9 ms·
Same as Gitlab then[0]. US Sanctions should not affect internet services (so long as they are provided for free)[1], but political pressure appears to be very
by dijit 7y ago
Same as Gitlab then[0].
US Sanctions should not affect internet services (so long as they are provided for free)[1], but political pressure appears to be very strong.
Personally I find it quite abhorrent, and would cite this as a reason not to use US based companies in future.
[0]: https://about.gitlab.com/2018/07/19/gcp-move-update/ https://about.gitlab.com/2018/07/19/gcp-move-update/
[1]: https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/Programs/Documents/ukraine_gl_9.pdf https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/Programs/...
- jlengrand 7y agoWell thanks for the extra info :). Sad news imho :S.
- krageon 7y agoThere was already the privacy concerns and complete lack of ethical oversight. Now we have some more ethical reasons not to use them.
- marcthe12 7y agoThe thing I am woried is that harfbuzz is developed by Iranian developer. It is an integral part of Linux font stack.
- gtirloni 7y agoWell, for a well-known project, they won't miss GitHub visibility benefits. They can host the git repository anywhere. Self-host an issue tracking system or find a non-US company that does that (and is not required to follow US sanctions due to trade agreements, that'll be hard). It's an annoyance, for sure.
- r3bl 7y agoThe problem is that they'd require a payment method to rent the server somewhere else or to use a non-US company that doesn't offer a generous free plan. The most prominent payment providers (Visa, MasterCard, PayPal) are all US-based. > (and is not required to follow US sanctions due to trade agreements, that'll be hard). I really don't know much about sanctions against Syria and Crimea, but Iranian developers could use every country that hasn't withdrawn from the Iran deal: EU, UK (separate signature, regardless of Brexit), Russia, China.
- quickthrower2 7y agoEnter... crypto
- jdbernard 7y agoBetween the speculative get-rich-quick rollercoaster of Bitcoin and the fraud of other crypto currencies it feels like the promise of decentralization has been forgotten.
- r3bl 7y agoThat's just shifting the problem one inconvenience further. How do you purchase cryptocurrencies without Visa/MasterCard/PayPal?
- quickthrower2 7y agoI'm not sure what options they have, but ideally, for convenience some kind of local country bank transfer, which could be to a local crypto dealer. That might take days but you might "stock up" on crypto to compensate. Or peer to peer cash/crypto swap might be required. Or businesses themselves sell some of their services with crypto.
- chriswwweb 7y agoIt's unfortunately not that easy. Iranian students studying in the UK for example, currently have a lot of trouble to pay their tuition fees. Because the U.S. insists that any bank (from the EU or wherever in the world) that wants to do business in the U.S. must comply to U.S. sanctions, which means an U.K. bank has to choose if it wants to block Iran or get blocked itself in/by the U.S. for doing business with Iran. More about this can be found on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_sanctions_against_Iran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_sanctions_agains....
- rjzzleep 7y agoEven before the US withdrew a lot of financial institutions wouldn't allow doing any kind of transactions with iran. It's not like the sanctions were actually dropped even though they were supposed to. That was the whole point of the critiques of the JCPOA.
- LeonidasXIV 7y agoBehdad Esfahbod lives in Canada though, also most of his FOSS contribution (pango, fontconfig etc) are on the freedesktop.org and GNOME git repo servers, not GitHub.
- dijit 7y agoI know this is just nitpicking, but US Sanctions apply to sanctioned state nationals; regardless of location.
- styx31 7y agoAre you sure ? Quoted from GitHub CEO Nat Friedman on Twitter: > The restrictions are based on place of residence and location, not on nationality or heritage. If someone was flagged in error, they can fill out a form to get the restrictions lifted on their account within hours.
- dijit 7y ago> Any company or national of Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Sudan, Syria, and the Crimea region. Export licensing of commodities or services intended for these countries is presumed denied; Wording like this appears on the treasury documents, Google cloud and Oracles official documentation on sanctions. I'll just link the Oracle one because ironically the one that google uses is really difficult to find: http://www.oracle.com/us/products/export/export-regulations-345813.html http://www.oracle.com/us/products/export/export-regulations-...
- jwieczorek 7y agoBy that wording, who is a national of the Crimea region? Did they mean residents?
- chriswwweb 7y agoNo they don't! The sanction is against the country, not nationals. So if you are a developer from the U.S. with U.S. nationality and move to Cuba the sanctions would also apply to you. Actually there is a very good wikipedia page "United States sanctions against Iran" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_sanctions_against_Iran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_sanctions_agains... about this, if you want more info.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dijit 7y agoI would have said "move to git.kernel.org" but that's also hosted by a US based provider: organisation: ORG-PHI3-RIPE org-name: Packet Host Inc org-type: OTHER address: 30 Vesey Street, Suite 900, New York, NY 10007 US And, obviously GNOME git servers are US based, since they're owned by RedHat/IBM.
- maze-le 7y agoUse a self hosted gogs installation (https://gogs.io/ https://gogs.io/) under your own domain and root server outside US jurisdiction.
- swiley 7y agoOr just use ssh. That’s what I’ve always done with my friends when we didn’t want to use GitHub. There’s no need to over complicate things.
- nerdponx 7y agoGitLab is self-hostable as well, although I imagine Gogs is easier.
- dijit 7y agoGitlab is actually super easy if you keep to the omnibus installation methods or docker image. The only problem regarding gitlab is resource consumption.
- cuillevel3 7y agoIf your company operates in the US and uses a provider, who does not implement sanctions, does it have to enforce them on its own? I mean, something like selling a product, maybe based on open source tech in the US and cooperating with devs in sanctioned countries via a workaround provider..
- cyphar 7y agoIf we end up with a project like [1] actually taking off, then with Secure Scuttlebutt you wouldn't need to care about server hosting and the pub servers could be distributed globally. [1]: https://people.kernel.org/monsieuricon/patches-carved-into-developer-sigchains https://people.kernel.org/monsieuricon/patches-carved-into-d...
- behdad 7y agoHey. HarfBuzz maintainer here. I live in the States but one of our core developers is in Iran. This whole incident was a huge miscommunication on github. Fortunately they have addressed some of it. In short: Open Source and public repos are not affected at all. Cheers
- onetimemanytime 7y agothey took the easy way out...ban them all, just in case. Not worth the trouble or lawyer fees explaining it to DOJ
- murbard2 7y agoI don't think it is about political pressure in the sense that, I doubt the USG fundamentally cares about whether or not Iranians can use GitHub or not. For companies like Google or Microsoft, this is about minimising the attack surface because they do other (legal) things that the USG does care about. You can't punish a tech giant just for doing a tech giant, but you could try to make other things stick.
- wickerman 7y agoThe amount of harassment that citizens of any state that the US claims to hate at any given time endure on a daily basis is disgusting. Exiled iranians living outside of Iran for 20 years have got their bank accounts closed solely for being Iranian. I can't help but think that these internet services will be going that way in the future. The fact that the "free software" community is not putting their foot down for this is disgusting. Especially when there's so much back-patting when it comes to "the value of the community". Where's the community for crimean or iranian developers?
- AmericanChopper 7y agoYa know what was actually disgusting? The war in Iraq, or any other recent regime change the US executed. If economic warfare is the way it’s done now, then that’s great. Let the casualties be inconvenienced github users, rather than ya know, actual casualties...
- cdmckay 7y agoYou realize that sanctions also kill people through lack of supplies like medicine being available, people being unable to economically support themselves, and, if the sanctions cause the government to collapse, all the death that results from that. So let’s not pretend sanctions are somehow nonviolent.
- celticmusic 7y agoand yet, that will be less than the war in iraq. It's github. I would personally be inconvenienced, but not terribly so. I cannot imagine their life is going to crash in some meaningful way for not having access to github.
- tehbeard 7y ago> it's github. Are you naive enough to think the sanction is explicitly targeted exactly at github, and not any number of services, or part of a wider economic attack?
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> Personally I find it quite abhorrent, and would cite this as a reason not to use US based companies in future. Then I’d highly recommend that you try doing that. I consulted for a company once that tried this, and it was an absolute nightmare. Every single piece of technology they used was worse than second rate. Making comments on HN is really easy, backing them up with action, in this case, is not.
- mugsie 7y agoAny company that does business in the US, or with another company that does business in the US. Not just US based companies are subject to these restrictions (if they want to sell into the US)
- AmericanChopper 7y agoDon’t make it too hard on yourself. If you want to use your own economic clout to take a swing at the US, then just stick to boycotting US companies. See if it’s even possible to operate your project like that. You’ll be taking a step back in time by at least 10 years.
- mugsie 7y agoI am not sure I could do it at all. The Linux Foundation is a US corporation, and that rules out nearly all my options for the work I personally do. (and, well working for one doesn't help it either)
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThen make it even easier. Only apply the principle to services or products you pay for.
- dijit 7y agoThe sensibility you have expressed is chiefly why we should fight US dominance of the tech sector. Not why we should lean in to it.
- cochne 7y agoIt looks like the free services provided by GitHub are still available: "A selection of GitHub services such as access to public repositories will remain available to everyone, the company said in a statement on its website. “This includes limited access to GitHub public repository services (such as access to GitHub Pages and public repositories used for open source projects), for personal communications only, and not for commercial purposes.”
- mieseratte 7y agoSo what can't restricted foreign-nationals do? Private, paid-for repositories? Is there something else particularly important?
- Algent 7y agoIf I recall right from previous thread they can still create and commit to public repo but can't delete them. They also can't touch even their own private repo anymore.
- theturtletalks 7y agoThey added the option to make private repos public so you can back it up. But again, you can’t delete the now public repo.
- emilfihlman 7y ago>They added the option to make private repos public so you can back it up. And allow all to see their contents, likes business and trade secrets. Top tier.
- theturtletalks 7y agoYep. If you want to access your blocked private repo, you literally have to let everyone access it. And you can’t even delete it afterwards.
- thenickperson 7y agoThis affects companies that have US users too. Your only option is to move out of the US and not use products with any users in the US. That means your only option is China, which is far worse for online rights than the US.
- miracle2k 7y agoLike I wrote somewhere else, the Gitlab case is both worse and better. Gitlab did not make a specific decision to block Iranian users, it merely made a technical decision to move to Google Cloud, and Google Cloud is blocking sanctioned countries on a network level (which is abhorrent). But I don't see Gitlab making an active decision that they have to do this for sanctions compliance reasons, it was just a side-effect and they didn't care enough for it to change their minds about the move. Specifically, if I sign up to Gitlab, set my country of residence to Iran, and Gitlab lets me create private repositories, then they are not enforcing the sanctions the way Github does.
- espeed 7y agoSee comments in this previous thread from 31 days ago [1]... Google Safety & Security Blog: An update on state-sponsored activity (2018) ... Detecting and terminating activity on Google properties "Actors engaged in this type of influence operation violate our policies, and we swiftly remove such content from our services and terminate these actors’ accounts. Additionally, we use a number of robust methods, including IP blocking, to prevent individuals or entities in Iran from opening advertising accounts." ---//--- [1] "An Open Letter to Google and Apple: Stop Hindering Iranian Entrepreneurs" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20302547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20302547
- whoopdedo 7y agoCan we start calling this "The Great Reverse Firewall"?
- espeed 7y agoNot all of it is US sanctions [1]. The US will protect its networks and will not allow a foreign adversary to use US platforms to target US citizens, but the US has no incentive to restrict the Iranian people's access to information or communications or ability to speak. Most of Iran's cyberspace restrictions are coming from within... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Iran https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Iran [1] "Iran's Rulers Speak Of More Cyberspace Restrictions As Conditions Worsen" https://en.radiofarda.com/a/iran-s-rulers-speak-of-more-cyberspace-restrictions-as-conditions-worsen/29909929.html https://en.radiofarda.com/a/iran-s-rulers-speak-of-more-cybe...
- not_a_cop75 7y agoYeah, it's totally abhorrent that the US blocks people that would prefer they get wiped off the face of the earth. How dare they!!!
- syndacks 7y agoYour sentence uses "they" ambiguously, FYI. Two very different interpretations possible.
- alt_f4 7y agoHave you considered that regular people that live under an oppressive totalitarian government have no control over said government and are actually just victims?
- not_a_cop75 7y agoHave you ever lived in the US?
- csomar 7y agoI think non-US companies have to comply with the sanctions too. Your alternative will be the pool of sanctioned countries and friends. Which don’t have the infrastructure most people need.
- yxhuvud 7y agoThere is no real difference between sanctions on internet service and any other thing, except things directly involved in the reasons for the sanctions (notably military material)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]