14 ms·
High-Density Housing Near Public Transit Is Aim of San Diego Code Change
- azinman2 7y agoToo bad the public transit is poor and the city/county is very spread out.
- koverda 7y agoAmazing, a path opening for a west coast city to develop additional housing! We need more of this. I bet there are NIMBY heads exploding in San Diego, probably on Nextdoor.
- kart23 7y agoNah, most of these areas are already relatively dense. All the nimbys live in places like rancho santa fe or La Jolla, which are almost exclusively homes and have some truly insane houses. However, San Diego already has a huge traffic problem. Either they really need to scale the major highways, or get people closer to their workplace, which this is a great first step for. San Diego is awesome, but growing pains showing.
- bsder 7y agoSan Diego still has lots of areas that are gentrifying from being really crappy, so the NIMBY's aren't up in arms yet. San Francisco has the problem that all those crappy areas got gentrified and now everybody is trying to protect their "investment". In addition, downtown San Diego isn't really considered to be a place where the cool kids hang out (and still has a lot of industrial area around). So, there is less fighting going on there right now. The problem is that the transit in San Diego is lousy. The trains are horrifically slow between downtown and Solana Beach. And the limited number of tracks means that Amtrak regularly has to wait for passenger trains, and, if someone jumps in front of a train, the system shuts down for 4 hours.
- repsilat 7y ago> everybody is trying to protect their "investment" Nearby construction can decrease your property values, but upzoning and by-right permitting increase property values by making them more attractive to developers. I think it's both more correct and more charitable to think that people arguing against things like SB50 are doing it because they don't want the density in their neighbourhoods, and not for financial reasons.
- hart_russell 7y agoI live in San Diego and just waited 30 minutes in bumper to bumper traffic to drive 7 miles. Until better traffic infrastructure is installed, more people sounds like a nightmare.
- jongalloway2 7y agoThat's the entire point of this zoning change - moving the higher density housing near to public transportation, with integrated restaurants and stores so they're walkable. The current five zone types (explained in the article) separate commercial and residential, requiring people to drive to businesses and work. (also a San Diegan)
- hart_russell 7y agoHow often do you use public transportation in San Diego? I'm guessing you don't, because you'd know that it's nearly impossible to exist in San Diego and only use public transport. More people will invariably mean more cars. I know this might come as a shock, but this policy might not translate to the real world as intended.
- koverda 7y agoAlternatively, more people living by public transit makes it easier to invest more in and develop better public transit.
- dickeytk 7y agoit's not about whether or not people _own_ a car, it's that they won't have to _use_ it every time they go out to do something
- ivalm 7y agoAlready in some places in Hillcrest you can walk to restraunts/shops. In UTC you can get around on busses (well, because UCSD spurred more public transport density). Right now San Diego feels like an overgrown suburbia. If we transform into a real urban city I welcome it. The increased housing density will also presumably decrease housing prices, further making a more equitable city.
- hart_russell 7y agoIf"transit stop" includes bus stops, this is going to be terrible. Public transit in San Diego is God awful because everything is so spread out. Realistically, you need a car to get anywhere, so more people is going to mean more congested roads.
- ivalm 7y agoIt is spread out because it is lower density. As you get higher density you won't need to travel as far to get somewhere, therefore decreasing traffic load.
- asveikau 7y agoYou stated that it's "because everything is so spread out". So the way to fix that is to build new stuff densely. It won't change overnight but you would need to start somewhere. You can't take the status quo as an inevitability.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoNever traveled, eh?
- lol12345 7y agoYes, let’s cram even more people into a drought prone desert region. /s
- themark 7y agoThe trolley extension to UTC will juice a lot of this kind of development. Maybe this is where the city thinks the scooters will ultimately fit in.
- buss 7y agoI was just in San Diego for GopherCon and, boy, what a beautiful place. This change will ensure San Diego can keep growing and prospering, meanwhile San Francisco continues to stand athwart history yelling STOP!
- dmode 7y agoAs much as I hate NIMBYs in SF, the City has built a lot of housing over the last decade, and I would say more than San Diego. The SF skyline is completely new, and places like SOMA, East cut, Mission Bay, Dog patch are entirely new neighborhoods. Sure, we need to build more on the West side and iPhone Sunset and Richmond, but we will definitely get more bang for our buck by up-zoning San Mateo, Palo Alto etc
- tmh79 7y ago"City has built a lot of housing over the last decade" The city has build a lot less housing than office space over the course of the last decade, and that is the metric that counts (jobs-housing balance). "The SF skyline is completely new" - Salesforce tower (office space), 181 freemont (2/3s office space) etc etc. "SOMA, East cut, Mission Bay, Dog patch are entirely new neighborhoods", and yet still 77% of the land in SF is zoned for single family homes. SF recently passed the Central Soma rezoning plan which creates an amazon HQ2 worth of office space (space for about 50k workers) but only housing for about 7k people.
- examancer 7y agoDenver is taking the same approach, and, really, it's the only tool we have for preventing huge increases in traffic as population increases and actually getting people to rely on public transit. I live in a transit-oriented development zone near train+bus stop and love how easy it is to walk to anything I want. Transit-oriented development is the only sensible approach I've seen to scaling a modern city.
- dktoao 7y agoI think this is awesome and the path forward. After reading a lot of the comments I think one thing that could help very much with the pain of this transition is encouraging a culture shift in how computer laborers are required to drive to a computer at work every day instead of just using the computer in their house... Seems obvious to me anyway.
- rsync 7y agoI am very much in favor of the idea of building high density housing centered around public transit. It sounds like a perfect solution to a large set of related problems. I am scared to see what the end result will be in US cities, however, because public transit for almost all of the US means poorly run busing routes that nobody wants to take. Having lived in San Diego for many years (as well as Denver and MPLS which I think are relevant comparisons) I believe that what will happen is that existing (poorly run, poorly utilized) bus routes will be chosen by developers who will use the "blah blah transit blah blah" designation that was just gifted to them to build high end units for people that will drive their cars. No actual transit (the kind that runs on rails) will be built, some more car-centric housing units will exist at high end prices (they're not going to build garage-less buildings nor are they going to build low end units). Oh, and the buses will still be empty. I want this kind of policy regime to be pursued, but they need to build the transit lines first. And buses don't count.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- radus 7y agoGood news - San Diego is well on its way to extending the trolley system from downtown to UTC.
- theluketaylor 7y agoHere in Kitchener-Waterloo the project approval to build a light rail system included automatic upzoning for a radius around each of the stations and easier approvals for high density development. Tying the rail and zoning together was a deliberate choice to drive density in areas served by transit and prevent as much NIMBY interference as possible. The construction took several years and the trains have just started running, but the city has already transformed. Many dense buildings went up while the rail lines where being built and many more are under construction right now. It will be many years before the true success and failure of the project is known, but the signs look good to me. I'd like to see general loosening of non-safety related zoning restrictions to help keep housing prices in check, but this program was a good compromise since developers were guaranteed an investment of transit and other city services and could take more risk.
- beowulfey 7y agoThis is great, and I hope it spurs on more transit development in general down there. San Diego is one of those cities that I adore, so long as I don't have to drive anywhere. Right on the ocean, the weather is perfect, it has lots of great food and beers, and it's generally a pretty cool place. I also appreciate that a lot of the roads are not very wide, so areas like downtown feel great to walk around because it's not very busy. But it drives me nuts that if you want to go literally any other neighborhood it requires a car and sitting in traffic. It's not super dense in terms of population now, but with proper infrastructure growth it could be one of the greats!
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoEvery time I read something like this, I roll my eyes - most of these proposals are dead on arrival. By the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation. And then I always think it would be best to build a city from scratch. A great one. With good principles. Time-proofed. Collectively we should know how to do it, but it seems that it's incredibly hard to come up with the resources to do it properly. It's still only a dream.
- MegaButts 7y ago> Every time I read something like this, I roll my eyes - most of these proposals are dead on arrival. By the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation. Every time I hear about self-driving cars being just around the corner I roll my eyes. Most of us will be dead before self-driving cars are in effect, and by then our infrastructure will have already moved on.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agofully level-5 cars? Maybe. Autonomous doesn't have to be fully level-5 to exist in cities. e.g. autonomous subways have been operating in Singapore since 2011, and been technically ready since 2003 [0]. You might argue, "that's public, not private transportation", and of course you're right. But are you sure nothing can be done to private cars to become fully autonomous, without requiring a level-5? e.g. many car models currently on the market are "fully autonomous" on highways, for example. Don't underestimate the innovation that can still happen there. "All new MRT lines built since the North East line in 2003 were equipped with CBTC from the outset, and have the capability to be completely driverless and automated, requiring no onboard staffing." p.s. I rode on the driverless line several times in 2011 and 2012. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Rapid_Transit_(Singapore) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Rapid_Transit_(Singapore)
- EliRivers 7y agoBy the time this will be in effect, public transit will have been transformed (if not removed) by private, automated transportation. Honestly can't tell; is this because you're massively pessimistic about how long it will take the proposals to come into effect, or because you're massively optimistic about the advent of private, automated transportation?