11 ms·
Motion smoothing is ruining cinema
- comboy 7y agoTo me it's like music creators telling people not to listen to their music on v-shaped headphones. Yeah, it's not what you intended. But that's what they've chosen to use. Also, if they want the picture to be displayed in a certain way, couldn't they push they movie as 60/frames per second where in fact it's 24/frames per second with static frames? Wouldn't that effectively disable motion smoothing?
- jacobush 7y agoThat solution sound incredibly convoluted. Besides, the next (or current?) generation TVs would probably analyse the frames anyway.
- comboy 7y agoIt's just a few additional bits since everything is compressed anyway.
- mrob 7y ago60 isn't an integer multiple of 24, so it would result in uneven frame timing. It would look worse than playing 24fps with every frame shown for the same time, which modern TVs can do.
- mwfunk 7y agoNobody’s telling anyone to do anything. The problem people are talking about is that this setting looks like absolute garbage and it’s inexplicably turned on by default on almost all TVs these days. The only people who think otherwise are people who just literally do not care at all about picture quality and probably also do stuff like stretching the picture to get rid of letterboxing. These are not the people that default settings should be based on.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoQuite an opinion you've got there. I too think the smoothing is odd, but I'm over 35.
- mwfunk 7y agoI'm certain age has nothing to do with it. The only thing that determines someone's opinion here is how much they care about accurate AV reproduction, and that's not driven by age, only passion for the content.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoIt's possible those who will grow up with higher frame rates will consider the smoothing normal. And they may consider 24fps choppy. Time will tell.
- mwfunk 7y agoI wonder if we're focusing on two different things here. I'm not thinking so much about the merits of the 24fps video experience vs. the 60fps video experience. I'm just focused on clean playback of the source content. If something was recorded in 24fps, I want to see it in 24fps. If something was recorded in 60fps, want to see it in 60fps. I'm more complaining about the automatic 24->60 (or 120 or 240) conversion that's enabled by default on a lot of new TVs. I'm not at all opposed to higher frame rate video, I like it. I've just never watched something on a TV where the 24->60 conversion didn't look significantly worse to me than playback at the native frame rate. Maybe my unconscious assumption is that people's preferences about the ideal frame rate can change over the years, but that reinterpolating the video to a different frame rate will always look worse than native, regardless of the source and destination frame rates. Maybe this isn't true, but that is my assumption.
- brokenmachine 7y agoIf it says 200Hz on the box, it must be better than the one that's only 120Hz, right? This is the amount of research people do before buying something they'll stare at for 4h per day for the next 5 years... Never mind that the native framerate of the panel is only 60Hz. This is why we get Vivid HDR mode ("Torch mode") and motion smoothing enabled by default.
- giobox 7y agoThat has its own issues - you can’t completely “smoothly” convert 24FPS source material to 60FPS, and many viewers can detect the uneven frame cadence when this is done due to the inconsistent introduction of extra frames to get it to fit the 60FPS cadence. You can often see it in slow panning shots, were it introduces a perceptible judder to the video. While the Wikipedia article on 3:2 pulldowns mainly discusses converting 24FPS film to 30/60 FPS broadcast, the same conversion is virtually always done on digital material as well, in software at playback time or by the video codec changing the frame rate. As mrob also writes, you only get smooth frame rate changes usually if the new frame rate is an integer multiple of the original one, as then the extra frames introduced is consistent. This is why 30FPS video doesn’t have this problem at 60hz, but 24FPS does. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down
- atoav 7y agoAnd to me it is like a painter complaining about a museum which shines a RGB-Disco-Light onto a piece of work whose colors have been purposefully considered. Music as well as Films are pieces of work who are only really existing in their projection, a playthrough or a concert. Everything that mangles with that projection without beeing a willful choice of those projecting it makes it harder for artists to speak to an audience in the way they intended. There are perfectly fine reasons to change a projection, e.g. for the or visually impaired or because you just prefer it that way, but ultimately it should be a willful decision to deviate from the expected default..
- PorterDuff 7y agoI take it that you aren't a fan of pan and scan.
- atoav 7y agoIndeed : )
- comboy 7y agoIt's not a cinema. So it's not a painter complaining about a museum. It's a painter complaining about the light in your living room. I understand the artist, but most people won't get best of anything. You don't see coffee companies complaining about your grinder settings even though you definitely could get a better taste if you only paid attention.
- lagadu 7y agoThe root cause of the problem is cinema still using 24fps instead of a proper standard in 2019 (with a rare exception here and there).
- mrob 7y ago100% agreed. 24fps is far too low for fast motion. People in the industry talk about "art" to justify their low frame-rate, but I don't believe them for a moment. 24fps lets film-makers get away with sloppy technique that would be exposed if we could actually see moving things clearly. 24fps is cost-cutting. TV makers are just trying their best to improve things under the constraint of bad quality source material. Motion smoothing isn't perfect, but I'm not convinced it's worse than the alternative.
- zzzcpan 7y ago60 fps is probably not that important for most movies and tv shows though, but it's a bit annoying to watch music videos at 24 fps.
- tgb 7y agoI agree that we should move past 24fps. Panning shots judder to my eyes in a very unpleasant way, even if not panning particularly quickly. It's not just action shots that suffer at the low frame rate. If people hate it because they're used to 24fps, well, then they'll get used to a new standard soon enough.
- andybak 7y agoIt's just peculiar that all the director's named in that article and almost everyone I know who thinks in any depth about this issue disagrees with you. It's conceivable I might "get used to it" but that's like telling someone who hates cilantro that that will "get used to it". They don't want to and neither do I.
- mrob 7y agoIt's not peculiar in the slightest when, as Upton Sinclair famously put it, "it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." The industry is under increasing financial pressure (e.g. see https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/why-hollywood-as-we-know-it-is-already-over https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/why-hollywood-as-we-... ), so why increase costs when customers are still buying 24fps material?
- DogOnTheWeb 7y agoThe ultimate solution here, I think, is to allow creators to encode the desired setting, frame rate, or content category in the metadata so that a user can benefit from the technology when watching sports without it detracting from a film later on. Then the default setting could be "auto" and diehards could override one way or the other. I'm glad to see a brief tip to that solution in the article and hope it becomes part of an industry specification.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vegetablepotpie 7y agoAn industry standard media meta data interface for motion smoothing would be the best solution. It may not necessarily make it to the TV industry though. Although industry standards have been made and adopted widely before (such as USB) there are plenty of other standards that have failed to be adopted (FireWire) despite technological superiority (data rates). The standard didn’t really give a company much advantage by adopting it, USB worked well enough for most use cases and Apple wanted too much in royalties. Ultimately any decision a company makes is about money. From the article “It’s meant to create a little bit of eye candy in the store”. TV companies think Motion smoothing increases sales. It doesn’t matter what film directors say about it. The reality is that TV manufacturers are making a commodity, they don’t want to be. No one wants to sell a commodity, there’s no money in it. It’s a constant race to the bottom on price. That’s why we see 3D TVs, curved TVs and a myriad of gimmicks. Everyone wants to differentiate themselves. If there’s a new industry standard that makes consumers and content creators happy, who cares? If I hire an engineer to implement it will it be worth it?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wernerb 7y agoTurned off the "feature" as soon as Tv was on. Have been advising friends and adjusting their expensive oled TV's as well. In every case they were grateful for me "fixing" their TVs which only took a few minutes. People just don't want to muddle around in the settings. And here lies the problem. It would be great if manufacturers would open up their interface settings to be influenced more easily by mediaplayers or settup boxes. Those in turn, could have a ruleset: if 24p, then disable motion blur if else enable motion blur. If sports enable motion blur. And so on. It's not even limited to motion blur, I have low light and normal light profiles I'd like to have changed automatically based on the actual light in my room.
- mrob 7y agoMotion smoothing is designed to reduce motion blur. It doesn't always work, because it's just heuristic processing that attempts to estimate the missing information, but when the motion is easily predictable (pans are an obvious case), and the exposure time (shutter angle) is low, it can do an excellent job of interpolating the missing frames. This eliminates the sample-and-hold blur[0] that would otherwise appear. It's motion sharpening, not motion blur. [0] Blur Busters has a good introduction, that's relevant to all non-flickering displays, not just OLED: https://www.blurbusters.com/faq/oled-motion-blur/ https://www.blurbusters.com/faq/oled-motion-blur/
- NullPrefix 7y agoSensible defaults, oh where did I heard that from?
- nemosaltat 7y agoI work in the lighting control industry. Your final paragraph piques my interest. I’m curious, why automatically change the TV if you could automatically change the room? Shades drop, light intensity lowers, CCT warms, etc...?
- iforgotpassword 7y agoMost people aren't exclusively using their TV to watch movies. When turning on the TV in the afternoon to watch your favorite soap opera with finest motion smoothing, you might not bother that much and just want the TV to be a little brighter.
- lousken 7y agoI've tried SVP which is motion interpolation software and while anime looks amazing, it totally destroys any real motion picture.
- korm 7y agoWhat TV manufacturers are doing is unacceptable. It introduces strange artifacts and the motion looks very artificial compared to a native 60fps video. So it really doesn't solve anything. The argument that it's the filmmakers' fault for using 24fps is flawed. What about animation? What about stop motion? Those may never be produced at a higher framerate. Movies with high VFX budgets will be much more expensive due to the additional frames when rotoscoping and compositing. So if it is inferior and only makes sense for a subset of productions, why is it the default?
- mrob 7y agoIn many cases the bulk of the VFX budget is artist wages, not CPU time. If you already have the motion paths set up then it doesn't take much more human effort to render more intermediate frames. You might even be able to reduce the cost per frame by exploiting the smaller differences between frames, e.g. with temporal noise reduction. Hand drawn or hand posed animation is the rare case where increased frame-rate really would take more human effort, but it's often already produced at extra-low framerate (e.g. 12fps or 8fps), with frames duplicated for playback. The same duplication can happen with higher playback framerates. Modern video codecs handle duplicated frames well.
- korm 7y agoThat's why I specifically referred to rotoscoping and compositing, not rendering. The artist has to edit frame by frame.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoAnd yet many fully computer-generated movies today are converted to 3D in post, rather than being created in 3D in the first place. For CGI movies, doing 3D at creation time gives better results and requires zero human labor (it's just a translation of the camera's matrix), so why isn't it always done?
- Mathnerd314 7y agoCG movies are created in 3D, they use 3D modeling software. There's nothing to "convert" to 3D unless they lose the original models and have to retrace them or something. Which apparently is a quite common occurrence, according to some articles on the 2D to 3D conversion of Toy Story and Shrek. So collateral damage from capitalism is the main explanation for old movies. For new movies, where there is proper data, the 3D camera for each scene still requires more than "zero human labor"; you have to specify the inter-ocular distance, convergence plane, and tweak the scene a little for cinematic effect or 3D weirdness. And since there are thousands of shots, and the work is fairly tedious, it makes little sense to work on it in parallel with 2D during production when shots might just be cut entirely. So you end up with a bias towards 2D or 3D during the creation process. Dreamsworks apparently has a made-for-3D animated movie division (https://animatedviews.com/2007/dreamworks-goes-3d/ https://animatedviews.com/2007/dreamworks-goes-3d/), where presumably they are flattened to 2D in post. Reviews of their movies (https://www.3dor2d.com/reviews/how-train-dragon-hidden-world-3d-3-d-movie-review https://www.3dor2d.com/reviews/how-train-dragon-hidden-world...) unsurprisingly say "great use of 3D". Since that's the goal of the division I'd expect them to continue doing 3D-first movies. In contrast Pixar so far has stuck to a more 2D style. In this interview (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HepIGDJK98s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HepIGDJK98s) their stereo guy says they do 3D in post. The 3D in their movies is described as "well done but a minor aspect" (https://www.3dor2d.com/reviews/Toy-Story-4-3D-3-D-Movie-Review https://www.3dor2d.com/reviews/Toy-Story-4-3D-3-D-Movie-Revi...). In the interview the guy basically says that he could use more 3D but he's more concerned with keeping the director happy so he doesn't. Pixar is now focusing on originals so maybe one of their next films will be 3D oriented. But they're making tons of money anyway so who knows if the right director will come along.
- MikusR 7y agoAnd ebook readers that allow changing of fonts are ruining book publishing.
- tgb 7y agoI can't tell if you're joking, but I purchased a math text book as an undergrad that I needed last-minute as a Kindle ebook and it was an awful mistake, in part because of text reflow. You'd see a formula at the top of a page but days later when you went back to look for it it would now be at the bottom because the text had reflowed. It really threw things off. There were other problems: the index was garbled and useless (it still had the page numbers of the paper book in it and the formatting was completely off), the text could be resized but the formulas were rasterized and did not scale with the text and were frankly hideous. This was form a major publisher. I'd much rather have had a PDF. But for novels, changing font size and hence reflow of text are super nice.
- _nalply 7y agoTo help you, perhaps you can get the PDF from Library Genesis. Google "libgen", then enter the title or ISBN of your book.
- coldtea 7y agoWhooooshh.... (way to miss the point)
- tgb 7y agoA year or two ago, the TV my roommates and I had would give weird artefacts while watching sports. I wasn't sure if it was the TV or the broadcast but the effects were things like people's eyes would move relative to their head or the logo on the shirt would move relative to the shirt. They'd sort of bounce up and down. Is this motion smoothing? My guess at the time was it was an image stabilization algorithm put on by the studio since sports broadcasts involve long-range videography. Presumably the logo or eyeballs were getting "stabilized" in place while the rest of the person wasn't, making them appear to jiggle up and up down compared to the person's movement. It was eerie. But these were major sports streams, like world series baseball, and I'd be surprised if they messed it up that badly.
- brokenmachine 7y agoThat almost sounds like interlacing, but when you say it was only parts of the image that were moving, I don't know.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jajag 7y agoIs the article actually suggesting that the brain subconsciously detects the frame rate, and then "frames" the movie to match the perceived medium? High frame rate means TV implies soap opera, low frame rate means film implies more serious, weighty content? Or am I completely misunderstanding what this "soap opera" effect is?
- jim-a-1020401 7y agoI think it is perceptual but not that specific to the medium. A faster frame rate “feels” closer to reality and the 24fps frame rate is far enough from reality that it’s easier to perceive as “something else” which allows fiction or dramatic content to be perceived differently. I tend to agree with that conception of it. The idea that when the frame rate gets high enough to not be noticeable then the brain treats it more as a real world perception and the standard is higher so it is more harshly judged and ends up seeming as lower quality reality instead of fantasy mode.
- noisy_boy 7y agoSo this is what made me feel watching the new smart TVs at the showroom like it was "too realistic" and "less cinematic". I wrongly thought it was a side-effect of super high resolution - didn't even know that this was a thing before I read this piece. This has no value except a being a gimmick which can be used to say "look how smooth/real it is". Worse is to set this to be "on" by default. They should have just had a button on the remote with a marketing-inspired name, like "motion flow" or something, which people could have turned on if they wanted this.
- overcast 7y agoThis is exactly the reason, and it makes everything look like a horrible soap opera. 24fps and motion blur, is a lot of what makes movies, look like movies. Otherwise it turns into someones home video.
- brokenmachine 7y agoI don't mind the high frame rate so much as the obvious artifacts. I can't help myself and I end up hunting for artifacts to be annoyed by more than enjoying the show. Every TV that uses motion interpolation is the same, it's horrible.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoThis is yet another example of technology designed to impress consumers in the store which actually worsens the experience once they get the product home. Apple's business strategy for computers has been centered around this trick since Steve Jobs died.
- Merrill 7y agoFor decades broadcasters have converted movies to NTSC video using three-two pull down, where each movie frame is converted to either three or two video fields in order to convert the 24 frame rate to the 60 field rate (well, actually 29.97 frames/second to 59.94 fields/second). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down How can the new smoothing conversion be worse than that?
- sbergot 7y agoMy issue with TV smoothing is that it is inconsistent. It can revert back to the original framerate when the scene is too complex.
- mrob 7y agoI agree that it's a problem, but a constant 24fps is also inconsistent in how much blur it produces. 24fps is fine for a static talking scene, but as soon as the camera moves everything turns blurry and jerky looking. That harms my immersion just as much as inconsistent motion smoothing.
- sbergot 7y agoI guess those things are subjective. I don't mind some motion blur the same way I don't like hand animation smears.
- ryanjshaw 7y agoThat is copying the original frames pixel for pixel. Motion smoothing involves interpolation heuristics (if you're lucky) between two original frames, creating an artificial frame that the film creator never intended nor vetted.
- codefreakxff 7y agoThe 24 FPS movie rate premise is that the human eye can’t detect the difference of higher frame rates. But the higher frame rate TV demos look amazing and movies that are resampled look like crap to people because they CAN see at more than 24 FPS. I’m not saying that the resampling is right, but I am super questioning this film rate in a digital age. I’m also questioning the algorithm that just creates a messy blur of nonsense between two frames. Surely we can create a smarter algorithm
- 33mhz 7y ago24FPS is chosen because of the work it engages the brain in; it's a sweet spot between seeing film and seeing a series of pictures.
- mrob 7y agoOzu Yasujirō was famous for his use of static cameras and lack of action scenes. His films are probably the most low-motion mainstream films ever made, which means they do not engage your brain very much in interpreting the 24fps motion. And yet they are still highly regarded by critics, and in my opinion highly engaging in terms of characters and story. Would they have been improved by shooting at 12fps, to make your brain work as hard as it does with conventionally shot films?
- greedo 7y agoWatch La Jetee (Chris Marker). A "film" comprised mostly of stills with just a few actual scenes with movement.
- marci 7y ago"La Jetée", the original "12 Monkeys".
- teddyh 7y ago> A "film" comprised mostly of stills with just a few actual scenes with movement. …which was remade into a high-budget Hollywood CGI-laden production, starring Bruce Willis and Brad Pitt. I’m not even joking; it’s called 12 Monkeys, and was released in 1995.
- thinkloop 7y agoI don't get it, what's the "debate"? According to the article there is literally no advantage to motion smoothing. When motion smoothing is off, if the video is shot at high frame rates, like TV or sports, it displays them that way as people like, and if the video is of film at 24 fps, it displays it like that as people also prefer. The article seems to try to engineer controversy by vaguely hinting that sales could be lost if smoothing weren't on for certain key edge cases, like in-store demos, but that's not the case. So the question is why is ti default at all, what's the issue?
- jim-a-1020401 7y agoI don’t understand why TV manufacturers can’t just have dynamic frame rate change to match the content like Apple ProMotion (https://m.gsmarena.com/understanding_apples_promotion_display_on_the_new_ipad_pro-news-25446.php https://m.gsmarena.com/understanding_apples_promotion_displa...)
- discreditable 7y agoMoney.
- rini17 7y agoAll TVs are capable of displaying 50Hz European content natively. Converting 24fps to that is trivial - play it at 25fps(not noticeable) and every frame twice.
- brokenmachine 7y agoNewer TVs are starting to support Dynamic refresh rate, ostensibly for gaming modes. I wonder if this tech becomes mainstream, it will eventually start to be used for normal content.
- Aardwolf 7y agoExcuse me for being ignorant, I don't really watch much TV, but: Why do they need this feature for sports? Couldn't they broadcast the sports at 60Hz? If they don't broadcast sports at 60Hz, then what framerate are they broadcasting it at, and what are the 60Hz TV's intended for in the first place?
- mrob 7y ago60fps is still too low for very fast motion, of which sports is a notable example. And the focal point of most sports is a ball, which moves along predictable paths, so motion smoothing can do a good job of increasing the frame rate to the point where the sample-and-hold blur of 60fps isn't visible.
- Aardwolf 7y agoSo do the televisions use 120 fps then? Phew, then at least displaying 24 fps movies without interpolation should be possible because 120 is an integer multiple of 24.
- mrob 7y agoYes, or higher than 120fps. And 120fps can indeed be used to show 24fps with consistent frame timing (as well as 30fps and 60fps, so it's a convenient frame rate).
- Aardwolf 7y agoIt's got to be bad for cycle or motorcycle sport by the way. I saw some videos on youtube showing the motion smoothing in slo-mo, and heads and bodies were moving at different speeds between frames with this.
- dahart 7y agoMy kids aren’t bothered by high frame rates, so personally I suspect it only bothers adults who are used to 24fps. > And an entire cinematic language has developed around the rate of 24 frames per second — the way actors perform, the way shots are composed and cut and cameras move. (This is why an awards show or a news broadcast shot on video at a higher frame rate looks and feels different from a film.) This is a real stretch. Very, very few filmmakers are doing anything specific for 24fps that they wouldn’t do in 48 or 60. If they did, they’d slow things down so you could see them, but instead we have ever faster and faster fight sequences in Marvel and Transformer movies where you can’t even see the details during the action. The “cinematic language” of a news show vs an action movie is different, but has almost nothing to do with frame rate, and if frame rate was the main issue, we’d be doing news in low frame rate and action movies in high frame rate. Horizontal pans in 24fps have started to drive me crazy. Films do it all the time, and you can barely see anything while that’s going on. Higher frame rate pans are so much easier to watch, even if they make the movie look like BBC tv.
- sneak 7y agoMost adults aren’t bothered, either.
- soulofmischief 7y agoIt's more than just a higher framerate. It's false motion, which some are hypersensitive to because it's not natural looking.
- dahart 7y ago> It’s false motion I agree if we’re talking about motion interpolation. I’m personally sensitive to artifacts from the 24->60 conversion, and I sometimes turn off frame rate up-sampling, unless the show has a lot of panning, and then I prefer the frame rate up-sampling despite the artifacts it causes sometimes. Like Game of Thrones for example has so much panning that I kept turning on the motion smoothing. But then the artifacts were so bad I kept turning it off. There isn’t a good option, so I wish it was filmed at a higher frame rate, and then displayed lower for people who prefer that. Above I was really only referring to high frame rates in general and deconstructing the argument that 24 is inherently better for artistic reasons. While many filmmakers and viewers like 24fps, most filmmakers aren’t choosing 24fps nor are they doing anything specific with 24fps. 24 is just a standard that almost everyone is stuck with, most people wouldn’t even consider it a choice today, save the few directors with big enough budgets and studio backing that they can distribute films in a non-standard frame rate.
- discreditable 7y agoOne problem is that TVs run at 60fps and don't support adaptive sync. 60 is not evenly divisible by 24. Without some kind of trick you're padding to 30fps by duplicating every 4th frame, or trimming to 20fps by dropping every 6th frame. Padding is usually what's done. You can see it in NTSC (30fps) DVDs which come from something originally produced for PAL (25fps). Every 5th frame is duplicated. It makes me curious what framerate movie projectors run at. Maybe the "cinema experience" includes goofy frame duplication and nobody realizes it.
- dbcurtis 7y agoTraditionally, each film frame is projected 3 times. The psycho-perceptual reason is that the phi-phenomenon (“light chaser effect”) kicks in about 12–15 Hz, so camera frame rate must exceed that to give a perception of smooth motion. The critical flicker frequency is around 50 Hz for most people, so projected frame rate must exceed that to avoid the appearance of flickering. Silent movies were shot 18 fps and projected 54 fps. The frame rate for talkies was boosted to allow enough bandwidth for the audio. The reason silent movies look jerky today is every third frame is projected twice. They are smooth when properly projected.
- mrob 7y ago50Hz is below the flicker fusion threshold for most people. Even 60Hz visibly flickers for many people. Silent movies were shot and projected at many different framerates. Some early silent movies were shot at 18fps, but the average frame rate increased over time, and the standard 24fps was picked as a compromise that was around the average frame rate at which films were displayed at that time.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoNowadays with digital TVs that conversion between frame rates is completely pointless. The playback device just switches to a different frame rate and resolution and the tv should adapt. My cheap TCL TV accepts different rates just fine. I can somewhat understand that they keep doing that for DVD releases since someone somewhere might watch it on their old trusty CRT, but other than that you might as well just import the release that has the original frame rate. Oh wait, there are those region codes right? opens the pirate bay ...
- PorterDuff 7y agoJust as an aside, there was a lot of work on this kind of thing (ie. 'improving' 3:2 pulldown) before the modern flat panel tv. Improving slow motion sucked up a few kilobucks of engineering time.
- rowanG077 7y agoThe problem is the refusal of hollywood to release true 60fps content. I'd take a 60fps version of a movie any day over 24 or 30 fps.
- bitL 7y ago60fps changes your perception of a movie. For some reason ~24fps you get the cinematic feeling, with 60fps you get "amateurish" videographer feeling. Not sure what's the science behind that.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoFaster shutter = less motion blur?
- psychometry 7y agoIt's just conditioning. If it had been the opposite, you'd find 24 jarring and 60 natural.
- cma 7y ago24fps lets you focus attention with motion blur (tracking shot on two characters walking, they will be in sharp focus, while everything else will be blurred but still convey movement, etc.). It's a similar tool beyond depth of field. However, a 60hz movie could just have 30hz portions. Stuff like panning cameras over a landscape looks terrible at 24hz. I don't know how you could combine the two without making things feel too much like changing between technology all the time during the movie though.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoI must admit, I might not even care that much if the processing weren't so flawed. What drives me mad is those weird patterns or glitches, e.g. when someone walks in front of a background with a high contrast pattern on it while the camera pans along while zooming out slightly. It usually creates very visible artifacts around the person.
- rv-de 7y agoActually this effect has been observable for several decades with cathode ray tube TVs. Recordings from normal amateur video cameras look more / differently fluid compared to scenes from movies. This is particularly obvious with some movies from the 90s where you have scenes cut into the movie which have been recorded with regular video cameras - for example for dramatic reasons. Awkwardly few people seem to be able to recognize this at all. To me this motion smoothing is absolutely obvious and I find it mostly terrible. Real HFR adds to the realism of animations in my opinion. But it seems that for some super subtle reason some people's visual processing feels repulsed by this fake HFR - like uncanny valley - it's smoother but in a way that doesn't seem right while you're not sure why.
- sneak 7y agoMy new top-of-the-range Sony 4K UHD HDR oled has this setting turned on - FOR EACH OF FOUR INPUTS. You have to turn it off (as well as a bunch of other adaptive contrast junk) per input. It’s maddening.
- bovine3dom 7y agoThis whole thread and article is like it's from an alternative universe to me. All of my tech-savvy friends go to great lengths to turn motion smoothing on everywhere ("smooth video project" is the best I know for PC) they can so that panning shots don't look awful. They wouldn't play videogames at 24Hz, so why should they watch a film at 24Hz? It does introduce artefacts. The solution to all of this is for filmmakers to move on from the 1930s and film at 120 fps or higher. If people only want to watch a quarter of the frames, it can be downsampled easily. The argument reminds me of musicians who didn't want their albums chopped up and sold as individual tracks, to be consumed however listeners desired.
- dondawest 7y agoAng Lee already tried the 120fps thing, it was a colossal flop. No one likes watching movies in anything other than 24fps dude. Filmmakers filming in 120fps would destroy the film industry overnight because NO ONE would watch what they produced.
- bovine3dom 7y ago> No one likes watching movies in anything other than 24fps dude. I know of at least 6 people who prefer higher framerates, myself included. I don't know anyone who has expressed an opinion the other way. As I said, this whole thread is like some kind of alternative universe to me. Motion smoothing apparently hasn't stopped people buying TVs.
- zrobotics 7y agoMany people hate motion smoothing though; my mom was complaining that their new TV made everything look like a soap opera until I disabled it. Like many other things, this is all down to personal preferences; similarly I have friends who can't stand to game at anything <120FPS and one who gets motion sick at 60FPS, while I would rather turn up the graphical detail and survive with 60. Neither opinion is more correct, and you have had several people upthread saying they prefer 24 for films (myself included).
- 7y ago
- TrackerFF 7y agoI remember when a friend of mine got their first HD TV and Blu-ray, none of us had ever seen that stuff. We were still used to CRT screens, and at best DVD. We borrowed a movie, fired it up - and everyone thought there was something wrong with the movie. The image quality looked almost like something from handheld camera, just very non-cinematic. We returned the movie, and went with another one. Nope, same problem. We just figured that's the way HD looked like.
- eddyg 7y agoIf you want to experience for yourself the effect frame rate (and the related motion blur) has, this is a really great demo: https://frames-per-second.appspot.com https://frames-per-second.appspot.com
- Brian_K_White 7y ago"looks like a soap opera" exposes everything you need to know about the ignorance behind this position. Reality does not judder. If you want judder for some artistic purpose, you can have that, just like any other reality-distorting filter. Some shots are intentionally blurry for valid artistic purposes. Should all movies and tvs be blurry at all times? Some shots are intentionally monochrome for valid artistic purposes. Should all movies and all tvs be b&w or red tinted at all times? Some shots are intentionally too bright or too dark, for valid artistic purposes... You want stroboscopic stop-motion, go ahead and use it. Superior reproductive technology in no way prevents you from creating a scene that has that and any other kind of artificially applied crappiness like static interference or low resolution or analog scan lines... But crappy reproductive technology does preclude the other 99.9% of the time when you don't want an artificially crappy reproduction. Video tape was cheaper than film, and tvs and video tape ran at higher frame rates than film, and soap operas were cheaper than movies, and so the one superior aspect of soap operas became associated with "cheap". It's a freaking ignorant assosciation is all. It's obvious as hell, and you have to be a moron not to recognize why you think "this looks like a soap opera" and see past that.
- resoluteteeth 7y agoSeriously, if people are this determined to tie themselves into knots trying to defend their ridiculous bias that smooth motion = soap opera, it kind of makes of despair about whether its actually possible to change anybody's mind about anything ever. Luckily the fact that tv's with motion smoothing are selling suggests that the rest of us have spent the 2 minutes necessary to get used to it and realized that it's superior.
- dperfect 7y ago> Superior reproductive technology in no way prevents you from creating a scene that has that and any other kind of artificially applied crappiness... The technology to produce movies at high frame rates has been around for a long time (and projection/display technology could have supported it much sooner if the content were there), and yet directors have deliberately, almost universally chosen what you categorize as "artificially applied crappiness" (24 fps). Practically speaking, it is artificially applied, and that's exactly it - it's an intentionally distorted version of reality, and it's that way on purpose. You're free to attempt to remove that filter (by smoothing motion on your TV), but that doesn't represent what the director intended. Even with "superior reproductive technology", directors are still choosing to produce films at 24 fps, so can you at least appreciate and respect that that's how most of them intend their work to be displayed? True, "reality does not judder" (proper 24 fps content doesn't either, by the way), but reality isn't what filmmaking is about. To argue otherwise misses the point of film as an artistic medium. For other types of content, I agree - reality is the target, but not in film.