16 ms·
Alibaba partner announces 16 core RISC-V chip
- rwmj 7y agoThere are several links available for this announcement, but none of them are that great. Alternatives: https://kr-asia.com/alibabas-pingtouge-launches-own-processor-aiming-to-be-a-chip-infrastructure-provider-for-ai-and-iot https://kr-asia.com/alibabas-pingtouge-launches-own-processo... https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-07-25/alibaba-chip-subsidiary-launches-first-product-using-open-source-architecture-101443785.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-07-25/alibaba-chip-subsidi...
- yorwba 7y agoAlibaba doesn't seem to have any press releases written about this, not even in Chinese. All reporting seems to be based on what CTO Zhang Jianfeng said at the currently ongoing Alibaba Cloud Summit ( https://summit.aliyun.com/ https://summit.aliyun.com/ ). Maybe they'll have more information on the specifics once the summit is over.
- dang 7y agoThose do seem marginally better so we swapped out https://onties.com/china/brother-pingtou-released-the-first-chip-xuantie-910-the-strongest-risc-v-processor-in-the-industry-pingtous-brother-the-first-the-chip-xuan-tie-910-the-strongest-risc-v-processing-technolo/ https://onties.com/china/brother-pingtou-released-the-first-... for one of them.
- joelthelion 7y agoWhat's the significance of this announcement? What are the likely markets for this chip?
- rwmj 7y agoI don't have any special knowledge on this, but from the announcement: According to reports, Black Iron [Xuan Tie] 910 can be used to design and produce high-performance end-to-end 5G chips, artificial intelligence and automatic driving. So I guess they want to sell it as an alternative to ARM/nVidia/Qualcomm in those roles.
- yourfate 7y agoI'd assume custom server hardware for ali's cloud services.
- privateSFacct 7y agoChina is going to be key here. It's not just a normal market - China may see this as essential to its ability to develop its technology. It's Made in Chine 2025 policy. That's taken on new urgency as the west has started cutting China off from western tech - so it may be normal companies wanting some insurance in case intel / arm cut them off (trade disputes etc) AND the govt itself wanting to product its industrial base from cutoff during trade disputes.
- IceWreck 7y agoFor one, RISC-V is fully open hardware unlike x86, amd64, arm and other architectures. More adoption is always a good thing.
- majewsky 7y agoRISC-V is an open ISA, but a particular RISC-V chip is not necessarily open hardware. In fact, most probably aren't.
- tpetry 7y agoWhat i don‘t get is how optimizations should work for Risc-V. For e.g. intel chips you can do optimizations for every generation because some things have been optimized in the architecture so you can do different tricks. But with risc-v only the instruction set is the same and every cpu could implement it differently with different performance characteristics. How should someone optimize for this?
- rwmj 7y agoThere's two ways: Firstly different chips will have different sets of extensions. Secondly macro-op fusion - you can optimize particular sequences of instructions in order to try to get certain optimized micro ops, and it's expected in future that different sequences will be needed on different cores. A "wrong" sequence will run slowly but still run. Of course all of this is a PITA from our (software) point of view.
- floatboth 7y agoIt's been already happening with ARM. Clang has tune flags for cortex-$generation, thunderx, thunderx2 (vulcan), (not upstream yet) emag… and regular distributions ship generic just like on amd64 :)
- tpetry 7y agoYeah because ARM sells the complete implementation for the ARM core. But with Risc-V there may be hundreds of different implementations, you can‘t really add optimizations for everyone.
- stunt 7y agoChina's market is enough for it. Also all national security stuff.
- mbrumlow 7y agoIndeed. RISC architecture is gonna change everything.
- nickik 7y agoI would really liked to know what extentions they will support. Will the support the Vector extention? How about some of the once that are not quite finished yet, like Bit manipulations.
- snvzz 7y ago>I would really liked to know what extentions they will support. Me too. >Will the support the Vector extention? The vector (V) extension is not standarized yet. It'll likely take two years, as per updates in recent conferences. >How about some of the once that are not quite finished yet, like Bit manipulations. That one (X) isn't ready either, but more likely to be ready soon.
- Symmetry 7y agoJust because standardization isn't finished doesn't mean they won't go ahead an build the closest thing to the current consensus they can manage.
- tpetry 7y agoOr build something they prefer. If someone is too slow in standardizing there often many concurring „standards“ because people needed a solution.
- childintime 7y agoThat and the power envelope
- mtgx 7y agoThey probably won't be in a hurry to support the security extensions.
- londons_explore 7y agoHow long before Android runs properly on RISC-V? And will they be able to persuade app-makers to rebuild all apps for the platform - x86 Android shows how hard that can be.
- buildzr 7y agoMany apps will work with minimal if any changes as they don't use native stuff at all. There's also some interesting solutions for this like libhoudini that emulates ARM to make many native apps work without any effort on the app developers part.
- asdfzxh 7y agowrr
- sct202 7y agoIf China's doing the push, they only need their local app ecosystem to move over.
- jdietrich 7y agoTo a first approximation, "local app ecosystem" = "WeChat".
- microcolonel 7y ago> How long before Android runs properly on RISC-V? It's mostly up to OpenJDK and V8 porting. When it comes to porting V8, I've found out the hard way that there's more to it than a generic understanding of compilers. Somebody still has to step up to the plate for a real JVM. > And will they be able to persuade app-makers to rebuild all apps for the platform - x86 Android shows how hard that can be. Real x86 Android devices had libhoudini (DBT), which was pretty decent. If RISC-V starts with low-end devices, or with a high-visibility model that developers are pretty sure will sell well, then the native compilation target will become more popular over time. If China's bizarre local app market is involved, chances are they'll start supporting the target as soon as it's available.
- tgtweak 7y agoArticle explaining the relevance of this news: https://technode.com/2019/07/24/chinas-chipmakers-risc-v-sanctions/ https://technode.com/2019/07/24/chinas-chipmakers-risc-v-san...
- estomagordo 7y agoLink seems terribly dead =/
- jtbayly 7y agoWorked for me.
- exohuman 7y agoTry again? I was able to see it.
- chvid 7y agoThis article adds good background. Also what the announcement seems to be about is a design for a chip yet to be put into production. How this will compare to arm and intel cpus in terms of cost and performance is unclear (to me).
- class4behavior 7y agoJust load it via an archive? https://web.archive.org/web/20190724090600/https://technode.com/2019/07/24/chinas-chipmakers-risc-v-sanctions/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190724090600/https://technode.... https://archive.is/I5bgm https://archive.is/I5bgm
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 7y agoBeing in Arm's position sucks now. Would they not be so enthusiastic about sanctions, Chinese would've been way more cautious jumping on RISC-V boat. Now instead of having RISC-V as one off research projects, which would have probably died off silently, now they are all treated as survival essential projects.
- mark_l_watson 7y agoI agree. I feel like we (USA) are forcing China on a path that will make them more competitive long term.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI wonder if most of what we are doing is being done for political purposes? Sort of, just to look good and get more votes. And if so, you kind of have to admit that from that perspective, the calculation works out even if China surges ahead even faster. (In fact, you might even be able to use that surge, to do more grandstanding, to get more votes.) Not saying this is 100% what's going on, but it's undoubtedly a factor in the equation here.
- privateSFacct 7y agoFor sure. Third party countries may also decide less risk in buying from China (ie, China less likely to cut them off because of real or perceived issues).
- adrianN 7y agoAnd in the end competition is good for normal people, so great job?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- madez 7y agoEurope could have stepped up and become competitive long before, but they are too complacent with the status quo. It's good that finally someone steps up.
- microcolonel 7y agoToo bad they only quoted the CoreMark, and only compared it to an in-order processor. I'd love to see a real benchmark, and a comparison to a processor in the same ballpark in terms of power and area.
- bogwog 7y agoThis is both awesome and terrifying. I'll never forget this research(https://www.wired.com/2016/06/demonically-clever-backdoor-hides-inside-computer-chip/ https://www.wired.com/2016/06/demonically-clever-backdoor-hi...) which showed how an attacker can insert a backdoor into a chip during the manufacturing process in a way that is practically impossible to catch. That makes me very concerned about using a chip completely manufactured in China. But at the same time, RISC-V needs to happen. It's a critical step to move computing forward. It's just a damn shame that this is the way it's going to happen. Hopefully this will push RISC-V manufacturing efforts in the US before the market becomes flooded with cheap open source and most likely backdoored chips manufactured in China.
- microcolonel 7y agoNobody can afford to keep the compilers and subroutine libraries to themselves, so the more people use the ISA, the more useful it becomes. Even if you wouldn't in a million years deploy such a chip at your financial institution or on your email server; or, without a separate network, in your home.
- flohofwoe 7y agoNot sure how to best say it, but I think in the end it's better to not put any trust into any hardware- (or software-) provider anyway, it shouldn't matter whether your chips are built by a "good" or "bad" actor, just assume it's a bad actor when designing the systems around it. Maybe this leads to more robust systems overall, also for cases when there was no "evil intent" (see Spectre/Meltdown).
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's not practical. If bytes anywhere in memory can trigger a backdoor, webservers won't be possible because they have to listen to arbitrary requests.
- madez 7y agoIt's maybe not practical, but it is not impossible. You can build a four-component system that does the job. You build two computers with different ISAs from vendors you assume to not share a backdoor, and let all I/O happen through a simple verifier, that copies the input for both machines, compares byte for byte their output. For cryptographic purposes, the random number generators of the machines must be linked, which would be our forth component. The software for each computer should be derived from different sources, which must follow the same I/O specification.
- chvid 7y agoHow does this compare to the Intel X86 CPUs in terms of power consumption, price and performance? Is this CPU a viable alternative for server and desktop computing?
- rwmj 7y agoThis chip exists entirely as a file on a computer, and maybe a few FPGAs, so I doubt even the company announcing this has very much idea. It seems as if they're hoping to get SMIC to manufacture this, so it won't exactly be a competitive node (although China is pouring vast amounts of resources into making their semiconductor manufacturing competitive, so give it a few years).
- chvid 7y agoSo far is this thing actually from being produced? (In time and cost)
- rwmj 7y agoAlthough it sounds radical (16 cores!) it's a rather low end chip. So months to a year, and millions to low 10s of millions of dollars. However the Chinese govt is massively investing in semiconductors at the moment so they will regard that as valuable research and investment rather than a cost.
- gridlockd 7y agoA better question would be, how does it compare to ARM? ARM is generally more competitive in terms of price and power, less competitive in peak performance. RISC-V would have the added price advantage of being royalty-free.
- bhouston 7y agoWhen will RISC-V move to multi-chip modules (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-chip_module https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-chip_module) as AMD has done very successfully with Ryzen? It allows for easy scaling of CPU designs as well as increasing yield by making smaller components that have overall lower defect rates. hat seems like the logical next move for most CPU chip vendors/designers except for maybe ARM.
- rwmj 7y ago"RISC-V" isn't an organization that can "move to multi-chip modules". RISC-V is a foundation which essentially publishes a couple of PDF files (the user spec and priv spec) and organizes a bunch of other stuff around reference hardware designs, simulators and the software toolchain. All of this is BSD licensed, so anyone can pick it up and manufacture chips based on the specification or by modifying one of the reference designs. Note that the largest part of designing and building a chip is not the choice of ISA (that's probably well under 10% of it). What you may want to know is whether any manufacturers are going to make modular RISC-V chips. None of them to my knowledge. But most of them are currently focusing on the ARM space (embedded, IoT, AI, etc.) including this particular design.
- digikata 7y agoThe nice thing is that software and work on a RISC-V toolchain can now be much more common for vendors that elect to use RISC-V, though it remains to be seen how well the actual manufactured chip variation gets supported like instruction set extensions, peripherals, and configurations for many cores. ARM had some motivation to help ease the customization pain for tooling for their IP licensees, so I'm curious if RISC-V support will be more like ARM or more like early UNIX vendors.
- monocasa 7y agoLike a lot of chip desicions, this one is based on the effects of the process node in question. So the answer is probably when a company gets to TSMC 7nm while being capable of the high end bonding on the package substrate between chips, at a per chip gate count probably close to the ryzen cpu chips. Before then, it doesn't really make sense.
- ackfoo 7y agoAs expected. When you first outsource your manufacturing base because every decision that generates a few more cents in profit becomes obligatory, and then you conduct an idiotic trade war that cannot possibly restore the skills or supply chain you have lost over 30 years of foolishness, your outsourcing partners are bound to come back and eat your lunch eventually. China is off the chain, and they will naturally compete successfully by producing more efficient architectures and ecosystems that cannot be contained by the old capitalist tools of copyright and trade secrets. Open source will be exploited to beat the US into oblivion, and developers who are heartsick from the bullshit (can't get a MAC address in IOS? Can't run a VOIP app in the background?) Will jump ship in droves. I, for one, am desperate for this to happen, not because I hate America (I don't; I love it) or because I hate capitalism (again, it's the best system we have found) but because American capitalism is totally out of control. Citizens United will be the downfall of a great nation because it allows corporations to control the government instead of the other way around.
- ibic 7y agoHmm, i thought HW is about tech, why are there so many politics and propaganda (or what I perceive as smearing)?
- yipbub 7y ago"anything that satisfies ones intellectual curiosity" https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 1121redblackgo 7y agoThe 'muddying the waters, what about the US' comments on these threads always intrigue me.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoReminds me of Adapteva's Parallela, which I bought and was really excited about, but was obviously a commercial failure. I work on software that has an above-average (but far less than HPC) need for concurrency, but even our most demanding customers seem to be content with off-the-shelf Intel, either because they don't need THAT many cores, or because they value the more sophisticated instructions (like encryption acceleration, etc.) I'm curious to know what kind of use cases y'all work on that might crave something like this.
- Quequau 7y agoWhen they first did their kickstarter they were talking about doing a follow up with 64 cores and being able to connect them together with those fancy pants connectors they had going on. I was all set to buy four... and none of that ever materialised. I got the impression that a lot of folks had unrealistic expectations about how Linux would support the chip right from the start, which honestly wasn't all that surprising recalling the way they worded some of their promotional material.
- panpanna 7y agoOne presenter claimed the board would pay for itself if you used it for mining... I assume something like that would be much easier to implement than a real multicore system like linux but I never heard of anyone mining on their boards.
- UncleOxidant 7y agoMaybe back in 2013 that might have been possible, but it seems like nobody figured out how to effectively use those boards back during that timeframe. And since then GPUs and then custom ASICs took over.
- BubRoss 7y agoModern x64 is very difficult to beat and takes a lot more than just raw core count. The out of order execution, prefetching, multiple execution units, SIMD, cache, cache synchronization etc. are all very strong. I think the space where more weak cores can be utilized but not GPUs is pretty slim. Intel themselves even had that briefly with their high core count out of order atom core chips that didn't take off (or weren't given a chance). I think software that can take advantage of more than a few cores without just using brute force fork-join parallelism in some of the heavy loops is rare. I don't think it has to be that way, but the problem comes down to software architecture which isn't going to be solved by leaving each application programmer to their own devices. It will take libraries that give them the means to do it without having to reason about low level synchronization.
- ev0lv 7y agoFor all my .NET developers, if you want your .NET Core app to target RISC-V ISA, you would need to use Mono AOT and to specify the LLVM target is RISC-V.
- zoobab 7y agoI mirrored the PR of RISC-V foundation here: http://www.zoobab.com/alibaba-unveils-most-powerful-risc-v-processor-to-date http://www.zoobab.com/alibaba-unveils-most-powerful-risc-v-p...