4 ms·
Worth pointing out that, as purely an exercise in military hardware intelligence, the Navy surely learned far more about China's fancy new drone than the People
by ajross 7y ago
Worth pointing out that, as purely an exercise in military hardware intelligence, the Navy surely learned far more about China's fancy new drone than the People's Liberation Army did about the capabilities of a 30 year old missile cruiser.
- branchan 7y agoMaybe China WANTED the US to know about their drone technology.
- adventured 7y agoMore likely the US has known about the Xianglong since around the time that its development began. It has been public knowledge that they were working on it for at least 13 years now. Its capabilities would be very unlikely to surprise at this point. Globally the UAV space is well understood and mostly incremental, nobody has unleashed anything too surprising or radical in the field since the Global Hawk 20 years ago. The odds are the US military understands well what China's UAVs can and can't do, without requiring these flights to inform that particular aspect. The Navy probably appreciated getting an opportunity to track it however. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guizhou_Soar_Dragon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guizhou_Soar_Dragon
- igravious 7y agoA thought struck me while reading this piece. That these UAVs make the world a lot safer. Countries can surveil, do reconnissance, and remotely monitor better without risking human life. This enhances security and stability because there are less surprises. Also if a drone gets shot down, even though it's expensive loss and the gesture is hostile, it's not so hostile that a lethal response is warranted in return. We saw this play out in the mass media recently. I guess what I'm saying is that I never thought about these machines like this before. Even though they are military hardware, they are conflict-reducing military hardware. In the same way we discourage the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction maybe we should encourage nations to develop high-level military-grade UAV capabilities?
- redis_mlc 7y ago> UAVs make the world a lot safer. Sweet Jesus, no. The next world war will be started with drones. Without a bodycount, many politicians are ok with initiating conflict. After all, who's gonna complain? No press, no moms, no VA patients - at first. Until there's a loser, who gets "The Terminator", but for real. Another scenario where drones are destabilizing is for surprise attacks. The most successful aerial attacks have been against bases (Pearl Harbor, Taranto, Egypt.) Drones would make planning first strikes even easier with real-time ground truth.
- beamatronic 7y agoYes, let the robots fight instead of humans
- TomK32 7y agoLet those old farts who start the wars fight it out.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoNo, the Iranian downing very nearly led to open war, it was only Trumps genuine unwillingness to start killing that prevented it, no other part of the military apparatus showed any restraint over an unmanned drone.
- ryanmercer 7y ago
- ajross 7y agoWhat China WANTED was a press hit like this, making them look big and important on the world stage. There was no need for surveillance here at all. They knew exactly what that cruiser was doing, the whole point of that naval mission was, after all, to say "Hey China! These waters aren't yours! Look at our giant cruiser sailing around with impunity!".
- codyb 7y agoThe only reason that might be true is if no one read the article (so, depressingly plausible). Quotes like “ The US has hundreds of comm satellites... China only has dozens... hampers ability to stream high quality imagery... or even control the uav ...a total of seven Xhialong have been seen at three sites... China only recently deployed their Xhialong’s, while the US has had Global Hawks in air since the 1990s The Pentagon employs tens of thousands of UAV operators, it will take China a long time to catch up China has trouble producing military grade engines for helicopters, planes, uavs... “ Didn’t really paint a great picture of China’s military capabilities to me. And those are just the ones I remember off the top of my head.
- krageon 7y agoIt is of course always in the best interest of a country to make it seem as if its military is much better organised and more well-equipped than its adversaries. In other words, I'd take such statements with a grain of salt.