7 ms·
> The question is how. China’s imports from the United States only a fraction of the trade going the other way, so it cannot match Washington tariff for tariff.
by baybal2 7y ago
> The question is how. China’s imports from the United States only a fraction of the trade going the other way, so it cannot match Washington tariff for tariff. Much of that trade consists of agriculture goods like soybeans, as well as specialized products like Boeing jetliners or the American-made chips for the smartphones China makes.
The question monetary value, but where widgets are physically made made. This simple realisation eludes so many "China Experts" in the West.
Were Beijing to pull an inverse Huawei ban on any company in the West, that company would be dead in a few months no matter what it is. It can crash US stock market, pension funds and assuredly secure the non-election of Trump for the second term.
China is fully capable of economic retaliation against US and can genuinely make it hurt, but it chooses not to because people in Zhongnanhai have no guts for that.
What surprised me most in recent months is that out of all people, the criticism of Xi's overly conciliatory tone with Washington is now coming from people whom you can call Chinese industrialists class. This criticism is quite strong worded, emotional. I never ever saw somebody so up on social ladder here being so openly critical of Xi before.
- baybal2 7y agoOn BBK's internal mail list, there was a letter from Duan saying that Xi's indecision lets USA to slowly bleed Chinese industry while American companies have sweet time relocating out of China at easy pace, and show US politicians how easy is China for picking, and that doing so is a totally repercussions free way to gain political capital. And that assures that China's troubles will not end with Trump now. Another sentiment from a forum quite popular by industry oldtimers is beyond unflattering, pretty much a personal rant on Xi, so I can't say the source. The point was that Xi, a very insecure man, and the elites of his generation, were unable to resist influence of Trump's powerful ego, and that they are plainly frightened by him. From my own view, this is indeed the case. It is hard to explain to somebody who live in the West how it works, but I'll try my best here: See, that generation of people were risen in the culture dominated by the social class of "Big Men," and all of their social programming and mental processes work around one attaining, securing, maintaining, extracting benefits from, giving or forcefully taking that "Big Man" status from somebody. In eyes of such people, somebody like Trump may indeed look like a very "top dog" person, more so than even Xi himself. And it is Xi's insecurity that pushes him to seek engagement with Trump, to show his peers that he "can talk on equals even with a big bad boy like Trump." If he were to break off that engagement, and if he would've lashed out on Trump, many of his peers would've seen that as him going on defensive, and admitting his inferiority to Trump, as if he was skulking away from Trump's intimidating presence.
- Mirioron 7y agoThis reads like a summary of a conflict from many Chinese novels. It also gives an explanation why such a theme is popular in those stories.
- DuskStar 7y agoAnd since impressions often matter more than reality (particularly in politics), it may also force some actions by Xi.
- Mirioron 7y agoThat's what I mean. If you read popular wuxia/xianxia novels from China you'd see exactly this kind of "saving face" and being arrogant as GP mentioned. The next step in stories is usually that the conflict boils over and innocent people become collateral damage.
- adventured 7y ago> Were Beijing to pull the inverse Huawei ban on any company in the West, that company would be dead in a few months no matter what it is. China can't do any of that because it would harm their own economy far more (what remains of their industrial / trade trust would vaporize further) and it wouldn't likely kill the company they target (unless it was a small hyper dependent company). The US move against Huawei works particularly well because of the US partners willing to go along with it as a group; the same is true of US sanctions. China has very few allies and few global levers. Plus, the US would respond very harshly and China knows that. China isn't a gentle flower, it isn't avoiding hammering strategic US companies out of the goodness of its heart; it isn't attempting that maneuver because it knows the cost is too high for itself. The US is one of the least trade dependent nations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_trade-to-GDP_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_trade-to-... And: https://i.imgur.com/7JIIX8Q.jpg https://i.imgur.com/7JIIX8Q.jpg On imports + exports as a share of GDP, the US ranks #6 in the world as least dependent, with those two items making up 27% of the US GDP. China is at 40%. Germany is 87%, France is 63% and the UK is 62% by comparison. The US is also, essentially, entirely energy self-sufficient, with Canada's help. Something China is nowhere near being. The US could shut off China's access to foreign oil and a lot of coal supply very easily and it would grind up their economy. Let's run the hypothetical though. Ok, do it to Microsoft, Google, Facebook and Oracle. Those are three of the five largest US companies and four of the largest tech companies. Might as well also hit Netflix, Adobe, Intuit, Salesforce, Workday, ServiceNow, Uber, Lyft, Twitter, Snap, Pinterest, Slack, Dropbox, etc. Also Exxon, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, Occidental, Phillips 66, Valero, Marathon, EOG. Run it against JPMorgan, Citi, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, BlackRock, NY Mellon, Fidelity, Vanguard, etc. Next up do Visa, PayPal, Mastercard, Discover, Amex, Square, Stripe. Then do it to Pfizer, Amgen, Merck, AbbVie, Gilead, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Biogen, Eli Lilly. Maybe Lockheed, Raytheon, Northrup and General Dynamics. How about Comcast, AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile / Sprint. Also McDonald's, Yum Brands, Kraft, Mondelez, Coca Cola, Pepsi. Total result: barely a scratch overall, if that. Few of these companies, many of which are among the largest corporations on the planet, have a critical (threat-of-death type) exposure to China. A few would lose 5-10% of their businesses and life would continue just fine. This is the fundamental mistake China made by keeping its economy so restricted and locked down to foreign companies. Most of the US economy doesn't have a critical dependency on China. That's also why the large China tariffs are having near zero inflationary effect and that will continue to be the case. The only serious effect it's having is that it's pushing manufacturing out of China, which was one of the goals. Also fortunately Taiwan != China
- nine_k 7y agoGoogle, not exactly a small company, did experience an effective ban in China, and had to stop operations there. I don't remember any major panic about it, and not even a spectacular NASDAQ crash due to that. I see that a trade war is a war of attrition, but I don't see US industry as more vulnerable than Chinese in this regard.
- pcr0 7y agoApples and oranges. Banning Google in China meant that its product (user data) couldn't be produced in China. That's unfortunate but they still have users elsewhere in the world and on VPNs. On the other hand ad sales _to_ China have continued growing ever since the ban. Huawei (or any smartphone company) has no alternative to chips that license US technology.
- nine_k 7y agoLast time I checked, most chips for smartphones were made in China, Taiwan, Korea, Japan. US-made chips are necessary for high-performance computers; there is no China-made Xeon or Power9. But this is not smartphone stuff. Re Google: ad sales in China did not stop, but Google received no revenue from that huge market then.
- pcr0 7y agoCorrection, I didn't just mean chips made in the US but also chips that license US technology. This was the reason ARM, a British company had to suspend their relationship with HiSilicon, Huawei's chip manufacturer. [0] [0]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/22/18635326/huawei-arm-chip-designs-business-suspension https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/22/18635326/huawei-arm-chip-...
- lumost 7y agoThere's no guarantee that the chinese government would respect US copyright and patent law in a split up. It's just as likely the payments to US firms would end, and manufacture would continue.