16 ms·
How Turkey Purged Its Intellectuals
- bau5 7y agoiSlam is not an educational app.
- sittingnut 7y agowhat is an "intellectual"? seems a very nebulus and vague concept. perhaps someone who thinks like writers who contribute to nytimes? in that case ... .
- stcredzero 7y agoThe takeaway for those in the US: To detect nascent authoritarianism, look at who in particular is getting persecuted in academia. Another good heuristic: Look at who's over-serious and who is best wielding ridicule.
- monksy 7y agoRight now there are people who have stated criticism of political bias (pro-conservative, conservative-leaning speakers, center-left, etc) that are being punished in the US academic world.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gumby 7y agoI'd be curious about some substantive examples. I have seen that assertion frequently made, and even have attended multiple seminars on the topic (I have some friends very worried about this issue) as well as some FIRE meetings and fundraisers. Yet I typically see the same few examples repeated and amplified. FIRE loves to talk about the cases it has challenged under Title IX -- and it always wins, because the law considers this an important issue! (https://www.thefire.org/issues/title-ix/ https://www.thefire.org/issues/title-ix/) Look at the recent (past couple of days) kerfuffle about Prof Wax, whose statements I consider abhorrent. Based on past practice I am pretty sure she'll keep her job. There are issues around groups peripheral to universes (non-sponsored student groups and the like) but they pretty much by definition aren't part of universities.
- monksy 7y agoNote I'm not the best one to provide you with numerous examples because I don't know where the document is that has detailed all of the examples in the last few years. But hearing about this is fairly frequently. 1. There have been protests about conservative speakers at campuses and universities whom have pulled shady stuff on trying to prevent the speakers from coming. (there was a Dave Rubin one where he was magically moved from a theater to a hockey arena). Substantially high costs on security. (Also video cases of where the security isn't actually enforced [Milo at the Depaul thing.. ] 2. There have been punishments against professors who question the progressive/extreme-left movement. (losing tenure, being brought up that they're "violence-inciting", etc) 3. A Portland professor being brought up on disciplinary actions for doing a POC on how you can get a paper with outrageously false claims published without question. (https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/01/08/author-recent-academic-hoax-faces-disciplinary-action-portland-state https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/01/08/author-recent... This was a team of three that was involved one in the UK) 4. "Diversity offices" - I don't know direct examples here, but from what I've heard they've created trouble.
- zajd 7y agoI think this is his point. You keep hearing about "There have been punishments against professors who question the progressive/extreme-left movement. (losing tenure, being brought up that they're "violence-inciting", etc)" or "Diversity offices have created trouble" but these "examples" are basically non-existent when you actually look for them.
- ryanobjc 7y agoSo a lot of the argument about how "right wing commenters" are unfairly, well, whatevered, is based on some very serious anecdotes. And you know what we say to those - not today. A few things: - Protests are valid free speech expressions. - Holding an entire protest as invalid due to a small number of individual's actions is unfair. - Many of those conservative speakers aren't trying to spread discourse, but trying to create an outrage and play off of that (evidence exists of the malignant intent). While perhaps being protected by the 1st amendment, that's academic dishonesty. And we should not accept prima facie the arguments they're being oppressed. - The portland professor was being brought up based on academic dishonesty, human experimentation, process, and ethics. We're going to need better evidence not to take the disciplinary board at face value. Basically "I hear about this frequently" and "there have been..." is pretty weak evidence. It's mainly relying upon the recency bias, availability cascade, base rate neglect, and our inability to assess large events. For example, the Berkeley campus protest is constantly referred to. The problem is this is a splashy example which distorts people's thinking. People rarely talk about the thousands and thousands of conservative speakers that hold events without a hitch. We cannot talk about a systematic risk by only referring to events that are so rare that we keep on referring to the same one for the last several years! That is _by definition_ the opposite of a systematic bias/risk. Basically I call serious BS. Lack of data, cherrypicking stark examples, and the reuse of the same events over and over again while appealing to the impression that there should be more events like this, when there are not, is garbage.
- mklingen 7y agoJust come out and say what you mean instead of slimy implications. It's obvious you believe in the false narrative that conservatives are somehow being "persecuted" in academia. This is a disengenous lie spread by right wing propaganda networks like fox news from a few cherry-picked examples. And even if it were true, people disagreeing with your position and calling you out on it is not "persecution."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- not_a_cop75 7y agoAndy Ngo, an independent journalist, almost losing his life is hardly a cherry-picked example.
- mklingen 7y agoWTF does Andy Ngo have to do with "persecution" in academia? Is Any Ngo an academic?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Can_Not 7y agoJust a quick fact-check, it would be more accurate to label Andy Ngo as a fascist propagandist and agitator than "independent journalist" and a having a milk shake thrown at you is not "almost losing your life".
- chrisco255 7y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-09-17/colleges-have-way-too-many-liberal-professors https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-09-17/colleg... It's not a lie. Liberals own academia. 39% of colleges have no Republican professors. In many majors, the ratio is between 15 and 20 to one Democrats per Republican. There is no world where ratios like that exist and discrimination doesn't occur.
- askafriend 7y agoThis makes no sense. Why should those be the heuristics we pay attention to?
- stcredzero 7y agoSaul Alinsky
- askafriend 7y agoSorry, you're going to need to try harder than that to convince me.
- wefarrell 7y agoThat's hardly the takeaway from this article. In Turkey the state took jobs and freedom of mobility away from those with ideologies that the regime did not favor. This article says nothing about persecution from the academic establishment to which you refer.
- d1ffuz0r 7y agoSounds like California
- stcredzero 7y agoThat's hardly the takeaway from this article. The article talks about academics being persecuted. In Turkey the state took jobs and freedom of mobility away from those with ideologies that the regime did not favor. Good point. To look for authoritarianism, look for powerful organizations and people taking away jobs and economic security from "those with ideologies the regime did not favor." It works for more types of organizations than just the state.
- zzzcpan 7y ago> look for powerful organizations and people taking away jobs and economic security from "those with ideologies the regime did not favor." That's going to make those people desperate and ready to fight the government. Next step for the government is going to be imprisoning lots of people and manufacturing consent and all that.
- stcredzero 7y agoand manufacturing consent and all that That's another good heuristic. Look for those who manufacture consent, and try to suppress dissent.
- Steko 7y agoOr you could just look for the anti-intellectual movements seeking to marginalize academia in general, which your comment itself appears to stem from.
- philwelch 7y agoCriticizing academic institutions isn't inherently anti-intellectual, any more than criticizing government institutions makes you an anarchist.
- Steko 7y agoHe's not criticizing 'the institutions' so much as their ideas and modernism itself which, funny enough, is one of the 14 handy 'heuristics' for identifing nascent facism that Eco listed in 1995 [1]. It's a good list. At the risk of courting Godwin I'd suggest that 'concentration camps' would be a good 15th point but I guess it's covered more generally. [1] https://kottke.org/16/11/the-14-features-of-eternal-fascism https://kottke.org/16/11/the-14-features-of-eternal-fascism
- philwelch 7y agoThe standard criticism of academia these days is that it has abandoned modernism for postmodernism, not that it's too modernist. Fascism itself was also very modernist in many ways, such as the obsession with industry and technology, the aspiration to innovate "beyond" liberalism and Marxism, and even the artistic and architectural styles it adopted.
- stcredzero 7y agowhich your comment itself appears to stem from Another heuristic: Look out for people who would "argue" purely from resemblances. (And primarily by tarring.) [citation needed] I'm not out to marginalize academia in general. My wife is a former college professor, and a Stanford PhD. However, I would like to call out those in academia who would marginalize others in academia purely for their opinions. If anything, the threat to academic freedom is even more potent, when it comes from within.
- psychometry 7y agoPopulist uprisings against educated people have happened many times throughout modern history from both left- and right-wing movements. Remember this when wannabe autocrats like Trump rail against educational institutions and "coastal elites": It could happen here, too.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoFeel free to look to either side for autocrats. Just because Trump has some autocratic tendencies doesn't mean Obama wasn't also quite full of them. As a nation autocrats tend to be the ones that abuse power rather than limit their power to what has traditionally been acceptable. You can also look to see which presidents support institutions which would seem to allow autocracy to more easily flourish.
- organsnyder 7y agoOP said as much: "from both left- and right-wing movements". Trump is currently in power—Obama is irrelevant at the moment.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoBy that logic, Reagan is also irrelevant, but people spout about Reagan all the time.
- MrLeap 7y agoHistory is rarely irrelevant. The law changed to allow the government to indefinitely detain American citizens without charge or trial under a republican administration. When its sunset came, the power was affirmed by a democrat. The authoritarianism wheel hasn't been turned backwards in a long time.
- shmerl 7y agoThe era of fascists like Erdogan will come to an end as well.
- joncp 7y agoSadly, not as long as human brains are made of meat.
- hyperion2010 7y agoMore 'made using primate genes.' There are many perfectly good brains that could be made out of meat, they just need to have certain bits about social hierarchy from our primate past removed or tweaked.
- race-realist 7y agoand with those removals and tweaks, you erase the fundamental core of humanity - appreciation of beauty, fear of strength, and the journey of the hero to save the damsel.
- tim333 7y agoThere is a trend against that though in spite of meat issue.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThe appeal of a strongman who will “clean up” is always strong. Look how well the message “drain the swamp works.
- mhh__ 7y ago"People have had enough of experts" - Michael Gove God help us
- sremani 7y agoNo, God help the now unemployed experts.
- benj111 7y agoTo be fair Gove would say that. It's like BJ is unlikely to say that the people want a competent PM that makes well thought out decisions, and has tamed hair.
- Vinnl 7y agoI really dislike people bringing that quote up, because the full sentence was "People have had enough of experts (...) who are consistently getting it wrong". [1] It's still not necessarily true, but by taking just part of that quote is misrepresenting what he said. Just thought that'd be good to keep in mind next time you might consider digging it up. [1] https://youtu.be/GGgiGtJk7MA?t=71 https://youtu.be/GGgiGtJk7MA?t=71
- duxup 7y agoI wonder if for most folks that it matters. I'll give the speaker the benefit of the doubt just for the sake of argument, but I have my doubt most people voting for folks decrying "experts" or "the establishment" have paid the least bit attention to what experts actually say. The end results seems to be the same sort of "oh man those jokers" argument in favor of ... some folks who seem like bigger jokes / less knowledgeable.
- mhh__ 7y ago"People have had enough of (experts, who are consistently getting it wrong)" Or "People have had enough of experts, (who are consistently getting it wrong)." Regardless, his logic is completely wrong and unfounded but who cares anymore. Who are these experts? No idea. When are they right? Irrelevant. What constitutes being wrong? Doesn't matter. They clearly decided on the nuclear option, i.e. Campaigning with an incredibly vacuous overly-simplistic divisive message that has broken the United Kingdom. Some of the more abrasive untruths would have made Goebbels proud: Particularly the idea that this was them against the "establishment" e.g. Their mates, or the £350 million affair - Not because of the figure but because of the tax income from doing trade with the EU.
- race-realist 7y agoOr look at how minorities talk about white people in every western nation. The underclass revolting against the white upper class.
- naukrihold 7y agogood
- mcguire 7y agoWhile on the one hand, I can see the advantages to us of reducing competition from another country, the weight of the disadvantages in general is far too high.
- VLM 7y agoThe difference between propaganda and news is propaganda tells what happened AND dogmatically enforces what to think. This situation is similar to how its a holy obligation to snarkily tell blue collar workers to "learn to code" when their jobs become obsolete, but snarkily telling journalists "learn to code" when their legacy jobs go away is reported as a hate crime. “It all depends on whose ox is being gored” The argument in the propaganda seems to boil down to its a tragedy that people publicly trying to subvert a society won't be getting paid anymore by the society they're trying to subvert. As if an immune system response is somehow immoral. Also this article is strongly biased anti-immigrant. If you don't want this kind of culture replacing the legacy in Scotland, Sweden, or France, you're just a racist. This is just kinda how the new culture of Europe does things and its beautiful.
- baq 7y agoIt begins with experts being blamed by politicians for daring to know things incompatible with a particular world view. When opinion gets more important than fact, democracy becomes populism and in the limit, authoritarianism.
- jjtheblunt 7y agoI think that distinct groups of Americans feel this way about both the Democratic Party supporters and the Republican Party supporters.
- baq 7y agoi'm not from the US nor live there so can't really say :)
- meshr 7y agoIntellectuals should stop sharing their knowledge/skills with obscurantists. They should allow obscurantists to fail or at least to make obscurantists to depend on intellectuals. The motto should be "first control then money gaining or sharing"
- duxup 7y ago>Intellectuals should stop sharing their knowledge/skills with obscurantists. What does this mean?
- meshr 7y agoYou shouldn’t teach anyone how to make a "weapon" if you can’t be sure that it won’t be used against other intellectuals. See also my reply above.
- duxup 7y ago>You shouldn’t teach anyone how to make a "weapon" if you can’t be sure that it won’t be used against other intellectuals What does that mean?
- magduf 7y agoWell in places where the intellectuals are fleeing, that's basically what they're doing, no? They're not trying to control the money exactly, but they are ceasing to share their skills with the rest of the people in that country, and removing themselves from its economy.
- meshr 7y agoI don’t think it is right. They harm their selves much more than its country. Dictator will easily buy their replacement from free world when needed. The problem is that intellectuals could be bought and sold because there are no contract commitments on how to use the knowledge. You are even free to use your knowledge against your teacher to make him to leave the country.
- dang 7y agoAll: please don't post unsubstantive comments or ideological flamebait in this thread or any other HN thread. Please do follow the site guidelines. They include "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chewz 7y agoWe had something like this in 1968 in Poland with communist propaganda condemning intelectuals and cosmpolitans and workers activists beating students on the streets (like they do in HK these days). Sztoptanski called that Dictatorship of Dishrags. Generally the best weapon against such times is irony and a sense of humor and grotesque. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Janusz_Szpota%C5%84ski https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Janusz_Szpota%C5%84ski
- madez 7y agoAfter reading that article, I'm happy for the polish to live in a better state now, and I immediately started to think where people are now oppressed by their government whenever they are deemed 'harmful to the nation', and China came to my mind, and not just for the Chinese state cooperating with the organized crimes triads to attack protesters in Hong Kong. The situation there is different for now, because China is economically developing, so that may stabilize the government, but eventually China will get rid of its oppressive regime. I wonder when and how.
- blfr 7y agoWe weren't really oppressed by our government. The March events, as they're know here, were mostly homegrown commies pushing out the Jewish wing of the party with decent people getting caught in the purge and following protests. But it was all happening with two hundred thousand Soviet soldiers stationed in the country. The communist government wouldn't have lasted a month without the Soviet support. The situation is different because China is not being occupied by a foreign power. Neither is Turkey.
- madez 7y agoGiven that history, are there common opinions and feelings in Poland regarding Russias ongoing war with Ukraine?
- blfr 7y agoI don't know anyone who would support Russia in that conflict but Ukraine itself isn't very popular with many due to unresolved Volhynia massacres[1]. Mostly though people just don't care about a low intensity war that feels far away (even if it isn't). [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres_of_Poles_in_Volhynia_and_Eastern_Galicia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres_of_Poles_in_Volhynia...
- notadoc 7y agoThe USA is purging intellectuals as well through outrage culture, online mobs, and the weaponization of political correctness. Both the far right and far left do it routinely to their advantage, they both seem to think the ends justify the means. Whoever has the loudest megaphone and can effectively stir up a sufficiently large outrage mob is the winner. Facts do not matter, evidence can be deemed "offensive" and is immediately discarded, there is no room for nuance, opinions must conform to group-think, and attempts at humor is often the worst offense of all. Anything can and will be taken out of context. Their intention is to harm, destroy, cleanse the culture and ideology into acceptable thought. Careers are ruined, achievements are discarded, lives are destroyed, names are slandered. That this type of behavior has been recently normalized, encouraged, and incentivized by both the far right and far left in the USA is a very disturbing trend. Historically this has never worked out well, so let's hope it all stops sooner than later.
- ap3 7y agoDo you have any sources for this purge of US intelectuals?
- CorruptedArc 7y agoA Harvard Law Professor was forced to step down due students feeling "Unsafe" over clients he was representing in court. There are many similar examples like this: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/24/opinion/harvard-ronald-sullivan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/24/opinion/harvard-ronald-su...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoYou're misunderstanding the story. He was made to step down from a particular post he held, and I'm not saying that's okay, but he's still a Harvard Law professor and there was never any prospect he wouldn't be.
- ryanobjc 7y agoTo be absolutely clear, this professor did not lose his job, he lost his post as dean of a residential house. This is a role whereby he lives in close proximity to students, acts as an mentor and helps students with all sorts of things, like for example if a student was sexually assaulted - their dean is supposed to be on their side. Students are right to question if he takes sexual assault seriously if he represents Weinstein. There are many other fine lawyers, and this was a totally voluntary job he took on. His real job, which it certainly appears like he shirked, is to be the best advocate for his students, to help them navigate college, which is often a difficult time. It's easy to say that his voluntary role in the defense of Weinstein has no merit or conflict with his job. But is that really true? You can say "students should grow up" or toughen up or something, but is that the kind of advice you'd offer to your own child? I think not. The appearance of conflict of interest is enough. That his students express discomfort and feelings of unsafe _in their own home_ was easily dismissed by this professor is additional evidence that he doesn't treat his job of dean to a residence seriously enough. "You should reason yourself so my volunteer role and job are not in conflict" is not good enough - he's putting all the effort on the weak and less powerful. And that's not right. Ultimately the story he spins in that article is that Harvard "capitulated to a mob", but my spin is this: Harvard did the right thing by protecting the less powerful from the more powerful. And there is no disputing a tenured Harvard law professor, with tons of connections, a guaranteed for life salary, etc, is the more powerful person.
- CorruptedArc 7y agoSo firing 6,000 academics and restructuring and a single major university counts as a purge? I mean a great many places are laying off professors with Liberal Arts Degrees many more than 6,000. In modern day the focus is shifting away from those careers. Even if that is a bad thing it is still the truth of the matter. This just seems like its trying to push a ham-fisted narrative. I'm no fan of Erdogan but this seems like textbook attempt at Yellow Journalism.
- radres 7y agoAt least 100 000 people lost their jobs. 6000 is only the number of academics. We are talking about Stanford/MIT grad, >40 h-index young academics (at least in science which is not the focus of the article) Some of these high-achieving people couldn't even leave the country even though there were a lot of positions waiting for them. Some people tried to go to Greece on boats which many of them died on the way.
- magduf 7y agoIt sounds like someone needs to organize some good, seaworthy boats to come pick these people up and take them someplace better, and help them get set up. After all, if they're intellectuals, they should be a huge asset to any country that takes them in. There's a reason we have the term "brain drain": countries that get the brains usually benefit greatly, while the countries losing them suffer economically.
- zwaps 7y agoI know you didnt mean this, but perhaps these people don't want to leave? Turkey is not a hellhole. Sure, it is a divided country, but it has a rich history and lots of beauty (I say that not being a Turk, nor being from Istanbul). Let's remember that the current position as a developing nation is historically rather new. There is a strong sense of nostalgia and, until recently, there was some realistic hope that Turkey would claw its way back. I'd personally argue there arent many comparable places where you can (or could) indeed live a good academic and intellectual life in a non-western, non-east-asian society. I know people who were ousted from their jobs, and yes they can all move elsewhere. But that's not the personal tragedies lie. If you grew up in a city full of thousands of years of history from East and West, it is entirely possible you will never be quite as happy living in sterile, uniform, blocky corporaty cities in the US or Canada. Those academics who stayed in Turkey despite their credentials, probably have such a preference.
- thaumaturgy 7y agoTurkey's GDP peaked at $950 billion in 2013, just before Erdogan became president. By 2017, it had slid to $850 billion, and after the intellectual purges, slid to just $766 billion in 2018. [1] People may argue from ideology for or against politics like these, but I can think of no clearer indication of these policies' failure than the impoverishing of a country. [1]: https://tradingeconomics.com/turkey/gdp https://tradingeconomics.com/turkey/gdp
- dmitriid 7y ago> Turkey's GDP peaked at $950 billion in 2013, just before Erdogan became president. By 2017, it had slid to $850 billion Do you realise that Erdogan has been in power since 2001? So if economic downturn is his achievement, then the economic growth is his achievement, too.
- anticensor 7y agoHe had significant checks and balances when he was the prime minister. Many of them are removed, nearly half of the executive powers lie upon the president, without any balance, currently. This is thanks to "presidential order"s (Cumhurbaşkanı Kararı), which is separate from "presidential decree"s (Cumhurbaşkanlığı Kararnamesi), which can be struck by the constitutional court.
- dmitriid 7y ago> Many of them are removed, nearly half of the executive powers lie upon the president, That I know, too. And that happened (as in many authoritarian states) so that he could maintain the illusion of legitimacy: "hey look, I'm not a prime-minister forever, I am now president". But do give Erdogan some credit. He is not stupid. And it's disingenuous and deeply simplistic to paint what happened in Turkey as "Erdogan became President in 2013, look Turkey immediately slid into recession because of that". "Checks and balances" alone cannot explain Turkey's growth prior to 2013.
- devmunchies 7y agoGDP is not a north star metric. GDP in the US is high and we have more suicides than ever. Many authoritarian (or especially populist) governments KNOW they will lower the GDP because by limiting low-wage labor immigration or focusing on nurturing a native culture or preserving the environment and not buying into a soulless consumerism/globalization they are creating a GDP cap. "growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell" --edward abbey (I don't know anything about what's happening in Turkey, I just don't believe in GDP as a metric to chase)
- tomohawk 7y agoDeplatforming is just bad. If you can't win your argument without getting rid of anyone who disagrees with you, what does that say? Evicting professors and others from universities. Blocking access to social media. Closing down newspapers and other new outlets. And it doesn't matter who's doing it. Erdogan. Carlos Maza. Antifa. None of them are doing anything constructive.
- lordCarbonFiber 7y agoYou cannot have freedom of speech without freedom of association. When it comes to deplatforming it does matter who's doing it, because there is a fundamental difference between a private entity (corporate or living person) and a government (only one has a monopoly on violence). The government shutting down your youtube channel; that's a problematic infringement on speech; Google shutting down your channel, that's within their rights.
- zzzcpan 7y ago> because there is a fundamental difference between a private entity (corporate or living person) and a government (only one has a monopoly on violence). Only works for private entities in markets with a lot of competition and no dominance. Otherwise there is no difference whether a government does it or a private entity under pressure.
- ryacko 7y agoThe EFF defends Backpage when credit card companies are pressured to withdraw services to Backpage. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/sheriffs-threats-against-credit-card-companies-violate-first-amendment https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/sheriffs-threats-again... The EFF does not defend Wikileaks when pressure was placed for hosting companies to withdraw services to them. http://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker/how-lieberman-got-amazon-to-drop-wikileaks http://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker/how-lieberman-got-ama...
- root_axis 7y agoNot a great example. Backpage was facilitating prostitution and trafficking for years, naturally that is going to attract some negative attention from the authorities.
- baxtr 7y agoMy favorite concept right now is the “meritocracy of ideas” - a fancy way of saying that the best ideas win. Somehow I feel that this is a core driver for success, in an organization, small or big. So by excluding smart people and their ideas you may significantly limit yourself and the futures your organization.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoHow do you define meritocracy? Ideas are infectious and they clearly do not need truthful or academic merit to spread like wildfire.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThey don't necessarily. But historically, allowing ideas to spread like wildfire seems like it's been a lot more effective at reaching the truth than having the authorities decide what's true and only let true things spread.
- vkou 7y agoTautalogically, in the same sham way that we generally define meritocracy. "These ideas won, because, clearly, they are the best." "These people are successful, because, clearly, they are the best."
- sjg007 7y agoThis is insightful. The other part is that some ideas matter and most don’t.
- cheriot 7y agoMeritocracy requires some sort of result that holds an idea up against reality. The scientific community uses experimentation and replication of successful results. The economy uses "creative destruction" to a similar end. People believing an idea doesn't add to its merit.
- sjg007 7y ago
- tuvan 7y agoI don't really know what is so special about the school which they decided to base the entire article on. This is just a small sample of the ongoing intellectual purge in Turkey. Every university rector is appointed by Erdogan, most professors in STEM, if they haven't fled, avoid any kind of political stance to continue teaching with the hopes of raising intellectuals who will help save the country. This is the university side of the situation, most of the successful students leave the country as soon as they graduate. This migration is on a scale that is record high in countries history, according to some unofficial numbers more than 300.000 young and smart individuals leave the country every year. And I have a problem with this story about its portrayal of Turk-Kurd relation. Turkey is an extension of a multi-national empire. For most people living there, Turkish is not an ethnicity. Most of Kurds, Armenians, Greeks, and more identify themselves as Turks. Portraying Demirtas as a charismatic Kurdish rights activist that wants to unite everyone with peace is despicable journalism. Demirtas is a proud terrorist supporter, he has stated his love and respect for Abdullah Ocalan repeatedly. Abdullah Ocalan is/was the leader of P.K.K., a group that is seen as a terrorist organization by every major intelligence agency of world, he is responsible for the murders of tens of thousands of innocent men, women, children.
- tepidandroid 7y agoIt's interesting to note that the NYT publishes this damning piece mere weeks after Erdogan green-lighted Turkey's purchase of Russian S-400 missile systems despite the U.S threatening to kick them out of the F-35 program if they did so. The story appears at a time when an important NATO ally is straying from the pack and leaning instead towards Russia's sphere of influence. My prediction is that we will be seeing more and more mainstream-media pieces like this in the near future, with a healthy sprinkling of words such as "regime", "dictatorship" and “fascism”, and featuring characters like Demirtas as protagonists of the story. They will undoubtedly be portrayed as freedom-fighters leading the fight against oppression. Manufacturing Consent was truly prophetic.
- jayess 7y agoNYT has always been a tool of the political establishment.
- TomMckenny 7y agoIt's disturbing this produced a sort of flame war. In the not-so-distant-past, a dictator purging academics would be clearly and universally acknowledged as bad. Somehow it's now twisted around to claim that critics of _supporters_ of a regime are actually the real "oppressors". Interesting times.
- Bartweiss 7y ago> In the not-so-distant-past, a dictator purging academics would be clearly and universally acknowledged as bad. Honestly, I'm not so sure that's true. That's still a consensus view for people without a stake in what's happening, and it never has been clear and universal for those close to the topic. (Who, as here, generally accept the principle but reject the accuracy of both 'dictator' and 'purge'.) It's not hard to find people, even in the US, who in their own time excused (or praised) each of fascist crackdowns on historians, Soviet enforcement of Lysenkoism, Pinochet's 'disappearing' of artists, Maoist 'reeducation', or even the Khmer Rouge's outright mass murder of educated people. Mostly, those purges have only been near-universally reviled in hindsight.
- TomMckenny 7y agoYou are correct, unfortunately. There must always be a contingent that supports the autocrat or else he would not be in power. "universal" is indeed too broad a term. And indeed, in the US there were things like the Madison Square pro-nazi rally in 1939. And just as there were pro-democracy denunciations of Pinochet that Nixon et co ignored, so too today there is denunciation of appalling autocratic behavior that will be ignored and will need to be watered down to justify to the public. Perhaps in the past too there were arguments of the form "thousands of political firings do not constitute a purge because the New York Times is X" I am accustomed to solution oriented discussions on these topics. So while interesting from an anthropological point of view, defense and praise of autocratic behavior is a breaking distraction from finding solutions.
- sgnelson 7y agoSame thing has happened in Hungary https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/06/george-soros-viktor-orban-ceu/588070/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/06/george-...
- deogeo 7y agoAmazing how a billionaire funding an institution with a self-admitted propaganda purpose is 'democracy', while elected officials trying to limit the influence of foreign capital is 'authoritarian'. By that logic, limiting the influence of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confucius_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confucius_Institute is also anti-democratic.
- spaced-out 7y ago>Amazing how a billionaire funding an institution with a self-admitted propaganda purpose is 'democracy', Source?
- deogeo 7y agoThe very article linked in the post I replied to: "Soros had conceived the school during the dying days of communism to train a generation of technocrats who would write new constitutions, privatize state enterprises, and lead the post-Soviet world into a cosmopolitan future." And its wikipedia page (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_European_University https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_European_University) states: "A central tenet of the university's philosophy is the promotion of open societies." It cites https://www.ceu.edu/rethinking-open-society https://www.ceu.edu/rethinking-open-society, which supports that statement.
- peu4000 7y agoIt is quite amazing that different situations are different.
- deogeo 7y agoThis reads like a dismissal, yet refutes none of my observations.
- ng12 7y agoHN is the only place I've seen people outright defending the PRC's human rights abuses. Something about HN really brings out the ultra-nationalists.
- sgnelson 7y agoOver the past few years, it seems to me, that HN is suffering a bit from the eternal september effect. It seems (again, to me) that many HN commentators are very technically knowledgeable, but are sorely lacking in understanding politics, social sciences, liberal arts, etc. It also seems (again, to me) that there has been a lot more authoritarian beliefs expressed by the comments. Take my opinion and observations for what you will.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIn my experience, it's usually the people who've been here for long that tend to express views differing from what we're all supposed to believe. So maybe it's a reverse eternal September? Maybe it's a reflection of a growing disillusionment with geopolitics and its reporting in western media? I mean, the story looks pretty damning on the face of it, but you have to consider that the last time the same media called a ruler a "bad guy" and people acted on it, it ended up completely wrecking a perfectly fine nation (Libya). Some time before that, the US wrecked another nation (Iraq), justifying it by fabricated stories people bought into at the time. I think you can excuse people for their lack of trust.
- discreteevent 7y agoThe guy was bad and the action taken was bad. One can't be afraid to say something in case someone might overreact to it.
- TomMckenny 7y agoThere is zero possibility that anything like that will happened to Turkey just as there is zero possibility of that happening to Saudi Arabia for their journalist murdering. The current rulership of the US (and Poland for that mater) actively dislike academia and the free press. Also, the US will need to use Turkey for whatever it plans to do to Iran. So if anything, revealing Erdogan's atrocities is annoying to the current leadership not helping. > what we're all supposed to believe...growing disillusionment with geopolitics and its reporting in western media Since we're talking about the NYT, I must say that at this time the US is overwhelmingly controlled by a party that condemns the media and its own free press as a lying enemy of the people. This is why the hated there grew enormously in the last few years. I understand there are similar forces in several other nations.
- TrackerFF 7y agoIn Cambodia, you could get killed for wearing glasses. Their purge of intellectuals was extreme - and that's just 45 years ago. Not saying that every pseudo-dictator is going to end up like pol pot, but it's good to see the warning flags.
- atoav 7y agoAs somebody who grew up in a central european province governed by popularist right wingers and then left, this was a question that always bugged me: If I am leaving, am I not making it worse there? But should I really go through unbearable suffering in an environment that is so corrupt, so completely devoid of rationality that the only few semi-okay people you know start acting like trauma victims, never just able to cope with the environment they live in. I can't blame anybody who fled in such a climate, especially in a nation which has it's unprocessed genocides not to far in the past. The border between what we call civilization and pure, stupid, evil fascism is extremely thin and given the right conditions the transition can be so incredibly fast, when the public starts to realize, it will be too late.
- sjg007 7y agoDepends on your philosophy. You could effect greater change outside the country for example. Or you could stay inside and create a revolution. I think the creative difference would be your resources and network.
- cat199 7y agoThe modern turkish state has been suppressing various kinds of intellectuals since its foundations via forced secularism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secularism_in_Turkey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secularism_in_Turkey what has happened is a shift in who is being suppressed, rather than the ab-initio creation of suppression. This is hinted at but not actually elucidated in the article: This measure was both practical and symbolic: The decaying Ottoman Empire had given way to a rebellious new nation that required statesmen (like himself) who were dedicated to secularism, modernity and nationalism. AKA required actually means required here, not just 'required in some sort of abstract sense of fitting in with the zeitgeist' the omission is unsurprising, since previous suppression fits secularist editorial bias of NYT, whereas current suppression does not. this is neither to say that I am in favor of either, nor that there was/was not intellectual freedom under ottoman times.
- zwaps 7y agoIstanbul these days is a tragedy, at least it feels like it. One of the three greatest cities in human history, and so many signs of "almost making it back". But now, everything has the stench of moving into the wrong direction. Seriously, you can feel it in the people, the shops, the buildings. It makes me really sad never to have been there in its prime. Turkey was never not a troubled country, but Turkish friends tell me Erdogan has sucked the optimism out of the intellectuals and academics that prevailed in years prior. What is left now is the typical Turkish melancholic nostalgia. It seeps through the streets of the city nowadays. Tragic.
- deogeo 7y ago> It makes me really sad never to have been there in its prime. Narrowly missed it by ~six centuries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_Constantinople https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_Constantinople :)
- ayayecocojambo 7y agowe are hoping when erdo gone we can recover as intellectuals are still out there. clock is ticking for him. but most terrifying thing is rising popularity of the populist leaders in the west.
- nurettin 7y agoThe, purge, the loss of jobs, the continuous state of emergency, all terrible ideas. However, painting everyone affected as "intellectual"s is going a bit too far. Although many innocent people got hurt, a lot of them were nur cult members. They believe said nursi was a prophet. They took over the education industry to spread their dogmas. Everyone in Turkey knew that and turned a blind eye because they were harmless.
- misingnoglic 7y agoNot true how substantiated this is, but I heard one of the reasons for moving Turkey away from the traditional script is to make it so people can't read texts about the Armenian genocide. Truly chilling stuff :(