21 ms·
He doesn't quite say it by name, but most advertising is a classic arms race. Especially given how the internet now makes information easily available, a great
by wpietri 7y ago
He doesn't quite say it by name, but most advertising is a classic arms race. Especially given how the internet now makes information easily available, a great deal of advertising is about manipulating consumers to pick company A's products over those from competitors B, C, and D. This forces those other companies to spend to get and keep customers. It's pure waste.
For example, everybody on the planet is now familiar with soft drinks. If anybody has never tasted Coke, it's not by accident. But Coke's ad budget is enormous. If all soft drink companies stopped advertising tomorrow, society would not be worse off. And we'd have billions of dollars [1] to spend on something useful.
Like the author, I won't work on ad tech. I don't like manipulation and I don't like waste, and most advertising is both.
[1] e.g., https://notesmatic.com/pepsico-advertising-and-marketing-budget/ https://notesmatic.com/pepsico-advertising-and-marketing-bud... https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/081315/look-cocacolas-advertising-expenses.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/081315/look-co...
- kiliantics 7y ago> It's pure waste. And yet capitalism is still lauded as the most efficient economic system...
- chrismcb 7y agoI would argue that society would be worse off. There are a lot of things we enjoy, for free or cheap, because of advertising. Tv, radio, street fair, among other things And no, we wouldn't have billions of dollars to spend on other things. The soft drink companies would have billions of dollars more profit. And fewer people would have jobs The cost of drinks wouldn't go down. Basically the only thing that would change is we would lose a lot of free things, and fewer people would have money.
- gtfratteus 7y agoThank you for your service.
- remeq 7y ago"we'd have billions of dollars [1] to spend on something useful." - If companies stopped advertising tomorrow the people doing those ads wouldn't go building space rockets.
- _nalply 7y agoBut Coke could be sold for less.
- FroshKiller 7y agoEvery single day, new people are born who actually do not know what Coca-Cola is and thus have never bought a Coca-Cola.
- rabidrat 7y agoThe same is true of cocaine. Yet without advertising the people who 'need' cocaine manage to learn about it and acquire it, often at great personal cost.
- buboard 7y agoDealers advertise their stuff. Otherwise you have a chicken and egg problem
- rabidrat 7y agoSmart dealers don't "advertise". They communicate their available goods to individuals who are already looking and who pass a basic smell test. While on vacation a few years ago, I went out at night to see if I could find some plant matter, and passed a guy on the street who looked like he might know the score. (Being present at a particular time/place to serve a market and dressing in a non-official manner is not advertising). So I said "got any green?" and he said "no...white?" and I said "ah, no thanks" and moved along. No advertising required.
- GauntletWizard 7y agoIf you were to take away all of the coke tomorrow, the first thing I'd spend all that extra money (and more!) on would be to try to invent a new cola.
- jniedrauer 7y agoWhy? They're a net negative to society (soft drinks themselves, that is)
- ribosometronome 7y agoCouldn't the same be said of any luxury?
- lostlogin 7y agoI’ve not considered coke to be a luxury product before. But if you mean that it’s not a necessity, it guess... maybe?
- zentiggr 7y agoNot a luxury when it's a net negative to your health to drink it. Lawmakers have slowly banned advertising for more and more obviously addictive and harmful things. They just can't make headway against the most pervasive and least obviously harmful things.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoNo. Refined sugar is incredibly toxic. It doesn't just rot your teeth, make you obese, and eventually turns you into a Type 2 diabetic, but it also raises the risk of heart disease, strokes, Alzheimer's, and many other conditions. The direct economic costs - health care costs, lost productivity caused by illness - are immense, and the soda and junk food industries make no contribution towards them. There are also less direct personal and emotional costs, in the form of family/partner illness and sometimes death. Some luxuries are similarly toxic, but as a "cheap" luxury sugar abuse affects a much larger demographic. IMO the ad efforts that support these products are unconscionable, and there's no question the money would be better spent elsewhere.
- rifung 7y ago> For example, everybody on the planet is now familiar with soft drinks. If anybody has never tasted Coke, it's not by accident. But Coke's ad budget is enormous. If all soft drink companies stopped advertising tomorrow, society would not be worse off. And we'd have billions of dollars [1] to spend on something useful. Not that I disagree, but where do you draw the line? Sure, if Coke stopped advertising we'd have billions of dollars to spend on something "useful". On the other hand, if Coke stopped making soft drinks, we'd have billions of dollars to spend on something "useful" AND significantly decreased obesity. If you are going to make the argument that having soft drinks improves life somehow, then that implies it's better for people to know about soft drinks, and how will they know? Advertising.
- wpietri 7y agoSoft drinks aren't an arms race where most of the money spent is pure waste. When I buy a soft drink, I value it directly, so it isn't waste. > that implies it's better for people to know about soft drinks, and how will they know? Advertising. Are you really saying the only way you have ever known about a product is advertising? I honestly have trouble believing that, but if that's the case please consider that you're an outlier. Me, I avoid ads vigorously and have for decades. I have no trouble learning about new products.
- joshgel 7y agoAs a doctor, I'm all for banning soft drinks, recognizing that it probably will never happen. But, the health externalities associated with drinking such beverages should get priced in and be used to offset eventual health complications. This is not easy because no one likes taxes, but you get what you pay for.
- solipsism 7y agoMay we be allowed cake and ice cream or would you ban those as well? Maybe you can get a special license if it's a birthday?
- conception 7y ago
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI didn't use the term "arms race", but I tried to communicate this point in few places, calling out the zero-sum and negative-sum properties of advertising, and the waste it creates. I'll update the post later on to make the arms race aspect more visible.
- derg 7y agoI constantly think about how the world would look if even a fraction of the people doing creative for ads were free to be creative elsewhere.
- buboard 7y agoThey are free to. There s just no money in that.
- randcraw 7y agoNo, there's plenty of money in alternative careers to advertising. It's absurd to claim otherwise. But advertising is an easy way to make money fast, that is, if you're happy to sell people stuff they don't need at triple the commodity price. Or... you could turn your hand toward more constructive and lasting alternative endeavors like treating / defeating disease, cheaply desalinating sea water, or a zillion other ends that would do more than pry money out of the clueless hands of fools.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd if all of the people doing creative elsewhere didn’t advertise, how would they get the word out about their work?
- megaman821 7y agoYou don't think they have ever tried that. They stopped ad spend in certain locations and in those locations sales went down. People don't have time to research every single choice in their lives. At some point you just go with brand trust. When I see Uncle Floyd's Cola and CocaCola, I just go with what I know. Advertising establishes brand trust.
- wpietri 7y ago> People don't have time to research every single choice in their lives. At some point you just go with brand trust. Advertising establishes brand trust. This is a non-sequitur. Brands existed long before advertising, and regardless they aren't the only way to solve the problem of choosing what to buy. If you really care about making things easier for purchasers, you'd be eager to eliminate advertising, which a) adds a great deal of confusion and distraction, and b) reduces the value of earned brands in favor of whomever can spend the most money.
- chipperyman573 7y agoThat's part of the problem imo, these companies have done nothing to earn trust (and often are significantly worse than companies that actually try to earn trust by being trustworthy), because they can just rely on the ads to build it for them.
- cousin_it 7y agoSome advertising, like Superbowl ads, does establish brand trust - because you know a fly-by-night company couldn't afford a Superbowl ad. But targeted advertising, which is the whole point of adtech, cannot do that - because you never know if it was shown to a million people or just you.
- DevKoala 7y agoAll advertising is targeted; the granularity and fidelity of targeting are what changes. Also, the systems used to calculate conversions from Superbowl ads, TV ads, cross-reference multiple data sources that often contain more private information than whatever data sources are consumed by your regular targeted banner advert.
- Aperocky 7y agoHow do you define "Something useful" though? The advertisement money eventually makes it to Google, broadcasters, sites, TV-channels, sports events and people running those organization in term gets more money to spend on [Potentially useful stuff]. It's not like the money magically vanishes to never be seen again, and business to business transaction like this make the money flow faster instead of slower. Economy is basically production vs consumption, money is just the grease to keep the cycle flowing, to follow the money isn't getting to the base cause of our problems.
- Zarath 7y agoThe money itself doesn't vanish obviously, but the work does magically vanish, in the form of human consumption. The sheer amount of useful energy and resources required to feed those people, power their computers, etc. is being "burned" in the same sense that bitcoin mining "burns" something. It's millions of hours of work for simply redistribution of demand. Bill Gates could pay 10000 people $10/hour to dig a hole and 10000 people $10/hour to fill the hole back with dirt. Obviously this money doesn't "vanish", but millions of hours are wasted (and the food and resources needed to power this work).
- wpietri 7y agoThis is basically the broken window fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window If I go around smashing windows, I will make money move faster. The people who install replacement windows will have more money to spend. It's not like the money magically vanishes! But it's still a terrible idea, because all this economic activity is based on systemic waste. It's the same for most advertising.
- tsimionescu 7y agoA lot of advertising money is actually lost from the economy to profit for advertisers, stock buybacks, bonuses for the ultra-rich etc.
- zentiggr 7y ago> It's not like the money magically vanishes to never be seen again No, it remains in corporate budgets, which, without all the marketing spend, can be shifted to better wages, charity work, capital investments, better wages, safety and health initiatives, better wages...
- amiune 7y agoIf every company stopped advertising then google and facebook and twitter will disappear. Are all these companies pure waste? How do you fund a replacement for them? Should these services be provided by governments?
- asark 7y agoIt wouldn't be that big a deal. Ad-funded commercial services like Facebook and Twitter would probably just be protocols, if not for all those ad dollars incentivizing moat-creation and jealous user capture. We'd figure something out to replace google—the need's too strong not to. The replacement(s) probably wouldn't make $3,000,000/employee or whatever Google does, though. Which is fine.
- amiune 7y agoIt seems that the cancer creates, allows or at least sustain a coordination that society can't achieve by other ways.
- tetraca 7y ago> If every company stopped advertising then google and facebook and twitter will disappear. I don't see the downside.
- kyruzic 7y agoEach of those companies has a FOSS competitor that does not rely on advertising money yet still exists.
- dooglius 7y agoThere's a FOSS competitor to Google?
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoIn principle, yes * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MetaGer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MetaGer * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YaCy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YaCy
- ensignro2340 7y agoWhile I’ll agree he never uses the phrase “arms race”, he does say this: >The growth of advertising is fueled by the enormous waste it creates. In any somewhat saturated market - which, today, is most of them - any effort you spent on advertising serves primarily to counteract the combined advertising efforts of your competitors.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoAh only a strong central government could redirect resources and restrict freedom of speech in such a manner. In theory this works, in practice it doesn't. Nobody is quite sure about what the dichotomy is between the theory and actual results. Basically by allowing commercial interests to control the direction of capital you get useless areas of inn-efficiency like advertising. The weird thing is, these types of economies still thrive. However, when you restrict and redirect resources in a centrally controlled manner, the economies tend not to thrive. Nobody really knows why. However there are hints as to why it works. Google, gmail, search, google docs, hangouts and google maps would not exist if it wasn't for advertising. Google and the services and technologies they provide to the world would not exist if they did not receive revenue from ads.
- anoncake 7y agoThat's why a strong central government is important. To make sure resources are allocated to useful purposes rather than garbage like advertising.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoBut then you wouldn't have services provided by companies like google.
- anoncake 7y agoIf they're useful, they will be provided by other companies and organizations instead.
- crimsonalucard 7y agofor a fee. The services google provides are widely used because they are free.
- anoncake 7y agoNo, they aren't. It's paid by advertisers, advertising makes products more expensive. Ultimately, you do pay. Advertising has no benefits.
- dheera 7y agoI'd really love to have an AR real-life ad blocker. Replace all billboards with works of art. Separately I think advertising will have to find new forms of expression that are less repulsive. I won't want to block ads if they are actually fun and interesting.
- w-ll 7y agoWhat makes you think the company that makes the best AR wouldn't put ads in it. The top 3 in the field Microsoft, Facebook, and Google to some extent, would never let you disable ads let alone override them with something you wish.
- Qwertystop 7y agoIf people are buying the AR to remove ads, the company that makes AR that just replaces ads with other ads probably won't sell much.
- blfr 7y agoThis is demonstrably not true today because Google wrote the operating system of my phone and I block all ads on it.
- jjulius 7y agoTo your point, I was about to respond to OP as well, and point out that ad-blockers can be installed on Chrome. Then, I remembered that that's not likely to be the case in the near future[1]. https://www.wired.com/story/google-chrome-ad-blockers-extensions-api/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-chrome-ad-blockers-extens...
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> and point out that ad-blockers can be installed on Chrome On desktop, yes (not for much longer). But not on Android.
- 7y ago
- alexott 7y agoThere are examples when companies are doing well without advertising: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oettinger_Brewery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oettinger_Brewery
- pearapps 7y agoThe wikipedia page literally lists them as a sponsor of a team: "From 2006 until 2018, Oettinger was the official sponsor of Rockets, a professional basketball club based in Gotha. The Rockets played as "Oettinger Rockets" in Germany's first distribution, the Basketball Bundesliga.[5]"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 7y ago> but most advertising is a classic arms race. Small brained primate thought du jour; advertising shouldn't be an allowed business expense.
- 0xEFF 7y agoI'm no fan of ads, but that would only result in making ads ~30 to 50% more expensive for pass-through small businesses and ~14% more expensive for most [1] large US companies. [1]: https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/tax-rate-paid/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/tax-rate-paid/
- dwild 7y agoI would have agreed in the past but now that my SO has started an escape room, if your ideal world existed, she would be bankrupt right now. Most ads isn't about manipulation, it's just about getting your attention and reminding you that this product exists. Ads are the only way to reach her market. You could argue that search is a good one too (which is true), but sadly people have trouble paying to watch videos online, there's no way they would pay for a search engine. We are still not really high in the search result after a year of existence either and paying for ads is a good way to get people on the website (which I'm sure will help our position in search results). EDIT: In case it's not clear, I don't believe she deserve to be higher than other escape room in the search result, we have actually almost no competition close to us and it's pretty much why she started that business. Simply that Google have no metric to know that her website has to be higher than another one, so clicks are needed to provide some. She always asks people what they think of the experience once they are done and recently one even said that we are not visible enough. It's a pretty great feedback, we are lucky that's our main issue, but sadly ads are the only way to become visible to others. Ads are almost amazing by allowing investment into market that people aren't ready to pay for but yet provide great entertainment, learning experience or a great service. Without ads, I probably wouldn't be the developper that I am today because the guy that did the great tutorial that create the passion in me wouldn't have time to works full time on them.
- skummetmaelk 7y agoIf the current ad model of the popular search engine(s) was made extinct by law. I would be extremely surprised if search simply disappeared rather than move to a paid model. Who wouldn't pay to have any information in the world reachable in the 30 seconds it takes to craft a query and scan the first page of results? It is a huge competitive advantage.
- kspacewalk2 7y agoMy guess is that the vast majority of people wouldn't pay. Firstly, because it's notoriously difficult to get people to pay for something that used to be free. Lack of tracking and respect for privacy is not something most people would recognize as an obvious upgrade - hence the need for legislation in the first place. So the public will see it as paying for the exact thing that used to be free, and just won't do it. If Google won't find a loophole to bring marketing, paid results or some other monetization back in such a legislative environment, someone else will. You'll end up with something that's won't necessarily be better for consumers than the advertising model.