6 ms·
Why not just price water to reflect supply realities? Why would anyone care about saving water when it's so dirt cheap? "Awareness" seems like a waste of time
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
Why not just price water to reflect supply realities?
Why would anyone care about saving water when it's so dirt cheap? "Awareness" seems like a waste of time in comparison.
- wrong_variable 7y agoBeing able to "price" something requires existence of a functional market. Markets can only exist when contracts can be enforced. Being able to enforce a contract requires monitoring and ability to issue fines, you also needs appropriate laws. All of the above does not exist when it comes to ground water harvesting - especially in India and even in a police state like China.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoYet companies build plants on the Great Lakes, hoover up all the water, filter it, bottle it, and sell it to the unsuspecting, who happily buy it. I never ever saw bottled water as a kid in Europe. It wasn't until I moved to the US where it appeared to be commonplace. When I went back home to England last year, they've got it in every supermarket I visited. Sad, really. I still just drink out of the tap here in Texas.
- swimfar 7y agoWhat you wrote about bottled water not being a thing in Europe is definitely country specific. When I lived in Germany none of my German friends drank water from the tap. They would buy packs of bottled water for drinking at home.
- brianwawok 7y agoDepends on where exactly you live. Much of the US cities have great tap water. Some places (Flint) get lead going on. However, much of the water in the US by area is well water. Well water tastes gross, and has some dubious health effects if not filtered right. Bottled water seems reasonable for those people. Just because bottled water is not useful for you, does not mean it's not useful for anyone.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoI never said it wasn't useful. Obviously there are people who need it. I just won't pay for it when I already do by paying for house water. Our tap water is clean here in Texas.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pkaye 7y agoI've heard though in Europe it is more common to have sparkling water in restaurants while in the US its plain water (maybe filtered tap water)
- chupasaurus 7y agoThe only reason for that is to charge more.
- padobson 7y agoYet companies build plants on the Great Lakes, hoover up all the water, filter it, bottle it, and sell it to the unsuspecting I can't speak for every state, but here in Michigan (The Great Lakes state!), companies like Nestle have to apply for a license that subjects them to regular inspections to make sure they're not over-burdening the local groundwater supply. They pump from wells on their own private land using their own facilities. Their license fee is pretty cheap, something like $300USD. This seems like a common-sense regulation that doesn't overly burden either the company or the regulator. I buy Ice Mountain spring water with a clear conscience.
- sitkack 7y agoThe aquifers they pump from definitely reach beyond their land. Your con-science shouldn't be so easily manipulated.
- SilasX 7y agoIf it makes you feel any better, California is perfectly capable of doing all that, but they still don't, and are stuck in a tragedy-of-the-commons type water shortage where farmers will gladly waste $1 of water to produce 5 cents of crops, because the alternative is to get nothing.
- ip26 7y agoAdditionally, if they don't waste $1 of water to produce $0.05 of crops & do nothing with it instead, they lose the water rights next year.
- r00fus 7y agoDoes market economics work if there's no way to prevent the tragedy of the commons?
- not_a_cop75 7y agoThis is the most important question of our era.
- ip26 7y agoThat's a confusing question. The tragedy of the commons happens specifically when a resource is under- or un-priced.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoIt's not a confusing question. The tragedy of the commons happens when a company or person abuses a resource that is provided for the good of all. We can look at any company and realize that compared to an average individual the pollution and resource consumption is crazy. The problem with industry is that everything is value added but nobody looks at externalities sufficiently or value subtracted.
- jbay808 7y agoIf a free market is left alone to set prices, do any resources end up under-priced?
- ip26 7y agoNo- but that presupposes the existence of a well functioning free market, which everyone agrees we do not have with water.
- aeorgnoieang 7y agoThe key is to 'sell' or 'gift' the property rights to the resources that were previously part of the commons (and to a party that can economically protect their new asset). I'm hoping one day something like that will happen with fisheries, e.g. someone will own fisheries or maybe even schools of fish. Anything less seems doomed to tragedy. Note that government management of a previously 'commons' resource is, in theory, the same basic arrangement. In practice tho, the very different incentives shaping government organizations doesn't seem to as reliably protect resources as for private entities. ('Markets fail'. Governments fail too. What's the expected difference in the rate of failure of the two?)
- Amezarak 7y agoA lot of people outside of cities have their own groundwater wells, which is at least part of what the article is talking about. How do you price water people are pulling directly from the ground with their own equipment?
- ip26 7y agoAren't water wells permitted? In that case, you simply require a meter, ideally the cellular or zigbee sort. I'm sure there would be water bandits but it doesn't seem totally impossible.
- ricardobeat 7y agoOr simply charge more for the license itself.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoI assure you that you will have a very difficult time enforcing permit rules anywhere that is not dense enough to have town water.
- ip26 7y agoWho knows, farmers understand that they essentially compete with their neighbor for groundwater, so maybe they would police eachother & ensure that everyone plays fair & had a meter. Just dreaming.
- tclancy 7y agoHang on, you want me to pay the local government for water under my land that they don't treat or pump for me? You're going to have to adjust some property laws in the US (and at least England and Canada I would guess) to do that.
- ip26 7y agoLook, it's not my pet project, I'm just pointing out that if we decided we needed to track groundwater usage for whatever reason- price, allocation, whatever- it could probably be reasonably done.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoBecause we as a society have decided that we are all better off if it's cheap enough that poor people can still use it on a whim. Of course this results in some people over-using but we think that's less of a problem.
- azinman2 7y agoI don’t know about the rest of the US, but in SF water pricing is tiered. A small amount costs x per gallon. A larger amount costs 2x per gallon. And even larger amount costs 4x per gallon, etc. Unfortunately the rich can still abuse this, as it’s not actually proportionate to income. I wish more public fees were, like speeding tickets, car registration costs, etc, so that rich/poor impact was more normalized. N.B. The multipliers are illustrative and not the actual numbers.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoTiered pricing seems like a decent compromise. Scaled pricing is stupid. I didn't work my ass off climbing the ladder just to get screwed out of the same fraction of my money by the government as when I brought home a few hundred a week. If you want to cut the poor a break then make fees and fines tax deductible.
- sitkack 7y agoAhhhh, I want a gold classism card as well. Climbing the ladder is a choice that the rest of shouldn't have to bear. Your choice, your price.
- nshepperd 7y agoArtificial suppression of water prices is equivalent to a direct cash transfer proportional to water usage. The more water you waste, the more money you get. The exact same thing (making the poor able to afford water) could be accomplished much less destructively by making the cash transfer a flat constant (thereby not incentivizing gratuitous water wastage).
- plutonorm 7y agoGreat idea. Then when the air gets dirty we can just charge people for purified air.
- triceratops 7y agoI get that you're being facetious. But if purified air became sufficiently expensive, and it was the only way to breathe, everyone really would get serious about polluting less.
- mikepurvis 7y agoWould they? The whole point of a polluted commons is that no one actor is able to make an impact from their own choices. Only collective action can make a difference, and that requires an enforceable agreement to cooperate plus enforcement to make sure that no one cheats. In a world of unbreatheable air, the most rational individual action is not to reduce polluting; rather, it's to pollute as hard as possible in order to make lots of money with which to buy purified air.
- triceratops 7y ago> Only collective action can make a difference, But how do you motivate collective action and fight apathy? High prices are one way to do it.
- thatoneuser 7y agoOr more like the people at the bottom would be choking to death while the top % of the world would go on without changing anything because it wouldn't affect them. Unless you're proposing to apply a sliding cost based on income (good luck) this would just lead to poor genocide.
- driverdan 7y agoThat's not a reasonable comparison. A more realistic one would be to tax anything that pollutes the air to compensate for the cost of purifying it. Which is a great idea.
- abraae 7y agoExactly. My father in law lives in a town that has no water metering (and usually, but not always, plenty of water). In the summer he puts his sprinklers in 2 or 3 times a day, even when dire warnings are issued about water consumption. Human behavior is all about the impact on the back pocket (particularly if you are a pensioner).
- bilbo0s 7y agoWhere does he live? Serious question. I'd be interested in whether or not his behavior is a function of living in an area drowning in fresh water sources? If he does not live in such an area, then I'm really interested in how the municipality is able to keep the price of water that low? That would seem to defy the rule of supply and demand in my mind.
- Spooky23 7y agoMost places in the Northeast have an abundance of water, and water rates mostly fund infrastructure. For example, NYC only began metering water usage in 1986.
- abraae 7y agoHe's not in the US, but in a town of 160K-odd people, with a very decent river running right through. Water is indeed very cheap, but the main thing is that there's no metering. Metering is seen by some as taking away their rights, and possibly leading the elderly/poor to skimp on water and thus hygiene - so there is considerable resistance to water metering. It's not a sustainable position though (because of people like him :) and metering must arrive one day.
- avip 7y agoDo you care about saving petrol?
- yummypaint 7y agoDoing so would probably make poor people die of dehydration as scarcity increases. Those with the means to drill their own wells will do so, especially if there is a strong commercial incentive. We already saw this play out in past years in california as individual humans faced onerous water restrictions while big agro continued to grow almonds using the same water supply. Bringing symmetry to regulations should be the first priority before any further burden is placed on individuals.