8 ms·
"on a three-acre footprint" Is there a reason these installations are always shown laid out very flat? Is there a disadvantage to stacking them up or at least
by sp332 7y ago
"on a three-acre footprint"
Is there a reason these installations are always shown laid out very flat? Is there a disadvantage to stacking them up or at least putting them on different floors of an appropriately-reinforced building?
- Zekio 7y agoWell I would assume they weigh a ton and moving them and/or replacing them will be less troublesome if you can just bring a crane or something similar
- bertil 7y agoAmusingly, heavy things carried up and down by cranes are a promising way to store electricity.
- Dylan16807 7y agoI can't really agree with 'promising'. A tower that can lift 100 tons 50 meters is not exactly cheap, and only stores 13.6 kilowatt hours.
- redler 7y agoHere’s a company pursuing that very idea. https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surprisingly-efficient-way-to-store-energy/ https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surpris...
- mbreese 7y agoExactly. It’s really the same principle as pumping water uphill except using concrete blocks and a crane. Potential energy is potential energy. I’d just love to see it in action.
- Dylan16807 7y agoAh, if you actually build the structure out of the items you're lifting, then that certainly changes the math. Compared to just lifting with a crane you get a thousand times the capacity at the same infrastructure price.
- amirhirsch 7y agoconsider off shore gravity batteries that can drop mass down 2 to 4km. Major fixed cost is Hvdc out 100miles, but it’s extremely scalable after that.
- Geee 7y agoI wonder how much more energy this setup would store if they added cranes. Also it could be possible to make a circular vacuum maglev train out of these and add energy to it by accelerating.
- mbay 7y agoThere was an episode of Nova about energy storage that included a company that made kinetic energy storage devices. IIRC they had 5000 pound flywheels that spin in a vacuum and can be installed in your home. Expensive to purchase and install but essentially unlimited lifespan and totally renewable.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoI've heard about either a working system, or a calculation of something like that but with regular trains. Long story short, it can't actually store that much energy. More efficient (and less mechanically complicated) would be pumping water up a hill into a lake.
- astrodust 7y agoLead-acid batteries are pretty damned heavy and would make a great kinetic battery as well as a chemical one.
- IshKebab 7y agoYes, it's more expensive. They're not normally situated where land is expensive. You can ask the same question about car parks. Same answer. Building up or down is expensive.
- sneak 7y agoSpace isn’t an issue in the places you need to locate these things, with a few notable exceptions (eg Japan). Building up is a lot more expensive, and there is no shortage of available land on Earth at the moment.
- FluffyKitty 7y agoProbably just the simple economics of cost of land vs cost of construction of a new building + ongoing maintenance. I'm sure if they ever saw need to place this in a city they would construct a building. But for now, it's probably cheaper to just build out where land is cheap (and possibly closer to generation source) and then transport the energy to where it's being used.
- malandrew 7y agoHow safe would it be to put large quantities of a potentially unstable alkali metal in close proximity to lots of humans?
- core-questions 7y agoI mean, we all sleep with phones under our pillow, so
- floatrock 7y agoI know your comment is meant as a potshot, but it actually points out an interesting side-point: safer than putting in a natural gas plant. In California, the Puente gas plant made headlines last year because they found it was cheaper to create battery storage than an equivalently-sized gas peaker plant. A large part was permitting and land rights. People don't want an emissions-spewing gas plant in their backyard, but an array of batteries in what looks like every other industrial warehouse is much more palatable. (Time-to-go-live was another factor: battery arrays are modular and can be distributed across multiple sites to further minimize risk, a gas plant is a massive multi-year centralized organizational challenge with all the associated costs and all-or-nothing risks) https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/sce-picks-major-battery-portfolio-in-place-of-puente-gas-plant https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/sce-picks-major...
- elihu 7y agoBesides land being cheap outside of cities, it might also be a safety thing. Like, you might not want batteries close enough that if one catches fire it could catch the rest on fire too. You might also want easy access for fire crews.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]