc83 7y agoTheir are far more mosquito species that don't bite humans, those species would almost certainly fill the gap.
- Scoundreller 7y agoBut will they still fly around my ears as I’m trying to sleep? If so, in the bin they go.
- amelius 7y agoUse earplugs.
- wmeredith 7y agoAnnoying is a far different proposition than plague-spreading.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIf you can solve one, we're not much further from solving the other. People do a lot to solve annoying. Here's Winnipeg Canada's Nuisance Mosquito Fogging Program: https://winnipeg.ca/publicworks/insectcontrol/mosquitoes/nuisanceschedule.stm https://winnipeg.ca/publicworks/insectcontrol/mosquitoes/nui...
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoGet over it.
- ip26 7y ago
- Tiktaalik 7y agoWhen has humans meddling in ecologies ever worked fine without huge negative side effects?
- cm2012 7y agoOff the top of my head: Eliminating hookworm in the USA. Bringing wolves back to Yellowstone.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoWe can probably strike wolves off the list since it's a restorative act. In Yellowstone's natural state prior to human intervention it had wolves were part of the ecology. The general way meddling in ecologies goes is that humans remove or add something and the entire ecology becomes grossly distorted. (Eg. Driving Sea Otters to near extinction creates a bloom of Sea Urchins, which devastate ocean habitat of so many other species etc etc)
- diggernet 7y agoExcellent point. Let us also strike eradicating invasive species from the list for being a restorative act. And then proceed with eliminating the Aedes mosquito from most of the places it is now found.
- namdnay 7y agoEradicating smallpox?
- coldtea 7y agoWell, let's not celebrate our success on the war just after a battle was won, let's wait for the next battles first. We could have just made things worst and more threatening... https://www.reactgroup.org/antibiotic-resistance/the-threat/ https://www.reactgroup.org/antibiotic-resistance/the-threat/ https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/antibiotic-resistance https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/antibiotic-... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4378521/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4378521/
- coldtea 7y agoThe fact that we know almost nothing about complex environmental chains and interactions, and we have made huge messes almost any time we attempted to mess with such a system (either on purpose or not). Of course, Earth in the end will be fine (it will reach some other equilibrium), but tons of us might be wiped out in the process.
- jdsully 7y agoCan you point to any other species we’ve eradicated that has resulted in a massive human death toll? From my perspective we seem to be pretty good at killing things and getting away with it.
- coldtea 7y agoIf those things are creatures like tigers, living in isolated environments, yes. If they are creatures that live all around the environment and play into special roles, then no. E.g. http://sos-bees.org/situation/ http://sos-bees.org/situation/
- nine_k 7y agoWe of course should not eradicate all mosquitoes. We need to only eradicate the blood-sucking types. Many mosquitoes do not suck blood; they eat plant products and / or suck plant juices. They could take over the ecological niche of the blood-sucking varieties, and can even be cultivated a little bit to support the local mosquito-eating populations of birds, bats, dragonflies, etc.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoNatural ecosystems are notorious for unintended consequences of intervention.