4 ms·
This is a problem in just about every language that isn't English. Since the language of science is English, either you borrow the English word (which interesti
by lordnacho 7y ago
This is a problem in just about every language that isn't English. Since the language of science is English, either you borrow the English word (which interestingly is likely borrowed from Latin) or you know a local word that.
But at some stage your local vocabulary runs out, and you wonder whether you should just use English for everything in that domain to make it consistent.
I've run into this problem with a load of languages, I just don't know the right word for things like DNA or vector calculus, or it sounds wrong.
- x3n0ph3n3 7y agoHow do you "borrow" spoken words into sign language? You can't, really -- which is why he has to invent hand gestures.
- OJFord 7y agoI suppose the equivalent is (what I now know is called) finger spelling: an unnatural 'sounding' word that breaks the flow, but it's [spelling is] taken from a language where it already exists.
- x3n0ph3n3 7y agoSee how well spelling out words rather than pronouncing them works for you in conversation. This really is a unique problem to adopting spoken words into a non-vocal language.
- _nalply 7y agoDeaf myself: usually we start with fingerspelling. If we discover it being cumbersome we invent something. Borrowing is different but not impossible.
- zapzupnz 7y agoNot to mention the new signs can involve the hand shapes from, say, the first letter of the borrowed English word. Say the word starts with a D, and everybody recognises the fingerspelt word just from the D alone (in context), then the new sign might use the hand shape for D but give it a specific action.
- _nalply 7y agoDeaf myself: Often you can incorporate a fingerspelled letter into a sign, so some borrowing still happens. Where I live mouth pictures are important, so often you sign the general concept and mouth a part of the complicated word.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe word is medical Latin-Greek, which is actually neither of those. (In many languages it is deoxyribonucleic acid with first part not translated.)
- annachronistic 7y agoIs etymology so relevant? The lexicon of the word is scientific jargon; its language is English.
- edgarvaldes 7y agoIn spanish it is Ácido DesoxirriboNucleico. It's very easy to construct, given that "ácido", "des" and "nucleico" have latin roots.
- frenchyatwork 7y agoBoth Spanish and English have a fair bit of influence from Latin and from languages that were influenced by Latin. A better example would be what the word is in Swahili, or Mandarin.
- fao_ 7y ago> Both Spanish and English have a fair bit of influence from Latin and from languages that were influenced by Latin. I think you're missing the point. OP claimed that English is the language of science in most other languages. The parent showed, using an example from Spanish, that the actual language of science in most languages is Latin. It is neither here nor there whether or not the language is latin-derived. And regardless, it's not possible to distinguish whether or not it is 'English' or 'Latin' from examples from non-latin-derived languages because English-speaking scientific establishments, up until the 1800s (and even to this day in some fields like botany, etc.) uses Latin nomenclature in scientific work. Most of the examples that you can find, the examples in the foreign language, English, and Latin are all going to match (I believe the exception is Medical German -- practitioners in Germany have to learn both the German and Latin versions) and it is difficult to prove without specific work into the foreign etymology, that in that case the foreign language is following Latin and not English! In case I haven't made myself clear, it's trivial to take your Swahili question to demonstrate the point. According to Google Translate (I couldn't find a Wiktionary entry for it) in Swahili it is "asidi deoxyribonucleic". Now, is this because it follows the English form or the Latin form? You can't know without doing some digging into the Swahili Etymology.